Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including the tech response to Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the impact of social media on social justice movements, and the challenges of regulating tech companies.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. Scott Galloway is out today who knows what he's doing. So we've got a very special co-host in his place. She joins me early today after taping one of her first episodes as host of MSNBC's 11th hour. Welcome, Brian Williams.
Stephanie Ruhle
Oh, no, Stephanie. A much shorter version of Brian Williams, both from the state of New Jersey.
Kara Swisher
Oh, in so many ways. So many ways. So many ways. So talk to me about how the first week on the job was. You couldn't be more different than Uncle Brian. I hate to do this, but was that vinyl that you were wearing, white vinyl, on the first night?
Stephanie Ruhle
You know what? It was pleather, to be perfectly honest. It was pleather. I thought a lot about what I was going to wear, and I thought pleather might be a good call. Listen, it's been a super stressful week, and there's tons of news going on. So this whole idea and the pressure that I've... Listen, Brian Williams is a hero of mine and an icon at NBC. When I got this opportunity and everyone said, "So what show are you going to make?" I was like, "I'm going to join Brian Williams' team." I think a lot of people often think, "Oh, what are you going to call that show?" A lot of people love to use their last name and turn it into something. Brian made a great show that has a great audience and I'm joining it.
Kara Swisher
And what's the difference between morning and night? We have this long text chain, a bunch of friends of ours, including Stephanie, like, is it going to be naughtier? Is it going to be sassier? What is it? How do you look at it, though? Because you have to make it yours. And what's the difference between what you do in the morning and night?
Stephanie Ruhle
I think Brian and I... I'm probably, by nature, naughtier and more sassy than Brian is. But the difference really between day and night is time, right? At 11 o'clock at night, you've got a lot more time to go deep in conversations. At 9 a.m., we're really covering news, news, news. Now, in cable and MSNBC, nighttime really is where we have perspective shows. While I'm definitely not an opinion person, right? I don't have deep ideology. I am excited to have a little bit more flex in what we cover because I think there's a huge difference between having a point of view, which you can absolutely change, and having deep ideology.
So, much like Brian, a lot of our guests are going to be reporters. Not just correspondents who are covering a story today, but really reporters who know their beat. If you're somebody who's covering... Cara, you are someone with an opinion because you have been covering a beat for years and years. That's very, very different from being an activist with ideology who has a goal of an outcome. At 11 o'clock at night, there are people who watch cable all day, but there are other people who just want to know, "What's the most important thing? What do I need to know? And how do I get ready for tomorrow?" That's kind of our game plan. So I'm joining Brian's team.
Kara Swisher
And you've jumped into huge news. I mean, boy, talk about jumping into the fire. What has that been like? And how do you decide? Obviously, Ukraine is the story, period. From a programming standpoint, you're really ripping up the script. When I think back to starting the show, who are the guests going to be? What are the ideas? All that flies out the window. Right now, we're just trying to help people get as much information as they need to know about Ukraine.
Stephanie Ruhle
I would say maybe what I'm really trying to do, when there's giant news like this, you have a chance of an audience that's bigger than your traditional cable news audience that wants the wonky policy. You've got people who are simply saying, "What the hell is going on on the other side of the world?" We're trying to focus on that for people who don't know every in and out of all of the policies. They're not foreign policy people. Just, "What does this mean to us? Why do I need to care?"
For me... I don't know. Do you ever... Last night when we started, it was really our first show. Gary Kasparov was one of the first people we had on. Gary, chess grandmaster, but he's written many books. He was the one who said, "Winter is coming. Putin is a madman." So now here we are realizing his fears. He walked us through, not a snarky "I told you so" last night, but this whole idea that we're going to have diplomatic talks, Ukrainian delegates and Russian delegates. He's like, "What are you crazy? Putin is completely isolated. And if you think Ukraine is the only place he's going for, you're sorely mistaken." That point is why people really need to pay attention. Those people who say, "I don't even know where it is on a map. What does it matter to me?" It certainly matters because it's a threat to democracy.
I think the amazing thing that we've seen this week, think about all of the Western countries that have coordinated around these sanctions. I mean, extraordinary what they've gotten done.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Yeah. And yet there's still fear in Poland and Finland and Sweden and other places, in Germany, especially the first time Germany's added to its defense budget and Switzerland hasn't been neutral. I mean, Switzerland, their brand is neutral.
Stephanie Ruhle
Yeah, not today.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, we'll talk about the latest developments in Ukraine and a new investigation into TikTok, which has to do with China also, in terms of the social media space and manipulation. We'll talk with author Gal Beckerman about the difficult relation between social media and social progress. But first, a correction. Earlier this week, my absent co-host Scott cheered on two teams in a soccer match, of which I knew nothing about. But he got the name of the match wrong. It was the League Cup Final, not the FA Cup Final. Thank you to everyone who wrote in about that. Again, sports ball is not my area of expertise and obviously not Scott's.
Anyway, let's check on some headlines. Melinda Gates, wow, spoke about her divorce from Bill Gates for the first time in an interview with Gayle King. Let's play a short clip.
Clip plays: Melinda French Gates: People look at you, Melinda French Gates, and say she has it all. Well, I think it's really important to say, look, I had a lot of tears for many days. I mean, days where I'm literally laying on the floor on the carpet, you know, this close to me, thinking, how can this be? How can I get up? How am I going to move forward? And days I certainly was angry. That's part of the grieving process. You're grieving a loss of something you thought you had and thought you had for your lifetime.
I was not expecting this from her. She plays it very close to the vest. Gayle King interviewed her. It's usually all business, what she's working on, which was a lot of the philanthropy and some things around education or whatever she happened to be working on. She's a very serious, professional demeanor. I was sort of surprised by this. What do you think?
Stephanie Ruhle
I know her pretty well, too. I was surprised by it. But at the same time, Melinda's the real deal. She doesn't want to be treated like or viewed as Bill Gates's plus one who does stuff at the foundation, right? She is a force. It certainly sounds like, reading between the tea leaves, she really went through something with him. I don't think she's going to air all of their dirty laundry, but it almost seemed like she was saying, "That person I was living with... it wasn't about forgiving someone for doing something. It was about a person I was married to living a different lifestyle."
I was surprised to see Melinda Gates be so vulnerable. But the reason it's so refreshing, when people of influence kind of not show you their dirty laundry, but show you how complicated life is, it gives freedom. It gives license to everyone else that life is bumpy and ugly, but it doesn't mean you can't lead an extraordinary one. So I think it's great that she did it. At the end of that interview, the piece that you saw, she said, "2022, it's a new life for me."
