Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including the rebranding of Twitter to X, the Biden administration's agreement with tech companies on AI safety commitments, and the release of the movies Oppenheimer and Barbie.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Ad Break
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
I'm in San Francisco, Scott. Where are you?
Scott Galloway
I'm in Aspen. I spent the weekend in LA and we had a wonderful time. I told my youngest we could do whatever he wanted. So we did two malls. We did the Century City Mall, which is one of my favorite malls. I kind of grew up there. And then we did The Grove, where Barbie was filmed.
Kara Swisher
But anyway, go ahead.
Scott Galloway
There you go. Then we did The Grove. We saw two movies, Mission Impossible and Oppenheimer. We did In-N-Out Burger. We did Universal Hollywood, all of this in about 36 hours. We had a really wonderful—I was just telling our producer, Lara, I'm at that point where the end of my kids being kids is now painfully visible. So I'm really enjoying this kind of stuff.
Kara Swisher
Oh, it's going to be great. I'm here in San Francisco with Alex, who's 18. We're on a little mom-son kind of thing. And then next week I'm going to do one with Louis before they both go away to their various and sundry fall activities. Louis to Argentina and Alex to Michigan. But yeah, it's not the wonder of, "Oh my God, they put chocolate on this ice cream." There's definitely something about 12. He finds things so fascinating, that childhood wonder.
Scott Galloway
I don't know.
Kara Swisher
Alex talks about the most esoteric things. He's like, "Did you know about this particular factual thing?" And I'm like, "Don't be so fucking mature. I'm trying to be melancholy."
Scott Galloway
Don't be melancholy. You have new relationships with your sons. It's really nice. You have to develop relationships over time. You should be thinking about our relationship, for example. But let me just say, speaking of relationships, you know what I did this weekend? Why don't you ask me what I did this weekend?
Kara Swisher
What did you do this weekend?
Scott Galloway
Amanda and I went to salsa lessons. I gave it to her for her birthday. I hate dancing.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you told me about this.
Scott Galloway
She loves it. And we went again. And I'm not bad. I wasn't bad this weekend.
Kara Swisher
That shocks me. That you're better than you thought of something. That shocks me.
Scott Galloway
No, I just didn't think I sucked.
Kara Swisher
That shocks me. You and I should do salsa dancing together. I will lead, obviously.
Scott Galloway
It would look like Ichabod Crane and Hervé Villechaize having an epileptic attack at the same time.
Kara Swisher
No, I think we'd be trying. By the way, I'm sure that triggers the National Epilepsy Protection League.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, okay. You're getting so Ron DeSantis these days. Everything is woke, woke, woke.
Kara Swisher
He got COVID right. That should be a tagline, his tagline. But then he didn't.
Scott Galloway
I got COVID right. But then he didn't.
Kara Swisher
But then he didn't. He doesn't want to own that. Oh, you read that article about the Times.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I don't know. Whatever. He shifts back and forth depending on the way the wind blows. His campaign is a disaster right now, apparently, from all the different stories I've read. But we should do things in our relationship. We should find something we can do together. Rock climbing, perhaps.
Kara Swisher
I don't know. Or we could just have a podcast and make a shit ton of money.
Scott Galloway
All right. How about that? We'll do that.
Kara Swisher
All right. Okay. I just want those special moments. We were in Canada together. We were in the south of France together.
Scott Galloway
Yes, we were.
Kara Swisher
Did we have a good time?
Scott Galloway
We had a good time.
Kara Swisher
We had a nice time with you swimming. My favorite moment was when we were at the Hotel du Cap and we were with Amanda. You looked at me like what you are, a 60-year-old mother of two infants. And you said to me, "Can you take the kids to the pool and just leave me alone for like 30 minutes?" You looked at me like your last wish.
Scott Galloway
It's true. You're like, "We're friends. I can say this to you." And you said it out of earshot of Amanda. You're like, "Take the kids somewhere and just keep everyone away from me for 30 minutes."
Kara Swisher
It was true. "Let me have some rosé. I don't even drink wine, but I'm going to order it. And just lay here." You need that moment as a parent of your kids.
Scott Galloway
Oh, you need a lot of those moments. I took the kids to visit an employee of mine who had just had a baby and let Amanda have a little of that time. She went and got her nails done, which was nice.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you need those moments. Anyway, we have a lot to talk about besides our relationship. We'll talk about Twitter's rebrand, which, of course, as usual, Elon inserted himself into the news. He's trying to get one over on Barbie, I guess. A new agreement between the White House and tech companies on AI. And our friend of Pivot is Alondra Nelson, formerly the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy. She led the development of the Biden administration's blueprint for AI Bill of Rights. So we'll talk about that.
Scott Galloway
But first, Scott, it was a huge weekend at the box office. Barbenheimer brought in a combined grand total of $244 million in ticket sales in the first three days. That's a big number. Barbie accounted for $162 million of that, while Oppenheimer brought in $82 million, well over expectations for both of those movies. That's 12.8 million tickets bought for Barbie and 5.8 million for Oppenheimer. It's set to be the fourth highest box office weekend of all time. And Greta Gerwig is now the most, has sold the most tickets for female director in, I think, history. The people have spoken. Barbie is clearly the winner here, financially speaking. You have not seen Barbie still, even though it's about men and women and the things you talk about of men being lost. I will ask how you thought of Oppenheimer, but Barbie was the clear winner financially and is leading the way and dragging and bringing Oppenheimer, which is also a fantastic movie, with it. And combined together, people were very excited and made it an appointment viewing, which hasn't happened in a long time for both of them. And they both spurred interest in each other. So tell me what you thought of Oppenheimer.
Well, first of all, the weekend and the box office receipts are really a win all around. If there was an industry that needed good news, it's not only just Hollywood, it's specifically movie theater. Something that was really inspiring, we did dinner before Mission Impossible at the Century City Mall. I'm not exaggerating. The mall was electric and everyone was wearing pink.
Kara Swisher
For Oppenheimer?
Scott Galloway
No, go ahead. For Oppenheimer. All the women were in pink. There was a lot of men wearing pink. I thought it was nice. I think anything that creates a collective is nice. I think we need more of that. Our plane got delayed on Saturday by four hours. So I said, "All right, let's bomb to the movie theater." We went to the Van Nuys Regency and we were five minutes late to see Barbie. So we saw Oppenheimer, which was starting in 10 minutes. I'd love to talk about it a little bit.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, let me talk about that. I think it's really—first off, I was going to love the movie before I even walked in. It's World War II. It's science. It's this tortured genius. It's just like everything I want in a movie. And I think Christopher Nolan is a genius. I think a lot of its lessons apply to today. People take for granted that science really wasn't incorporated into government, much less the military's plans, until World War II. The integration of scientists and their elevation to near gods, which continues today, really happened around World War II with this project. The recognition of whether it was Turing breaking the Enigma Codes or Oppenheimer, who developed a celebrity-like status. Both of whom suffered after they had had their accomplishments.
