Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics including the rise and fall of General Electric (GE), Twitter's plan to bring back banned accounts, the impact of Elon Musk's ownership on the company, and the current state of democracy and politics.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Ad reads
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. Scott Galloway is doing customer research at a Chipotle on Knightsbridge. So today I'm joined by author, journalist, and dear friend of Pivot, Bill Cohen. How you doing, Bill?
William Cohan
I'm great, Kara. I'm so glad to be here with you today. Thank you.
Kara Swisher
Actually, Scott is probably on a plane reading your book right now. Actually, I know where he is. He's going to the World Cup, I think. And we're going to talk about a lot of things today. Your book, by the way, is Power Failure, The Rise and Fall of an American Icon. And it's about GE, which is probably, I don't know how to characterize it compared to today's companies. But give us a quick idea of what it meant to people, GE.
William Cohan
Kara, it was so iconic, a company. If you can imagine Apple, Google, Microsoft, Facebook in the day, Netflix in the day, all rolled up into one company. That was GE. Not only was it a technological leader—a serious leader in technology—it had products that we all took for granted, like electricity generation, light bulbs, aircraft engines, X-ray machines, first electric cars. Under Jack Welch, it became the most valuable company in the world, the most respected company in the world. It spawned so many executives and ways of thinking, management style.
Kara Swisher
Management expertise, management factory.
William Cohan
Exactly. And then, what the hell happened? There's a dead body on the ground. How did it get there? This became a forensic assignment for me, like a corporate autopsy. I felt compelled.
Kara Swisher
Compelled. Why compelled? Why not go do Musk? If Apple disappeared, wouldn't you feel compelled to?
William Cohan
Yes, actually, you're right. That's a really good comparison. I think it really did lead everybody. And Jack Welch, for better or worse, was the iconic CEO for everybody around.
Kara Swisher
And his theories—what was the theory? Six Sigma?
William Cohan
Six Sigma, which he copied from Motorola and his friend Larry Bossidy, who was then the CEO of Allied Signal and had been his right-hand guy at GE. He decided to bring it into GE. You might accept some flaws in baggage handling when you travel—the bag doesn't show up once in a while, you might be okay with that. But with an aircraft engine, you may not want a whole lot of flaws.
Kara Swisher
And it was also a vicious culture, correct? One that was quite...
William Cohan
Well, I worked there for two years out of business school, financing leveraged buyouts at GE Capital, which I was not competent to do. But I learned—I'd been a journalist. Actually, I kind of liked it. It was not coddling by any means. It was Darwinian to some extent, but much more pleasant than Wall Street culture, which is another 15 years. You got rewarded with perks. I got a car to go back and forth to the office, trips around the world, and I wasn't hardly a top performer. Jack made it an incredibly valuable, important company, respected, had to be in everybody's investment fund. That's what made its downfall so disappointing and tragic for so many people. That's why I wanted to figure out what happened, and that's what this book is about, with all the great characters you can possibly imagine.
Kara Swisher
Who's your favorite character in the whole thing?
William Cohan
Jack is such a great and compelling character. I spent a lot of time with him towards the end of his life. He died in March of 2020, right before the pandemic. I'd had six or seven long interviews with him by then. But also people like Dave Cote, a kid from New Hampshire who went on to become the CEO of Honeywell, who Jack had fired and later regretted, wished he'd selected him instead of Jeff Immelt. It was nice to meet Jeff Immelt. It was nice to meet Dave Calhoun, who's the CEO of Boeing. David Zaslav, who's the CEO of Warner Brothers Discovery, has his own problems to handle now. The cast of characters is just fabulous. It really was the crucible.
Kara Swisher
And a lot of companies—there are little crucible companies in tech and stuff like that—but it certainly is important. Today, we'll talk about Twitter's plan, or lack thereof, to bring back banned accounts. Also, we'll look at the latest hurdle in the News Corp Fox reunion. And we'll speak with the author Anand Giridharadas about the latest threats to democracy and how they can be overcome. All right, I guess we have to mention—before we move to Twitter, Elon had a picture of his gun on his bedside table. He was making a joke, as one does with guns on bedside tables. People are very upset about it. It's just another stunt he's playing. There are two non-firing guns: one is a replica of George Washington's flintlock pistol, the other is a replica of a video game revolver from a game he likes to play. It's another stunt. Everybody calm down. Unfortunately, it's distasteful to people like Fred Guttenberg, whose child died in gunfire. It's just tasteless. He's become the expert in stunts—meaningless stunts, throwaway stunts. I don't know whether it's masking what are obviously going to be bigger problems at that company, both financial and operational.
William Cohan
What about the four caffeine-free Diet Coke cans also by his bedside? Why bother?
Kara Swisher
Is that a gun on your bedside table? Are you just overcompensating? Anyway, that's as much as I can say about that. But let's talk about a couple of things. Amazon believes in movie theaters. The company reportedly plans to spend $1 billion a year on theatrical movie releases. Bloomberg reported that Amazon plans to build up production in 2023 with a planned 12 to 15 releases per year after that. Cinemark, IMAX, and AMC stocks jumped after the news. What do you think this is about? The spending in streaming, which you've talked about, a lot of people at Puck have talked about, is really off the charts, and some people are suffering for it. This is a real doubling down in the movie theater area.
William Cohan
It makes sense, Kara. They spent close to $9 billion buying MGM that closed earlier this year. They have a lot of content on Prime Video that they're trying to apply to their Prime customers. It's a way to keep them sticky and keep them on board. There are problems elsewhere in Amazon land, so this might be a nice growth area for them. The Alexa unit had the largest layoffs in company history, for example.
Kara Swisher
Exactly. AWS is off the charts, great. But maybe they have to spin that off. The road to Hollywood is paved with people who hoped to do well there and got their head handed to them. I don't know whether that's going to happen to Amazon at all. But to spend a billion dollars to put movies through another distribution channel is the reverse—coming out of the back way. They started with streaming and now they're going with it. People are going to go back to movie theaters. I can see it happening slowly but surely. Once we think this pandemic is over, hopefully we're not fooling ourselves. But people like...