Kara Swisher
Why though? I just didn't know why. She wanted to say it, I think. She just wanted to say it publicly because she's been silent.
Stephanie Ruhle
Yeah. I mean, I think back to when I used to... I'm sure you did these interviews. When I used to interview Bill and Melinda when their letter would come out. And listen, it would always be...
Kara Swisher
This is an annual letter they put out for people who don't know.
Stephanie Ruhle
But let's be honest. When they would come for interviews, everybody would want to interview Bill and they were a package deal. She probably felt like she didn't get the credit that she deserved and maybe she didn't. Now she wants it, right? Especially from a philanthropy standpoint, she's got a whole lot of money to give and she wants to give it in a purposeful way and be a voice of influence. She's saying, "I'm here to do that."
Kara Swisher
She also has Pivotal Ventures. She's also an investor. She's been doing a lot of investing in women-run companies, et cetera. So I suspect she wants a higher profile. In a very different way. People love to like MacKenzie Bezos, Melinda Gates. MacKenzie Bezos in the most extraordinary fashion is giving her money away. She's giving it away in a big public fashion, but she remains very quiet about it and is going to stay that way. Melinda's different.
Stephanie Ruhle
Yeah, absolutely.
Kara Swisher
So other things, something that you know a lot about. Jerome Powell said the Fed is ready to raise interest rates and the Federal Reserve chair said he will move to fight inflation. The move comes as the Ukrainian war has already raised gas prices and probably will further. But Powell says the effects of that war in the U.S. remain highly uncertain. So if the issue is gas prices, shouldn't Democrats seize the moment and propose clean energy subsidies? Obviously, they're releasing gas from our different reserves and liberate West from Russian oil. Biden has said nothing's off the table when it comes to banning Russian oil imports. And still, the oil prices, I think they're higher than $113 a barrel. I saw $117 a barrel. So talk a little bit about the interplay between energy prices, interest rates, and inflation.
Stephanie Ruhle
The gas prices thing is really rough. It doesn't matter how well we're doing in the economic recovery because we are doing well, right? Unemployment is at 4%. Biden created six and a half million jobs. Wages are up. All those things are great. Consumer spending is up. Household savings. However, look how he's polling, especially in terms around the economy. Very low. It's because of inflation. It's because of how people feel. When gas prices are high, it's a political disaster because you could have a great new job with a great new salary. But on your way to work, you're driving by six gas stations and people pay attention to the price of gas. My son was just saying, "Look at that price." I was like, "What do you care? You're not paying for it." It's my mom's favorite topic.
This is an issue for the Biden administration. They say nothing's off the table. Earlier this week, they're like, "Well, they're releasing barrels from the Strategic Reserve." It's a drop in the bucket. We could see things that we didn't expect. They could potentially strike a deal with Iran. I just asked the question last night. I wasn't advocating for it. I asked Secretary Buttigieg, I said, "Any shot the president could authorize the Keystone Pipeline?" And Twitter just lit me on fire. Biden's in a tough spot.
Kara Swisher
You look pretty good.
Stephanie Ruhle
And Jerome Powell is, too. Right. If you want to start to address inflation, it's about raising rates. Now, given the situation in Ukraine, it gets hard. But I just think back, why are rates as low as they are, Cara? Interest rates are supposed to be at zero when you're in an economic crisis. They have been extraordinarily low for way, way, way too long. It's why the stock market did so well. It was just this giant, giant safety net. So now we're here in a situation where this inflation problem is a huge issue.
One thing I've been thinking about in the last 24 hours: inflation is a problem. Gas prices are high. And this is all coming just as people are going back to work. You heard Joe Biden say in the State of the Union two nights ago, "It's time to bring federal employees back to work." On one hand, I absolutely understand that. You live in D.C. where the city doesn't have a lot of people going to work. It's empty. It's hard on the city. But people have also proven over the last two years, many people, that they can get the job done. They can work in different ways. Now we're going to ask people to go back to work, to get in the car and commute when gas prices are really high and getting a coffee, getting lunch is so expensive. What we should be doing is saying, "You know what, if you're saving some money, that's a good thing." So it's complicated.
This is a time when a lot of business leaders maybe need to rethink who is coming back to work, what does work look like? We convince our... the Jamie Dimons of the world are of the mindset, "Work gets done if everybody's sitting at the conference table." I don't entirely disagree with him. I certainly like to be with everyone. But this is still a complicated time, not just because of COVID. Maybe we should be reimagining work. For federal employees, if you're commuting an hour and a half to work, and we often say, "How do you get people to take some of these jobs? How do you get really smart accounting people to go work at the IRS where they're not going to make as much money as they would in the private sector?" Well, if federal employees could work from home, that's a lot more attractive to a lot of people.
Kara Swisher
You work from home, you always have.
Stephanie Ruhle
Yeah, I always have.
Kara Swisher
But the political pressure to bring people back... he's competing against Ron DeSantis or whoever. This is also a political issue as well as anything else. I think he has to say COVID's over. A democratic version of COVID. "We're going to be safe." He said it in the State of the Union. But we also need employees to start saying not, "I need to stay home from work. I need to stay home from the office because of COVID." Now is the time where we can say to our employers, "Let's talk about optimizing my job, my performance, and is there a chance for me to work from home?"
Stephanie Ruhle
I fully understand how frustrating it is. Listen, there are all sorts of business leaders that you and I both talk to who say, "I don't get it. Right here in New York City, office buildings are empty, but our bars and restaurants are open." There are a lot of employers who aren't buying the argument that people don't feel safe. They don't feel safe enough to go to work. When the Expedia CEO is expecting the biggest travel summer ever, you can't make the argument, "I'm staying home because I don't feel safe." But you could potentially make the argument. Now it's inflation. Now it's gas prices. But guess what? How about this is a time when businesses can talk to their best employees and say, "What is it that you're looking for?" It might not just be compensation. Work from home should be viewed in a different way now. Let's get creative. But to just say, "Oh, it's not COVID safe. I'm not coming in." That's a hard argument.
Kara Swisher
But interest rates going up to deal with inflation. They have to. They have to. There's no choice.