Hugely.
Scott Galloway
One of the lessons you take away is this notion of being a genius comes with downsides in terms of your own self-torture. But I thought it was a really interesting lesson. Oppenheimer, as much as he was a genius, he invented a new type of charisma. Everyone who met with Oppenheimer felt that there were these brilliant insights that he had yet to reveal. They wanted to be around him and be near his work. He was able to bring together unbelievably different cultures—a culture of physicists, a culture of the military, a culture of the government—to pull off something. We thought at the time we were literally in a race.
It ended up that the Germans had taken a wrong turn and we were really the only sole contender for the bomb. Something else people didn't realize is we only had two. We ran out. One of the great philosophical questions they talk about in every philosophy class now is, okay, maybe you can justify dropping the first bomb, but could we justify dropping two? It was meant to say, "Hey, we have a lot of these." But also, there was no reason why a scientist wouldn't logically think, now that we can do this, it's really the end of the world. I see it as a victory for society globally because we were able to destroy a city in a flash.
And we've, in the last 75 years, we haven't had more detonations. Because the world has decided this is bad.
Kara Swisher
Go ahead. Okay. I want to know what you thought of the movie. So, to get to the movie. What did I think of the movie?
Scott Galloway
Thank you for that history lesson. I thought it was a master class. Christopher Nolan—there were about a dozen stars in this movie who are used to being the star. Robert Downey Jr. will win an Academy Award. He was the biggest star in the movie. Rami Malek, who is a big star, had a small role, but he was so excited to work for Christopher Nolan. There were master performances at every turn. Emily Blunt was just fantastic. Super, phenomenal. There were all these incredible cameos by these brilliant actors in the cinematography.
Kara Swisher
So you didn't think it was too long?
Scott Galloway
You know what's interesting? My 12-year-old said it was his favorite movie ever.
Kara Swisher
Oh, okay, good. I didn't think a 12-year-old would be able to get through three hours of it. Interestingly, Alex and Louis went to see Barbie this weekend. And what did they think?
Scott Galloway
You know, I think they liked it. It is aimed at women a little more, but it certainly provoked a lot of conversation. I think Alex called it seven out of 10 because he's an Oppenheimer stan, no matter what. And he has to compare them, which they're not comparable. They're actually complimentary. Mission Impossible and Indy are dropping off rather significantly. And Sound of Freedom, which was another original movie, even though the guy who stars in it and pushed it out is very Trumpy—he thinks Trump is like Jesus, essentially, and has QAnon edges to him—that did very well, too. All these are original movies in a lot of ways, versus a sequel or a superhero movie.
Well, look, the industry will constantly play up successes. The reality is there might be a blip up, but movie theater box office is in structural decline, and it'll maintain its decline. So good for them. Enjoy the moment. But I always like to try and relate this to some sort of business learning for a young executive. One of the lessons or takeaways from Oppenheimer is that hubris can best genius. This was a guy who ultimately got a security clearance taken away.
Kara Swisher
Unfairly.
Scott Galloway
But taken away. And returned.
Kara Swisher
But go ahead. Jesus Christ. Literally, give me some running room here.
Scott Galloway
All right. Let me acknowledge that Barbie's the greatest movie ever before seeing it. Okay. So, also, just the notion that he wanted to stop the arms race before it really hits its stride. Edward Teller was a big proponent of moving to an H-bomb testing, and the arms race just burst wide open. His message was undermined by his hubris. At the end of the day, if you're an asshole, if you don't respect other people, if you embarrass them publicly, if you sleep with their wives, it will come back to haunt you regardless of what a genius you are. I think that has a lot of lessons today. There are people who take science and their prestige garnered from science is convincing them that they're almost godlike. Hubris can undo any genius.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I just thought it was—I can't stop thinking about it because I'm interested in that era. I also think he was a pretty deeply unhappy person.
Scott Galloway
Sounds like it.
Kara Swisher
It was interesting because one of the things I thought from the movie was he wasn't as arrogant as many science and tech people we know. He was very thoughtful and had a lot of good relationships. I do think the carelessness and thinking that Russia or whoever wasn't going to steal the secrets—I thought they would have gotten stolen no matter what. Russia would have gotten to it, the Germans, whoever. I thought it was a beautiful movie. It was a very beautiful and moving movie. I'm glad it stuck with you. Is there one scene that stuck with you? And then we're going to move on to another topic.
Scott Galloway
I thought when they tested the thing, it was really powerful. When you think about what they did, it was so visionary and strange. He brought everyone to this remote place in the desert and said, "We need to build a church, restaurants, a post office, and ask everyone and their families to move to this place." That's just so incredible. I'm trying to think if there's one scene that stands out.
Kara Swisher
Is there one scene that stands out for you?
Scott Galloway
Well, the bombing was just his breath. All you heard was the breath, not the noise of the bomb.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it was very dramatic. I'll tell you, you know who I thought was great? Matt Damon.
Scott Galloway
Another undersung role. There were five amazing—there were literally a dozen great performances in the movie. It was a real team effort.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it was. It was a great role for him. There were a lot of complex topics and people and relationships that they managed to keep going. I'm going to go back and see both Barbie and it and Mission Impossible because I think there's a lot there. The line that stuck with me—Gary Oldman, again, another amazing actor playing Truman.
Scott Galloway
"Crybaby"?
Kara Swisher
Well, that, but he has this line. Oppenheimer says, "Sir, I have blood on my hands." And he looks at him and goes, "No one gives a shit who built this thing. They care who dropped it." I thought that was very powerful. And he was right. It's the decision to drop it, not to build it.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. I mean, you can literally go—if we talked about this for longer, which we can't, we'd go, "Oh, and this amazing performance and this amazing performance." I thought Ullman was great.
Kara Swisher
He was great. "Get that crybaby back in here." "Don't let him back in here." It was interesting that he could have really been celebrated more and he just decided to say no.
Scott Galloway
All right, speaking of moguls who have big responsibilities, 10 years after buying the Washington Post—I can't believe it's that long—during which his levels of interest in it have varied, mostly not very interested. Jeff Bezos is rolling up his sleeves again. The company's down a half a million subscribers, which is a lot, and set to lose $100 million this year. Incredible amount of money. He's reportedly planning for 2023 to be a year of investment, but not a year of profit. He appointed Patty Stonesifer, who I have great regard for, as interim CEO last month after the publisher, Fred Ryan, stepped down. Bezos gave him an easy exit by funding his civility efforts. Meanwhile, he's weighing in personally on a project for the opinion section. Full disclosure, my wife, Amanda, works for the opinion section, but is not involved in any of this. He's greenlighting an overhaul of the style section and an online redesign. What thinks you of this? I still think he's going to lose interest. I don't think he just sort of ended up with it. It's not that energetic, but he put someone in who is very good. Any thoughts?
