Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various business and technology topics, including Elon Musk's bid to acquire Twitter, the potential implications of such a deal, and the future of streaming media.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Podcast Intro Music
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Scott Galloway
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you're quiet. Why are you quiet? Did you have a relaxing weekend?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I had a nice weekend. I was with my boys on a boat. And whenever you're on a boat, you feel like you should do an ad for some sort of cryptocurrency. Because clearly being on a boat means you're smart and very successful. But it was fun. We went.
Kara Swisher
This is a nice boat. This wasn't a rowboat like I own, correct?
Scott Galloway
Yes, it was a very nice boat. But we went spearfishing and we did a bunch of stuff on water vehicles and all the kinds of things I could slip and break a hip doing that I do as an older father to try and bond with my sons. But yeah, it was really, anyway, it was lovely. What did you do?
Kara Swisher
I spent the weekend with the golden child and we were stopped many times on the streets. People were like, is this the golden child?
Scott Galloway
People would say that?
Kara Swisher
They would say, is this the golden child? Yeah, it's crazy how many times I'm getting stopped now and here in San Francisco all the time. I'm in San Francisco.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I like that. I like it when people stop. They're always friendly.
Kara Swisher
Yep, I was with Alex and Clara recently, and they're like, oh, it's Gigantor and the golden child. They're like characters in art. That's funny. Speaking of characters, can we recall when you took me on a boating expedition, what happened? Where did we end up? Make America Florida and Trump flags everywhere. Wasn't that hilarious?
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. I literally was like, I can't even. I can't even. It was not hilarious. You're like, I'm not going in the water. And I'm like, no one asked you to go in the water.
Kara Swisher
No, I never go in the water. I'm like a cat. I'm like a cat. It's not because of the Trump people. I'm not a big water person anymore. I used to love the water. But literally, we went to slap into one of those boat rallies. It was quite active. People were having a good time. They're running around with their flags and stuff.
Scott Galloway
You know what I say? Let Florida be Florida, just like they should let everybody else be what they are.
Kara Swisher
Thank you. Yeah, I know. That is my speech. Speaking of TED Talks, there was one by Elon Musk, as you know. Anyway, we'll talk about Apple unions, online shopping, and what CNN Plus launch means for the streaming market. And we'll speak with Puck's William D. Cohen about why he thinks Elon will buy Twitter, which a lot of people do, even though you do not. I have to say, there's a movement afoot saying there are no other, there can only be only one and there is only one. But first, let's catch up on where Elon's Twitter bid is now. This is our first big story. So let's do it.
Transition
On Friday, Twitter's board adopted a poison pill to fend off Elon's bid. A lot of people don't like it. It's not shareholder friendly. Under the plan, Twitter's stock will dilute if Elon or any buyer acquires 15% of the company's shares. Many think it's anti-shareholder and an entrenchment of current management and board. Elon took the news exactly how it expected. He tweeted a critique of the board and said their opinion doesn't matter because of their low number of shares, which is often the case with boards. He also hinted there may be other potential bidders. And of course, all of a sudden, stories all over the place that he was joining with people. And on a quick call, a lot of the people I thought might be against him or for him and might be rejoining with him. I'm not going to say names, but it's the ones you would imagine. Anyway, these are hedge fund and private equity people. Of course, I think you've been talking to people, Scott, would be my guess. So weigh in on this idea of this poison pill, et cetera.
Scott Galloway
So as someone who was in a past life an activist investor, you don't like poison pills. It's typically thought of as one of the weapons of mass entrenchment. I remember when I was on the board of Gateway Computer, by the way, I acknowledge a very weak flex.
Kara Swisher
Yes, it was. I was going to say nothing.
Scott Galloway
People were aggregating shares. The company was, so if you go back 25 years, there was a debate on whether it would be Dell or Gateway, and they were both trading at the same price. Dell, better strategy. They went SMB. We went consumer. We actually had stores. Imagine an Apple store, but if it was nothing like an Apple store.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I recall.
Scott Galloway
And a lot of poor execution. And Ted Waite, who was a visionary, but the company just didn't do – the company ended up going from $76 a share. And then when I got involved, I think it was at $2 a share. Yeah. And I went in and said, we need to sell this thing right away. And they said, okay, okay, smartass. We've been trying to sell a thing for two years. Sit down. And people started acquiring shares and one individual started acquiring shares, including the person who was backing my adventures and activism. And the chairman of the board at that time, a guy named Rick Snyder, who went on to be the governor of Michigan, said we should put in place a poison pill. And I'm like, that's just a weapon of mass entrenchment.
Kara Swisher
Explain what a poison pill, like how this is to in order to not let people acquire too many shares was during Green Mail days and the Carl Icahn, those kind of things.
Scott Galloway
So it's basically meant it was invented by, I don't know, the guy, a lawyer in New York who was on the board of NYU. I forget his name. It essentially blocks anyone from acquiring more than a certain stake. Because what happens is once they hit a certain threshold, in this case 15%, the other shareholders are offered shares at a discount, thereby diluting that stake, that 15% stake that triggered it weighed down. They flood the zone with shares.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but the net effect is it blocks you from acquiring more than that threshold.
Scott Galloway
Right. And I usually have an adverse reaction to them because my feeling is if you're willing to show up and continue to buy more shares and push the price up, that in the short run is bad for shareholder value. So the reason why Twitter stock is 20 percent below his offer price is, one, I don't think people believe he can actually raise the money. And two, when you put in a poison pill, it does kind of block them from acquiring the company.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Or it moves it to – it moves sort of a standstill so they can negotiate with him. That's another reason people do it, to like slow things down.
Scott Galloway
Well, that's what I remember the chairman of our board, Rick Sainter, saying, you know, if they want to come in, they have to come in through the front door. And I'm like, the front door? What does that mean? Deal with someone who doesn't own any shares, i.e. you? And also, to Elon's credit, a really fair criticism is accountability should be linked to ownership.
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
And this board doesn't own a lot of shares. Nor do they use Twitter a lot, just FYI. And that is a really telling sign that maybe they're not great fiduciaries for other shareholders or their users when they don't use it and they don't own shares. I've always thought that every dollar you get in compensation on the board should be reinvested in stock in the company such that you can put yourself in the shoes of shareholders, at least to a certain extent. Because some board members don't have a lot of money and they can't come in and buy millions, but they should at least put their fees back into the company. But what you have here is – so I've been – I'm telling you, Cara, the world of alternative investments and hedge funds is a flutter with this deal. I'm getting calls from probably a lot of the same people you're getting calls from saying, what do you think is going on here? Should we finance this? Is he serious? Is he serious is the question I'm getting.