Stephanie Ruhle
Unfortunately, the people who are... when you look at polling, who are most worried about inflation, Cara, are wealthy people. One of the things that keeps prices very high is that people are willing to pay those prices. When people aren't willing to pay the high prices, there's pressure for them to go down. Right now, while there are a lot of people struggling economically, at the same time, there are lots of people who saved a lot in the last few years, and they're doing quite well.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and they're spending a lot of money. Okay, let's get to our first big story. Russia's invasion of Ukraine is forcing big changes for companies in tech, media, and finance. Apple halted sales to Russia earlier this week and pulled apps of Russian state media from its app store, although there's plenty of other Russian state stuff that you don't see as clearly. But apps remain available to Russian users, however. Meanwhile, Instagram users in Russia and Ukraine can now send encrypted messages in the app. Meta says the change is part of its effort to keep users safe. Encrypted messaging is already available in WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger. YouTube is doing all kinds of things. Facebook, Google, Oracle stopped doing business there. Obviously, there's rumors that Microsoft is considering it, although they're trying to figure out what to do about its current customers, its existing customers.
I think most companies feel they probably aren't going to be doing business in Russia now for a while, but they have existing customers there that they have to service. So what has to happen with that? Apple's stock is down since the invasion began. Russia's business is estimated to be $2.5 billion, but there's no physical store locations. It's certainly not as important as China or other places. So how do you look at the tech response, which is sort of finally making choices that they were unwilling to make in other areas?
Stephanie Ruhle
Well, this time, Kara, it truly is life or death. Civilians are being murdered in Ukraine. Eight days ago, across Ukraine, children were going to school. Now they're either in the crossfires in a war zone or they've fled their country. Chances are with their mothers and not with their fathers or teenage brothers, right? When you really think about how grave this situation is and how much worse it can get, there is no reason to believe if Putin is successful in Ukraine, he's not going to push further. To see tech companies step in right now is huge.
What's happening in Russia, those people are in an information vacuum. What Russian state-run media is shoving down their throats is beyond conspiracy theories. Just yesterday, there were some radio stations that shut down in Russia because they just can't bear to be pushing out the lies. The fact that Putin is telling people this is a "denazification" of Ukraine is just absolutely insane.
Kara Swisher
Although, I think a lot of the population doesn't believe it because, for example, they shut down the independent news organization TV Rain. The site's editor-in-chief says that he's now fled Russia. They notice these things. They've depended on these stations, too. There's been a few independent ones, mostly for entertainment and things like that, because most state-run media is decried by... they make fun of it. When you're in Russia, that's what they do. But nonetheless, they have an information deficit there, as you said. When these things go away, they notice that. They notice that maybe the truth isn't there. A lot of this information is seeping through, whether it's all kinds of ways that people do manage to get information. Do you consider what the tech companies are doing to be a good thing, throttling them off in terms of information?
Stephanie Ruhle
Absolutely. Absolutely. I do think it's a good thing because the tech companies, when it comes to Russia, have to deal with the government. The government controls everything. So it's not like Apple was the lifeline for the people there. I do have an enormous amount of sympathy for Russians. They're experiencing economic warfare. While Putin, who is a multi-multi-billionaire, doesn't mind being cut off, he is sending them on a road to North Korea. With every passing day, they are more isolated and their economy. It's always important to remind people, Russia may be a nuclear superpower. They are an economic midget. Before this, they were the 11th largest economy. Okay. It's like the size of the state of New York. It's pathetic. Under Putin's rule, their economy has done nothing. Their only exports are oil and gas and wheat, no other industries. That is pathetic. Now all of those Russian people are suffering yet again economically, and he's never cared, right? The oligarchs are richer than beyond belief, as is Putin. He's never cared about his own people suffering.
The question will be, will this get so bad that he could get removed from office? I don't think there's ever been a time that he's been in power that people have thought about that credibly. You wonder, if the West is successful at sanctioning oligarchs, and even though we're talking about it and we're doing it, I still don't believe it because you know better than I do, if there's one thing that mega-rich people know how to do, it's find loopholes. It's get protected. If those oligarchs really start to get punished, you wonder if they will turn on Putin. Because guess what? None of them live in Russia. They live in London. They live in the south of France. They live in New York. They don't have his delusions of grandeur about Russia being a superpower. They're just his boys. He's been theirs. He's enabled them to become obscenely wealthy. But if that changes, they could turn on him.
Kara Swisher
They could. Now, the online investigators are still tracking private jets and yachts of Russian oligarchs. That's become a problem for Credit Suisse. The bank asked investors this week to destroy documents showing its financial relationship with sanctioned Russian tycoons, specifically their yacht and plane loans. Credit Suisse said private documents were leaked to the media. What were they thinking, this leaked documents, the Suisse secrets, I guess?
Stephanie Ruhle
Okay, well, I just say pathetic to Credit Suisse. I worked at Credit Suisse for six years of my life. They're panicked right now because Credit Suisse years ago was a major global investment bank. Now they're not. If you go to their website right now, it basically says private wealth management with a kick of investment banking on the side. So they desperately need to keep all of those private banking clients. Right now, it is all about being a private Swiss bank. So they don't want any of that information to get out. The fact that they want it kept secret just shows how self-serving they are.
I would go one step further. If you look at the last few years, even from the financial crisis, how well banks have done, how well bank stocks have done, Credit Suisse's stock has sucked. This speaks to the culture of a company. If this is how you operate, you can see a through line and say, "Wow, Jamie Dimon, who runs a completely different type of bank, has had much stronger stock performance." Here's a great example why.
Kara Swisher
But they're not in bed with these people. So one of the things that's interesting is sort of squeezing Russia informationally. We can get to what Ukraine is doing, which is very canny. It doesn't mean it means anything because it's one thing to win the social media meme war and it's another to have a tank roll into your city and bomb all the apartment buildings. It's a really interesting juxtaposition. In some ways, it's a very good thing that they're winning this war, especially the cyber war, or social media war. But does it mean anything from your perspective? Does it actually matter?
Stephanie Ruhle
That remains to be seen. While we're all standing here saying, "I stand with Ukraine" and "It's amazing to watch these civilians fight for their country," we're saying that from the comfort of our homes, right?
Kara Swisher
Like it's a narrative, like it's a movie.
Stephanie Ruhle
The president, right? Zelensky is in a bunker right now with a helmet on, and he's public enemy number one. Thousands of people are losing their lives. When you look at those videos of women and children leaving and saying goodbye to their sons... Kara, if you were Ukrainian, you would be leaving your sons there. So I think we sit here and we're like, "We're so inspired by Ukraine. It's so amazing what they're doing." I don't think we're appreciating what they're experiencing. We'd rather do memes.
