Main Topic: The podcast discusses various topics, including Magic Leap's pivot to healthcare, the FTC's case against Meta, the future of retail, and the concentration of power in industries such as big tech, big pharma, and big ed.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Listen, you keep sending me your location information. I want to know what that's about.
Scott Galloway
I don't mean to do that. I don't know what's going on there. You are on the Atlantic coast of Florida. Thank you for that information.
Kara Swisher
I mean, I usually, when I drop a pin, it's usually got something to do with male prostitutes or crystal meth being dropped off.
Scott Galloway
Right. That's what I figured. So I'm curious why you keep sending me a map.
Kara Swisher
I saw that. I saw why she's sending me a map.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, you've done it. I said, why is she sending me a map? And I'm like, no, I just sent her a map of where I live.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you did.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah. I'm definitely easing into that old man. By the way, I'll sell that to the highest bidder.
Kara Swisher
Doesn't get it. I'll sell that to the highest bidder.
Scott Galloway
Oh, yeah, what a thrill. What a thrill. Anyway.
Kara Swisher
Come roll with the dog.
Scott Galloway
It's like I can see you misdoing your iPhone. And then, oh, I sent this by accident. What am I talking into this? It's very funny. Kara, you have no idea.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but it's not at night. It's not late at night. It's like in the morning. No, there's no excuse. I'm not even drunk. It's really funny. Anyway, Scott is on the Atlantic coast and anyone wants to know.
Scott Galloway
I'm sorry to interrupt you, but I have a board meeting today for my company and all of them got wonderful pictures of my dog and children bathing. Because I didn't realize I thought it was sending out the deck. And I'm like, oh, there's a PDF. That feels like a picture. So they're all so nice. They're like, this is really cute. Oh, how old is the young one now? And I'm like, sorry, I didn't want to send these.
Kara Swisher
Oh, wow, that's professional. That's professional. Anyways. So today we're going to talk about the FTC's case against Meta, which is back. We'll take a look at the biggest video game deal in history, and we'll take a listener question about the future of retail. All such interesting things. But first of all, Magic Leap is pivoting into healthcare. The company previously set out to make a consumer AR headset, and its next product will target applications for surgeons instead, which is interesting. It's a big area. Meanwhile, analysts are excited about Apple's VR and AR gear, even though the company hasn't announced any.
But as you and I have talked about, it's probably going to be nifty. So talk about Magic Leap. It was sort of a Florida company, so I want you to take the lead here. It had lots of big investors. Google was in there. Like, everybody was in Magic Leap. Huge amounts of money. It's now being run by a very terrific executive named Peggy Johnson, who I know from Microsoft. She was doing their acquisitions and strategy there. Really smart person. So what do you think about this? Is it just they're like, look, this is too hard to do from an entertainment perspective or what?
Scott Galloway
Well, first off, it's a real knock on Florida. We only, until recently, had two unicorns. Chewy, which is a really inspiring company in Miami, focused on pets. They kind of came in and proved that you could compete against Amazon. Great merchandising, great operations. And then Magic Leap was sort of the first. And Magic Leap, there's just no getting around it, has been an enormous disappointment to date. And it was supposed to be kind of the original, the OG in VR.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And the person who founded it. Very interesting founder, et cetera. Reportedly a genius, one of these. And anyone who spoke to this person wanted to invest, and they did. But I think the pivot here is necessary and smart. If you think about VR, the economic costs are large, and the non-economic costs, specifically putting something like this on your head, are also really high. The notion that they would go after B2B markets where the utility of performing a surgery in India with somebody who doesn't have access to a world-class cardiothoracic transplant surgeon, and maybe you can simulate it with a combination of robotics and VR...
I've always said, and the lesson here for young people is, have a bias towards B2B versus B2C. Because B2C is more interesting, more romantic. It's more fun to talk about Netflix. It's more fun to talk about vans. It's more fun to talk about a headset for consumers and gaming. So it's over-invested. Take your company and sell it into large enterprise and small and medium-sized business. Because if you can show some utility there, they're much less price sensitive. It's not nearly as over-invested. Every company I've started has been a B2B company. Every one, except for one, B2C, which was Red Envelope.
And that was my Vietnam. I can't get over how demanding consumers are and how price sensitive they are. If you walk into Walmart and say, I can help you figure out your digital innovation, or I have data that can help you, they will pay real money and they're nice to deal with. Consumers, oh my gosh, are they difficult.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
So I like this. I think it's a smart pivot.
Kara Swisher
Do you have any thoughts? I have a lot of regard for Peggy Johnson, and I'd love to hear her talk about it. Maybe she will at some event soon. But I think they have a lot of weight on them, given all the investments. It's been the sort of the longest running next big thing for a long time. It had a lot of mystery around it, a lot of problem. The founder had done some really crazy interviews, as I recall. I don't even remember them, but I remember they were crazy. So it was interesting they located in Florida. It was interesting, the investors. You've got to make something of this. And it's an incredibly... they probably have fantastic technology. I don't doubt it. But there's a lot of people piling in here and they've got to get going. You can't be... there's an expression, the planes are covered with the bodies of pioneers. They don't want to be those pioneers, I guess, in the early days of this stuff. They were definitely early to this and the first people talking about it. A lot of it was sort of fluffery, but some of it was very significant. So yes, I think so. I agree with you. It's a nice pivot. We'll see. I'd like to hear more about it.