William Cohan
It'll be lesser down, though. It's not going to come back. The numbers are pretty clear. Streaming from home is so convenient, and with TVs being like many movie screens these days, why not? But there are some movies you do want to see in the theater, or are only available in the theater. I just saw Wakanda Forever, and I had to see it. The Menu was only available in the theater—a rollicking good time if you like people ending up all dead.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I always do like that. But it's interesting that they're spending here when other companies are thinking about cutting back. The issues around Bob Chapek at Disney, for example, had to do with that and others. You also mentioned David Zaslav. It's a really interesting problem they have because the spending is way too high.
William Cohan
Look, it depends if you're a content provider, as we both are. We kind of like a lot of spending. People like the content and appreciate the content. Do the economics work? They were working. Then Netflix lost customers earlier in the year, so there was a revaluation of whether the economics make sense and how to value that. But streaming is not going away. You need to spend on content. Hollywood has always spent on content. Do you need to spend $200 million on a Wakanda Forever? Netflix is spending $17, $18 billion or more a year on content. Amazon is trying to keep pace. Disney is keeping pace. David Zaslav has to try to keep pace. It's a very expensive game. They're trying to get the economics in line. Netflix—I think investors completely overreacted to losing customers. The stock has done a lot better lately. It's been the best performing stock of the year, one of them in the last six months. Having 220 million people paying you money every month is not something to sneeze at. They'll make it work. I have confidence in that management team.
Kara Swisher
So this move into movie theaters is a good thing?
William Cohan
Why not? Netflix has movies coming out of movie theaters. You have to. This is just another venue, another avenue, another distribution network that they weren't in. Sure. And MGM's movies have always been in movie theaters. The Bond movies, et cetera.
Kara Swisher
And they don't have full rights over those, which is interesting. Another topic—you mentioned Apple as big as GE and if something happened to it. Right now, workers are revolting over COVID policies at the world's largest iPhone factory in China, actually all over China, over these very stringent COVID policies the government has. China's zero COVID policy requires extreme lockdowns, but factories are allowed to stay open if employees are living on the site. Employees at Foxconn in central China, which makes a lot of the iPhones, complain about sharing rooms with COVID-positive workers, about being misled, about compensation. Disruptions are significant. Protests have broken out throughout China over these policies, including some that call for the removal of Xi Jinping, which is unusual. Talk a little bit about this. Apple is trying to build capacity outside of China and Taiwan with facilities in India and even the U.S. How do you look at this from a global perspective, from a business perspective? It's really dragging down the stock market and other things.
William Cohan
I'm no expert on Chinese politics, but obviously the COVID lockdowns—people are reaching their breaking point. People are human everywhere. If that were the case here, we'd be freaking out. Unfortunately, we've tolerated a much higher death toll and infection toll than China did. Maybe now with things easing on those fronts—still, 250 people dying a day, maybe.
Kara Swisher
They aren't as infected. They didn't have as much COVID there. Or so we're told.
William Cohan
Maybe they have and we don't know. These lockdowns are trying to keep it contained, and people have been fed up with that. We have vaccines here and many people have used them. I've had five vaccines, and I'm happy to have them. This is an increasing political problem in China, and it's going to probably increasingly affect what Apple can get out of China in terms of its products. But I suspect Tim Cook and the smart people out there—they have to diversify the supply chain. From a human rights perspective, from a supplies perspective, this has been, except for the app store stuff here in this country, its biggest vulnerability, presumably.
Kara Swisher
I agree with that. But we haven't really heard about shortages of product, right? They probably have too many Apple iPhone 14s at the moment. I see them being Black Friday, Cyber Monday discounted. So it is a potential problem. There are solutions they are working on. It takes time to build a new factory.
William Cohan
Absolutely. I think it's their biggest challenge. I suspect Tim Cook is certainly up to that challenge.
Kara Swisher
It's not a good look to have this go on and people getting beaten. Apple gets dragged right back into those stories from before, which is the treatment of workers at those factories. But interestingly, anyone looking for news of protests on Twitter will have a hard time. On Sunday, numerous Chinese language accounts flooded Twitter with links to escort services and other spam alongside names of Chinese cities. The Twitter team that has been fighting that has been radically downsized. And that gets us to our first big story. The band shall tweet again. Elon Musk announced that nearly all previously suspended accounts will be welcomed back on Twitter, perhaps as early as this week.
Musk says the accounts that broke the law or posted spam would remain banned, and I guess they're sorting those out, but Twitter hasn't announced a plan for how they'll make that distinction. One Harvard instructor called the move "existentially dangerous for various marginalized communities" and said that Apple and Google should consider removing Twitter from the Apple store. They have not said anything. I certainly know they're looking at it from people I know inside the companies. They're watching it carefully. It would be a big move on their part to do something like that, but they've done it before with Parler, and that was an unusual situation.
What do you think about these returning accounts and what's happening there?
William Cohan
For any other person, any other company, this would be both a financial and operational existential crisis. The company would be teetering on the edge of bankruptcy and might yet, honestly. But since it's owned privately by the richest man in the world, who is still pretty rich even though Tesla stock is down and Twitter is looking like a financial wipeout at the moment, he can probably weather a lot of this and is probably willing to weather it for reasons I do not for the life of me understand. To bring back banned accounts is a high beta move. How long has it been since Trump was allowed back? A week or two? I don't think I've seen any Trump tweets yet. That's an interesting dynamic. Trump has a contractual obligation with Truth Social that he seems to be observing, which is quite out of character for him. I'm wondering when the dam is going to break on that front. Other banned accounts coming back—after he said he was going to set up a committee and let there be a vetting process, he seems to have blown through all of that.
Kara Swisher
What does this do to the advertising business? I had heard that they have gone down to $400 million from $1.5 billion, or something like that, from different people internally. It's a significant decline in advertising, and that's a significant amount of their revenue. Explain to people what will happen when that happens.
William Cohan
Twitter is not much of a business from a profitability point of view. EBITDA has been roughly a billion dollars on a good year, when advertising has been robust at $5 billion a year. If that's coming down substantially, he's got $13 billion of debt that is owned by his banks who did not sell that off. They still own it. They didn't sell it off because they knew if they did, they were going to have to perfect a 50% loss—a $6.5 billion loss. So they are pretending that loss is not really there. They're going to hold on to the debt at least into 2023.