Kara Swisher
Well, that's the thing. Morgan Stanley. There's a lot of is he crazy. You know him, that kind of thing. Morgan Stanley is out there trying to put together the capital for this thing. And the question is, is Morgan Stanley had honey poured on them and been sent hunting for bears? Is this just a fool's errand?
Scott Galloway
Right. And someone – I think Matt Levine, who I continue to believe is just this incredible writer, has basically said it's very hard to deal with someone when you don't know whether it's a joke or not. You don't know whether it's a joke. And I also think there are potentially people lining up to come in and be the blocking move of the white knight. So, for example, Vanguard is now a larger shareholder. They might be on management's side. If Twitter can find another 10% shareholder to come in and not be in favor of the deal, they're fine. They're probably – Elon's not going to be able to do the deal.
Kara Swisher
What's their take? What's the one that wants to go up against Elon? Ooh, this is a choice target. Although looking at the business, it's not such a choice target, right? Explicitly, it could be, certainly. I think people look at the influence and the position it commands and says, okay, you have one of the handful of social media networks that has global influence.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
And it trades at a fraction of the value of anything else of that influence in social media. And if it can trade at 76 bucks nine months ago, it's just likely it's going to trade back there again. And so – but the terms I've heard from people who are contemplating investing in this behind Musk, they want their pound of flesh. And that goes to the next point. And the reason why I don't think this happened because people – I don't think people are sketching out what I'll call the second-order effects. They're like, let's talk about a few things. Let's talk about what happens when this private company has a preferred convertible, some sort of preferred instrument or debt that wants 12% a year. I mean, you're talking about expensive debt. People look at this and go, okay, Ilan, if we're going to back you.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, right now. Debt's a big deal right now with the interest rates, but go ahead.
Kara Swisher
And then what happens, this is the other question I have. How do you raise money when you have said publicly, this isn't about money, it's about free speech? I don't think people are going to spend billions of dollars to fund your misadventures and free speech. I think that's the most pertinent point. I think this is not about money for Elon. I don't think he did. If he wants to make a killing, he could do it in 10 to 12 other places so quickly. And he does build substantive companies. And so and I think that's where his real interest is for the real wealth. Whatever you think of Tesla stock, what he's doing is a massive thing and has a massive opportunity. Here, the opportunity is dicier than even Tesla, if you think about it. Like, Tesla is such a complex product. This is a difficult product.
Scott Galloway
But that's the other second order. There's two other second order effects, and we'll come back to Tesla. But the next second order effect, what happens to the employee base the day they close?
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Because I'm going to argue that the people there, as it relates to their view of First Amendment or censorship or free speech, they have decided whatever Twitter is doing is kind of where they're down with. They aren't doing walkouts. And they're saying, okay, this guy's coming in with this new vision of censorship. And all he's said is this isn't about money. Well, I'm going to go out on a limb here and assume that a large number of people at Twitter are there for the money. That they're there to make a living.
Kara Swisher
Well, yeah. And I think they also feel like they're under siege with this guy because he keeps insulting them. You all suck is essentially his message. I've lost confidence in management after saying I like them a week ago.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, management. You're not running it right. You're not doing it right. And that's, of course, a normal thing. But in this case, he's more influential. Whatever he says matters a lot more. And they don't, you know, I think they don't, you've seen them pop up on Twitter quite a bit. You don't see that often. They're like, fuck this, like essentially.
Kara Swisher
I think that's one of the things. They also, what's really funny about the poison pill, it adds up, Matt Levine was pointing out, it adds up to 420. Also, they're making a little weed joke back at Elon, which is kind of cute. What it will do, just for people to understand, this will slow Elon down. It will not stop him. Correct? This is, right?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but you know what will stop him?
Kara Swisher
What?
Scott Galloway
He's going to find another shining toy. He's like a cat chasing a red dot. You keep saying that. This is a toy to him. This is shiny. He's not going to hang in there. He's setting itself up so he can say, I tried to save it, and now I'm going on to Shiba Uno. I mean, I—
Kara Swisher
He could buy something else. He could buy Gab. Gab is trying to get sold to him. That's by the way. They offered up an investment. They're going to run out the clock on the guy. And specifically, they're going to run out his attention span, which is a 24-second clock.
Scott Galloway
Well, we'll see.
Kara Swisher
I know. I get it. You and I are at different points, and I think Bill's going to provide a different viewpoint than me.
Scott Galloway
Also, what happens, he has not outlined a single cogent strategy for how he's going to actually increase value. Other activists have done that, including you, including Chris Saka, if you remember. They had very serious proposals to do that. So you're asking the employees, if this thing closes, to sign up for some Fox News misconstrued perversion of what censorship is or isn't from a new owner who says he doesn't care about money. And it's like, well, I'm supposed to sign up for your misadventures in free speech, and you've said it's not about money? Come again?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. This is now – what are the odds there's another bidder, like a Google and the rest? You know, obviously Mark Cuban talked about that. I have not – there's some private equity firms. I think it's Toma. Is that right, Toma? Toma Bravo, yeah. Yeah, there's a couple that are sort of putting their feet in the water. And several ones I thought might – gave me no comments this weekend, not no fucking ways. So it's interesting that they've got it. Like, I don't see another bidder. Who is the other bidder?
Scott Galloway
Well, so this is the thing. I don't think somebody wants to take this private. I think what somebody does is come in and says, we think there's an opportunity here. Even at $45, someone could talk themselves into believing it's undervalued and says, we'll be a blocking move here. If we buy 10% or 12% of the company, we effectively, it's sort of game over. Vanguard doesn't go along with Musk. That means that there's 22%. I don't think he can raise the money, Kira. We'll start there.
Kara Swisher
Reddit's former CEO, Yashan Wong, who writes great threads, wrote a long thread about the challenges of content moderation. He's like, you don't want to catch this car, dog. And why Elon's free speech argument is all wrong. Essentially, he's like, this is an unmanageable situation, no matter how you slice it. And there's no way out of it and no way to make a lot of money. Of course, Elon tweeted his takeaway, we need long-form tweets, which we do, by the way. He's good on the edit stuff, for sure. I thought that was a very thoughtful—whether he can get it or not is one question. Whether he can run it or not is another one, of course.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but that's manicuring. That's not a fundamental change in business model. I just think the employees—Twitter would become the most—would be the most fertile hunting ground for recruiters in the last 10 years if this thing were to close under Musk's leadership. I think a third of senior level management would be out of there within 90 days.