Kara Swisher
I think this is an example. Ideally, we could have long-form journalism and companies that were traditional newspapers and bring a level of fact-checking and reverence for long-form journalism or gumshoe reporting. You'd like to think that's an industry that's self-sustaining. It's not. The best you can hope for is a benign billionaire, someone like a Bloomberg. But basically that's what's happened. Sam Zell, whoever you look at—newspapers, the Tribune, the Times—they buy these things. Billionaire Democrats buy newspapers and billionaire Republicans buy football teams. When I was involved with the New York Times and we hit some rough patches, I think I heard from every Democratic billionaire in the nation saying they were interested in getting involved. They were interested in owning it. They would wake up in the morning and say, "Hello, publisher of the New York Times."
Scott Galloway
Right, her owner.
Kara Swisher
The reality is these things just economically don't work. There's a tell here. They're going to lose more money this year because Patty Stonesifer wouldn't have taken this job unless she had a commitment from Bezos to make the requisite investments. She's a smart woman. This is why the Grahams probably sold it to Bezos, to continue that level of journalism. You're just going to lose a shit ton of money. Here's the good news: he has a shit mega ton of money. Even if he loses a quarter of a billion dollars this year, on $60 billion in wealth at 8%, he's going to make $5 billion more this year in his investment. So it really doesn't matter. I think he has proven so far to be a very responsible steward. I've been in some newsrooms. I find the journalists, when they see this billionaire come in, they kind of—I don't want to say they ignore the business realities—but they expect that person, they rightfully believe what they do is noble, but they expect that person to just invest. They don't expect this to be profitable. They're like, "Come on, this is more important than that." There's no one who can invest like Jeff Bezos. I think Jeff Bezos is a gift to the Washington Post.
Scott Galloway
I agree. I think it would be interesting if he was even more involved. I don't think he has as much interest in it. He has obviously put someone he values in that spot, which I thought took far too long. Fred Ryan was really floundering toward the end of his tenure and hadn't been decisive the way Meredith Kopit Levien has been at the New York Times or the Sulzberger family has been in terms of adding on things that make it profitable. They're not very profitable, but they're profitable now. One of the things they talk about is, "Oh, New York Times, the runaway success." I'm like, it's not that profitable.
It's just a little profitable. But you're right, it takes a commitment. They could certainly make this profitable, I think. I expect there's room for two big national news organizations that own a lot of different properties, not just the print newspaper itself. But for the Washington Post to be profitable, it'd be a shadow of itself. They would have to cut so much spending. The New York Times, over the last 30 years, has gone from a regional to a national to, quite frankly, a global newspaper. It folded the International Herald Tribune. It's just got global reach. The Washington Post, to get to where the New York Times is, would need to lose a couple billion dollars or invest a couple billion dollars and it would take them a decade.
Kara Swisher
So what would you do? Give me something you would do. So just keep at this minor level of loss or possibly get it to break even. That's what you would do.
Scott Galloway
What I would do is realize that I'm going to be dead soon, regardless of the amount of andro and testosterone I'm taking. And regardless of how hot my girlfriend is, I'm going to be dead soon. My mark here is to do something really wonderful for democracy. An incredible evangelist for Western values is the Washington Post. If there's anything that's worth investment and worth 1%, 2%, 3% of my wealth, it's not a giant clock or some giant dildo into space. It's the Washington Post. So what would I do? I would continue to make big investments in this wonderful property that espouses Western values. And get it to break even. Maybe break even.
Kara Swisher
Well, it has to be. It can't be hemorrhaging money because at some point people die.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Because at some point, someone else. So get it to a point where it's ideally like the New York Times and it's self-sustaining. This is what sucks about these other media companies. I always tell the story of Bill Keller of the New York Times. I had dinner with him in 2008 and he had to excuse himself. I'm like, "Where are you going?" He said, "I have to go negotiate the release of one of our journalists from the Taliban." I'm like, "That's what we're doing." Meanwhile, Google has a bunch of engineers that they slip a pizza box under the door. It's stealing our content and making a shit ton of money while we try and negotiate the release of our journalists. And they're trying it again with AI.
Kara Swisher
There you go.
Scott Galloway
So, yeah, I think it's wonderful Bezos is involved here. I think he can make a big difference. I think these things matter. The reality is these things need benign billionaires that are willing to invest. The benign billionaire Scott theory of things.
Kara Swisher
All right. Well, speaking of not so benign billionaires, let's get to our first big story. Twitter is called X now. The bird is dead. The new logo is an X on a black background. I thought it was terribly designed, by the way. Elon says tweets are now called Xs. The rebrand was announced about a day before it was implemented. Musk said it would only happen if the logo was good enough, which it is not. Go look at it. As of Monday morning, Musk hadn't even secured the @X handle. The word "tweet" is still all over the site's UI and the domain X.com redirected to a GoDaddy page. This isn't entirely out of the blue or the black. In October 2022, Musk tweeted—or rather X'd, I can't do it—that buying Twitter is an accelerant to creating X, the everything app. I'm told he's told a lot of people about it. He told a lot of political people, including Donald Trump, from what I heard early, that he was doing this. Linda Yaccarino X'd that it's "exceptionally rare in life or business, you get a second chance to make another big impression." She also had a word salad that I could read for you if you really want to hear it. It had all the words in it except for synergy.
Scott Galloway
Can you read what she said?
Kara Swisher
All right. Linda Yaccarino, among other things, said it was going to do everything. She tweeted, "X is the future state of unlimited interactivity centered on audio, video, messaging, payments/banking, creating a global marketplace for ideas, goods, services, and opportunities. Powered by AI, X will connect us all in ways we're just beginning to imagine." She said it will be everything. I don't even know what to say.
Scott Galloway
So it's pretty clear at her Toastmasters class, she sat next to Adam Neumann.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, her son. I mean, let's literally read that. It's such consultant speak and such nothing. She's literally showing up. I think she looks ridiculous.
Scott Galloway
I agree. This is the first time I was like, "Whoa, Linda, dial up." She clearly has absolutely no input into anything and is there trying to make chicken salad out of chicken shit and pretend that she thinks any of this makes sense.
Kara Swisher
A lot of words. Even Aaron Levie, who runs Box, which also has an X in it, said, "What do these words mean?" And then he took it down because everyone was like, "Huh?" The big question about X is, of course, Y or WTF. Talk about this. He's fired a bunch of employees, made a hugely unpopular change to the platform, scrapped all of the brand equity now by changing the name. I don't know if Linda knew he was going to do this. Maybe she did. Maybe she didn't. But she's certainly trying to back him. Talk about the brand equity, because Mark Zuckerberg changed the name of Facebook to Meta, but they kept Facebook. They kept Instagram. They kept these important things. Can you talk a little bit about the brand change?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they're totally different because Facebook kept a consumer-facing equity. It just changed the corporate name, which is really for employees. Google did the same thing with Alphabet. You could kind of justify those. The first thing is to acknowledge that Elon Musk has built or been the driving force behind two of the most ascended brands the last decade: Tesla and SpaceX. He did it in very innovative ways. He didn't use advertising. He used Twitter as his primary vehicle. The guy, no matter what—whether it's something stupid, innocuous, controversial, or repugnant—he's figured out that if I'm in the news every 48 hours, my brands will have global awareness.