Kara Swisher
Explain why they're holding on to the debt for people. This is $13 billion in debt that they have lent him against some of his shares in a declining asset, correct?
William Cohan
The debt is secured by the assets of Twitter, as opposed to maybe his stock being part of that asset base too. Basically the assets of Twitter—buildings, intellectual capital, code, cash flow. $13 billion on—it's ironic because there's never been an LBO with more equity in it. There's $31 billion of equity, $24 billion of which came from Elon, $7 billion came from friends of Elon. So there's a lot of equity. But there's also $13 billion of debt on what was a billion dollars of EBITDA. That's 13 times EBITDA. Now that's going to be less than a billion. So now we're talking serious junk territory on this debt, even though it's senior secured debt. Given that and the fact that interest rates have increased dramatically since this deal was first cut back in April, the banks, in order to sell this debt, have to—
Kara Swisher
Take a shower.
William Cohan
Have to price it to yield at a much higher level than it would be given the current interest rate they're getting out of Elon and Twitter. To do that, they have to discount the debt to sell it. People have told me something like 50% would be where it would clear the market. That's a $6.5 billion wipeout on their $13 billion of debt.
Kara Swisher
Which they'd have to put on their books, correct?
William Cohan
Absolutely.
Kara Swisher
And then who buys that? You've talked about this. Musk would have to buy this debt. Could he buy it and then make money on it?
William Cohan
Normally, who would buy it would be investors all around the world—Japanese banks, investment funds, Apollo, whoever. Now, if Elon were really smart—he doesn't listen to me, but if he were really smart, this is my theory of the case at the moment. I think he's shit-coining or shit-talking Twitter continuously and doing all these ridiculously stupid, erratic, operationally questionable things to spook the banks, so that the value of their debt decreases even further, so they'll take anything that Elon offers them. If Elon came along and said, "I'll give you 50 cents on the dollar," they'll leap at it because the chances of it going to zero due to looming bankruptcy—if he doesn't make interest payments, the first one is coming in April, then they can file an involuntary bankruptcy on him. Why not try to shit-talk this thing down so he can buy the bank debt from them at a severe discount and retire it?
Kara Swisher
Why would they give it to him versus an Apollo or someone else? Why would they sell it to him?
William Cohan
Because he would agree to pay more for it.
Kara Swisher
I see. So he would pay more for it, but he's trying to bring it down to a price that's affordable for him.
William Cohan
It's a balancing act. Talk it down so that when he offers them 45 cents on the dollar, they think to themselves, "Oh my God." Then they'll go out and try to sell it to Apollo, and Apollo will say 35 cents. So suddenly Elon's 45 cents looks pretty great, even though in a normal situation it should be trading much higher. Then he owns the whole thing—both the debt and the equity. Then at least nobody can file an involuntary bankruptcy on him.
Kara Swisher
And he does that because... it's throwing good money after bad, potentially.
William Cohan
Right. But that way he's got control. Then he doesn't have that much money—it's billions, but it's not unaffordable. For anybody else, this would be a non-starter type of behavior. Then he could fix it up and sell it off. Fix it up, work his miracle, whatever it is that he does that turns out to be a miracle. He's so much smarter than everybody else that we never anticipated anybody could possibly do this. But because he's the brilliant Elon Musk, he turns it around. As I was talking to Martin Sorrell, he said they've only got a tiny fraction of the digital advertising market. If somehow he turns this around and advertisers flock back to it—which I don't really see how that's going to happen—but if it does, because he's much smarter than we are, then he'll turn around and sell it or take it public again. I don't really know who really wants this. Who's going to pay more than $44 billion for this thing?
Kara Swisher
Right. Except investors that like him.
William Cohan
That's right. And then it goes for $100. That's the only thing I can see him doing. Otherwise, it's a total wipeout. And it's fine for him because he's worth whatever, $200 billion. But the people who ponied up the $7 billion—my favorite story is Prince Al-Walid, who invested $300 million or so early on in Twitter. His Twitter stock at $54.20 was worth $1.9 billion. He could have taken that in cash a month ago. Instead, he rolled it over. That equity may be worth zero now.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. They'll all eat it, and he won't. Elon will own the thing, and they'll have no power. He controls it all. There's no board of directors. Some of this stuff—he's sort of lurching far right in an interesting way. A researcher and self-described Antifa member, Chad Loder, was banned after he tweeted about an alleged hack of Twitter user data. An anarchist publication, CrimeThink, was banned after far-right troll Andy Ngo brought it to Elon Musk's attention. He brought back Babylon Bee. He tweeted and deleted the defense of a police officer who killed Mike Brown in Ferguson in 2014. In the early hours of Monday morning, he tweeted that photo of the gun. You think these are all stunts—a stunt after a stunt after a stunt, correct?
William Cohan
That's my impression. Again, if there's any internal logic to Elon Musk at all, it's that he's doing these things to freak out the banks even further so they'll sell him the debt at a lower price.
Kara Swisher
What is the word on Wall Street? When you talk to them, what do they say? They'll have lunch with anybody, presumably. They'll do a deal with anybody. But what do they say?
William Cohan
They say, "My God, how did we get in bed with this madman, and why did we agree to finance this deal?" I'm sure Morgan Stanley is scratching their heads saying, "Why did we agree to get involved in this?" But on the other side, on the Twitter side, they're laughing all the way to the bank. Goldman Sachs and JPMorgan Chase did minimal work because deciding this thing was fair was the easiest thing that ever happened in the history of Wall Street, and they got paid $50 million or whatever.
Kara Swisher
And they avoided the $13 billion debt deal.
William Cohan
And they would suck right back up to him if he went public. All of them would. I'm sure they would be more than happy to underwrite an IPO if it actually became something that was IPO-able.
Kara Swisher
Is there any world where Google and Apple remove the Twitter app? I know they're looking at it. They're watching it. They did this with Parler. Musk is saying if Google and Apple ban him, he'll make his own phone, which is delusional as far as I can tell. This would be a big decision on their part. It would have to get very dangerous in that place, I think. Personally, I would like them to do that because then that would be it. I wouldn't have Twitter on my phone anymore. That's the excuse I'm looking for. I really know I don't want Twitter on here anymore, but I just can't push that delete button. But if it's banned on the app store, then it's gone and I can't get it. That's just for you, Bill. But do you imagine them doing this?