Kara Swisher
All right.
Scott Galloway
They're not going to sign up. He hasn't been able to articulate anything resembling a vision for how anyone there is going to make any money.
Kara Swisher
Would you leave? I don't think I would. I thought about this. Would you leave the service?
Scott Galloway
Oh, no. I would. I'm addicted. That's like saying I don't like my new heroin dealer. I'm still buying heroin.
Kara Swisher
Okay. Another thing is Elon has a lot of lawsuits on all fronts, too. He's being sued. Now, this is nothing new to him. He's been sued a lot. He's being sued by Twitter investors over his delayed disclosure. Those are the same investors he need to win over Now if he wants the bid to succeed he might have to settle with them Tesla investors are suing him over his 2018 funding secured stunt The judge ruled this month that those tweets were false and paved the way for a trial next month And earlier this year of course, California's Department of Fair Employment and Housing sued Tesla, alleging racist treatment of Black employees. That particular department is also controversial, but nonetheless, Tesla has said this was in the past and they fixed all the things. And so anyway, so that's where we are.
Scott Galloway
I'll just interject here. It's worse than that. Did you see the TED Talk at Vancouver that he just gave?
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
He called the SEC bastards.
Kara Swisher
He does that. He did that at Code. What did he call them at Code? He has a name for SEC. But go ahead. This is something, nothing new.
Scott Galloway
Called them bastards. But worse than that, he said that he, in fact, did have funding secured. And the SEC bullied him into saying that he hadn't when he, in fact, had funding secured. And then just a few hours later, news broke. A district judge who has reviewed all the evidence goes, no, he was lying. So I think this is an individual who is so detached from any sort of signals or advice or has no guardrails that he not only, quite frankly, is prone to falsehoods. He doubles down on them in the face of judges saying there's no evidence here that you had funding secured. He could have just sort of politely walked back and said, not brought it up again. Instead, he's saying, no, I had funding secured. No, he didn't. He did not.
Kara Swisher
Let me ask you a question because I got a lot of texts like this. Why is Scott so mad at Elon? You saw some of them on Twitter. And I'm like, he's not. He just doesn't agree with him. That's like, what's the deal?
Scott Galloway
He's definitely got – one of the things I hate about this is – I was going to tweet this because Glenn Greenwald had another asinine thing saying everybody who's against this wants to control all speech on all these issues. And I'm like, oh, stop it. And then I got another one saying, Elon is a fascist. We don't know if he's going to be a fascist. I'm like, he's not. What are you doing? So both sides of this on either of the strong sides, you're all assholes. You're all fucking assholes. This is much more complex. And so I think one of the things that I did get that I was also pushing back on was Scott doesn't, has a personal vendetta against you.
I'm like, no, he doesn't. This is just, Elon's not a fascist. Scott does not have a personal agenda. I own a Tesla. I have huge admiration for him. There is something about this, that this situation epitomizes that really bothers me and scares me. And that is, I think the fundamental, the elemental foundation of societies is relationships. And I think one of the key components of relationships is guardrails. And I just think we're all so much better when we have somebody who is making sure we make some trains and miss others that says to us, no, you're not thinking correctly. And I think there are so many levels.
The tribe, we're a herd species, not only because we need touch, but because we make much better decisions when we have other people and other agencies to provide guardrails. And let's look at the traditional guardrails. There's regulatory agencies. There's economics. So I just can't afford to do that. There's a board. There's your partner slash wife slash husband. There are your inability to just go out and buy an entire media company that's global. We haven't had that kind of wealth amassed before. All of these guardrails, Cara, whether it's the SEC, other shareholders, a wife, friends, a board, they have all been blown by.
And I think it's dangerous. And I think the founding fathers of America, when they came up with three different houses of government, I think they realized the importance of guardrails and churns and making sure that no one individual became too powerful.
Kara Swisher
That's great. But I think people overstating how powerful Twitter is, they're like, this is the end of – I was like, stop it. It's one – No, it's not a national treasure. It's not – but it does have a lot of – I do think – did you read Shoshana – Actually, did you read Shoshana Zuboff's article? on the Washington Post?
Scott Galloway
I will. No, I will. I will.
Kara Swisher
She has a good point. She says these algorithms under the control of one person, there's only one case study and it's Mark Zuckerberg and that did not end well. I think they're very different people. I'm going to say that I would suspect this will be run a lot better under him. But nonetheless, I'm not an apologist for him at the same time. You know, we'll see what happens. We're going to actually get an expert on here too. Bill Cohen in a second. But just so you know, 420 is tomorrow. Enjoy yourselves. Both Elon and the board have been slipping these 420 jokes in their filings. And also, SNL had fun with the news this weekend. Let's listen to that for a second.
Audio clip plays
SNL Performer
Elon Musk offered to buy Twitter for over $40 billion so he can loosen its free speech rules. That's how badly white guys want to use the N-word. Plus, I gotta say, Twitter's not even profitable anymore. It just feels like a bad business decision. And I say that as someone who bought a Staten Island ferry with Pete.
Audio clip ends
Kara Swisher
Well, that kind of encapsulated it, right? There it was, the bad business decision, white guys who want to say whatever they want. Although I cannot tell you how many of those there are. Every meeting I have now with a white guy or a powerful white guy is like, you know, I can't say what I want. And I'm like, oh, God, you're so fucking tiresome. I'm like, they're tiresome. I don't care if you can't say what you want. And it's not about – the whole wrapping it in the free speech First Amendment thing is excessive, as is the idea that this guy is going to somehow blow up the entire world. There are other people actually blowing up the entire world. That's my only point.
Scott Galloway
I think that's fair.
Kara Swisher
But I just – I flip on Fox and they're all there just with their hair on fire that thinking – or saying he's the William Wallace coming in to say free speech. And I'm like, free speech? What can people not say? Twitter. What? He hates them. So you not allowing Elizabeth Warren to respond in real time on your front screen? Are you censoring her? I just I can't get over this whole censorship. They're driving me crazy. And the other part is some of the people who know better, they're like, in them not accepting this immediately, they are showing this. I was like, no, this is how deals work, people. What are you, 12? You never just say, OK, thanks for this. This is great. I'll take the first offer. Can we help you raise money? There were like 10 people who know better who've done deals like this, and they're like, they need to accept it immediately. I'm like, are you kidding me, you greedy fucks? That's what I kept thinking. Like, are you crazy? Like, nobody accepts the first offer.