So here's another story you're going to like. A new lawsuit claims that the nation's top universities colluded to fix prices and violated federal law. The suit names a dozen universities, including Yale, Georgetown, where I went, Cornell, and Columbia. I also went there. Lawyers say more than 170,000 former students could join in the suit as plaintiffs. Oh, exciting for me. Currently, it's just five. Scott, will you be called as an expert witness? Tell me, what do you think about this colluding?
Scott Galloway
I used to do a lot of expert witness work.
Kara Swisher
Did you?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, a lot.
Kara Swisher
Did you pretend you were a doctor?
Scott Galloway
Dr. Scott Galloway. It's likely that she was dead for more than 24 hours. So, gong, gong. I just kept waiting for that sound after I would say something. I would make these bold declarative statements, but all my expert witness stuff was around IP.
Kara Swisher
Wait, wait, wait. I'm going to take down a little highway here. What were you an expert witness on? It hurts my feelings that you're this shocked.
Scott Galloway
Well, I am. I'm like, what could they possibly... So, what do you think I was? Let me put it back to you. What do you think I was an expert witness on?
Kara Swisher
I don't know. Marketing?
Scott Galloway
Marketing. I was an IP and brand strategy expert. I would talk about IP violations for brands. It shocks me that you find this so humorous and unbelievable.
Kara Swisher
Okay. Anyways. I'd like to meet those lawyers. There's an Alan Dershowitz wandering around somewhere. I was the go-to expert witness for Adidas for a decade.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Okay. Stop it. Three stripes. It's confusing when you have four or two stripes.
Kara Swisher
This area is so dear to your heart to bash universities where you work. Look, go ahead.
Scott Galloway
First off, a group of people colluding to increase prices and soak the middle class. Kara, I'm shocked. I'm shocked. Look at what's going on here. In every city, you have a duopoly. I don't care if it's Los Angeles or New York or Chicago. It's San Francisco. There's two great universities. And then there are a bunch of what I'll call second-tier universities. And what do you know? They all charge pretty much exactly the same price. Let's look at New York. There's Fordham, which has about a 50% or 60% admit rate. A good college, not what you would call a great brand. There's NYU, which is for rich kids who can get into a good to great school. And then there's Columbia, sort of the Mercedes. It admits 6%. They all charge somewhere between $50,000 and $60,000. Now, how does that happen? That's like saying, what would have happened if there were two auto dealerships and it ended up with Hyundais and Mercedes at the same price? Isn't something wrong? And we all raise our prices in exact lockstep. What if there were only two grocery stores?
Kara Swisher
Well, they sometimes do. Like people watch each other's prices. That's for sure. But there's no competition.
Scott Galloway
And here's the problem. There's no pressure to bring prices down because the only way you can be a working university is if you give your kids access to debt. And debt is based on your ability to issue debt to pay these usurious fees, which is based on accreditation. And who runs the accreditation institutions? The incumbents. As a result, over the last 30 years, only 157 new universities have been admitted, meaning that we have exploded education companies or organizations, despite the fact there's massive demand. Two out of three jobs now need a college degree, whereas one in three just 20, 30 years ago. We have exploded the market by 0.7% a year, such that we constrain supply. We leverage this rejectionist culture that makes us feel good about turning away 80, 90% of our applicants. And what we end up doing is creating the best business model in the world that lets us increase prices, including colluding with each other around how much financial aid we're going to give each other.
Kara Swisher
Collusion is a heavy word. Do you think it's colluding or...?
Scott Galloway
It's 100 percent. They get in a room. And they mutually agree upon an algorithm for how much financial aid they're going to give, which is price fixing.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And then the case said that the universities were actually given an exemption from this collusion and allowed to collude if they were, quote unquote, not need blind. That is, they weren't a cartel. They were not letting in people because they were rich and less needy. And what do you know? Shocker. They found out a lot of people are getting off the waiting list because they were the sons and daughters of billionaires. This higher ed has been the greatest assault on the prosperity of the middle class of the last 40 years. We have soaked the middle class of a trillion and a half dollars. Everybody talks about rampant inflation being bad. It is because if your salary doesn't keep pace with the cost of goods, then your lifestyle, your purchasing power, your prosperity goes down. The middle class has seen their wages barely keep pace with inflation. But the one thing that they are told they have failed as a parent unless they buy has skyrocketed in cost.
Kara Swisher
It's a real sticker shock. It doesn't matter how much money you have. It's crazy expensive.
Scott Galloway
But the amount of despair... Even the accreditation process, it's based on curriculum and quality of faculty. We want people like us with PhDs, our buddies from Carnegie Mellon, and we want this full complement of courses, including things on sustainability and leadership and ethics. So if a university said we got five smart practitioners who are going to teach four to eight amazing classes in cybersecurity and I can get these kids jobs at $100,000 right out of school, they don't measure outcomes. They're not interested in outcomes.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's the second part.
Scott Galloway
They're interested in PBS self-aggrandizement and arrogance. There are very few institutions and organizations that have been this rapacious and damaging to the middle class. All under the auspices of this fake nobility. Bring it. This is overdue. I like it.
Kara Swisher
I like it. Is it your lawsuit? No. We'll see if you get called in. I bet you could. But here's the problem. This lawsuit actually doesn't address the problem because here's the other dirty little secret. These universities, it's actually cheaper than most universities because they have so much money that they give out financial aid. The net tuition at Princeton has actually gone down because they have so much money. So what happens? Increased income inequality. Princeton isn't one of the universities in the lawsuit, but it's similarly a lead school. By way of example, you get into Princeton, you're set. You get an amazing degree at a lower cost. You get arbitrage down because you haven't built wells in Africa and have a patent by the time you're 17. Or your dad isn't Ray Dalio. And you end up at a mediocre car paying a Mercedes price for a Hyundai. This is really... I think there are a few things that represent a greater threat to America that we're not talking about than this rejectionist luxury positioning.