William Cohan
It's way too big. It's a big call. This is what he's hoping for—the same thing with the banks. He's hoping that they won't push a button that he will.
Kara Swisher
Well, the banks—he'll get a benefit from because he'll be able to buy the debt at a discount. If Apple and Google take it off their app store, I don't see how that benefits Elon Musk in any way.
William Cohan
It's not good for them, though. He can throw a tizzy, presumably. He's good at tizzies. If a tree falls in the forest and no one's there to hear it, does it make a sound? If you can't get it on your iPhone or your Google phone, where are you getting it? I don't think they're going to do it. I think they're watching it, and they'll do it if they have to. It's the last thing they want to do, from my perspective.
Kara Swisher
Sure. I agree with that because their customers like the product. But if other alternatives to Twitter get critical mass, then that probably makes it a little easier. Twitter will go the way of MySpace, but it's going to take a while.
William Cohan
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Speaking of Musk, he was attacking Sam Bankman-Fried and the fallout. Talk a little bit about your writing about this and the guy who's taking over for what's happened here. Give me a read on where this goes. There are people who are still bullish on crypto. ARK Investments, Cathie Wood—she kind of has to be. She bought over a million dollars of Grayscale's Bitcoin trust shares. She thinks Bitcoin is going to a million dollars.
William Cohan
Yes, she does.
Kara Swisher
What do you call her? A nincompoop?
William Cohan
She's a nincompoop slash delusional, yes. And has been for a while.
Kara Swisher
Explain where this goes. Part of me thinks this is a repeat of the Internet bubble in 1999, March 2000, when everything melted down.
William Cohan
I was there. I thought that was the end of the Internet. But guess what? It was actually the beginning of the Internet. It was the end of the beginning and the beginning of the next viable, useful phase of the Internet, when real companies sprung up providing real services, making real products they could make money from.
Kara Swisher
And real profits.
William Cohan
Massively real profits. So I think this is a fire that burns out the underbrush from the forest floor. Out of that, some green shoots are going to crop up. If there's any hope for cryptocurrency and the technology behind it—the blockchain and the rails that Sam Bankman-Fried liked to talk about, he talked about that when I interviewed him—then we need to get all of this gone. FTX is gone, the tethers, the binances—everything that has been, no offense to anybody, a massive Ponzi scheme or certainly seems that way. We have to clear all of this garbage out. All of it has to go. Then you're left with this pure technology that may be useful. I don't know if it will be or not. But if there's going to be any hope for this technology that the maximalists believe in and talk about till you're blue in the face, then this has to happen and is happening. Then we'll see where we go from there.
Kara Swisher
Tell me why people didn't catch him. You interviewed him. I never did a long interview with him. Why wasn't it picked up from your perspective on him?
He sort of was the adult in the room, even though he looked like a 12-year-old boy. And sounded like a 12-year-old pre-adolescent child.
William Cohan
Look, Kara, I interviewed him last December for 90 minutes for this crypto movie I've been working on that I had the honor of also interviewing you for. Think about it. Last December, crypto was, Bitcoin was at like 69,000 at its all-time high. He was still 29, so he was the youngest, the wealthiest person in the world, under 30, worth 25 billion. His company was about to be valued at $32 billion a month later by quote-unquote smart investors. You know, MIT physics grad, carefully selected to go work at Jane Capital. Both of his parents were professors at Stanford Law School. I mean, hello, I'm just a regular human being, right?
Kara Swisher
Right, right.
William Cohan
I'm not an Ubermensch. There's no way I would think to criticize him or question him. So I have a lot of admiration for people who did see this coming and questioned all of this. And they're kind of far and few between because most everybody was on board. The mainstream media was on board, cover of Forbes, cover of Fortune. I mean, obviously, he shows up on a cold December night, disheveled, wearing his uniform of short sleeve shirt and cargo pants and his hair every which way. I mean, who am I to question any of that? And so, of course, I didn't. I just asked him what it was all about, et cetera, and got his story for 90 minutes, which was fascinating to be able to see it all dissolve in a classic way. I wrote a book about the collapse of Bear Stearns. It just disappeared in a week. FTX disappeared in a week. The only difference was Bear Stearns had been around for 85 years and was highly regulated. FTX was unregulated, been around for three years.
Kara Swisher
Right.
William Cohan
And they hadn't been keeping records. They had been spending it on Bahama real estate, and everything like that. How could people have caught it? When you think about things like that, at one point, Matt Levine said, "This sounds like a Ponzi scheme." I think that's the toughest many of the interviews have gotten. And he's like, "Yeah, it kind of is." Which was ha-ha versus, how would you have found this out? It's a really interesting question, and that's the one I think is an important question.
Kara Swisher
I remember when Elizabeth Holmes was on all the covers. We never had her on because I didn't understand it, and that's how I felt about him. I was like, I don't understand this quite right. I don't get it. I don't get it. I don't know who's minding the store. I don't know these people, which was lucky on my part in a lot of ways, not prescient in any way.
William Cohan
Well, it was a total black box, right? I mean it was offshore in the Bahamas where they venue shopped specifically to be there to be free of regulation. But then he did things that ended up pissing off his brethren in the crypto space by trying to seek out regulation and try to testify in Washington, all of which-
Kara Swisher
Make him look better.
William Cohan
Well, or maybe manipulate it and give all this money to Democratic politicians and to try to sort of get the regulation that FTX could live with or wanted, pissing off CZ at Binance. And of course, that became the tipping point, right? Because CZ had been an early investor in FTX, wanted his investment back. That clever Sam paid him back with the token, the FTT token that they had manufactured and propped up, and he had 500 million of it. Well, basically, that was a gun that he had to Sam's head, just like the Chinese are our largest creditor. If they wanted to flood the world with dollars, that would probably have an effect on the value of the dollar. So CZ decides to say he will flood the market with FTT tokens that are rendered. They couldn't support.
Kara Swisher
Right, and completely worthless.