Scott Galloway
You know, they hope they do. Well, here's what's behind those people trying to promote the deal. Merge Arb is an entire category of investing where you take the offer price of $54.50 and you buy shares and you bet on the fact that the deal is going to go through. And right now, it's even with the stock up a little bit today, the stated price is 20% above where the stock is right now. So there's probably a lot of people taking a position in the stock and then will very publicly advocate to get their 20% two-week gain, which is an enormous gain. And here's the thing. I just don't – I believe the board and a lot of shareholders would believe that if you sell at the 52-week average and less than where it was four or five months ago, you're not acting as good fiduciaries. So the other – the X factor here, and I'm still holding on here. I do believe in government. I think the SEC is going to pop up here. We'll see. I think they're working very hard to show up and have a view here. They're like Godot in this.
Kara Swisher
In any case, we have someone to talk to anybody. That was a really good literature. Very good. Very good.
Scott Galloway
Speaking of white.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. Hello, Georgetown medalist. Jesus Christ.
Scott Galloway
All right, Scott, I'm not apologizing for my incredible education. I had an incredible education. But let's bring in someone who actually knows how this works. Bill Cohen from Puck News is really good on this stuff and has been writing for lots of places. I've been reading them for years on all kinds of companies. Bill, welcome to Pivot.
William D. Cohan
Thank you, Kara. It's great to be here. An honor, in fact.
Kara Swisher
So your latest piece, you argue, contrary to popular belief, Elon's bid is serious and it will likely succeed. So that's a conversation starter. Got me thinking, and you and I have been going back and forth on Twitter. It's actually moved me more to your side. I'm sort of in the middle, but I do think he's serious. So talk about why you think Elon's bid could work. And given all the things that's going against it, his offer is below the 52-week high, the board is lined up against him. He said publicly doesn't care about Twitter's economics, which could scare off potential partners, although I've heard a lot of people want to get together with him. So let's get your overview and explain what argument you were making.
William D. Cohan
Look, first, I think it's important to say that, you know, what Scott has said last week, I mean, you know, and you probably know better than anyone, Kara, he is a bit of a flake. So it's not exactly clear. He's the world's richest flake.
Kara Swisher
You know, it's incredible. He's worth, you know, obviously $275 billion. He could do this if he wanted to, but he's also a flake. So I'm not sure exactly what he has in mind here. But to me, it all comes down to proving out that he has the financing. That's it. If he can prove, I mean, I can't believe that Morgan Stanley and Scott worked there. I can't believe that Morgan Stanley and I worked at J.B. Morgan Chase, Lazard and Merrill Lynch. I can't believe that Morgan Stanley would take this assignment without knowing in advance or be highly confident, as we used to say in the old days, that Elon Musk could raise the capital that he needs for this $43 billion deal. And if he can show Morgan Stanley and then Goldman Sachs that he has this financing, I think this thing's over.
When I was talking to some of these possible partners this weekend, every single one of them, they called me. Is he crazy? Was the question that every, you know him, is he crazy? Is he serious? And it was a really interesting thing because that was the opening question of some very smart people who usually could, would like run right over their mother to get whatever they wanted. So I think I was really, I think that was their worry, which was interesting to me.
William D. Cohan
Again, I don't know whether he's serious. I don't know whether he's crazy. But look, the guy's accomplished a lot. I mean, you can't argue with the fact that he's the world's richest man. He's created Tesla. He single-handedly revived the electric vehicle industry that was 100 years old and dormant for 98 of those years. He's SpaceX is an amazing accomplishment. I don't really know what the boring company is all about. You know, but does he do some crazy things?
Yes, taking Twitter, taking Tesla private at 420, that whole thing, funding fully secured. That has really hurt his credibility on Wall Street, by the way, because everybody knew back then that that was a joke or whatever it was. It was not real, and nobody took it real. And I think that's definitely hurting his credibility. The merger with SolarCity, also between Tesla and SolarCity, basically made no sense except to bail out a bunch of friends and family investors. And so that made no sense. So he does lack credibility on Wall Street. On the other hand, the stock has done very well. He's the world's richest guy. He owns 9.1% of Twitter. He put up $2.6 billion of his own money. All that's real.
Scott Galloway
First off, Bill and I are friends and I'm glad. So I just want to acknowledge that whenever we're on different sides of an issue, you'd be best served to kind of go with the guy with the good hair. So, Bill, always good to see you. And you, Scott. But we are on different sides of this issue. So my sense is, and maybe I'm missing something here, but even this guy worth $240 billion, most of that comes from Tesla stock. I don't see how he raises the money without borrowing a lot of money against his Tesla stock. A Tesla analyst says there's a scenario where if the stock went up fivefold, it can go down 80% and we got to start doing margin calls on this guy. I think this ultimately puts pressure, even if he could come up with the money, on Tesla stock. Right now, I know Morgan Stanley is out there calling everyone that sits on multi-billions of dollars, and the conditions that lenders are going to put on this. One, I'm not sure he can raise the money. And two, doesn't it ultimately end up being nothing but downside for Tesla shareholders? That's OPM, other people's money. That's what he's asking about. But go ahead, Bill.
William D. Cohan
Look, again, it all comes back to whether he can finance this one way or the other. He only needs 40 of the 43, right? I can't decipher what of his Tesla stock is available to be margined or borrowed against. I absolutely agree with you 100%, Scott, that if he starts leveraging up or margining all of his Tesla stock to the point where lenders are going to... well, it's really going to be the Tesla board that's going to say, no way.
Scott Galloway
They have a board, Bill?
William D. Cohan
Well, theoretically, they have a board.
Scott Galloway
They never say no way.
William D. Cohan
Right. They never say no. If he wants to risk everything he has built at Tesla, and all the wealth he has created at Tesla, through Tesla, for Twitter, to buy Twitter, I suspect he can do that. Why he would do that, I have no idea.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
All right. So you wrote your piece before the board issued the poison pill. Can you talk about your thoughts on this use of it? And has that changed your prediction? Or is it just takes longer and he's got to?
William D. Cohan
Poison pill is a mere hurdle on the road to a deal. Every hostile deal ends up turning friendly if it gets done. So the fact that it starts off hostile, and I know last week Scott said, you know, he's saying this is his final and best offer. And who does that? Nobody negotiates that way. So what he says in an SEC filing, it's his final and best offer. It's not his final and best offer if he really wants this company. Now, if he's trying to pump and dump, then maybe it is his final and best offer. I don't know why he would pump and dump for an extra $700 million when he's got $275 billion. That doesn't seem very interesting, but OK, it's a win.