Kara Swisher
Another thing, by the way, American companies putting on pressure, which I think most of us support... Do they have to do it in every international conflict to come? They are facing criticism for doing this in Ukraine and not in Syria, Iraq, and Afghanistan. You're seeing a lot of that. But they are making choices. It's interesting, the choices they're making. People think it has to do with race and color and stuff like that. So it also brings those issues to mind.
Stephanie Ruhle
Well, they wouldn't have to make those choices if we had more regulation.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, right. Yeah, that's a fair point.
Stephanie Ruhle
If we had more government regulation about how these businesses operate around information in the way that traditional media companies like the one I work at does, then they wouldn't have to make these choices. I actually think it would be easier for them to conduct business.
Kara Swisher
Right. Well, they also have certain standards and rules at where you are versus other places. One interesting thing is they're also cutting off entertainment to Russia. No Batman. Which is an interesting thing. Batman, which is maybe a favor, it's getting terrible reviews. Warner Brothers is postponing the release of The Batman in Russia. Disney and Sony will pause their upcoming release schedule in Russia as well. Again, it's not a huge market for Hollywood, so it's not the biggest flex, I suppose. But the studio needs all the ticket sales it can get. Do you think taking this stand is a good thing? Or just a meaningless gesture?
Stephanie Ruhle
Whether or not it's meaningless, we should be doing absolutely nothing right now to serve Russia. Nothing. So just pull the plug on lots of things. But listen, I understand what you're saying, that when you make moves like this, it's a slippery slope. Because what about when the next conflict comes and the next conflict? But guess what? That's what the boys in the C-suite and women have to figure out. Not our problem, it's theirs.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Okay. Stephanie, we're going to have a quick break. When we come back, the law comes for TikTok. And we'll speak with friend of Pivot, Gal Beckerman.
Ad Break
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports, discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person. It's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivotpod. That's linkedin.com slash pivotpod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
Okay, Stephanie, we're back with our second big story. States attorneys general around the country are investigating TikTok's effect on young users. This is not a new thing. And Facebook already faces around Instagram. The inquiry looks at how TikTok may have tried to keep young users hooked on the app. It's a very hooky app. Another coalition of state AGs made a similar case against Facebook last year. And Facebook is still under the microscope. President Biden brought Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen. I was sort of surprised at the State of the Union address earlier this week. I was like, "What?"
Like when that popped up. Here's how the moment played out. Children were also struggling before the pandemic: bullying, violence, trauma, and the harms of social media. As Frances Haugen, who is here tonight with us, has shown, we must hold social media platforms accountable for the national experiment they're conducting on our children for profit. Oh, all right. That's a big thing with politicians, even though there's been some pushback that maybe we don't have enough research yet. I think there should be plenty. There should be more research and transparency to understand the causal relationship here and the correlation.
Stephanie Ruhle
So the state attorneys general case against Facebook still had trouble from the start, although it's a good political thing to pull out. The case against Facebook involved the acquisition of WhatsApp and Instagram and things like that. But this issue around teen girls is an important one. It's added with TikTok, which is owned by a Chinese company, and there are some worries about that. So what do you think about this?
Kara Swisher
I got to be honest, like you said, you were surprised to see Frances. I'm frustrated by it. It's a political show. Our lawmakers have done absolutely nothing from a regulatory front to curb these businesses and protect our children. And great, let's parade Frances in there. Well, you know who's standing outside the building? The scores of high-paid lobbyists that work for these same companies that are schmoozing up to these lawmakers, and it's working. So I just don't buy, "Oh, great, Frances is there." Call me when you actually do something. We haven't, and our children are suffering for it.
Stephanie Ruhle
There was this New York Times piece talking about whether this really does have an effect because we don't have proof. It wasn't saying it didn't. It said there isn't enough proof that we have it. What do you think has to happen?
Kara Swisher
I think there's been some legislation proposed to require transparency to outside researchers, et cetera, to get this information. There is a worrisome issue around TikTok collecting all this information on young people. Why go for this thing right here versus some other more serious issues around tech companies, do you think? Because there must be details around this one that make it gettable, right?
Stephanie Ruhle
I think that they're going for this thing for honestly technical reasons that are not very sexy at all. But the issue is there's not enough outside conclusive research. They're not actually breaking any current laws, rules, or regulations. But we know that these attorneys general would like to do something. And so I think there must be some level of technicality where they think they have a decent shot. And for the average person, this is so frustrating, right? They're saying, how on earth can nothing be done over this? Imagine what this is like for parents who have kids that are suffering, who have kids that they've lost, yet nothing happens and these businesses just get bigger and bigger and bigger. It's devastating.
Kara Swisher
Is it an issue you have with your kids?
Stephanie Ruhle
My kids are not very on those things. Most of them are like, "It makes me feel bad. Why should I do it?" The issue for me is that we're really strict in our house about devices. And the problem on the other side of that, it kind of makes your kid an isolated pilgrim. And that's hard too, right? Because kids aren't talking on the phone. This is what their world is. This is how they communicate. And I have a 15-year-old. As soon as he's on Snapchat, the world ends because he gets himself in trouble. And do I blame these teenagers? No, they're impulsive. If everything you and I did when we were 15, 16, 17 was recorded... Oh my gosh. I mean, disaster city. So our texts are bad. Our text group is bad. Kara and I are in a very, very exciting text chain. And so I feel sympathy. We're expecting our kids to have self-control that we certainly didn't have.
Kara Swisher
No, it's definitely a problem in my house. I'm most worried. I have an eight-year-old daughter who I'm on like a hawk. When you see what they have access to, it's just crazy. When I see my son, he's 15. And so this works from the girls who he talks to, what they're wearing, how they're behaving. And it's so hard for parents to even keep up with it.
Stephanie Ruhle
No, it's terrible. I mean, it's a huge problem.
Kara Swisher
Should you age gate these things? Scott has talked about age gating. Are you a proponent of that? This is one thing that could come of this, this idea of age gating all of these things. You age gate liquor, you age gate cigarettes, you age gate the military, etc.
Stephanie Ruhle
Yeah. And it's complete bullshit when companies like Instagram say, "Well, you can have an Instagram account if you're under 13." Like really? I invite anyone who works at Instagram to come sit next to me and I'm going to show you puppies, chimpanzees, and babies who have their own Instagram pages. And I assure you when they're having meetings with consumer brands and advertisers, they're not saying, "Oh, we don't have any eyeballs under the age of 13." That would be a big, fat lie. Absolutely age gate it. They do not have the impulse control. When I just think about how sad I was as a girl in the sixth grade or the seventh grade or the eighth grade, in fear of missing out or girls being mean to each other or not getting invited to things. And all I was doing was thinking about where other girls could be on a Friday night. Now you're watching it endlessly.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And you didn't have your white vinyl outfit then at the time. You didn't have your TV show and white vinyl outfit.