He also, to his credit, built amazing products, incredible breakthrough innovation, even things like opening a store in a mall for Tesla rather than a dealership on the outskirts of town. He has proven to be one of the most thoughtful, seminal brand builders in history. Changing Twitter to X will go down as absolutely one of the worst brand decisions in history. Probably a third to 50% of the world's population know what Twitter is, and they recognize the logo. About 97% to 99% of all money spent every day is on brands you've heard of before. You're not going to return an email to someone you haven't heard of.
You're not going to buy a tennis shoe you haven't heard of before. Awareness is a massive asset. It's also really expensive to build. The logo connotes something very distinct. You know exactly what it is when you see the bird. If you were to try and replace this and say, "We want to have a logo that everyone recognizes, they know exactly what it stands for, it has quite a few positive or relevant associations, it's differentiated, it's relevant, it has moats, and half the world knows it"—if someone said you have a decade and $10 billion, can you do this? You wouldn't be sure you could do it.
So at a minimum, he's taken $10 billion worth of brand equity and taken it into the street and lit it on fire. What it says to me is—I believe in billionaires. I believe in capitalism. I don't like the idea of a wealth tax. But when I was thinking about this over the weekend, this really is another signal that income inequality has gotten to a point where an individual in his spare time can make a dumb decision to buy something he doesn't want for $45 billion, use it to not wreak havoc but create a lot of tumult. Twitter in the last six months has not been accretive for the world. And then make a decision like this, which means there's nobody on his board that he listens to.
Typically, to buy a $45 billion company, you would have investors and other people that would weigh in on a decision like this. There is no rational justification for this decision.
Kara Swisher
No, he just decided to do it on a Saturday. It feels like that. Linda just tweeted, "X is here. Let's do this." With this very unattractive logo. It looks crypto. The design looks crypto. It looks uber male, but in a bad way. It's like a flag I don't want on my car or don't want to be near people with this flag on their car.
Scott Galloway
It feels like confederacy.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, exactly. It smells like confederacy. The design looks bad. They're talking about bringing all these things together, but where are all the things they're bringing together? Why not just have the bigger corporate thing?
I mean, you know, it's interesting because Walt Mossberg wrote, companies change names all the time, but popular products, rarely. The words tweet and Twitter have become part of the language. So the brand equity Musk is giving up is huge. I know he wants to add many functions and services to it, but why did it require a name change? And for some reason, JR, who is usually intelligent, says, "When you see how successful Alphabet and Meta have been with their name changes, you have to do it." He said they were corporate name changes, not product name changes. Alphabet didn't change the name Google. Meta didn't change the name of Facebook.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I don't know why. I don't know Alphabet. No one's saying that. He could have created his own financial brand or Twitter money or whatever. And he also was saying that it's going to be like most of the global financial network. I just was like, are you high? And then I thought, well, it's probably. The answer is yes.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. From a brand decision, and it goes back to hubris, and it goes back to not enough of these billionaires have guardrails in the form of other investors, much less regulation. Anyone who had anyone around them who had any credibility or any authority would say, we need to rethink this decision.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
Because if he put the brand up for sale and just said, you have access to the logo and the name, someone would probably pay a billion dollars plus for it. You don't take this kind of – this type of equity takes decades and billions. What's the argument? This is sort of a shoot the moon kind of thing. Someone was like, I appreciate him shooting the moon. I'm like, why? Why shoot the moon? I don't even understand it.
Kara Swisher
I mean, does it get rid of the badness around Twitter by calling it X? I mean, I know he loves the letter X, fine, whatever. He called one of his kids X. One of his early companies was called X. I get it. You like the letter. It's great. I'm fond of the letter C. I don't know what to say. But the branding discipline is really not strong here. This isn't shoot the moon. It's shoot yourself in the foot. And it's so clear that there's nobody home here. The site is a mess. Clearly, it just wasn't rolled out well. The name changes very rarely work, because usually it's a company trying to escape something. There's a disaster, an air disaster in the Everglades. They merge with another company. Norwest changes its name to Wells Fargo because it's a better brand in M&A. But to take a brand that's globally known and turn it to X and do it kind of incrementally, like, "Oh yeah, change that now. And oh wait, I want that," he's asked users to design it. It feels like you gave a 16 year old boy a couple hundred billion dollars and said, have at it.
Scott Galloway
These decisions, and maybe that's part of his genius that he has no guardrails. I don't know. But this one, every brand strategist, every head of an ad agency, any academic in the world of marketing is going to cock their head and go, they'll wait for a minute because a lot of the stuff he does ends up being not only just crazy, but crazy genius. But this just seems crazy. And it doesn't feel like it's very well thought through. And he's decided, this is my toy, and I like the term X. And Linda Iaccarino putting out these, like you said, this word salad, trying to, I feel like she's the circus clown behind an elephant scooping up shit every 30 seconds. It just feels, anyways, I'm sad. I wish he would put it up for sale because I'd love someone to buy it. I think it's a global brand. I would bet it's one of the top 50 most recognized logos in the world because this logo has been at the bottom of every media company on TV.
Kara Swisher
Well, they're talking about them, right? They're talking about it.
Scott Galloway
Well, he always manages to do that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, even as the Threads numbers are going down, because that's what happens in these cases, the usage numbers. Although I'm using it more, I have to say. I guess he just wants to put his name on it. I'm trying to give the nicest case scenario. In other words, he just thought of it because he had a bad trip one night and said, let's do this. And he likes the letter X and he's rich.
Scott Galloway
Well, but that's my point. Honestly, when people can just sort of buy $45 billion media companies and then start retweeting conspiracy theories and then just go, "Oh, let's just call it X." And I'm like, okay, we have gotten to a point where some people just have too much money. And when they have no guardrails and they can buy big companies like this and make these sorts of decisions errantly based on their blood sugar level and this idea they have. And clearly this just has not been thought out. It's clear most of the people that come to know that.
Kara Swisher
Let me, I want you, like, is there, will people forget it? Because no one likes Meta still. I mean, we just sort of go along with it and people still call it Facebook. What positive could it be that he gets to start fresh?