William Cohan
And so that brought the whole house of cards down.
Kara Swisher
Well, and also Carolyn Ellison, I thought she was a poker player, but apparently not. She set a price. And the minute she said that price, the dogs came, right? I mean, it was $22. As I said the other day, the children all scurried away like cockroaches when the lights come on. I mean, there were literally no adults in the room, let alone this 30-year-old guy who seemed like a child. They all lived together at their $30 million house or apartment in the Bahamas. Unlike what we're used to where, you know, Google, the kids get Eric Schmidt, supposedly the adult in the room.
William Cohan
Yeah, he was.
Kara Swisher
We talk about that all day, whether he really is or not. But there was no even attempt at that here. So what happens next? Very quickly.
William Cohan
What happens next is that hopefully the bankruptcy judge appoints an examiner who has subpoena power and can actually get to the bottom of whether this was a massive fraud or not. If it was a massive fraud with mens rea that Sam Bankman-Fried knew what he was doing and Carolyn and all of them, then off they go to Butner.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's where they go.
William Cohan
If it's just mislabeling, as Sam likes to say, maybe we'll know more when he speaks at the New York Times conference on Wednesday.
Kara Swisher
Yikes.
William Cohan
Yikes is right. Against his lawyer's wishes, I'm sure. Then we'll see what happens to him. But he's probably fleeing something out right now.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Five years, and here's what you need to know about these other people.
William Cohan
Right. Yeah, we'll see.
Kara Swisher
All right, Bill, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, there's an opposition to the Murdoch family reunion, and we'll speak with a friend of Pivot about how to save democracy.
Ad break
Bill, we're back. Let's talk some media news. First, Rupert Murdoch's plan to reunite News Corp and Fox faces opposition from a powerful shareholder. Independent Franchise Partners wants to explore breaking up News Corp. I don't know how much power it has. It's sort of like the Altimeter people over at Facebook at Meta. Rather than merge it with Fox, IFP is the largest shareholder that opposed this deal, but joins other shareholders who voiced opposition. What will happen here?
William Cohan
You know, this reminds me of the CBS Viacom merger, that if it weren't for Shari Redstone, it would never have re-merged. I mean, her father, Sumner, separated them for a reason, right? And the managements at both those companies were happy with that arrangement. Shari decided, "Hey, we own both of these things. It's going to be easier to sell if we put them back together." There was a lot of opposition to that. But of course, once Les Moonves was deposed, that was the end of that. And they were combined. But the stock has not done very well at all, even though Warren Buffett has sort of backed up the truck to what is now called Paramount Global. Same thing is going on here, basically. I think the Murdochs think that if they combine these two things into one company, it'll be easier to sell. But I really don't think that the Wall Street Journal people want to be put in the same boat with the Fox News people.
Kara Swisher
People again, right?
William Cohan
Again, right? They separated them for a reason. They also have real estate. They've got HarperCollins. They've got a lot of stuff.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they've got a lot of things that don't want to necessarily be in the same boat as Fox.
William Cohan
And I don't think it's necessarily going to make it easier to sell, just like it's not easier to sell Paramount Global. So this is very ill-advised, in my opinion. And the CBS Viacom thing went to Delaware court and it was going to be hashed out there until Les Moonves got deposed, overthrown, and perhaps rightly so. And this, I don't know whether it'll go to Delaware court or I don't think they'll sue to block it, but they might. But there might be some lawsuits to try to block this thing.
Kara Swisher
But you don't think it's a particularly good idea, correct?
William Cohan
No, I mean, it was separated for a reason, and there's no reason to put them back together.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, so keeping them apart would be, they could sell the pieces off if they wanted. Assume they're anticipating Rupert Murdoch's demise at some point, if he ever dies.
William Cohan
You know, Sumner Redstone thought he would never die either.
Kara Swisher
That's true, yeah.
William Cohan
I mean, I think they put it together because it's easier, they think, for tax purposes. It might be less of a tax bite or something out there together.
Kara Swisher
Right, but there's no synergistic idea behind this, except that they want it. The Murdochs want this. The question is, will they get it? But I think they have to get the majority of the minority, the non-Murdoch voters, and that might be tough here. Yeah. So one deal that News Corp doesn't seem to be part of, the streaming rights to NFL Sunday Ticket negotiations that are said to be ongoing and could stretch into 2023. Apple, Disney, and Amazon are all rumored to be contenders with a lot more money, with Apple supposedly the favorite. This is bad, correct? How important is this deal?
William Cohan
Well, I mean, there's a lot of potential money here and it's what people watch, Kara.
Kara Swisher
Yes, not me. Not Cara Swisher, but yes, indeed.
William Cohan
But you know, other people, as they would say on Seinfeld. Live sporting events are extremely popular and the NFL is the most popular of live sporting events in this country, just week after week after week after week, even though the product is not quite as much fun as it used to be or as exciting. But this is a big deal and I'm sure it'll be a blockbuster whenever it happens. So we wait a little while longer, but it's going to be a blockbuster.
Kara Swisher
And what about Disney in here?
William Cohan
Well, I mean, ABC, they sure. Disney's got to be a player. Apple's a player. Amazon's a player. Fox is a player. High price, Kara. High price. Big numbers. Big numbers.
Kara Swisher
Last very quick question. Successful second term for Bob Iger. Are you bullish or sort of worried?
William Cohan
Well, he's only got a two-year term. His big question is, who's his successor going to be? And my partner at Puck, Matt Belloni, yesterday tried to lay some of those names out. Dana Walden, Dana Walden, Andrew Peter Rice, things like that. It was fun to read, and it's a big choosing. He blew it once, and now he's got to get it right the second time. He'd better. But I'll tell you something, the stock price doesn't improve. Now that you've got Dan Loeb and Trian Partners, Nelson Peltz, in there.
Kara Swisher
Nelson Peltz, yeah.
William Cohan
Iger may not last the two years.
Kara Swisher
Oh, wow. And they're at cross, they're different opinions, correct, those two activists?
William Cohan
Well, I mean, Nelson Peltz apparently didn't want Iger to come back, but that's water under the dam. He's back. Now he's just a shareholder who wants that stock price to go up, just like Dan Loeb is. And if they don't get that and it doesn't start happening soon and going in the right direction, now we had a few good days last week and we'll see.