Scott Galloway
Well, and everybody wants free college. It's so interesting. Oddly enough I was reading Marianne Williamson tweets today. I like Marianne. And she was like everybody in America wants free college, some gun control, this and that. And when we do none of this. When you say free college to people, everybody wants it. It's a really interesting topic. And I agree. Speaking of which, I'm speaking at Princeton this weekend. I am. I'm going up to Princeton. I grew up there.
Kara Swisher
That's nice.
Scott Galloway
I grew up in Princeton. I didn't get in, but I am speaking there. So nonetheless.
Kara Swisher
Can I just go on for another moment here?
Scott Galloway
Yes, please.
Kara Swisher
Okay. So my class, we shifted to all online during the pandemic. 280 kids. What do they each pay? They each pay $7,000. So in order to take brand strategy with Scott Galloway for two hours and 40 minutes, 12 times, we charge them $1.96 million. Young people, $1.96 million. Can you even think of another product that an organization charges $2 million for and gets 98 points of gross margin? Can you even think of a product?
Scott Galloway
I have one. Zolgensma, which is this life-saving gene therapy that costs $2 million for two doses. So either save your life and not die of a terrible genetic disorder, or a brand strategy with Scott Galloway. Neither of those is sustainable. The amount of money we are charging young people is staggering when you really think about the true numbers and the impact and despair and financial oppression it is levying on American middle class households.
Kara Swisher
Many people speak of this to me. Many people I know still have college loans and they're quite old. May I just say, though, you're priceless. In any case, 3,000 United Airlines employees have COVID. Did you see that, according to the CEO? I like the CEO. He's really interesting. One-third of the airline staff in Newark called out sick from a single day. In better news, Kirby says the employee deaths from COVID have dropped to zero since implementing his vaccine mandate. So they're not dying, but they're getting sick. Previously, the airline averaged one employee death per week from the virus.
Kirby credited United's vaccine mandate for the change. He wrote, quote, "There are approximately eight to ten United employees who are alive today because of our vaccine requirement." Boom, he says. So all the airlines are canceling flights, not just airlines. We're just using them as a proxy here. Schools are happening like everything, everywhere there's people out. In the school line, all the parents are discussing all the strategies of everyone being out and when to go in. So everyone's canceled flights. I'll just use flights as an example. This is going to go on, although today there was also a story at several places about the virus peaking everywhere.
It's going to follow along Britain and South Africa's thing. So it could be over relatively soon, the illnesses, and people will work through them.
Scott Galloway
Your words to God's ears. So just as every day we get better at renting our human capital via remote technologies, which chips away at the office industrial complex's ability to bounce back, the other industry that is just going to get ravaged is business travel. I track everything I do. But it's not coming back because we're getting so much better. In 2014, I looked it up. I spent 238 days on the road for business.
Kara Swisher
Whoa.
Scott Galloway
I think the lesson here or the opportunity when you think about the pandemic is... I've been thinking a lot about professional unlocks. There's also a personal unlock or an opportunity in that. If you're blessed with resources coming out of this pandemic and good health, look at technology and decide what is the unlock for me. The unlock, as I was... I'll turn this back to me. I've decided I'm never going to spend more than 50 days away from my family unless it's with them and for fun or I'm doing something that's fun. There's just no reason to travel as much for business.
Kara Swisher
I agree. I've been coming back. I used to travel all the time. I'm traveling a little more going forward. I have a bunch of stuff over the spring coming up. But you're right. You and I, for example, are going to Europe. But did you know that? You and I are taking a romantic trip to Germany.
Scott Galloway
Yes. We are.
Kara Swisher
Oh, we're going to Hamburg. We're going to Hamburg.
Scott Galloway
That's right. Because Daddy brings in the cabbage for the high-ticket speaking gigs.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, but I agree with you.
Scott Galloway
Can you leave? Germans want us on stage?
Kara Swisher
I know. They love your chemistry.
Scott Galloway
Yes. We think you're funny, Kara.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, so here's the deal. I think that these airline cancellations are interesting. Business travel, definitely. People are wanting to travel, though, I have to say. Everyone I know does want to get on a plane. And pretty much everyone of my friends who's gotten on a plane has had a plane issue. So I think planes will be back for certain things. But you're correct about business travel. But I think most people really are dying to get the hell away from their houses in some fashion. And not near their houses.
Scott Galloway
We're not dying to get away from our houses. We're dying to get away from the individuals who occupy our houses.
Kara Swisher
Whatever. I think people want to go places. We're planning a lot for the summer, hopefully. I think people are just like, okay, enough of dinner at home kind of thing. So I don't know. We'll see where it goes. But most people... I just did a really interesting interview with Emily Oster, who's an economist at Brown, very well known, and sometimes controversial because she really was pushing for keeping schools open back in the day. She said, this was three weeks ago, the next six weeks are going to be really tough in terms of work. People are going to stick out, and she's been correct, and it's going to have an economic impact. So we'll see. I hopefully will be over soon.
Scott Galloway
Think about what COVID has done. There was a great article in the New York Times called "Davos Man."
Kara Swisher
Yes. We're going to have him on.