Scott Galloway
Look, I like how you try to, you're a journalist and you want to see both sides of this. There's not a lot of positive here because it's yet another opportunity for people to sort of abandon it. To say, I don't understand it. I don't get it. I'm going to try this threads thing. But name changes very rarely work. The reason most companies do a name change is in an acquisition, they acquire a company that's stronger than them. Norwest, a company known for mortgages that was a very healthy bank, acquired Wells Fargo. And they're like, Wells Fargo is a stronger brand. Dean Witter acquired Morgan Stanley. And they're like, you know what? Morgan Stanley is a stronger brand than Dean Witter. We're going to go with this one. Or someone says, our corporation, everybody hates us. Let's call the whole thing meta. And I think the metaverse is going to be a big deal. But Mark Zuckerberg was smart enough to go, the people who use Instagram do not want a different logo or a different name. We're not going to risk that franchise.
Kara Swisher
Right, right. And that's what he's done here. Just the downside here is exponentially greater than the upside. I will read from Lou Pascal, who's a very well-known ad person for years and years and still is. A very close friend of Linda's, by the way. "Latest in the unending series of idiotic edicts from Elon Musk announced last night, and uninformed by any user insights. Worst of all, his 'all the birds' comment is likely to reinforce the perception that the few remaining Twitter 1.0 team are unwanted. The Twitter Bluebird logo is beloved, ubiquitous, and has nearly 100% unaided awareness globally, something that most brands never come close to achieving. Virtually every newscaster, reporter, and byline features the logo exclusively, giving the brand millions in free marketing." I think he's right. I think he has a very good point. No brand discipline whatsoever and just shitting on what is, even though they have troubles, it's a great brand.
Scott Galloway
Great brand. I'm literally going to take $10 billion plus. It's impossible to put a number on it and just set it on fire and give people yet another excuse to think, well, maybe I'm just done here. I don't get it. He's got a vision for X. He likes it. He's allowed to do it. This will go down as one of the strangest moves in the history of brand strategy. It is very hard to justify this.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and Rick Wilson: "Desperate rebrands are inherently weak strategy when it's a product itself that needs the upgrade. Elon has worked diligently to make the site less fun, interesting, and easy to use. Grunting out my First Amendment on a private platform is like screaming Hanseatic League at the Denny's. You get weird looks but they're not connected issues. He can name it whatever he wants but it diminishes an already wounded brand." So I think he's right. The product matters. The product matters.
Scott Galloway
Okay. Well, that that. That really smart. Linda, call us. Seriously, you much smarter than this, but I guess she has to go along.
Kara Swisher
She has to go along. Not good. I thought she could get out of this cleanly, but I'm not so sure. And by the way, one more point is I'm not giving this guy my credit card after these kind of decisions. I mean, there's no way in hell I'm going to do financial stuff with them. But maybe the rest of the world is, as people point out, this isn't having as big an impact anywhere but the U.S. But the U.S. is its most important market. Okay, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, big tech agrees to AI safety commitments, and we'll speak with a friend of Pivot, Alondra Nelson.
Ad Break
Scott, we're back. The Biden administration announced that seven tech companies have voluntarily agreed to a number of AI safety commitments. The companies include OpenAI, Google, Microsoft, Meta, Amazon, and startups Anthropic and Inflection. That's pretty much all of them, all the big ones. Much of the agreement revolved around testing new AI models to ensure public safety and also to avoid bias and discrimination. Companies agreed to share information with each other about security risk and to implement bug bounty programs. They agreed to watermark AI-created images and audio, I think probably the most significant thing. The White House announced it's also working on an executive order and bipartisan legislation to codify rules around AI. What do you think about this? Just a press release?
Scott Galloway
I think it's important. I'm a bit of a cynic, and I hope it's not just an attempt to prophylactically avoid real regulation. And they're calling on their better angels and realize that it's probably a good idea for us to share this. The thing I like is the idea of a watermark around AI. And I caught up with a friend yesterday I hadn't seen in several years. Do you know who Daniel Lubetzky is?
Kara Swisher
Oh, the guy from Kind Bars.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Yes, of course. He's a lovely guy. Daniel's one of these guys that's always led with civic concern first. He is. He's just, he's from a young age. He started a company called PeaceWorks that meant to bring Israeli and Palestinian workers together to work on companies together, thinking that commerce was a great unifier. And he kind of, I don't want to say accidentally fell into Kind, but building a billion-dollar confectionery company couldn't happen to a nicer guy, and I mean that literally. And of course, I'm here in Aspen. He's here. One of the wonderful things about this podcast is when I'm somewhere, people reach out to me because they hear about it on the podcast. He said, let's get together for a walk. So, we're talking in Aspen, and immediately we talk about 2.30. Jesus Christ, in Aspen talking about 2.30. I think that's the wildest thing I've ever said.
Kara Swisher
[Laughs]
Scott Galloway
Anyways, and I would like, I think there's some potential here. I wonder if you really wanted to have teeth here. First off, there needs to be carve outs from 230 around certain topical domains, whether it's elections or health. I think there should be, in addition to sex trafficking, which has been very effective, there should be additional carve outs. Another idea for a carve-out was that anything that is algorithmically elevated is effectively you're serving as an editor. You're no longer just a benign platform, a neutral arbiter. You've decided to elevate certain content. You have certain obligations around fact-checking.
It's similar to every other media company. And that content becomes absolved or no longer has the shield of 230. Another interesting thing I think politicians should think about, and I was speaking to this morning, is that if it's AI generated, should that not have 230 protection, which would massively encourage investment to spot, screen, and filter AI generated content and images on these platforms? Because this shit could get very scary very fast. And there's already been AI generated images that have convinced people that the Pentagon is under attack, and we're just getting started. So I like this.
I think it's a step in the right direction. I hope they're not using it as a head fake and a weapon of mass destruction.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's my word. They have to pass actual legislation and give money and staff to these agencies, teeth to these things. And not say, you know, we were talking about the merger guidelines last week. They're using previous law to try to get a stronger hand for themselves, these regulators. But they really do need to define this as a different and new technology. And I think they've done that earlier than before, but the stakes are so much higher in this thing that they have to not just have executive orders. You could see the right go after this saying they're trying to tell these tech companies what to do and make woke AI, that kind of stuff.
You can just see all the attacks that could happen here. And in previous tech booms, they've done nothing. And social media and the Internet, if you want to use those, and I would put mobile in there. Very little done around privacy, very little block and tackle. And my worry is they're going to do a lot of these announcements and then nothing, actually. That's my biggest worry here. But the watermarking, this is the kind of stuff they have to do to cooperate together, especially around public safety, bias, discrimination. And of course, to me, provenance is the most important part of this. We give it a, what, a thumbs up?
Scott Galloway
A thumbs up.
Kara Swisher
A medium thumbs up.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Not as good as Barbie and Oppenheimer, but we—
Kara Swisher
Cautiously optimistic thumbs up.