Kara Swisher
Yes, the Bob Iger sheen. It's a very good sheen. It's a happy sheen. It's a nice sheen.
William Cohan
But if it doesn't really polish that apple to the satisfaction of Nelson Peltz and Dan Loeb, do not fool around. They're not like passive investors. They'll find somebody who does, especially Nelson Peltz. He didn't want Bob Iger to come back in the first place.
Kara Swisher
Right, right.
William Cohan
And by the way, he got rid of Jeff Immelt at GE and then also got rid of John Flannery at GE. So they don't fool around. They don't not fool around. They want a sock up Bob Iger.
Kara Swisher
Just from the Disney Town Hall, it just wrapped. Iger says no M&A in the near future, which means one of the things he told me was that Disney was barely big enough, which he can't buy the Warners, et cetera, or make some sexy merger at all. The hiring freeze remains in place. He's got a tough road. Bob Iger. This is not the same environment that he left in.
William Cohan
No, he's got a lot to do. He's got to basically unwind what his successor, Bob, did. And he's got to try to satisfy now Dan Loeb and Nelson Peltz.
Kara Swisher
What would you do? Give me one thing you'd do, and then we're going to get to our friend at Pivot.
William Cohan
You know, I guess you've got to get Hulu on board and you've got to reduce $50 billion of debt. It's too much debt. You got to do something. Spin off ESPN.
Kara Swisher
Well, if you can spin off the do what the ESPN, what AT&T did to Time Warner.
William Cohan
Yeah. Warner. Yeah. Just spin it off.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. That would be a big move.
William Cohan
That would be a big move. They weren't going to do it. Spin it off with debt, though. Spin it off with debt.
Kara Swisher
All right. Let's bring in our friend of Pivot. Anand Giridharadas is a journalist and the author of "The Persuaders: On the Front Lines of the Fight for Hearts, Minds, and Democracy." Welcome, Anand. How are you doing?
Anand Giridharadas
I'm great. How are you?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's so interesting. Your book is coming out about persuasion at a time when there's a lot going on about culture wars and polarization. And you profile people bridging the gap. But talk about, has it changed at all since the book came out? You've got this Twitter sale. We've got a little bit more polarization. We had the midterms. I'd love to get your sort of overview of where you are with this book in the midst of all this noise, I guess.
Anand Giridharadas
I mean, it's just intensified. We're in this moment where I think one thing that is widely shared across this country is people want things to change. People have different things they want to change, but there's a widely shared sense that we're not on the right track, that big things need to change if our kids are going to have a decent shot at a future. And yet we can't change anything. It just feels stuck. It feels like we can't change people's minds and therefore in a democracy, it's impossible to change things. And so the book is really a journey among people who I think show a way out of the kinds of conversations that get stuck on Twitter and that are getting more stuck now that it's owned by a two-year-old, and the kinds of conversations that get stuck in our families.
We just had Thanksgiving, the kinds of family conversations that get stuck at work. I think there is another way forward where we can reach people and bring people into the visions of the world we want while standing bravely for things, not diluting what we want in order to reach people, but standing bravely for things and reaching people. And I wrote the book because a lot of people out there doing this work on the ground knew things I didn't know, and I wanted to learn from them.
Kara Swisher
All right, but you just called the current owner of Twitter a two-year-old, which is not persuasive. It is a joke, I believe.
Anand Giridharadas
Oh, it's very persuasive. This is the thing, right? This is actually one of the core things of the book. Persuasion is not all about softening what you say to win over some imagined moderate or to win over the target of someone like Elon Musk. A big part of persuasion is rallying people to get more excited about the thing they may latently feel. And so, I don't literally believe Elon Musk is two. I think he's about 11. But I think there's a problem that a lot of us understand latently that need to be more focused on, which is that the highly limited men of Silicon Valley who you spent your career covering and making wake up in the middle of the night fearing your call. These highly limited men are now pushing us to being a highly limited democracy, highly limited society, because their own personal limitations have kind of become the limitations of our discourse, of our ability to speak to each other. I personally do not think the national or international conversation should be moderated by people who couldn't have a functional conversation with you at a party.
Kara Swisher
All right. So what messages do work? Republicans say "Build a wall." Democrats say "You'll get health care voucher and taxable savings account. You make X percent," which is more wonky. What is working now? Obviously, the midterm elections, the voters said a lot by their voting. Weren't listening to the noise, weren't listening to the yelling, weren't listening to the limit necessarily.
Anand Giridharadas
Look, I think this book in some ways is about organizers in particular, although I write about a lot of different people. What they all share in common is kind of a background in organizing and on the ground organizing as opposed to national limelight political work. And I think there's an organizer's playbook that does work and is working. So a couple elements of it. I think folks on the political left, I would say the pro-democracy side in general, are just not as good at commanding attention as some of the kind of bad actors in American life. And so commanding attention is really, really important.
Someone like AOC is very good at it. And you kind of see the difference between her and the entire rest of her party. Attention, for all the reasons you understand and have covered in your career, is just an incredibly important skill in this media and kind of technological infrastructural moment. Another thing is meaning making. Organizers think a lot about how do you stand with voters, with citizens 24-7, 365, through a process of them making sense of the world, not just transactionally ask them for votes and $5, right? And again, you see the Democratic Party is very much there in the big moments when it wants something from you.
"Go vote, go vote, go vote." But there is a longer term process that is happening in this country of real profound change, change in gender relations, change in race and demographics, change in LGBT rights, demands of all kinds of people to be seen and recognized and treated well. And I think that has led to, and by the way, trade, economy, tech, China, like all these things that have really discombobulated a lot of people's sense of who they are and how they fit in and what the future will be for them. And I think the far right has in many ways done better at walking with people through those psychological transitions and dislocations.
"You don't feel what it means to be a man anymore in your town? Well, let's spin you a whole story about how your manhood is being threatened by XYZ actors." And I think the political left, the pro-democracy side at this point, has not walked with people through the deeper structure of psychological transitions that I believe are at the heart of what is roiling our politics. Policy issues, the issues we often talk about in the news every day, are downstream of very deep things happening in the American body politic, primarily psychological, emotional things, people not feeling safe and whole in the world.