Scott Galloway
Which was making fun of Mark Benioff, which I think is unfair. I think Mark's actually made huge efforts to redistribute his income. But anyways, if you look at who's benefited most, billionaires have increased their wealth 70%. And the people who are getting sick, the people who are resigning are the people on the front line who don't have the opportunities to stay at home and don't have assets. It's really been a double whammy.
Kara Swisher
Speaking of which, you know what? I thought of you. Did you see Jamie Dimon's announcement yesterday?
Scott Galloway
No. What did he say?
Kara Swisher
He said, if you want to be back in the office, you have to be back in the office. And he said, if you want to be back in the office, you need to be vaccinated. And if you aren't going to be in the office, you can't work here. In other words, he said, if you want to work for J.P. Morgan, you need to be vaccinated. I think that's what leadership looks like.
Scott Galloway
Well, this Kirby guy was firm.
Kara Swisher
What's that?
Scott Galloway
The CEO of United. He got a lot of pushback from United staff. He was like, I don't care. I don't care. But what you said really struck me, and I'd like you to expand on it. When we were talking about FinTech and Web3 and this notion of decentralization and all these VCs talking about the great decentralized future, which will give them opportunity for greater centralization of wealth, you said, guys, I'd rather have Jamie Dimon running it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I would.
Scott Galloway
So say more.
Kara Swisher
Because I think it reminds me of a lot of these... I was talking to someone about my book that I'm working on. One of the things that was exhausting for most of the people I cover is they always have to do this change the world thing. Like, we're changing the world. I was like, you know what? Jamie Dimon doesn't do that. He's just a banker making money. Like, stop it. You're all making money. I think that was one of the issues. They sort of... I don't want to use the term virtue signaling, but that's what it kind of is. They always have an agenda that's not what they're saying. And I don't really feel like Jamie Dimon is tricking me. Does that make sense? At least he's here to make money. This is what I'm doing. I'm going to run at Adam Neumann because that's what I want to do. I want that deal. The agendas that are behind the agendas exhaust me with these people. They're using emotional terms with people who are more desperate to make them feel like they belong. It's very Trumpy. I find tech people very Trumpy in some ways. Popular people. We're here for the people, and they're the richest people on earth. I just don't buy it.
Scott Galloway
As you're speaking, the contrast I would offer is I spoke at... Jamie has a gathering of alternative investment professionals and he has a gathering of like 100 CFOs of the biggest companies and I spoke at it. Someone asked him about tax policy and he seemed very earnest. He's like, people in this room have killed it. Taxes probably need to go up. It's time. It's just gotten out of control. And you got the sense he really meant it. And then in contrast, when you go to the Valley, it's like, we're better capital allocators. We're an interplanetary species. They start talking as if they're the ones that are going to save the world and you have a moral obligation to tax them less because they are better capital allocators than the government.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they like to do that. And it's an entirely different sort of... Sometimes they are, sometimes they're not. It's like a religion with them. Listen, I've had a lot of beefs with Jamie Dimon, but I feel like I know where he's coming from. That's all. I just need to know where people are coming from. And you kind of know what you're getting.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, exactly.
Kara Swisher
Anyways, let's get on to our big stories. The FTC's monopoly case against Meta is back on. The case was previously thrown out last June when the judge said that the FTC hadn't shown Meta was a monopoly. Now that's changed and they're refiling the case. This is under Lina Khan, who didn't file the original case, I believe. The FTC used Comscore data and time on site to show Meta is drowning out its competitors. That was enough to convince the judge to let the case proceed. He just basically said, do better work. Do your work and return it to me. If the FTC wins and breaks up Meta, would it solve the issues that came out last year? But it's on, essentially. That's what we're saying is on. And is the problem of Facebook's size, Facebook's business model? And what can be done? Speaking of, like, don't mess with us because markets will... it will be their argument, like TikTok or whatever. That's what they'll say. But it's on.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. They had to do this. They've been working nights because when it got... Preet made an interesting comment when I was on his podcast saying that if you bring a case and it's dismissed, it's basically a very strong signal that this won't hold water. So they had to come back and get approval to move forward with this. This is absolutely needed. I believe the largest tax cut in the history of the corporate world would be if you figured out a way to lower the rents being charged by Facebook and Google. Because if a product or a service cannot be leveraged to differentiate your product as Nike did with TV or Williams-Sonoma did with catalogs, but everybody has to use it, it's no longer an offering. It's a tax. Yes. So if we were able to lower... I don't want them to be successful. I don't think the executives there acquit themselves well. We will spend, at Section 4, $3 to $5 million this year on Facebook. And you know why? We have no choice.
Kara Swisher
Any choice? Any choice whatsoever?
Scott Galloway
Well, it's Facebook. The answer is, do you do Facebook or Google? And the answer is yes. You have to do both. They have sequestered the entire online world. Two-thirds of all, 60 or 70 cents on the digital dollar goes to them. It's probably 80 to 90 if you throw Amazon in there. Amazon has increased its rents or the percentage of the take from third-party retailers from 19 to 34 cents. The entire gestalt of the valley around criteria for investing is, would this be a good company that we get 3x on? No, we don't invest in that. Is this a company that could potentially establish monopoly power and monopoly rents? That's everything they're funding. It's 80% Facebook and Google, according to the UK's Competition and Markets Authority. If you want to acquire customers online, which everybody does because the market... you just have no choice. You don't have a business. So I get, justifiably, pushback saying, Scott, you're such a critic of Facebook, yet you're funding them. And I'm like, well, I don't like coal-fired plants, but I turn on my lights. What choice do we have?