Scott Galloway
Cautiously optimistic. All right, let's bring in a friend of Pivot. Alondra Nelson was formerly the deputy assistant to President Joe Biden, acting director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy. She was the first African-American and first woman of color to lead U.S. science and technology policy in her role there. Among other things, she led the development of the blueprint for the AI Bill of Rights. She is currently the Harold F. Linder Professor at the Institute for Advanced Study, an independent research center in Princeton, New Jersey, where Oppenheimer was, by the way, and also Einstein. Thank you so much for being here.
Alondra Nelson
Thanks for having me.
Kara Swisher
All right. I want to start, Alondra, about your thoughts on this new agreement between the White House and major tech companies. I'm sure you're very familiar with it and the different things they went through. We just talked about it a second ago, a lot of around watermarking, AI images, but also other things. So give me a little rundown of how you think about it.
Alondra Nelson
Well, let's say at the top that it's generally a good thing. I think the fact that it's voluntary, that we can be justified in being grumbly about that and wanting a little bit more. But there are some good things here. I mean, I think the high level good thing is that the White House has been for government kind of moving at a clip around this. So they've been really serious and things have been moving. It's been happening since October of 2022 when I was in government, we did this blueprint for an AI Bill of Rights. And so the Biden administration has been well engaged in this for a while. And I think there are things that all of us would have wanted.
So there's some fundamental things. I would point people to the actual commitment document. There are fundamental things in there, like companies have a duty to make their products safe. These are kind of fundamental assertions that are really important, that the companies have to earn people's trust is what part of the commitments document says as well. And so I think we're in a place that's better than the social media moment at the same time. And I think that that's encouraging. It's an increment, it's voluntary, and there's a lot more to do. But I think in general, it's good.
Kara Swisher
So you said grumbly about voluntary. These companies, obviously, people would like to see laws in place that never happen with social media. These companies have the proper incentives to follow them because some of these could feel like a press release, right? As you know, you've been in government and that can happen.
Alondra Nelson
Yeah, I think we're getting there. And I think that the fact that these seven companies even agreed to this, I think, suggests that they know that legislation is coming and that they need to sort of get in line, get information. But there's obviously lots more to do here. But they've agreed on things like seven companies that are fierce competitors have agreed on things that are more than just principles. So we've got a level of granularity around red teaming that we haven't had before in the tech policy space, around basic consumer privacy. At the same time, on the other side of this, we already have the FTC, other kinds of regulatory bodies saying that the law is the law and that you've got to protect consumers. So it's not like we're only waiting for the companies. You've got, for example, the FTC saying we've got to protect consumers. You have CFPB, the Consumer Finance Protection Bureau, saying the same. So I think that we're getting to slowly, incrementally, a kind of perfect storm or a cauldron of things that will get us to a better place than we've been in the last decade.
Kara Swisher
Right. But legislation is really where it's at, whether it's merger guidelines or anything else. Guidelines are one thing. Absolutely. Real law is another. Scott?
Scott Galloway
Nice to meet you, Alondra, and thanks for your good work. So I'm curious where you are on the spectrum of people who think that AI is just another tool that we'll use and it can be used for good means or bad means, to the AI catastrophists, who think this is the end of the world, that this is now beyond any point of turning back. Where are you? Like, what kind of existential threat do you think AI presents relative to other technologies?
Alondra Nelson
It is just a tool, but it's a very powerful tool. And I think that there are potentially threats on the horizon. We know that there are threats that exist right now. So we know that there are, part of what I thought was great about the White House commitments document is that it felt like an attempt to harmonize various perspectives that have been emerging. So there are societal risks, risks around discrimination, bias and harm and these sorts of things, in addition to thinking about bioweapons and cybersecurity and the risks that are sort of far term. So I think that's what's good also about the commitments document. I think for me, particularly because I've just come out of government in February, I'm in the realm of the practical. So while I think that there are both near term and far term risks, we need to be able to do something about it. And I think it's not entirely useful to be living in the world of speculation and science fiction. Like, we've got to, what are things that we can do things about and what are we going to do about them?
Scott Galloway
What about the idea, and we were talking about this earlier, what about the idea of any AI-generated content no longer enjoys 230 protection?
Alondra Nelson
Listen, I've heard that Ron Wyden himself, who was one of the co-sponsors of Section 230, decades ago, saying exactly that. So I think there have been, I'm not a lawyer, but I think we already saw with algorithmic amplification happening in the social media space that the social media platforms were doing more than just hosting. They were becoming much more than just these sort of neutral things that were hosting information. And I think when you get to advanced AI, generative AI, in which they are dialoguing with people, having interactions with people, the systems and tools are sorting information that they're going to send out to people. And we'll probably see a whole panoply of companies that are choosing different ways to sort the information or to create layers on top of, say, GPT-4. So there's a lot of, I don't know if we call it editorial, but there's a lot of choice and selection and things being made here.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but it's not clear whether they're covered.
Alondra Nelson
No, it's not clear. I think there'll be lawsuits that will determine that. I would also say, from the Biden administration perspective, even going in, the president had said that he was looking at this and was suggesting that we needed to do a lot of reform, if not repeal in this space anyway. So there seems to be a lot of energy galvanizing behind doing something finally.
Kara Swisher
Or at least an explicit bill, I think, is it Warner and Hawley, about that it's not, that it excludes it specifically. So one of the things that you said, we had been talking about Oppenheimer a little bit and along with Barbie and stuff. You noted he is a cautionary tale about the risks of AI and the discussions that need to happen in advance. Now, you had done this with the Blueprint for AI Bill of Rights that you did, which was, I think, rather early, as you said. It was much earlier. I'd love your thoughts on why you decided to do it so early, and what are the biggest changes since it came out?
Alondra Nelson
Oh, great question. So we came into office. I was a day one person. And the president and the vice president already said that not only Section 230, which we've just been talking about, but harms to children, harms to young people, thinking about competition and antitrust, issues about the threats of social media to democracy. These are already kind of front of mind for the administration. And so the question then became, what is the proactive vision? Like, so we've got a lot of things that we don't like, that we want to be critical of and that we want to change. At the same time, is there a proactive vision for what we want to do?
So what are the rights, protections that the people should have in the best of world with these kinds of increasingly powerful technologies? And so that's how we went about the work. We spent a year talking to all sorts of folks from researchers to companies to high school students. And we also wanted to produce a document. The part of me that's a teacher sometimes that was readable. So it's a long document. It's 70 plus pages. But anybody can read it. It's a resource for people. I think it teaches people a little bit about AI and how systems work, teaches people a little bit about what you can do about it.
So we introduce red teaming and auditing and risk assessment and these sorts of things. And so it was really to sort of to say if we're going to move ahead with a better vision, how are we going to do that? Also, I think it was really the White House kind of setting the table and setting the vision. So the document's been referred to as aspirational. It certainly is. Much like last week's commitments, it's voluntary, certainly true. But I think at its best, what the White House does and what the president does is to create a vision and expectation for American society at its best. And a lot has changed.