Stephanie Ruhle
I did have a white leather fringe jacket that I wore for years.
Kara Swisher
Oh, dear.
Stephanie Ruhle
Yeah, that's precisely why you are sitting at home.
Kara Swisher
So when you think about it, is there any that's worse than the other? Do you feel like it's Instagram or TikTok?
Stephanie Ruhle
I have a burner phone that I use TikTok on because I'm quite worried about the Chinese government. And it's connected to nothing but public Wi-Fi. It doesn't connect to anything that is my information. And I watch a lot of air fryer TikToks. That's it. It's air fryers.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's what comes up. I just like air fryers. I just had the fire department show up at my house this week because of a slight air fryer incident, to be totally honest.
Stephanie Ruhle
I don't use TikTok. The only TikToks I see are through our friend Brooke Hammerling, who basically I think she just looks at TikTok all day long and finds the best one. So that's what she does. I don't use TikTok because I think I would get sucked into it. But it worries me very, very much. When my son, who's 15, when all of a sudden he comes downstairs with these crazy, ridiculous conspiracy theories that are often about young men or tied to politics, all I have to do is walk upstairs and see where YouTube or TikTok took him. Took him. And that is different. That is wildly different from when I was a teenager babysitting at people's houses, hoping they had HBO or Skinemax so I could watch rated R movies that I wasn't allowed to watch at home.
Kara Swisher
Skinemax. I haven't heard that word in a long time. Watching Gilbert Gottfried up all night on Saturday night is just nudity, right? What our kids are watching, how dangerous it is when you go down a TikTok path, is significantly worse than me wanting to babysit for rich people that had pay cable.
Stephanie Ruhle
Yeah, my kids stay on John Oliver. That's where they stay.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you know what? You're a show-off. You are a show-off. We all wish that.
Stephanie Ruhle
But they do. That's what happens. Our sons, they just watch John Oliver, as I'm borderline admitting.
Kara Swisher
I think my son is following alt-right influencers. Claire watches Encanto on a full loop that goes on and on and on.
Stephanie Ruhle
It's a very good movie.
Kara Swisher
It is. After this point, it's not.
Stephanie Ruhle
Last question, Facebook stock. We're going to have Gal Beckerman on in a second to talk about some of these kinds of issues. Facebook stock has been in the dumps lately. It's still in the dumps. What do you make of that?
Kara Swisher
Boo-hoo-hoo. Don't cry for me, Argentina. Okay. Facebook will find its way again. And I have no sympathy for Facebook. I have no sympathy for Facebook shareholders. What do I think about Facebook? I think Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg should sit down with you and I for an interview. Yeah, they're not going to do that. And I think it's so tiresome to watch Sheryl do her Instagram videos of, "Here's Sheryl Sandberg talking to a small business and how excited she is." Give me a break. Two of the most influential people in the business planet. Why don't you sit down and have an unregulated conversation about your real business?
Until that, they're not getting any more of our breath. They're not going to do that. My Jim Bankoff ran into some of them, and they were complaining about how mean I was. Anyway, their stock is down 44%, 45% for the past six months. I don't know if it's going to recover. They always recover. They're the only game in town from an advertising point of view. But I think there's a feeling about them that's not good. And I think Instagram is losing a little steam to TikTok. But their only hope is that TikTok is revealed to be controlled by the Chinese Communist Party definitively or if the Biden administration does something.
Stephanie Ruhle
Well, if that's your only business strategy, you need a better one.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I think their level of innovation, I think the spending on the metaverse is problematic, etc. But we'll see where they go. They are certainly trying to do the right thing in this case. And we'll see, I think you see the influence of Nick Clegg here from an international perspective. But do you really believe they're in any sort of trouble? You and I might say, "Well, we don't use Facebook," but millions of other people do.
Stephanie Ruhle
I do that. I do, but I think eventually all these companies die. No matter how big they are, or they morph into something else like Microsoft did. And we'll see on that.
Kara Swisher
Sure, but as you're saying that, I'm sure my sister is Facebooking whatever she ate for breakfast this morning while saying that she doesn't like Facebook.
Stephanie Ruhle
Yeah, okay. All right. So anyway, we'll see what happens. But now we're going to bring in our friend of Pivot. Gal Beckerman is a senior editor for books at The Atlantic and the author of *The Quiet Before: On the Unexpected Origins of Radical Ideas*. He joins us to discuss the way social media complicates and maybe inhibits any movement for social justice. Welcome, Gal.
Gal Beckerman
Thank you so much for having me.
Kara Swisher
Thank you for coming. So we were just talking about what was happening in Ukraine with their use of social media and platforms to get out their ideas. I guess I sort of want to start there. This is a book that talks about the history of this thing going way, way back. Orators in Victorian Britain, a futuristic manifesto, shouters in a Florence theater in 1913, the evening concluding with a light bulb smashing against the side of Filippo Marinetti's face as he tried to read out a political statement. This is not a new thing, the ability to scream and shout. It's just amplified and weaponized in some cases. So let's start with Ukraine. What do you imagine through the lens of this book you're seeing there?
Gal Beckerman
Well, what I tried to do in the book is look at the various modes that social movements and people who try to make revolution in their societies have at their disposal. The criticism I have of the last 10, 15 years is that we've sort of over-relied on social media. The loud bullhorn that Twitter or Facebook provides has made it so that activists, dissidents, people who are aching to make change don't recognize the smaller, quieter spaces where they probably should be first communicating and strategizing. As for this moment, what I'd say is that it is one of those rare instances where activists really need the bullhorn. They need to be able to draw attention to what's happening, especially considering the disinformation that's going on in Russia at the moment. Most Russian people don't really understand at all what's happening in Ukraine. They think there's some sort of minor conflagration in the East and not a full-scale invasion. And so a Twitter or a Facebook could be extremely helpful in getting out a narrative at this moment. Rather than these quiet spaces.
Kara Swisher
Can you explain this idea of the quiet spaces? Because social movements like Me Too and Black Lives Matter have been fairly successful. So have right-wing efforts to amplify and anger people, election lies, anti-vax and stuff like that. Very loud, very bullhorn. Talk about that versus the quieter organizational places. Because nothing's quiet these days.