Right. So if you were to go in and break these guys up — Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, three separate companies — and you were to break up YouTube, Google, break up their advertising monopoly, all of a sudden people would have eight choices, not two. The rents would come way down.
Think about what Google has achieved. There is no market in the world that has a 93% market share leader in a $150 billion category with the types of margins they have. That means they are extracting rents that are too high. So I am all in on this. We desperately need — the largest tax break in the history of corporate America would be us breaking up big tech and lowering the rents on everyone else in the ecosystem that really has no choice.
Kara Swisher
I like that. That's a good way to put it.
Scott Galloway
Now, listen, they're going to argue that they don't have a monopoly on social media. Other social networks exist — Twitter, TikTok, Snapchat, Reddit. Reddit is obviously doing an IPO. The FTC is countering by saying the other social networks don't focus on connecting friends and family. I would agree with that. There are no others. The rest are sort of communications or entertainment. I mean, Reddit's not — I don't go there with my family. I go there to read.
Kara Swisher
The data doesn't support that. 93% of search is one company. Two-thirds of social is one company. And the market share point is a data point. But I think we need to go to the more Brandesian view of antitrust.
Scott Galloway
Brandesian. I like when you throw in Brandesian. Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
I know. That's my safe word.
Scott Galloway
Stop Brandesian. That's my safe word.
Kara Swisher
How can you get it out with the ball gag?
Scott Galloway
That's a tough one with the ball gag. Brandesian. Actually, you know what my safe word is?
Kara Swisher
What?
Scott Galloway
You know what my safe word is.
Kara Swisher
No, what is it?
Scott Galloway
Oh, good God. I can't believe I just asked that. Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Maybe. Courtesy of George Han. Courtesy of Jihan.
Scott Galloway
G-Man.
Kara Swisher
G-Man. Oh, he's big.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. How about that? By the way, we were brainstorming for segments on my new CNN Plus show, and one of them is going to be "George walks the dog." He's just going to take me for walks, and I'm going to ask him a question.
Kara Swisher
Really? Anyways, isn't that funny? You make a star of George. I hope you do. I think he's already a star. I think he's going to make me. I think it's going to be the other way around.
Scott Galloway
I know, but people need to get some George. People need a little more Jihan.
Kara Swisher
Jihan, yeah. A little more Jihan. All right, back to this. So what do you think of this? I mean, I think that she has come to play. Lina Khan has come to play.
Scott Galloway
I do. Oh, no shit. She does her homework. She's like one of those people who does her homework. She's super inspiring. She's early 30s, an academic who wrote a paper while she was in graduate school, and now she's advising the president. I don't think people realize — just because I follow this stuff pretty closely — when you listen to President Biden right now, it is literally clear that morning he was in the room with Tim Wu and likely Lina Khan and likely Cantor, taking very copious notes. They are having an impact.
I find it inspiring that people like Tim Wu and Lina Khan, who devote their lives to really trying to understand the domain of a certain narrow area, can end up whispering in the president's ear. They can be lifted out of a university at such a young age and have this kind of impact. I think it speaks well to America. And they're both children of immigrants. I'm super excited.
I think the capitalist argument for breakup has to take center stage, not this bullshit that they're bad people or we're angry at them. Or Bernie and Senator Warren attacking them for being billionaires. It's like, well, Jesus Christ, that's your fault. Pass progressive taxes. I'm super excited about antitrust. I hope it continues to get momentum.
Kara Swisher
You're going to see more of it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I think so too.
Kara Swisher
All right. So we'll see what happens here. This is going to be an interesting thing. And also, it'll be interesting, the discovery and how much the government's willing. I do think there is a commitment on the part of the government to do something about this. All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about the deal with Zynga and take a listener mail question.
Ad break
Okay Scott, we're back with our second big story. Games publisher Take-Two Interactive is buying Zynga, the company behind games like FarmVille and Words With Friends, for $12.7 billion. It's the biggest deal in the history of video games. But investors didn't want to play — Take-Two's stock dipped on the news. The deal is expected to close by the end of June.
This is a long, long story. I've known Mark Pincus, the founder of Zynga, for a long time. He was almost there with a social network. He was really early to social networks and wasn't able to put it off the ground, long before he was in Washington, D.C. He had another company that was early to a lot of big trends that other people took advantage of later. Zynga's been way down, but under the new CEO, it's gone up a little bit. It definitely was the hot ticket item and then wasn't. So what do you think of this purchase? Take-Two's hits are on the console and desktop — Grand Theft Auto, NBA 2K games. Zynga's are mobile. What do you think about this? We don't pay a lot of attention to games. I'd like to get your take. I've been doing all the talking here. I'm dominating.
Scott Galloway
Well, Zynga has been sort of bumping along. They were certainly early to the game, but they just bumped along. They had a lot of ups and downs. At one point, they owned three buildings in San Francisco, a lot of parties, this and that. Then it's been a very hard ride. I think it's probably a good outcome for their investors because it's up significantly from where their price has been. I think it's okay. I think these people missed the boat essentially.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you're right. It's probably the most underappreciated industry relative to its size.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I think it's about $130 billion. By contrast, domestic U.S. box office — we're always talking about films and what's happening to movie theaters — that's like $7 billion. This industry is enormous. In addition, it's growing high single digits, 8% a year. There are very few industries over $100 billion, other than search and social, that are growing at high single digits. It's an incredible industry, high margin.