But I think some fundamental things are true. So a theory of the case with the AI Bill of Rights is that technology is going to change really quickly. It's changing all the time. It's changing all around us. So what do we want to anchor on? What are the things that, as we go from generative AI to AGI, as we go from a world in which we have generative AI and perhaps quantum computing that ends encryption as we know it, there's all of these technologies happening about us. We can try to regulate the thing, which is probably may not be the best idea, or we can try to regulate the outcomes or we can try to level set on the society that we want.
So whether or not you're talking about generative AI or quantum computing, do we want basic privacy for American public? The answer is yes. The question is, what are the processes, norms? How do we get there? I think will be different. But I think that we need to keep in mind the kind of holy grail is not AGI. The holy grail, the thing that we are guarding with our guardrails, is our democracy, opportunities for people, public safety, and things like that. And so the theory of the case with the AI Bill of Rights is that we're going to keep our eyes on that and think about the regulations, norms, standards, practices we need to get there.
Scott Galloway
So Alondra, I'm always heartened when I hear from insightful and intelligent people such as yourself that outline the issues really well. And then it all leads to a giant nothing burger. We've never had an industry this big with this lack of regulation. And so it strikes me there's a ton of insight, a ton of really brilliant articulate people outlining the issue, and it results in nothing. Why have we not been able to pass anything resembling regulation on an industry that is now by market cap the largest industry in the world, arguably the most influential industry in the world? What are the forces that you and your colleagues are facing that has gotten in the way of us being able to enact any of these very thoughtful views?
Alondra Nelson
I think that you had a wonderful conversation with Senator Warner a few months ago, and he really nailed it, which is lobbying. So you've got big industry, big tech on the one side of their mouth saying, we need to be regulated. This is horrible what's going on. And on the other hand, spending hundreds of millions of dollars every year lobbying against regulation. And so I think that's a fundamental problem and government cannot compete with that in a fundamental way. I think the president has succeeded in doing some bipartisan things. He believes in it. He thinks it can work. I think the horrors of the last decade and of social media are such that people are exhausted.
They see that a lot of harms have been done. And I think that there's a space for bipartisanship around this. Like people don't want children harmed and young people harmed. People understand that antitrust and competition might be a problem when you can do something like the Threads transition and no one needs to have a conversation about that. Certainly issues around privacy. I mean, I think even the fact that you look at the judiciary subcommittee that Senator Blumenthal and Senator Hawley are working on, they seem to be working really well together on that. So it does feel like a window of opportunity.
I also think the somewhat panic freak out of the public release of GPT-4 and all of the risk conversation has galvanized the public and got the public's attention in a way that hadn't really existed before. And then that gets legislators' attention. When the public is paying attention, legislators are paying attention.
Kara Swisher
Alondra, where would you start? If you had a magic wand, would you start with privacy, age dating, Section 230?
Alondra Nelson
At this point, having been in government for two years and a bit, please get anything over the line. Nothing can hurt. So if you do antitrust, if you do privacy, if you do protections for young people, none of these things are to the deficit of the larger goals we're trying to reach here. But I think privacy is a key one. To go back to Kara's earlier question, data privacy and data issues are the thing that's not in this White House commitments document. There's an assertion that privacy protections need to be strengthened, but we're not talking about the data piece, which is so important here.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I would agree. One of the things is, of course, the private sector tends to be running the show for most of tech, as Scott said. And the government has lost its preeminent voice on the topic. But it's interesting. I was just looking on X, or whatever we're calling it today. This guy, Martin Crowley, said, "If you're not using AI, you're falling behind." And then Sally Jenkins from The Washington Post said, "If you're using AI to write or create, you're plagiarizing." It's a really interesting back and forth going on, which I think people are surprised at.
So, Scott, of course, I don't think there should be a pause in AI development. How do you answer as a government that regulation inhibits innovation? Because that's what you're getting here. There's a gold rush on in terms of investment and money and start an AI company. No matter what you do, you need to learn it. How do you make that argument that regulation helps innovation versus inhibits? Because that's been the tech industry's go-to for far too long.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. One of the ways you make the case is, I think, just a business case. There was a Goldman Sachs report that came out in March or April that was trying to think about the market cap and what might happen as AI gets up and running. They were anticipating something like a 7% increase in global GDP, potentially trillion-dollar kind of investment and productivity globally. But as I said elsewhere, what I was really struck by was a lot of equivocating language. There was a lot of words like "uncertainty" and "it could potentially do" and "it might" in ways that documents from big finance don't usually do. They're really often just leaning into the hype cycle.
And so I think the uncertainty around the technology, the hallucinations, the question of whether it's going to work if I use it this time or differently if I put a layer on top of it and try to use it with a customer in another instance—the uncertainty around the regulation does not create a rich, robust space for innovation. So there's a business case for that.
I also think as a researcher sitting here in my office at Princeton, where people have come to think about really hard problems, the challenges around the technology—how do you explain it? How do we get to a place where you can make sure it's transparent?—those are real opportunities for innovation as well. The intellectual puzzle, being a nerd about it, are opportunities for innovation. I think the rest of it, a lot of the rest of it, are the lobbying narratives that lobbyists tell us. I don't think there needs to be a natural tension between innovation and releasing safe, exciting, fun products that lead to productivity and don't steal people's livelihoods.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but government's so stupid, Alondra.
Alondra Nelson
Government's not stupid.
Kara Swisher
I know that. I'm teasing you. It's bullshit.
Alondra Nelson
Oh, I know. But I must also say, this was my first time working in government. The congressional staffers are really good. They are. They're fantastic. There are a lot of good people working in government. I think what it is is that folks are tremendously outnumbered and outgunned. You're outgunned by the lobbyists. Going from the Reagan period, that sort of "government is the problem, it's too big" mentality—offices are way too small. Budgets are way too small for the work that has to be done. I think if we want to have nimble, agile regulation around big tech and some of these other fast-moving industries, we really need to revisit that conversation. Not that you should have excessive budgets for government salaries, but you need people to do the work.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Scott, last question?
Scott Galloway
Yeah. So just to reinforce, anybody who's exposed to people in DC up and down the supply chain is universally surprised at how hardworking and how smart the people are and committed they are. But let me make an ageist comment. They're also really old. Our average elected official is 63, meaning for every 40-year-old elected, there is somebody who's dead. I'm ageist around technology. I think younger people have an easier time grasping new technologies. I feel it myself. My question is, one, do you agree that part of the problem is our elected representatives are just too old to really grasp these new technologies? And two, how can we solve for that, if you agree with it?
Alondra Nelson
As someone who's closer to 63 than not and is increasingly finding myself turning to a graduate student or a niece or nephew being like, "How do I do this thing on this jing and the bob?" I fundamentally agree with you. But folks have young staffers. I think it's not entirely incorrect, these stories that say 20-year-olds run Washington. There are a lot of quite young staffers who really do get it.