Gal Beckerman
Nothing is quiet. And it's not just that nothing is quiet, but that these movements, the way they set their expectations, how they understand change actually works, has been really molded by the metabolism of social media. The thought is that all we need to do is gain this moment of visibility, this moment of attention, this sugar high of everyone turning towards our way and our slogan, and it's done. The reality is, we've seen over and over again, and I track the beginnings of this to the "Twitter revolutions" in the early 2010s and the Arab Spring in particular. What we've seen is that they do get these moments of attention and visibility. There's even moments where the conversation changes at a societal level. And undoubtedly that's important, especially when we're talking about the kind of progressive causes that we might all be on board with here. But then they just kind of fade away and they don't know how to translate that into on-the-ground organizing and moving laws in their direction. The actual real concrete tangible changes that are in many cases the ultimate goals of these movements, but that get swept away by the hugeness of that bullhorn.
Stephanie Ruhle
What about the fact that while it's extraordinary to see some of these amazing social movements that represent really important causes, the fact that they're able to mobilize and get these platforms and these megaphones is inspirational. But are we forgetting that on the other side of the coin, forces for evil, anti-vaxxers, conspiracy theorists are able to use these same platforms? When you said it's great for people who are living in Russia so they can actually see what's going on there, that's assuming the videos that are on those platforms haven't been altered, right? Because there's no standards on these platforms. You think, "Oh, we're going to bring this to the people so they can see the truth." But who's deciding what the truth is? There's no rules.
Gal Beckerman
Right. Well, that's one of the challenges of that sort of public sphere where it's so loud and so viral and so much about grabbing attention. We know that these are the incentive models on those platforms. And I think that the problem is that some of the movements that we look at today and think about the anti-social and terrible ways that they're affecting society, they actually have had some of that quiet space. And the reason is that they've been pushed down there. So I have a chapter on the white supremacists who built up to Charlottesville. I was able to gain access to their chats in the three or four months leading up to Charlottesville.
They were on Discord, the gaming app, because it was an extremely useful place for them to be. It was private. They had their own moderators controlling their little chat rooms. They could kick out anybody who wasn't on board with what they were talking about. And what I was able to observe there once I got past the disgustingness of even spending that much time in their presence was people really incubating a certain set of ideas. They were hashing things out. They were working as a movement towards making the kind of change they wanted to make in the world and consolidating their visions, figuring out, hammering out ideology, deciding optics.
Optics was a huge thing for them. They want to recruit more people to their worldview. How are they going to do that? What should they be wearing? Literally, what should they be wearing and what should they not be wearing? All of those questions had a space to really be discussed and worked out. And one of my worries is that because the bullhorn is so attractive, the movements that are allowed to flourish there, like Black Lives Matter or Me Too, don't give themselves that space. And in fact, we've kind of vilified those small, quiet spaces. We call them derisively "safe spaces." And my argument is that there is a definite role for them in the building and development of a movement.
Kara Swisher
It's interesting because if not Facebook and Twitter, what does good communication look like in a successful social movement? Reddit used to be a place for that, a quieter place, although it was a public place. These groups, there's all these new conservative social networks where they're all talking. They're not doing very well because they're talking to each other and they don't like it. They want to yell at liberals or they want to be engaged with you. So much is done out in the open these days versus in plain sight. What do you consider good communication looks like in a social media movement? Is using both, doing that hashtag activism? Or is it these, because nobody's been meeting each other physically for a while now.
Gal Beckerman
Well, first of all, I think you do need to use both. I wouldn't deny that there is an absolute role for the bullhorn. And I wouldn't want to take that away from people who now have the ability to reach at a scale and a speed that was never possible before. So let's put that aside. But then I think you also need a place for real conversation. And I think it's not hard to take the conditions that social media has imposed on our own personal life or personal interactions and even look at democracy and the effects that it's had on democracy and understand how those could apply to social movements in a negative way. The antidote to that is to say we need to be able to have a place to communicate with different incentive structures. If you just take away the like button or the upvote or this mode of communication that privileges the bombastic or the shouting, you immediately enter a space like this Discord room for these white supremacists where they're not just trying to get attention, but they're actually trying to continue a conversation.
Kara Swisher
To organize.
Gal Beckerman
They're trying to organize. And if you look at how a conversation develops without the like button, when the incentive is not, "Let me say the thing that's going to draw everyone's attention in my direction," but it's, "Let me say the thing that's going to keep the conversation going," that's going to say, "That's a good point. Have we thought about this?" or "I know you're saying this, but I think this." That sort of flow is just not, those platforms weren't built for that. They don't really serve those ends.
Kara Swisher
Well, it's a little like the QAnon thing. QAnon is this little club that everybody is in, that they're by themselves. And no one was aware of it for a long time. And then everyone lost their ever-loving minds that they were talking about these things.
Gal Beckerman
In a way, you could say that what I'm arguing is that the same conditions that have incubated a movement like QAnon could be a wonderful thing for a pro-social movement of, say, activists trying to figure out a different way to confront climate change. Do they have those spaces where they're just sort of in a small, heated, intense, intimate environment where they're talking amongst themselves as opposed to shouting out to the world?
Stephanie Ruhle
Can I ask, what was it like for you to spend those weeks or months in that chat room, in that space with white supremacists? What was that like?
Gal Beckerman
I mean, it's pretty, I'd say it's a combination of horrible and kind of slightly amusing, if I'm honest with myself. Because they're so embedded in their worldview there that even the jokes they make, the way they talk to one another, it's just like they're living on another planet. Which is the value of it, too, because they're able to feel that they're reinforcing one another's ideas, that those ideas actually have power. I'd say as somebody who's Jewish, it was particularly disgusting because they are obsessed, obsessed with Jews and the role that they feel Jews have in a nefarious way in affecting all levels of society. In some ways it was not new, but to actually be like, "Oh, who should the guy into the gas chamber first?" To see them make these jokes in such a flippant way. In some ways, it felt more anti-Semitic than overtly racist, bizarrely, because they think the Jews are really behind even things like immigration, helping minorities in all levels of society. It's the one evil that they imagine. And so witnessing that in real time...
Kara Swisher
But I guess I ask because how jarring it must be to actually hear it.
Gal Beckerman
Yeah. The other thing that was interesting to me about seeing, we sort of associate that sort of online white supremacy with a snarky mode of communication, always memes. But they actually, there was a level of earnestness.
Kara Swisher
Right, and intimacy.