Its biggest growth driver, and this speaks to the rationale behind this acquisition, is Asia, where it's growing double digits. 70% of the players in Asia are playing via mobile. The revenue model there is freemium, microtransactions, and advertising. The rationale for this acquisition — and Strauss Zelnick, who strikes me as a very savvy operator, nice guy, also super into fitness — has said, look, we have this incredible IP, Grand Theft Auto. They have some amazing games. But we don't have the skills and the DNA for this freemium mobile model. And Zynga does.
We said this last week — you are going to see the game space heat up. My boys, there's something about the young male brain, they just love video games. I'm trying to do a better job of not scolding my kids or manicuring what they're supposed to be interested in based on my preconceived notions. I've decided to lean into it. I did a Coinbase account with my son because he seemed interested. I thought, I want him to learn about the markets. Maybe this is how he learns to earn things. And my youngest is really into video games. I'm trying to figure out a way for him to take courses or online classes where we can learn how to program a video game because he seems interested.
That industry — oh my gosh. There are two industries that are growing right now. Media and everything else is kind of declining, other than shitty little podcasts. It's video games and streaming.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's true. Zynga's CEO, Frank Gibeau, who took over for Mark Pincus — maybe there was another CEO in there somewhere — he'll be leading these mobile efforts, and they can then take the franchises of Take-Two into a bigger space, into the mobile space. I think that's one of the things — some of these franchises they can make into mobile games. At first investors were down. Now the stock is up.
Scott Galloway
That's right.
Kara Swisher
They just said it out loud: "We see tremendous untapped potential to bring Take-Two's renowned console and PC properties to mobile, a high priority initiative energized by the addition of Zynga's leading development, publishing, and live operations team." And that's true. Zynga's been there a long time. Often Zynga was sort of a canary in the coal mine of a lot of things and then didn't take the most advantage of it. But at the same time, it's good for them. I think people are now feeling better about this deal.
Scott Galloway
I think they are. It makes sense. And you're seeing a lot of other game developers doing the same thing.
Kara Swisher
If you remember when FarmVille was so popular for a short time, it was one of those hot things. They rode to fame and fortune on Facebook, on the back of Facebook, speaking of which — when Facebook was doing well, it was sort of the accelerant for a lot of these different things. A lot of them, most of them, fell by the wayside. But it's also good for them. There's also the issues around Apple's privacy changes. So Take-Two needs more heft in fighting that. This privacy feature, App Tracking Transparency, ATT, has affected a lot of companies in iOS. As they're bigger, it's important to get bigger to allow them to get over the privacy roadblocks that this has put in their way.
Scott Galloway
The unintended consequence of the Apple privacy moves is that Facebook's earnings have not been hit because their ability to target has gone down. They've just passed through those price increases to the end consumer. Now, to acquire consumers on Facebook, your cost of customer acquisition has gone up. But it's not like Facebook has said, okay, we're cutting prices.
You brought up a really important notion. There are the haves and the have-nots now. The haves are the ones that have enough interaction with their customer base that they have enough first-party data to build that digital corpus, to come up with a recommendation engine or better targeting for advertising. Everybody is talking about first-party data. The company I'm involved with, OpenWeb, pitched one of the things about a more robust comments section — you just get more interaction and more first-party data. If the New York Times can't build an ecosystem strong enough to inspire a lot of interaction so they can capture that data to serve you better articles or target you better, they're going to be totally dependent upon the ecosystems that do have first-party data. That's specifically Google and Facebook. So everybody's trying to figure out, if I can't capture data from third party from other sites, I've got to get to a critical mass or heft of my own first-party data.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's important. But this company — I'm sorry, go ahead.
Scott Galloway
Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Sorry. The other thing is just around gaming. I'm looking at the market cap here. Take-Two, some iconic brands. The thing's $17 billion or $18 billion in market cap right now. You don't think — and I trust the DOJ and the FTC will get in the way of this — but when Facebook realizes this Oculus thing isn't working out, but they really want to jumpstart the metaverse, where do you think they'll go? What do you think they could acquire?
Scott Galloway
They'll start. And by the way, these are iconic titles, and it would be a 2% dilution. It would be nothing.
Kara Swisher
I think you're right. I think one of the things that's interesting is the ride of Mark Pincus. He was super early to a lot of this stuff and it was the hottest company. He still is an owner. He's been CEO twice — I think it's twice. It was the company. I can't even tell you. Then it was the IPO. They had a problem and then they had all these pricey acquisitions. He owns about 5% of the company at this point, so he'll make some money here. Not as much as you think, but it's interesting that he's going to make a ton of money. I think he's going to make about $400 million, something like that. He was going to be at the lead of it. And then he's getting sold. I was going to write him saying, oh, this is how it ends, I guess.
But it was FarmVille and what he had done on Facebook was really a big deal way back when. There was all kinds of drama around that company, almost always in terms of how they hired and different people that went in and out of there. They had some great ideas about their virality. So there's some sadness here in terms of it was going to be the Facebook or whatever. And then it's this.
Scott Galloway
He's going to have to settle for $400 million?
Kara Swisher
He's going to have to settle for $400 million.
Scott Galloway
Well, okay.
Kara Swisher
Oh, Don Mattrick was in there, Microsoft's Xbox. Then he left, and then Mark was the CEO, and they brought in this guy who wasn't as well-known, who was from Electronic Arts, Frank Gibeau. Anyway, it's just interesting. This is what's going to happen. You're right. There's a lot of others. A lot of people think that Pinterest should be in there. There's a whole bunch of companies that are at lows. So you're going to see a lot more purchasing going on in the next six months because a lot of them are at lows.