I think what you do have is a deficit of attention, particularly with legislators. They've got these huge portfolios. They're running local offices, and they've got a lot of expectations. They don't always snap to attention on the things that they need to. If you think about the difference between what I thought were really smart, sophisticated questions at this hearing that Sam Altman was at—relative to hearings we had even five or six years ago where people were saying, "What are the interwebs?" and "How do you make money?"—it's a big shift.
Certainly, I would make a pitch to folks who are listening that young people do need to go into government. It's pretty important. And run for office. I'm encouraged to see young people running for office as well.
Kara Swisher
Thank you so much. I wanted to bring you on for a long time. I think you did an amazing job with that Bill of Rights. It was way ahead in so many ways. I really appreciate it.
Alondra Nelson
Well, we tried. It worked really hard.
Kara Swisher
I know. You did. You did a great job. So anyway, I really appreciate it. And thank you so much for being here.
Scott Galloway
Thank you, Alondra. I'm a big fan.
Alondra Nelson
Thanks for having me.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, aren't you impressed?
Scott Galloway
I think Alondra—every time I talk to her, I feel smarter.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I remember what I said. People, when you get to this level of government, what you find is remarkably intelligent, committed people who have a lot of options and decide that they want to go to work for their country on both sides of the aisle. It's very heartening.
Scott Galloway
Absolutely.
Kara Swisher
It is. Anyway, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails.
Scott Galloway
Well, the obvious fail is what will go down as the weirdest rebranding in history.
Kara Swisher
Is it the weirdest?
Scott Galloway
I don't think you've ever seen a brand with this global awareness and quite frankly, positive associations, and then just overnight we're calling it X. I don't think this is new. Their best hope is the rest of the world doesn't care. That is a business fail and it sort of flies in the face of basic tenets of brand strategy. If he pulls this off, quite frankly, we're all going to have to rethink brand strategy. That maverick—everyone will go, "That maverick, he's such a maverick."
But also, I really do think we're at the point—and I don't like class warfare against billionaires—I do think this indicates that power makes you more stupid. Everybody needs guardrails. Corporate governance is important. This isn't going to damage the world, I don't think. But it's clear that he has absolutely nobody around him that he listens to. I'm now at the point where, okay, when we have five people worth more than the bottom half of America, we probably have gotten out of control in terms of what people with this kind of money can do.
Anyway, that's my fail. My win is I think every high school senior should be—I don't want to say forced—but I think every history teacher or science teacher should do what my teachers used to do in the fourth and fifth grade when they were terribly hungover: just put a film in front of us for three hours. I think *Oppenheimer*—I thought the movie was just such a difficult story to tell with that kind of insight and that kind of visual. I love that it had no CGI. I love that he wasn't wearing tights or a cape. I love that it wasn't a sequel. I love that it isn't a movie franchise—we're not going to have *Oppenheimer 7*. My 12-year-old is asking me all sorts of questions about war and about arms control.
I think we have lost a sense because the majority of America now has never been drafted. The majority of America has never known an economy that has been really disrupted through hyperinflation. We've never had an existential threat to our physical safety from a competitor. We had 9/11, but I don't think most people in the nation were actually physically worried about their own safety. Revisiting history is just so powerful when it's done well.
Kara Swisher
It is. You know, I think one of the things I think is interesting is—and you will see *Barbie*, it's actually a very smart movie. People say it's clever. It's really clever. It's got a lot of depth to it. Audiences are just smarter. They know what they like. They've been attracted to intelligence in both these movies. *Barbie* set off a great discussion, except for Ben Shapiro and I guess Piers Morgan, about women and men's relationships, about plasticity, about corporate power. There's all kinds of things to chew on in their feminism. And *Oppenheimer*, obviously so much stuff about compromise, ethics, science, et cetera. Audiences like smart stuff and they are smarter than us, the media, or the people who make these movies. Honestly, I have to say, I find audiences always tell you exactly what the right thing to do is.
Scott Galloway
I don't know. I think the average American is of average intelligence.
Kara Swisher
I don't know. I think they're smarter.
Scott Galloway
You sound like a politician right now.
Kara Swisher
I don't. I think they're smarter than you think. Anyway, I'm going to do my wins and fails.
Scott Galloway
I can prove they're of average intelligence.
Kara Swisher
All right. Okay. I like them better than many people.
My fails: I'm toggling between the Israeli parliament approving this judicial overhaul that hundreds of thousands of people are protesting virulently in the streets, which is what stopped it last time. But they went out and passed it anyway, saying they needed to correct judicial overreach. They don't have a constitution with a written constitution in Israel, so they can't lean on anything. Benjamin Netanyahu really needs to move along. But he's passed it despite what is obvious—protests happening, very significant, including the military protesting against it.
And then I don't know if the failure is worth with Ron DeSantis pushing the idea that black people benefited from slavery. I just don't even know what to say about that. And then he had Nazi imagery. He's going to change the name of Florida to X. Talk about something that does not—if there was ever more reasons to check back when people ask you where you're from and you have to say Florida. He wants to whitewash slavery in history classes.
For positive, I was happy to see all the people in the theater. It's actually a really nice community experience.
Scott Galloway
It is nice. I agree.
Kara Swisher
I loved the enthusiasm. And I know you could say *Barbie* is all about consumerism. My son was saying that. Just go see it and then we can have a normal discussion. Anyway, we'll see. I'm going to the theater. I like the community aspect of not just *Barbie* but going to the theater. I think the Barbenheimer thing, even though it's exhausting and finally tiresome, is great. I just loved it. I like the whole thing and I don't care if it's commercial and sells tickets. I don't care if it's dressing up and buying plastic dolls. Very lovely little moment in marketing, I think. As opposed to the X.com, which seems dark and glum and smells like Confederacy.
Anyway, we want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business tech or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show. Call 855-51-PIVOT.
Scott, I am from *Barbie*. You are from *Oppenheimer*. You went on about *Oppenheimer* just as much as I go on about *Barbie*.
Scott Galloway
Not even close.
Kara Swisher
Close. That means you lack self-awareness. Everything for you—we can be talking about AI and you reverse engineer it to *Barbie*.
Scott Galloway
Oh, you'll see. I didn't even have Barbies when I was a kid because it has a spirit I like.
Kara Swisher
You know, Barbie, she only orgasms with a G.I. Joe. I'm just saying.
Scott Galloway
I love that. I love that.
Kara Swisher
Our producer, Lair, is just saying, "Untrue. Barbie orgasms with other Barbies." Hi, Barbie. Hi, Barbie. You'll see.
Anyway, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Friday for more. Why don't you read us out?
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Neyman, Taylor Griffin, and Travis Larchuk. Ernie Injerdot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Dubros, Miel Saverio, and Gaddy McBain. Make sure you're subscribed to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thank you for listening to *Pivot* from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Have a great week, Karen.
Kara Swisher
Thank you.