At some point, Goldman Sachs has to do three things. Goldman Sachs represents Twitter. One, they have to find somebody else, anybody else but Elon Musk, to buy this company. I don't think they're going to. Number two, they have to decide whether $54.20 a share is fair. I don't see how any way in the world they do not find that this is fair from a financial point of view to Twitter shareholders. So that's two things in Elon's favor. The one thing not in Elon's favor, and it's a big thing, is his financing real? Can he attract enough odd billionaires, Silver Lake, whoever else might be willing to finance this and give them some sort of preferred return to put equity in here? Can he get enough of that? Can he go to SoftBank? Can he go to the Saudi Arabia principal investing fund? Who knows? Norway? I don't know who his friends are or where he's going to get this money. He does need to get this money. If he proves this is real, if Morgan Stanley can tell Goldman Sachs this is real, I think it's game, set, match over.
Kara Swisher
Can you talk, you mentioned Silver Lake, which is on the board of Twitter. Egon Durbin, who's the co-CEO, is on the board of Twitter. He voted for the poison pill, which was just a slowing tactic, really, pretty much, from what I can understand from reading you. How does that play in, that Egon just says, I'm going with Elon? Or what happens there?
William D. Cohan
I think it's important to note that basically the board of directors of Twitter owns essentially no stock, except for Jack Dorsey, who owns like 2.5%. So you look at the big shareholders: Vanguard, BlackRock, Morgan Stanley Asset Management, Elon Musk. Those three asset management companies, they're all going to go for Elon Musk's $54.20 a share if it's real. Egon Durbin, he's a private equity guy. He'll take this money and run so quickly and ka-ching it and say that he's got this win. When did he make this investment, a year ago? That's a beautiful IRR. So he'll just use that to fundraise off the next thing. So why did he go along with it? This is easy. This is sleeves off the vest. This is nothing. I don't think there's ever been a case where an actual poison pill that was put in place was actually invoked. In other words, giving shareholders a chance to buy stock at a discount. I don't think that's ever happened. It's just a way for the board to get this guy's attention and to slow him down a little bit and force him to negotiate with the board, who, by the way, owns no stock.
Scott Galloway
So let's assume he can secure the funding, which I don't think he can, but just for the purposes of argument. Let's assume that he can, and Morgan Stanley shows up with the capital. I actually don't agree. I think the board would be well within their rights. You use the term fair price. I think fair is almost a useless word in the realm of M&A. If I'm on the board, our stock was at this level in October. It's been as high as 76. I think they would be well within their rights to say this offer drastically undervalues Twitter, and we're going to keep plowing forward. Now, if he were to raise it to 60 or 65 and get within striking distance of the 52-week high or the five-year high, fine. But this offer right now, Bill, is just at the 52-week average, and the company has only gained in influence. I think it'd be well within the rights to say you're dramatically undervaluing the firm. We can only sell it once, and we're rejecting this out of hand.
William D. Cohan
I agree with some of that, but not all of that. I've given a lot of fairness opinions. I know what doing those is like. Again, without the financing being real and firmed up, I completely agree with you. This gets rejected out of hand. Goldman Sachs can just keep saying no. The board can say no. But the moment this financing becomes real, and I don't know if it ever will become real, at that moment, then Goldman Sachs is going to have a very difficult time saying this is not fair. Why? First of all, on a good day, the EBITDA of Twitter is a billion dollars a year. On a good day. So this is 45 times EBITDA. That's number one. Number two, you can DCF cash flows all day long and not get to—
Kara Swisher
Explain what that is.
William D. Cohan
Discounted cash flow. You project out the EBITDA of this company. You discount it back. If it gets to 43 billion, it will absolutely be in the range of that discounted cash flows, bars on the PowerPoint presentation. The publicly traded comparables will be in the range. The privately traded companies, the multiples will be in the range. So I don't see how... and yes, it is below its 52-week high of last year. So is the whole market. It's below, it's down from last November. Rivian went public at whatever it was, 75, it went up to 175. Now it's at 40. So the market is correcting. Interest rates are on the rise dramatically. The party is over. The punch bowl is being taken away. So if I'm Goldman Sachs and I have to prove that this thing is fair and say it's fair, you're going to be hard pressed if the financing is real to say it's not fair. In the old days, by now, we would have a letter from Mike Milken saying, "I'm highly confident that Elon Musk could have the financing." And that would win it.
Kara Swisher
What if he wins it? So what does he have? You're talking about not a very good business, is what I think you said. It's not a very good business, it's never been, but it's influential, right, as Scott has often pointed out. I spent a lot of time all weekend where everyone's like, "This is the end of the world." I'm like, it's not a very good business. It's going to be hard running it. It's going to be hard. Yashan from Reddit had a nice tweet, a series of tweets about that. I mean, what does he get when he gets this? Does he have a debt-loaded company with all kinds of problems? That's what it sounds like to me.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. It sounds like a poison chalice.
Kara Swisher
Oh, poison chalice. I like that. Explain for the people.
Scott Galloway
He's going to have a company that has a lot of debt on it that doesn't generate a lot of EBITDA. He could, he's Elon Musk, the world's richest man. He could pump more equity into it somehow if he's got any left. But more importantly, if he does any of the things that he's talking about doing, for instance, if he cuts out advertising, then that EBITDA is going to disappear, or a lot of it. If he brings back Donald Trump, forget about it, as we say in New York. He could lose two-thirds of the users very quickly, and then he's the king of nothing. He's paid $43 billion for something he just has to fold up and close, and it's a disaster. And maybe he doesn't care because he's the world's richest guy. But by that point, he will have margined and leveraged his Tesla stock. And it could be a total house of cards.
Kara Swisher
Well, if you were advising him, what else should he buy then? If he has an itch for this kind of thing. Obviously, he has an itch for Twitter. He loves it. But should he invest in Gab? They ask for money from him?
Scott Galloway
I would not have done any of this if I were Elon. He had tremendous... I would just stick at my 9.1% and see what happens. He has tremendous influence on Twitter without owning the company. He's got 81 million followers. He doesn't need to do any of this. But you know him better than we do. He obviously has an insatiable desire to be the focus of attention.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And also, he actually, I think he sat up nights smoking the weed and thinking about what he could do to fix this, right?
Scott Galloway
Smoking the weed. You're so down with the young people. Smoking the weed. Like the kids do.
Kara Swisher
For shizzle, Cara. Sarah Fischel. The 420.
Scott Galloway
Fellow kids.