Scott Galloway
Tons and tons of companies are.
Kara Swisher
Pinterest and Twitter. There's going to be interest in everything.
Scott Galloway
Pinterest is the one I'm looking at.
Kara Swisher
Really?
Scott Galloway
Yes. I think it's a bargain.
Kara Swisher
It's a bargain.
Scott Galloway
It's a bargain. Anyway, and they've had ups and downs, but it's down a lot. So we'll see.
Kara Swisher
All right. Let's pivot to a listener question. You've got mail.
Scott Galloway
I can't believe I'm going to be a mailman. You've got mail.
Listener (Hashim): [Voice message] Hi, this is Hashim from the Mojave Desert. I'm a Silicon Valley escapee. My question is what you think the principles of good retail should be as we get through COVID. The pandemic accelerated e-commerce and shook out a lot of bad retail. But coming out of it, there seems to be a desire for physical connection and maybe a new approach to physical retail that isn't all about going to e-commerce. If you were starting a consumer brand, what would you prioritize in a physical experience today? Thanks a lot.
Kara Swisher
That's a great question from Hashim. But why did you go to the Mojave Desert if you're escaping Silicon Valley? I'm thinking Hawaii, Fiji, or Scott's home in Florida where I can send you the map exactly where it is, if you'd like. You answer this one, Scott. You're the retail expert.
Scott Galloway
Well, first off, the desert is the most beautiful ecosystem in the world, Kara. Best sunsets. Anyways, look, you said this. Retail is bifurcating. From a consumer end, retail is bifurcating into either mass efficiency — I can get you everything at a good price within 48 hours to your doorstep — or experience. Whether it's the Museum of Ice Cream, the way you feel in Lululemon where there's someone doing yoga in the room, when you go into a Restoration Hardware and you think, wow, I'd like to hang out here for the entire weekend, or you go into an Apple store and you feel inspired, or a nice young man comes up to you and as a 57-year-old man makes you feel comfortable with him putting tea tree oil on your bags and you somehow feel like, wow, this guy really knows makeup and has incredibly high EQ and their cast is amazing. That was probably a weird example.
But I think it's one or the other. Music festivals are a form of retail. They're going to boom. Merchandising always matters, the voice, but it's bifurcating into experience or efficiency. The new core competence, as led by Amazon, in terms of determining the winners and losers, is having enough capital to rethink and reconfigure post-COVID your supply chain. Whether it's a quick service restaurant that gets over 50% of its orders online, or a company like Urban Outfitters that is now basically an e-commerce company with 550 warehouses called stores. Your ability to buy online, pick up in store, pick up at the curb, seamless returns across channels. Experiential is critical.
Kara Swisher
I almost took a picture today of all my boxes. I'm like such an ad for what's happened. I squished them. I had them all in the basement. Because I'm anal retentive, I organized them lovely out at the curb for the recycling people. But if I try really hard to shop local, it is so frustrating. Nothing's there. It's not just because the supply chain, but you never find what you want. And then Amazon, you find what you want in two seconds. Or Etsy — I've been shopping at Etsy quite a bit lately. And some other places. I was at Macy's the other day. I bought something from Macy's online. Obviously, they have stores, Walmart, all kinds of stuff.
I think the online experience has to be experiential in a creative, pleasing, or you can't get it anywhere else kind of thing. I think people have a tolerance. They may want to get back into stores. The same thing with movie theaters. They've got to have good popcorn or good seats or something that makes it like — if I can do it at home similarly, why would I go there? I know people talk about the social experience, say movies. I don't talk to anyone at the movies. Unless it's a totally packed theater, which you don't find anymore, and it's some Marvel movie or something. I think experiential is the only way to go here. Something special.
Scott Galloway
Correct?
Kara Swisher
Mm-hmm.
Scott Galloway
I like to make things and then put them on Etsy. I'm trying to sell my kids on Etsy. I don't know.
Kara Swisher
That's good platform humor.
Scott Galloway
I like furniture stores. I don't like shopping for furniture. I like to go look. Although, I just bought two chairs without going to a store, and they're very fine. They had a very good experience online. I bought two stores from West Africa. Literally one of my favorite things in the world on weekends is to go to the best furniture store in the world, this BDDW store in Soho, where a lamp costs $45,000, and just walk around and look at it and have them ask me about five times if they can help you, which is their way of saying, get out of here. I love a furniture store. But I literally just started buying furniture online. So I don't know, Hashim. It's got to be fun or interesting. Something.
Kara Swisher
What's old is new again. What's your favorite store?
Scott Galloway
Gosh, that's a really good one. My favorite store? Oh, hands down, BDDW. I think they do an amazing job. And I think Restoration Hardware is an absolute inspiration. I think their grand plazas or whatever they're called. Even if you don't like that furniture, what they've done there. Little things. You know the restaurant on top?
Kara Swisher
Yeah. That's a nice place.
Scott Galloway
But you know what Gary Friedman did with the restaurant? He said, wine, but no alcohol. I don't want a bunch of guys getting drunk up here and making women feel uncomfortable.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's a lot of ladies up there.
Scott Galloway
A lot of ladies. And they feel like they're in Mendocino or in the wine country. The vibe is wonderful. To do that and forego the margins of alcohol, every business person would go, no, that's a bad idea. And he's like, no, we want this to feel like you're in Sonoma. And they buy a sham on the way down, a $4,000 sham. My favorite store ever. What's your favorite?
Kara Swisher
Now my hardware store. I love a hardware store. You can't have an Amazon — Amazon doesn't give you a hardware store experience. I love wandering.