And I think we need folks who believe in democracy to get better at that.
Kara Swisher
But we keep voting for gridlock. I mean, we seem to like gridlock. Each president, whether it was Obama or Trump, love him or hate him. Biden, love him or hate him. They get their first two years where you can try to get things done and then it's either two or four more or six years of gridlock and we seem very happy with that. That seems a little antithetical to this idea of persuading people to either be active or to change things.
Anand Giridharadas
Well, I mean our system is in some ways designed to create gridlock and it was designed to create a kind of generative gridlock. If you go back to the debates of the founding fathers, they thought gridlock would lead to compromise and people representing rural areas and urban areas in ways that didn't railroad one or the other. And that was a good concept. And that was sort of what I studied in college and grad school was a very powerful concept at the time. Unfortunately, they didn't anticipate social media, money and politics, all kinds of other things that are new that have weaponized the checks and balances of our system to basically make us ungovernable.
At this point, it's an ungovernable country, in part because of these negative forces that have grafted onto deep parts of our structure that were designed to prevent tyranny, and now are being weaponized to create new forms of tyrannical threats. So it's a very big problem. And we need several deep structure reforms, like getting all money out of politics, like dealing with things like, not going to happen in any foreseeable way. I think we can make it more expensive to give money in politics. I think we can have disclosure requirements and things that make it more trouble than it's worth. And then the kinds of reforms which people are talking about in terms of gerrymandering, in terms of the Senate.
I mean, all would fall in the "not going to happen" category unless we are able to really have a pro-democracy movement that builds a big swelling case over a period of years to the public for these values.
Kara Swisher
Ungovernable country, which is the words you just used, is not what anyone wants to hear. I mean, that's scary.
Anand Giridharadas
It is scary. And this is why, part of why it's ungovernable is because I think people have given up on the idea of persuasion. And so my prayer with this book is that folks will reclaim the idea of persuasion, even if we are tribally divided on different sides of different issues. On many other issues in our lifetime, most notably, I would say, the status of gay people in this society, but many other issues. There have been huge, huge shifts institutionally in terms of mores and values. We're also living through bigger shifts than we realize: the status of women in our lifetime, the conversation around race. I mean, how many white people had their parents or grandparents grow up thinking about whiteness as a thing that anyone had ever thought about? So this is a good thing.
Kara Swisher
Now, listen, some writers like Ezra Klein argue that polarization is parties sorting themselves into alignment on policies like drugs, immigration, race. And isn't it good if the Democratic Party has fewer people who support regressive and racist policies? Yeah. Isn't it good to make that stand?
Anand Giridharadas
At the core of the book, I actually agree with that to the extent that I don't think polarization, which is to say people being on different sides of an issue, maybe on more, is necessarily bad. I actually don't think anger and division are necessarily bad, right? I mean, politics is about, if we got a hundred bucks left in the society, do we help your aging parents or my school-aged children first? Those are rough issues. They're going to get rough. It's supposed to be rough. I think the problem is contempt and dismissal, right? Being angry at you may drive me more towards politics and democracy and wanting to get in the arena.
Thinking you are just who you are, you are never going to be susceptible to any kind of change. "You think that way because you are that way. You will never move. You didn't want the vaccine last year. You're never going to get it this year. You voted for Trump once. You will never not vote for him." That kind of contempt and dismissal and fatalism is the enemy of democracy. And the book, in many ways, is an attempt to say, we can be polarized. We can be angry. This stuff's going to get real because it's intense. But we can't allow ourselves to lapse into the view that nothing can change. People can't change because people can and do change all the time.
And there are amazing persuaders on the ground right now, changing people's minds, showing how it's done, and we can learn from them.
Kara Swisher
And the return of Donald Trump, if it happens, is that going to be good or bad for the persuasion theory?
Anand Giridharadas
I mean, look, it's a funny mix of the two, right? In the sense that I think he is so, in some ways, discredited right now that you probably have some near-term successes for the pro-democracy side because he's in the arena. I think his announcement probably makes the runoff in Georgia much more favorable to Democrats, so on and so forth. However, I am not of the view that it's good to have him in the arena because I think he's just existentially dangerous. And I think there is a part of the critique of the book, a kind of loving critique of the book to my own friends on the pro-democracy side is, I don't think we're out competing him fair and square. I mean, there's a whole bunch of rigged stuff to be sure. And this election stuff they're doing and all the ginning up of fake results and audits, it's all BS and it's all real. However, I think in an honest war of ideas, I do not think pro-democracy people are clearly out-competing American fascism as it might.
Kara Swisher
Or narrative building. You're talking about narrative building. Narrative building is at the heart of it. Who is telling the better story about America right now? A story that is simple, clear, easy to understand. I mean, all three of us are in the business of talking to a ton of people, reading a ton of documents, reading a bunch of data, and then you got to just take it all in and tell people something, right? People don't want all the data you read to understand how to think about Silicon Valley. They over-lecture and they get tsk-tsky. I mean, I'm just in the middle of something right now. And I'm like, either go or stay. I don't care. And that was, you know what I mean? Like, pick your poison. So who is a good, we have to finish up, but who is a good persuader right now from who you think and who is not?
Anand Giridharadas
So I think AOC is a remarkable example of the attention point. How do you actually shift the entire conversation of the country by wearing a dress or introducing a certain policy that may never happen, but that can reframe how people think? I think if you look at Gavin Newsom, governor of California, there's a real sense of fight that has been missing in virtually every other Democrat of his profile. It's OK to pick fights. It's OK to not go high when they go low. I think he's demonstrating that in a powerful way. I think if you look at some of the incredible local civic stuff that came out of the pandemic, mutual aid and other things, Democratic Socialists of America doing this, the sense of home building as part of movement building, not just asking people for votes, but building IRL community.
The Democratic Party does not do this. The Democratic Party does not meet up in real life. It's not in your neighborhood. It's not in your building the way it used to be 100 years ago when center-left parties were dominant around the world, where if you got a weird letter from the IRS, Mildred on the third floor from the local Democratic Party person would help you. That's gone. That infrastructure needs to be rebuilt, and there's local groups showing how that's done.