Kara Swisher
Well, what do you think the role is, or is there a role for a white knight here? Somebody who comes in and says, "Hey, Twitter board, we'll take 10% and basically be a blocking move." Is there a white knight here?
Scott Galloway
I don't know if 10% is the blocking move, but sure.
Kara Swisher
What is?
Scott Galloway
51%. That will be for sure the blocking move. There's certainly a role for a savior here. An old-fashioned white knight. But it's $43 billion. It's 43 times EBITDA. None of the private equity guys are going to play in this. Brava, Bravatoma all day long can talk about this. But 43 times EBITDA, and that's on a good day. You need Google or Microsoft. Or Apple or Microsoft to come to the table.
Kara Swisher
What about Salesforce?
Scott Galloway
Well, Salesforce, maybe. But I don't really see it.
Kara Swisher
Actually, just some nuance here, and that's a really interesting idea. What if Benioff just comes in and Salesforce comes in and buys 10%? And a Vanguard? I got a bunch of calls over the weekend from people asking for thoughts around Twitter and Elon and its value. And I couldn't figure out whether they were lining up behind Elon or against him to block him. And I disagree. I don't think it's 51%. I think Mark Benioff could come in and do the math and say, if Vanguard's not with Musk, I'll come in at 10%. And it's basically game over because they're not going to get to 50%. Only 80% shows up at a special meeting, meaning you need 40%. And if there are 20 of this, I don't think a blocking move requires much more than kind of low double digits. And then Benioff gets to keep it out of the hands of Musk and see if he wants it at some point and gets to act like the hero and say—
He likes that. He does like that.
Scott Galloway
"This should be a company with diverse sets of owners and a real board. And it should assign itself and acquit itself of more democratic input and good governance. And I'm going to be part of that. And then maybe we'll swing back in a year or two years and talk about doing a transaction." And he looks like the white knight. Your thoughts, Bill? Do you think that could happen?
William D. Cohan
I think there's plenty of room for a white knight here. The only premise that I don't agree with is I think Vanguard... why would Vanguard stick around for this if they can get $54.20 cash?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they represent retail investors. This is a 38% premium to what it was trading at before he announced.
William D. Cohan
Do you know their cost basis? I guess that's a question. What did they get in at?
Scott Galloway
Well, I don't know Vanguard's cost basis.
William D. Cohan
Because if they've gotten in in the last five months, they're down.
Scott Galloway
If they haven't gotten in in the last five months, excuse me, they're down.
William D. Cohan
Yeah, but either way, $54.20 in cash is real and a nice premium and you can have a victory lap. And it's not only Vanguard, it's BlackRock. It's this Morgan Stanley asset management business.
Scott Galloway
Which is going to be with Musk.
William D. Cohan
Which is going to be with Musk. So I would say that 10 plus 6 plus 8, what's that, 24 is going to be with Musk pretty quickly.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Because that's retail investors. They're not going to stick around and wait for Mark Benioff.
Kara Swisher
So you think you're still sticking with your guns on that one. Okay. If the financing is real. And only if the financing is real. Is there any important business stories the world's missed in the last two weeks because everything is Elon?
Scott Galloway
That's a great question. Yes, of course there is.
Kara Swisher
Pick one.
Scott Galloway
Well, the most important business story out there now is the end of quantitative easing, the end of the Fed-subsidized free cost of money. Look at what's gone on in the high-yield market since the beginning of the year. But since, talk about 52-week highs or lows. In last September, right around the time that Twitter was reaching its 52-week high, and every other company was, the average yield on a high-yield bond was below 4%, which was, of course, absurd. Because back in the days of Mike Milken, it was 10%, 11%, 12%, plus warrants.
William D. Cohan
Plus warrants, right, Scott?
Scott Galloway
And now it's back up to about 650. So it's gone up 50%. Still cheap. Interest rates are still below where they need to be. So that yield curve is moving up, and that's going to cause a tremendous amount of pain in the bond market, which is four or five times the size of the stock market.
Kara Swisher
Bill, you've dealt with boards. What I found most interesting that came out just in the last 30 minutes, or came out over the weekend, was Jack Dorsey, who is set to leave the board but is still on the board, came out and said something that violates what I call the code of the white guy. And that is, board members never publicly come out against each other. You just don't see that very often. And he wrote, "Twitter board consistently been the dysfunction of the company." And it just struck me that a guy sitting on the board... what I think this means is that he was fired. I've always said that as soon as Elliot showed up, they said, "Okay, this can be your idea, but you're out of here." But for a sitting board member to say that the board has consistently been the problem, he's clearly siding with Elon.
Scott Galloway
Do you think he could be... This is not a surprise, Scott. Do you think maybe... I mean, there's just so many fun scenarios here. He could come in and give $5 or $10 billion and say, "I'm the new co-CEO again?"
William D. Cohan
Absolutely. He could team up with Elon. He's got 2.25% of the company. He could vote that with Elon. I'm telling you, if Elon can firm up the financing and if Morgan Stanley can convey that to Goldman Sachs, I think it's over. But that's a big if, because as you correctly point out, Scott, there's huge risks to Tesla for Elon Musk leveraging up or margining his remaining Tesla stock that's not already pledged to some loan or other.
Kara Swisher
Well, this is a developing story. We got to get going, unfortunately. But Bill, should we start a subscription newsletter at Pivot? How's Puck doing? You enjoying yourself?
William D. Cohan
I think if you get the right talent, Kara, you know about that. That's the hard part.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's the hard part. I'm dragging this codfish around everywhere I go. Keeping up with you two is very hard work. And Scott had a great cameo in... the fake Scott had a great cameo in *We Crashed*. He's my new partner. Kelly, Kelly O'Coin. Bill, thank you so much. We'll be back with you soon. You're fantastic.
William D. Cohan
Thank you, guys. Congrats on Puck, Bill.
Scott Galloway
Thank you, Scott. Thank you both for having me.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott. He is so smart, isn't he?
Scott Galloway
He is, yeah. I like Bill. He's also a really nice man.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he is. He's written some of the best things that Vanity Fair used to do. Everything. He's just really good. I like that he's shifted over to Puck. Boy, are they getting some really great stuff out there. When we come back, though, we'll talk about CNN Plus, and we'll make some quick predictions.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, we're back. It was the best of times, it was the worst of times for streaming media market. The tale of two companies, Discovery and Warner Media, has raised new questions about the industry. Will Disney finally buy out its partners at Hulu? Will Discovery fold everything into HBO Max? And of course, what will happen to CNN Plus? Because all I care about is you.