Scott Galloway
I'm just gonna hold my tongue. I'm just gonna hold my tongue. Ask Amanda.
Kara Swisher
I love a hardware store. I know. I'm so happy in a hardware store.
Scott Galloway
You're literally baiting me. You're baiting me right now. This is a ploy to get me canceled. I see what's going on here.
Kara Swisher
Here is what I like. There was a store when I was growing up called Fiorucci. I would take a bus from Princeton, New Jersey to New York to go to Fiorucci. It was delightful. I didn't know what I was going to find there. It was like all these trendy — it was like Z Gallery when I was young. They had the coolest furniture.
Scott Galloway
It's cool. You remember Spencer's Gifts? They had the dirty toys. They had the dirty presents and stuff like that.
Kara Swisher
That's really old. There's so much great retail. I love Super Target. I love roaming around Best Buy. Apple — I guess the Apple store, I suppose.
Scott Galloway
Amazing stores. If Apple opened a coffee store, that would be my new office. I don't order it online. I go there. It's just as easy to order online. Fantastic store. I enjoy it. I'm very happy there.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that would be a good example. Anyway, Hashim, thank you for the good question. I love airport retail. I love Bottega Banana.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I do like airport retail. I love Kiehl's stores. I like airport retail. I like luggage stores at retail. Anyway, we're so strange.
Kara Swisher
The Ramona store. I love Ramona. There are so many amazing great brands right now. I love the new On store — On Running store in Soho does a fantastic job. Le Colombe, that new artisanal coffee place. There's just so much great retail out there, and it has to be great. I think it's called Compass Coffee. It's wonderful.
Scott Galloway
Anyway, that's a good question. Send us more. If you've got a question you're curious about, go to nymag.com/pivot and submit it for the show.
Kara Swisher
All right Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for predictions.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, give us this week's predictions. It's so nice of us remembering good stores. Stores can be wonderful. Anyway, what is your prediction?
Scott Galloway
By the way, I took my boys to Barnes & Noble last weekend. Speaking of stores, it's interesting. They're like, let's go to Barnes & Noble. We went to Barnes & Noble and Chick-fil-A. Unfortunately, I made the mistake of going on Sunday. Jesus getting in the way of my bonding with my kids. Anyways, everyone just totally mocked me on Twitter. I'm like, we're off to Chick-fil-A. I'm like, shithead, it's Sunday.
Anyways, my prediction. We're seeing a lot of really healthy discussion around the concentration of power and the onerous rents it charges on people — whether it's big ag, big pharma, and obviously the one we love, our go-to is big tech. In 2022, we're finally going to see an overdue discussion around big ed. When I say big ed, I mean the cartel that is higher education and their ability to prey on middle-class homes. This dream — or this general feeling that you failed unless you send your kids to college. This rejectionist culture that arbitrages kids down to a Hyundai for the price of a Mercedes, which places huge strain emotionally and financially on middle-class households.
We need more competition. We need to revoke the nonprofit status of any school with an endowment over a billion dollars. It's not growing its freshman seats faster than population. They've decided they're no longer public servants, that they are, in fact, luxury brands. We need to dramatically open the spigot in terms of competition. We need to put schools on the hook for some of that bad debt. Their job isn't to get you debt sponsored by taxpayers that they then cash the check — they have no real incentive to ensure you're able to pay it back because they got their money. They're not on the hook for it.
It is overdue. The conversation around antitrust, around monopoly and big whatever — fill in the blank — is going to move to this talk around big ed. We know the problems, and it stems from the same ugly place: artificial scarcity and monopoly power. Over 2022, you're going to hear the term "Big Ed" more.
Kara Swisher
Big Ed. All right. I'm going to put in a little prediction here.
Scott Galloway
Pinterest. Yeah, go for it.
Kara Swisher
You're going to see some action around Pinterest. I'm just guessing.
Scott Galloway
Pinterest. And who do you think it will be?
Kara Swisher
I don't know. That one I haven't figured out yet. We'll talk about that next week. It's probably going to be PayPal again. You know PayPal's interested. Someone.
Scott Galloway
You're 100% right. That number is so far down. I kind of want to buy it.
Kara Swisher
You're in? You're ready?
Scott Galloway
I'm in. I'm not buying anything. Are you kidding? Let's do it.
Kara Swisher
You know what? We could do a Dow. The jungle cat and the dog Dow. Okay. We're buying Pinterest.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
I just have a — my little spidey sense is tangling.
Scott Galloway
Is tangling. I think he knows something.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, Scott, as usual, what a great show. We are very excited to be going. I'm excited to go to Florida soon. We really do have a really good program. It's coming up and it's going to be great. So buy your tickets and stuff like that. I think we have a lot of people on the list, but please, if you'd like to go, let us know.
Okay, Scott, that's the show. We're observing MLK Day, so we'll be back on Wednesday. But we're not going to not have a show for you because that's the kind of people we are. So we are going to tape on Tuesday and come on Wednesday. Scott, will you read us out?
Today's show was produced by Laura Naiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Mia Silverio. Ernie Entretot engineered this episode.
Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts, or if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify, or frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts.
Thanks for listening to Pivot from Box Media. We'll be back next Wednesday for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Scott Galloway
The greatest assault on middle-class prosperity, the self-aggrandizement, arrogance, and poor commitment to the commonwealth of higher education that is drunk on exclusivity and has raised rents faster than any sector in the world. It is time to break up Big Ed.