Gal Beckerman
Yeah, and intimacy. If you took three steps or many, many more steps than that away from the actual content of what they were talking about, they were like, "Hey, fam." They would refer to each other as family. I remember there was one exchange that made me laugh and was disgusted at the same time about a guy who comes in and says that he went on a date with a woman who he found out is half Jewish. And everyone is consoling him and saying it's okay, man. It was almost like a locker room kind of thing. And I was just struck by the level of vulnerability that they allowed themselves in that space.
Kara Swisher
You know, one of the things when I was covering the earlier net, one of the great things was for people that were like-minded or had like-minded hobbies, finding each other. Whether it was gay people who never could, who were separated and disparate. Or I remember a time when all these quilters came together at AOL and they made a quilt online for Steve Case. And it was really quite moving in terms of people finding each other across chasms of time and space. Then what really happened, though, is the right wing took over this. I interviewed Ralph Reed very early. They were using online spaces like this to find each other because they were zeroed out of regular media.
They were zeroed out of newspapers and television. This is pre-Fox News. And what was interesting to me is that they could find connection. And the connections they found were like white supremacists or right-wing things. And they do very well in these spaces because they need that feeling of community and connection. And they're being attacked. So I would ask you what I think of when you have these, one of the great things about the internet is millions of connections that get made every day. It's astonishing. And people can be thoughtful or they can be thoughtless or whatever they want to be.
But it does create a perfect place for people who are disgruntled to gather. And you see this with Gavin McInnes, Richard Spencer, etc., who you see physically, but there's many more spaces that are either anti-vax or election lies. It tends to go towards the aggrieved more than the "let's all get together and talk about air fryers," which again is my biggest interest these days.
Stephanie Ruhle
Why are you so into air fryers?
Kara Swisher
Why are you so into air fryers? Because they're cool. They are. Just don't even speak to me about it. They're cool. They please me. They please me on air fryers. I don't know why. I'm not going to explain it to you. It's one of my passions. Anyway.
Stephanie Ruhle
I like an air fryer. I look for air fryer recipes, but it's definitely not my go-to. Gal doesn't care about any of this. What I'm wondering is why does it tend towards the negative? He might.
Kara Swisher
Why does it tend toward the negative and not the enjoyment of air fryers, for example? And it does to an extent, by the way. So I'm actually really interested in this question of what the internet was for and how things got skewed in a different direction. It was nice.
Gal Beckerman
It was nice. I actually have a chapter in the book that's about cyberspace, as we called it back then. And I focused on The Well, which I'm sure you must be familiar with. The Well was pre-internet, in the 80s. It was this group of a few thousand people, mostly in the Bay Area. And it was truly the first online community. There had been message boards beforehand for geeky Star Trek message boards, but this was a really interesting bunch of intelligent people all communicating in this new disembodied way. What was interesting about it is the people who ran The Well were hippies. They were people who had all lived on communes in the 70s and they felt they were bringing to this community a knowledge of what it means to create community and what guardrails you need to have up to keep things productive. How you pull people aside and say, "Look, things are getting intense here. Let's cool down." And they did all of that.
Kara Swisher
It was also about how they lived. It was out of the Whole Earth Catalog, right? It was about build your own tire home, that kind of stuff.
Gal Beckerman
Yeah, they believed in the power of tools. So what was interesting to me in delving into The Well was that there was this idealism that emerged from The Well, that the internet could be this place that had all of these private spaces where people of common interest could come together. But Silicon Valley has picked up that ideology and that romanticism in a big way. If you listen to Mark Zuckerberg, he still talks about what he produces as being a place to make connections. But the part that got lost, that got forgotten, was that on day two, they had a troll. They needed bouncers in cyberspace.
And they understood this. That element of it, the need for a kind of structure to make sure that the conversation that was going to happen, these spaces that were going to exist for people actually proved to be creative and productive for them, that part of it got lost somewhere along the capitalist route towards creating bigger and bigger platforms that were going to keep people on for longer and longer. So I do think that that seed is still there, what you're talking about, this place where time and space doesn't exist, you can connect with people in new and interesting ways. I think it's just right now, we've lost a bit of self-awareness about where that can happen.
Kara Swisher
The metaverse.
Stephanie Ruhle
So what's your takeaway at the end of all this?
Gal Beckerman
My takeaway is that my book is focused on how new ideas enter into the world. And the fact that the public sphere that we inhabit today is one that is not particularly good for generating those new ideas.
Kara Swisher
Twitchy and reductive.
Gal Beckerman
Twitchy and reductive. And we know this. This is not new. We know this in almost every other realm of our life. We know this, right?
Even in the time that I've been working on this book, I feel like there's been such a growing awareness of how it's affecting us, how it's affecting my kids. But yet when it comes to the building of movements, you know, to change happening, social and political change happening in the world, I think we still hold on to this kind of romantic idea that all you need is a hashtag to go viral and like everything will change.
Kara Swisher
I mean, I'm being a little flip, but I do think a lot of people kind of still have that sense of it.
Gal Beckerman
And what I would like people to do, to the extent that I have any recommendations for coming out of this book—because it's essentially a book of stories that I hope people will sort of learn from—is that there are other modes of communicating and that we should look for them. It's not that we can't find them online, but we need to maybe stop vilifying the kind of value of seclusion a little bit. Understand that that's important too.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, we need connective tissue.
Gal Beckerman
Exactly. And we need connective tissue, and it can't be through a TikTok dance video.
Kara Swisher
Yep. Anyway. All right, Gal, thank you so much. It's a terrific book. I love all the historical stuff. And I indeed was using the Well... and it was quite a place, I have to say. It was irritating, too, on some level.
Gal Beckerman
I'm sure it was.
Kara Swisher
But it was in a good way. You sort of... it was a different time and a different place in terms of what the internet would become. And it did not become that. It became a capitalist engine of financial growth. Anyway, Gal, I recommend you reading this book. It's called *The Quiet Before: On the Unexpected Origins of Radical Ideas*. Thank you so much.
Gal Beckerman
Thank you. Thank you for having me.
Kara Swisher
Okay, Stephanie. Aside from insulting my air fryer love, one more quick break. We'll be back for predictions.
Break
Okay, Stephanie, predictions. Here's a prediction. Kanye West is now putting up a new music video where he decapitates and buries Pete Davidson, who is apparently dating his now ex-wife.
Stephanie Ruhle
Do you say "apparently" because you want us to act like you don't pay attention? They are dating.
Kara Swisher
They are dating. I don't know. I never know if it's real.
Stephanie Ruhle
I don't know if J-Lo and Ben are going. Okay, thank you. I'm glad you're friends with them.