Scott Galloway
You do, yes.
Kara Swisher
Just as we started this morning, speaking of quick tweets, Chris Licht, who's running CNN, pushed himself off of Twitter. He's like, "I'm sick. I'm out of this pop stand." Probably because he's making a point that it controls too much of the news narrative, probably on CNN. He's saying something very significant, I think, there. So tell me, Scott, I'm just going to let you talk about it.
Scott Galloway
It was launched to get ahead of the merger, and it's going to be folded in anyway by Mr. Zaslav, who was interviewed by Oprah Winfrey this weekend. They're old friends. So it was a really tough interview, as you might imagine. She didn't ask these questions, so I'm asking you. There's a lot of play here. But generally speaking, you have an art form or a medium or a channel that's overinvested. $140 billion is going into streaming. There just aren't enough credit cards to support that. So you're going to see consolidation. As it relates to CNN+, you've read the same stuff I have. Downloads of the app have been really anemic or have not met expectations. I don't know how much truth that is. If it was doing really well, they'd release the numbers. You know that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they would counter it. They would make you dress up in some fashion and be on the—
Scott Galloway
Or would they make me undress, Kara?
Kara Swisher
No, no. But you would be on the corner in Times Square with a big swirling sign talking about it.
Scott Galloway
Here's the thing. I wrote a piece on this in *No Mercy, No Malice*. It is very difficult to start a streaming network when you're not all in. The only way this works as a standalone streaming network is if at the end of every program, Anderson Cooper or Fareed Zakaria says, "If you want to see this without commercials, it starts 10 minutes late and it's on CNN Plus." Or slowly but surely, they start to put their best programming behind a wall. There hasn't been a streaming network started that's worked that's been an adjunct to anything that hasn't been all in. Having said that, I think the potential for CNN Plus is that if you make a great show, the distribution will find you. You could see CNN Plus becoming the R&D lab for Turner, Warner, Discovery, HBO Max. If the content is good, it will find distribution.
Another interesting observation is that if you look at my program, *No Mercy, No Malice*, it's always 21 minutes.
Kara Swisher
Why do you think they've decided to have it be 21 minutes? I don't know. Please tell me.
Scott Galloway
Because should they decide to put it on an ad-supported channel, it'll be exactly 30 with nine minutes of ads telling you you have restless legs or opioid-induced constipation. So that is clearly their plan B. They're setting everything up such that if this streaming thing doesn't work on CNN+, they can either go to other subscription, HBO, or they can put it on ad-supported. Maybe that's their little R&D lab. But you're going to see consolidation.
Kara Swisher
I agree. Listen, here's the problem. I've been using it again this week because I watch you. And I got to say, I don't necessarily want to hear Anderson Cooper talk about parenthood or Jake Tapper talk about books. And I think they're both really smart.
Scott Galloway
Don't say that about Anderson.
Kara Swisher
I know. Don't say that about Anderson. He's a good father.
Scott Galloway
That's great.
Kara Swisher
That's great. It's just, it's like least effort here. I think your show still remains one of the best. And the old Larry King lives, because I like to watch a dead guy. So I think that's what's popular on that, which is really interesting. We'll see. I agree with you. Good content always finds a way out. And I like what you're making. The other stuff, I can't point to something that I love on that thing.
Scott Galloway
But you know what else has really hurt it, Kara?
Kara Swisher
What?
Scott Galloway
The bottom line is the two people running it, Andrew Morris and Rebecca Cutler, are both super talented executives. Fantastic. But what probably dramatically increased the infant mortality or the opportunity for sudden infant death syndrome here is they lost their cloud cover when they fired Jeff Zucker.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Jeff Zucker has the gravitas. He's pals with Zaslav.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. He has the gravitas, the leadership, and he has the authority to walk into Zaslav's office and say, "Okay, this is what's right. This is what's wrong. This is how we're fixing it. And hands off of it. We're going to keep going for this for two years." So, quite frankly, dad's not home. That's the way I would describe it. We don't have any cloud cover.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and Zaslav's got enough things to do, including having lunch with Steven Spielberg and Oprah, stuff like that.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I agree. And they're big cost cutters at Discovery. They're tough mothers, as I recall.
Kara Swisher
Is that right?
Scott Galloway
Yes, they are. They're real good at it. You can make fun of them as cheapsters, but they know how to run a beeswax. Netflix, Disney, Warner Brothers, Comcast, and Paramount Global, 70% of the audience demand. These are all these different brands. Consolidation is happening individually at these places and all over the place. You'll see deals aplenty, I think.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, people are going to have to bulk up and cut costs. Like I said, they got to be bigger. Okay. So let's see what else in the news this week very briefly. Tell me what you like. I'm going to list them, and I think we'll know which one we want in a second. Staff at Apple's flagship store in Grand Central are collecting signatures to form a union. The organizers voted to affiliate with Workers United. According to the Washington Post, organizers say Apple has made efforts for months to convince employees unionizing is a bad idea, including giving them fancy new T-shirts. No, I'm teasing. Complaints include Apple's pay not keeping up with inflation and inability to hold managers accountable.
A lot of people who work at Apple stores are pretty happy. When I talk to them, they may be lying, but they seem happier than most, but still unionization. And then your other choice to talk about is Tucker Carlson's new documentary, which is raising eyebrows and other things. Trailer for *The End of Men* features shirtless men wrestling, chopping wood, a new man who appears to be tanning his testicles. "Hard iron sharpens iron," as they say. "And those hard times inevitably produce men who are tough, men who are resourceful, men who are strong enough to survive." Pick one: unionization at Apple or ball tanning.
Scott Galloway
Oh, this is easy. The Tucker Carlson take on masculinity. By the way, my episode this week on *No Mercy, No Malice* dropping Tuesday morning is on masculinity. I watched the opening scene for that. And all I can tell you is as a man, I have never so badly wanted to fuck other men as when I watched.
Kara Swisher
Yes, that's what a lot of straight men said.
Scott Galloway
I mean, Jesus Christ. I'm literally ready. Let's get down. Nothing screams masculinity like the bow ties and homoerotica of Tucker Carlson.
Kara Swisher
Did you see that thing?
Scott Galloway
I did. It was like Grindr meets Quentin Tarantino meets Cinemax. There were so many straight men who said, "Now I'm gay." I just can't. It's literally like, okay, maybe it's time to give it a whirl.
Kara Swisher
Maybe it's time to give it a whirl. I mean, I thought it was a parody. Have you seen it?
Scott Galloway
I have not. It's just too much fun to make fun.