Kara Swisher
And who's bad at it?
Anand Giridharadas
I think the Democratic Party as an institution, as opposed to individual candidates, is really bad at it. The kind of organs of the Democratic senatorial campaign, the congressional one. I think there's just a real deficit of speech making right now. Could any of us on this call think about the last time we heard a great line? Like, just a great line. We all know so many lines from past eras. I was at the FDR Memorial in Washington, a lot of great lines sprinkled around there. Are there any that you remember from the last, I don't know, 10 years? So I think the Democratic Party's institution has become very sclerotic and needs to do this.
At part, we need to tell a story about America that is thrilling and exciting and galvanizing, not just lecturing, not just talking about the problematic things, although there are problematic things, but offering a thrilling vision of a country that's going somewhere, that's going through some of these hardships because it's trying to do a hard thing of building a multiracial democracy with liberty and justice for all people. This is a cool pursuit. It's an awesome pursuit. It's a pursuit actually a lot of countries in the world are not engaged in. And we are. And I think we need to make it inviting to people and build a movement that people want to get in on.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. You mean the Grievance Olympics isn't working for anybody?
Anand Giridharadas
No. It may not be. I don't think that is. And it doesn't. It just, it doesn't. I'll tell you. I think a lot of people have reached their limit on that. One of the best tweets I ever saw. What?
I lost track of it, but it was someone who said, the secret to winning in politics is to have your side not be totally exhausting. That's a good one.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, Anand, his book is called *The Persuaders: At the Front Lines of the Fight for Hearts, Minds, and Democracy*. Thank you so much. And I like this, Anand. It's not as, you know, you were yelling at billionaires before, but this is much more hopeful. I like it.
Anand Giridharadas
I still yell at them on nights and weekends.
Kara Swisher
All right. Okay, good. That's great. Thank you so much.
Anand Giridharadas
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
All right, Bill, one more quick break. We'll be back for Wins and Fails.
AD BREAK
Okay, Bill, let's hear some wins and fails.
William Cohan
The fail and the win are the flip side of the same coin. And what I mean by that is I think that the FTX SBF disaster, the crypto meltdown, and today BlockFi filed for bankruptcy. It's still going and something tethered still needs to be wiped out. So the ongoing meltdown in crypto land is a major fail, obviously. But I think, as we were talking about before, it will result in some major wins for whatever this technology is that underlies all this that people still have faith in. Now, again, I'm not a technologist, so I don't frankly understand. I hear people talking about it. I know they believe in it. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me, but that doesn't mean anything. I don't know how a car works either. I don't know how the internet works, but I sure enjoy using it every day, and it's changed my life for the better. So hopefully something will come out of this. So you'll see that this is a necessary and important step.
Kara Swisher
Absolutely. Just like the internet bubble exploding back in March 2000 was a very important step in what we now take for granted on the internet.
William Cohan
Right, right. I think it's really – I think you're right. I think it does feel like that. It does, having been there during that time, and everyone thought the internet was a Ponzi scheme, and a lot of it was. At the moment, some of it was quite profound. And then they started really making money, starting with Google. Google was really the one that shifted everyone's thinking about that as they started to make a lot of money.
Kara Swisher
And how essential is that today? I mean, it's incredible how valuable that is. Incredible, incredible also. And also the turnaround of Apple and things like that with the internet and the apps and things like that. And it happened a lot slower than people think. There were a significant number of terrible companies and they all went away. That's one of the beauties of our system. And one thing to note about this is that this isn't that much money. Even though everyone's sort of focused on FTX, it's a very small part, as Scott points out, of the economy. It didn't tank anything. And very importantly, it's not interconnected to the financial system nearly as much as people thought or feared, as happened in 2008. So it's a very different dynamic. And frankly, we're blessed as a result of that because we couldn't go through that again right now.
William Cohan
Yeah, although a lot of people lost money. We're sorry about that.
Kara Swisher
Okay, sure. That's the way it goes.
William Cohan
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and Kathy Wood's still a nincompoop, correct?
William Cohan
Still a nincompoop, and I can't believe anybody gives her money. That just blows my mind, but they do.
Kara Swisher
So, okay, there you go. Anyway, I have only one win I saw in the theater, speaking of which. Like I said, a win and a fail, too. I saw *Wakanda Forever*, which was astonishing. I was so glad to get to the theater. We had an actual babysitter over the weekend, over the Thanksgiving weekend. It was a wonderful movie, perfect for the big screen, just beautifully done, very soulful, completely dominated by women of color. If you saw a man, he walked through on his way out the door somewhere else. It was just a beautifully wrought movie. And I recommend it to everyone. It's a blockbuster, and it's doing really well. And it's great to see it in the theater. That said, I still am not bullish on theaters. Everything else that I want to see, I'm going to see on a plane or streaming, pretty much, except I'm trying to think of a movie that's coming out that I'm going to rush to the theater for. There's a few, I suppose, but not very many, few and far between.
William Cohan
Well, *The Banshees of Inisherin*, which I saw in the theater, I recommend it. And I enjoyed going to the theater to see it. And it's a small movie. You live in New York, though, right? You're a New Yorker.
Kara Swisher
I do live in New York, yes.
William Cohan
So that's why. So it's hiding out in New York. But you can find it around. Independent theaters.
Kara Swisher
I do still think that theatrical experience is declining precipitously and will continue to do so. It'll be like Broadway. It'll be nice and people will go, but not the same kind of business. Again, a small business. Just another window.
William Cohan
Yeah, just another window.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot and submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT. We'll be doing an end-of-the-year mailbag, so get those questions in. Bill, that's the show. A reminder that Bill's book, *Power Failure: The Rise and Fall of an American Icon*, which is about GE, is out now, and you should absolutely read it. I love your comparison to what if Apple declined, wouldn't you want to know? I think that's exactly right for people to understand how important GE was to everything for a very long time. And it's quite a fascinating look at what happened there over the many years. Again, thank you so much for coming on, Bill.
William Cohan
Thank you, Kara, for having me.
Kara Swisher
We'll be back on Friday for more. Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman, Evan Engel and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Enderdot engineered this episode. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.