Kara Swisher
But in any case, I don't know. "God saved me from the crash just so I can beat Pete Davidson's ass" is his lyric. He's been harassing him online for weeks now. I feel like a restraining order is coming. That's my prediction. A restraining order.
Stephanie Ruhle
Wow. It's just appalling what he's doing. I'm sorry. It's gross. It's appalling. It's glib. But we look at it like it's entertainment. What they're experiencing is absolute harassment. And a restraining order should be coming.
Kara Swisher
I would say my... but the problem is he has legions of followers, just like Elon Musk does. And when they unleash this, it's a real issue.
Stephanie Ruhle
That is 100% true. My prediction: things are going to get worse in Ukraine, much worse before they get better. And while it's amazing and inspirational to look at all of these everyday citizens now fighting to defend their country, they're going to get exhausted. And we don't know what—and I don't mean nuclear power, but I just mean firepower, manpower—what Putin has. You've got people putting their lives on the line in Ukraine, and I'm very worried and concerned about how much worse it's going to get.
Kara Swisher
And from my positive, I'm happy to see... is there a better? You said "before it gets better." What's better?
Stephanie Ruhle
I mean, before this thing ends. People are saying, "Listen, Putin's humiliated right now. He's backed into a corner."
Kara Swisher
You're right. He's humiliated and backed into a corner. So what does an irrational animal do? Double down and get worse.
Stephanie Ruhle
No, there's often these thoughts like, "Listen, Putin's on his own. He's screwed." I think even if he is on his own and screwed, he will do horrible, heinous, ridiculous things that will cost innocent people their lives.
Kara Swisher
It's a little... Trump, same way. Like a lot of this stuff that's coming out just today, he's still here.
Stephanie Ruhle
Still here. Yes, but I'm using the word "brave," but I don't mean to. Brave isn't the word. It's like Trump. Putin is like Trump in the way he conducts himself, but he's far more fearless than Trump. Trump wouldn't actually do physical harm. I think Trump is more cowardly than Putin is.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's a very good... this guy is brutal.
Stephanie Ruhle
Brutal. Yes, brutal.
Kara Swisher
You're looking for... but this whole idea, right? People are saying, "Well, the January 6th committee now thinks Trump may be liable, may be a criminal." Listen, that would be great if that's the case. Wake me up when that happens. This is a guy who doesn't use email, doesn't use text. He rolls like a mob boss who never, ever puts his fingerprints on anything. So I'm hard pressed to believe that they're going to get him when they do.
Stephanie Ruhle
Great. My win: I'm really happy for school kids that so many across the country are going to get to play sports and go to school without masks on in a week. But I am sad for people like your family who get easily forgotten, who have kids under the age of five. People like mine who are celebrating going, "Oh my gosh, my family is about to have the biggest win." My sons cannot wait to play basketball with no mask, and my daughter to go to school smiling. Win for us. We're forgetting what a dangerous loss it is for families like yours. That's what I'm worried about.
Kara Swisher
And immunocompromised. I'm more concerned with immunocompromised people. I was... they'd just taken masks off in D.C. and I was in a store and someone was clearly immunocompromised. And I put my mask right on because this woman was wearing a mask. And you've got to be aware of kids. And I know you're sick of COVID. I know you're sick of masks. Most of the lecturing about kids in masks comes from people that don't have kids.
Stephanie Ruhle
Did you see Ron DeSantis yesterday?
Kara Swisher
Ron DeSantis was... he was kind of joking with them. No, he wasn't. Watch it closer.
Stephanie Ruhle
Yesterday at an indoor event. I saw what he did. Remember, people who are arguing against masks aren't saying that masks are dangerous. They're saying it's freedom of choice. The government shouldn't tell you you have to wear a mask, you have to vaccinate. And he walks in and screams at teenage boys to take their masks off. And then he proceeds to say, "I can't believe these Ukrainians are out there fighting." That's so weird. You wouldn't see that happen in France. It's a reminder that so many of these lawmakers are supposed to be... He went to Yale undergrad, Harvard Law School. He knows what happened in France in World War II. The sick thing is that he's banking on the fact that you and I don't. And that's what's gross.
Kara Swisher
Yes, yes. Yeah, he's a smarter Trump in a lot of ways.
Stephanie Ruhle
What's really interesting about that is, it's true. A lot of these people who don't want to wear masks certainly have been very aggressive in telling people not to wear masks. But that's the thing. What business is it of anybody else's?
Kara Swisher
Nobody's business. We're lucky to have these vaccines to allow us to move through this. But I'll tell you, let people do what they want and have their degree of comfort and stop it. You've already been assholes on one side. You don't need to do it on the other. How about be kind, full stop?
Stephanie Ruhle
Be kind. That's a very... be kind to Stephanie and Kara.
Kara Swisher
Okay, we'll take a listener question in our next episode. What do you want us to know? Go to nymag.com/pivot to submit your question. For us, call 855-51-PIVOT. The link is in our show notes. Okay, Stephanie, that's the show. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. I know you're busy and tired. This has been a tough... it's not a tough week, but you've had a big crash course in anchoring, I think.
Stephanie Ruhle
I know you've experienced anchor. You know, women, every time we have another child, we gain a superpower that our human bodies don't require sleep. We're just smiling zombies.
Kara Swisher
Then I am Captain Marvel in that case.
Stephanie Ruhle
But your show is terrific. We watch it every night.
Kara Swisher
Sadly, the golden child who liked watching your show in the morning cannot watch it now because she is asleep.
Stephanie Ruhle
Well, she may start waking up at 11 p.m. because she wants to have a cocktail and tune in. You never know.
Kara Swisher
I think not. I think she's watching *Encanto* and the family Madrigal. That's her whole media diet right now. Anyway, it's a great show. Everybody should watch it. *The 11th Hour* with Stephanie Ruhle?
Stephanie Ruhle
It is. It's called *The 11th Hour*. *The 11th Hour with Stephanie Ruhle*. You probably don't call it *11th Hour with Brian Williams* anymore. Just slight change.
Kara Swisher
I think he should have kept that. Yeah, that would have been exciting. Just fuck with people. Can you start using those folksy metaphors that he did? You know, like a two-headed chicken and whatever.
Stephanie Ruhle
He's got his own. I'm going to use my own. Brian had his own very special style that I wouldn't dare emulate or try to.
Kara Swisher
All right. Okay. Well, I like those folks. I miss those. Anyway, Stephanie Ruhle. She's a big star at MSNBC, and she still manages to come on the show. I'm going to read us out. Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Anderdot engineered this episode. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to *Pivot* from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Thank you, Stephanie.