Kara Swisher
You've got to see it. I saw the video. I've seen enough gay video. I live in the Castro. My goodness, I can just go down the street right now and enjoy myself IRL. Such things.
Scott Galloway
No, I'm in.
Kara Swisher
The guy, I did an interview with Tony Kushner today about "Don't Say Gay" and stuff like that. And his husband, I believe it was his husband, said, "I'm a gay man who's sitting with my gay husband working on my gay book. And I'm not as gay as Tucker Carlson." I couldn't get over it. It was like, okay, Tucker, are you going to do a documentary on what it means to have a wide stance in public bathrooms and airports? It's just—
Scott Galloway
Right. But it's so kind of oddly, strangely—
Kara Swisher
Men are ending, but they're not. I just have three of them. I just didn't get it. I'm raising them, so they don't seem ending to me. Do you have any comments about Apple's flagship story? In light of this, we have some other things to discuss.
Scott Galloway
I don't know. I think there will be some very well-publicized examples of union victories where they sign up 10, 12, or dozens of people. And I think unions have been the perfect enemy for corporations who continue to suppress the wages of frontline workers. I think the market has stepped in here. I think Apple will pay up.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, fine.
Scott Galloway
I like the fact that for the first time, the market is stepping in, and I don't see any reason why the federal government couldn't move minimum wage to $20 an hour over the course of the next three years.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, okay. A couple more things. Online shopping isn't as dominant post-pandemic. It's falling off. According to MasterCard data, online spending is down 3.3%, although it had a huge boom. The first year-over-year decline since 2013. Brick and mortar spending was up. People liking to get out. Online story note, Amazon fell by 1%, the first decline since the metric was disclosed. So this is not a surprise. People want to get out and about this weekend. Everyone was everywhere. That said, it's been a very secular move. People are very used to buying online now too. It's part of the record.
Scott Galloway
What this story misses is a nuance. At Panera, what we found is over 50% of our orders begin digitally. So what is online? What is offline?
And I do think that you've seen what I'll call a little bit of a sugar high for people who want to go out to the mall and get back into stores. But I think the same trends, essentially pretty much every year since '99, the percentage of online retail has grown by 1% as a percentage of all retail. And that continues. Now, whether we're going to check back from the pandemic, I still think e-commerce marches on.
Kara Swisher
Yep. Agree. I think it's just whatever. People are thrilled to be out. The stores were full. The restaurants were full.
Scott Galloway
I've been to lots of restaurants.
Kara Swisher
Getting COVID.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I still didn't get it. Me and the golden shot are the only people that aren't getting COVID. It's weird.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and yours truly.
Scott Galloway
It's the pivot vaccine. By the way, I got my second booster.
Kara Swisher
So did I.
Scott Galloway
So did I.
Kara Swisher
Everybody go out and get them. We're boosted. And I didn't feel anything.
Scott Galloway
I felt loopy on the first three. I didn't feel anything. I did not feel bad at all. I feel fine.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, it won't be for younger people. If you're older and you have issues, you definitely should get it. Otherwise, talk to your doctor.
Anyway, Alex Jones' InfoWars isn't just morally bankrupt. The company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, along with two other Alex Jones companies, after several defamation suits, including his claim that Sandy Hook was a hoax. They had him up for it. He didn't show up at trials. We had Elizabeth Williamson on talking about this. The judge found Jones liable for damages to relatives of students and teachers killed in the massacre. A trial to decide how much he owes them was set for August. Elizabeth had been talking about this, but he was on the hook, so this is not a surprise. He remains a fucker to do this, of course, because he wants to get out of it and protect his wealth from selling shitty vitamins. Scott, any thoughts on this?
Scott Galloway
No, look, we have corporations that create legal protection between corporate assets and personal assets. I would hope that they would be able to create enough legal arguments around slander and defamation that they would be able to go after his personal assets. I think what has gone on here is worse than being... I don't think he's crazy. I think he knew what he was doing, and I think he was trading people's despair. I think he was arbitraging and prostituting tragedy and people's pain for economic gain. Absolutely. And I think America – that's just not what America is about. And we have correctly hit back on things like that, and I hope we continue to do that here.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, let me just say, it also does send a signal, though, of having to go bankrupt, is that it's not so... don't go as far as Alex Jones. This is where it ends up. People do slap back, and now he's here. Nonetheless, his involvement with January 6th, everything else, is just... this guy is a toxic waste dump of a person. And anything that can take money away from him is thrilling. We'll see what happens here. He'll be protected, of course. But it's really gross that he's doing this to these people who he's caused so much enormous and incalculable pain. And whatever it takes to bring him low by them legally is fantastic.
All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for predictions really quick.
Ad Break
All right, Scott, let's very quickly, some predictions really fast.
Scott Galloway
Two players are going to merge in the Twitter battle. The SEC and Salesforce.
Kara Swisher
Okay. Oh, wow. All right. Okay. I don't know, but that's an interesting thing to say. That is an interesting thing to say. I'm not sure. Okay. Well, we'll leave it at that. That's a really good one. This was a really good show.
Scott Galloway
And I'm taking human growth hormone and clipping.
Kara Swisher
And I'm in the next... I'm in season two of Tucker Carlson's Homoerotica Adventures.
Scott Galloway
I'm in. You'd like to be.
Kara Swisher
Jesus. You'd like to be.
Scott Galloway
I'm so excited for the gay Scott. I'm so happy. I'm like, what is this strange feeling? What are these feelings?
Kara Swisher
Who would you ask out first? Who would you ask out first?
Scott Galloway
Oh, George Hahn. G. Hahn. George Hahn. And Anderson Cooper. I've always talked about this. I love your wife. They get it. They don't have hangups around threesomes. These are just hypotheticals. Most of the women I've been with don't like the idea of a third person in it. I'm ready to mix it up a little bit.
Kara Swisher
Okay. Anderson Cooper and George Hahn. Oh, wow. That's my throuple. The raconteur, AC and the dog.
Scott Galloway
And you will all be tanning your balls with Tucker Carlson. It's really a lovely scene.
Kara Swisher
I love America.
Scott Galloway
I love America. There you go.
Kara Swisher
As always, we want your questions. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit your question for us or call 855-51-PIVOT. The link is also in our show notes. Okay, Scott, that is a long show. We'll be back on Friday for more. Why don't you read us out?
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie and Jatot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Miel Silverio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for a breakdown of all things tech and business. Kara, I hope you have a wonderful week.
Kara Swisher
Thank you, Scott. I will.