Main Topic: The podcast episode covers a wide range of topics, including AI agents, the Biden administration's proposal to target Chinese retailers, the recent assassination attempt on former President Donald Trump, and the impact of AI on various industries.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Wins and Fails:
Closing:
The hosts conclude the episode by emphasizing the importance of having discussions about the impact of AI on society and the need for responsible development and deployment of AI technologies. They also encourage listeners to subscribe to the show and send in their questions and comments.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. This is Kara Swisher, and I look fantastic in a kilt. Scott, happy birthday.
Scott Galloway
You do look fantastic in a kilt. I'm Scott Galloway, and I heard you were excellent on the archery range and axe throwing.
Kara Swisher
And shooting. Let's leave that out.
Scott Galloway
That's right.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I was. It was really good. We're going to talk about you in a second, but I did. The Scottish men kept calling me Wee Lassie, which was irritating.
Scott Galloway
I love that.
Kara Swisher
They were like, "Oh, do you need to ride Wee Lassie up the hill?" You got the full Scottish experience. Scotland's actually quite progressive, I think. I think the UK is more progressive than the US in a lot of ways. But tell me about you. We had such a lovely time in Scotland. What a beautiful place. And your friends are lovely. Beata did an astonishing job. And by the way, it was interesting in all the tribute videos, it was all about how lucky you were to have her as a wife, and I would concur. How did you feel?
Scott Galloway
I was anxious for a while, and then once the speech was over on Saturday, I was able to enjoy myself. But when you ask 80 or 100 people to come to Scotland, you're really hoping they have a nice time. I had friends from LA and San Francisco, so you don't want everyone to have a good time. You want everyone to have a great time. And to be honest, Kara, I was just a little bit overwhelmed with emotion. I had everyone from my sister to my best friend from the fourth grade. It was just a lot for me. Once all the speeches were over Saturday and I got the sense everyone was having a nice time—I'm a transistor. If my kids are happy, I'm happy. If someone else is laughing, I'm happy. So once we got through halfway through Saturday night and it was obvious that everyone was having a nice time and all the speeches were done, I could relax. Everyone had a great day Saturday. It was very rewarding. I don't think I'll do it again.
Kara Swisher
What, the 75th?
Scott Galloway
Probably the 75th.
Kara Swisher
No, I still—in 10 years, I'll do my 60th.
Scott Galloway
Okay. There's an active thread on Reddit trying to figure out how much it cost.
Kara Swisher
Oh, really?
Scott Galloway
Which is sort of interesting. And also a Reddit thread talking about how on Instagram, I only follow hot women. I'm like, you didn't know that? What am I supposed to call economists? What's the point of Instagram? It's like my Cinemax.
Kara Swisher
Well, let me just say, it was a beautiful place. It was at a haunted hotel. That was nice. And it was full of preserved animals. It was really fantastic. It was so Scottish. It felt like we were in a movie in a lot of ways. But let me just say, Scott, you have a blessed life. That's all I have to say.
Scott Galloway
Thank you. I appreciate that.
Kara Swisher
You really do. And I know you have a hard time. We had a little chat while we were there on the couch, looking like we're dating. A lot of people were strangely disturbed by that photo of me.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's because you had a tattoo of my initials.
Kara Swisher
That's right. And it's still there, by the way. It's a good tattoo. But you have a heart. You should know you're very much loved.
Scott Galloway
I appreciate that. And I know that. Thank you. Can I ask one question though? What was that thing in the front that we're wearing? Is that a murse? The little furry thing that you wear in front of your penis, which I didn't have.
Kara Swisher
No, it's just a little purse. I don't know the actual name of it. Did you get a knife for your sock?
Scott Galloway
Yes, I got a knife, but it wasn't a real one. So I was vaguely disappointed about that.
Kara Swisher
It's called a sporran, apparently. That's what Lara tells me.
Scott Galloway
Sporran. Very good. Do you know more about Scotland than I do?
Kara Swisher
No, Lara just typed it to me. So I didn't know that. I just said "furry, weird."
Scott Galloway
Oh, wait. She sends you tips and not me?
Kara Swisher
Yes, that's correct.
Scott Galloway
I have the deck so stacked against me here.
Kara Swisher
It's true. I'm always the one that gets in trouble.
Scott Galloway
Yes, yeah. I'm always the one that has my jokes edited.
Kara Swisher
If you would even read the script, which you never do, you would be part of this.
Scott Galloway
I like to be authentic. It's the real dog. He doesn't go to the groomer. He doesn't respond to hand commands.
Kara Swisher
Which dog are you? Are you like a Scottish... People saw the picture of us because I'm so short and you're so tall, and they were surprised by us in kilts. But it did look like that Danny DeVito, Arnold Schwarzenegger movie, *Twins*.
Scott Galloway
You're a Scottish wolfhound and I'm a terrier. That's what someone said.
Kara Swisher
I'm sorry. We saw that picture. And I look like a recently divorced father dropping off his five-year-old daughter at Edinburgh Elementary School. We look ridiculous. There's a reason we're on a podcast and not on TV together.
Scott Galloway
I wouldn't be sitting down. We are just not Mika and Joe. We are a strange pair.
Kara Swisher
We are a strange pair. Thank God for the audio medium, because I saw those photos. Yes, we are a strange pair.
Scott Galloway
I looked like the alien from *Close Encounters of the Third Kind*.
Kara Swisher
You look like a Scottish redo of Hervé Villechaize going, "The kilt, the kilt!"
Scott Galloway
The kilt. Boss. Hey, boss. We look so odd.
Kara Swisher
We do. Cute in an odd way. I like it.
Scott Galloway
You know who I look good with? Not you.
Kara Swisher
You look childlike. You literally look childlike.
Scott Galloway
With George Hahn, I looked good. And by the way, George Hahn turned his kilt into a Britney Spears video later in the evening.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he did that thing with his shirt and he started... Oh God. "Hit me one more time." He did *Dirty Dancing*.
Scott Galloway
I admire anyone that behaves that way and he doesn't drink alcohol. I just think that's so impressive.
Kara Swisher
We had a good time, George Hahn. Your wife danced a lot too. I saw Amanda bust a move.
Scott Galloway
Bust a move. She likes to dance. You do not.
Kara Swisher
I could tell you were hating it.
Scott Galloway
I was. In the kilt. I can't dance in a kilt.
Kara Swisher
So anyway, we have so much to get to today, including President Biden cracking down on Shein and Temu, your two favorite Chinese retailers. And TikTok gets its day in court. But there's so much more going on. Plus, our friend of Pivot is journalist Evan Ratliff. He's got a brand new podcast, *Shell Game*, where he's embarked on a fascinating experiment with his AI voice clone. Kind of cool. But on to serious news. The FBI is investigating what appears to be a second assassination attempt on former President Donald Trump. It's not clear yet. But Trump was on his Florida golf course Sunday when a Secret Service agent opened fire on an armed man hiding in the bushes. The suspected gunman is Ryan Wesley Routh, a 58-year-old former construction worker. He's been charged with two federal gun crimes. He supported Trump in 2016, but more recently favored other Republicans like Nikki Haley. He's registered unaffiliated, but voted in a Democratic primary this year. He's all over the map, but pretty much a Republican again. What were your initial thoughts when you heard this?
Scott Galloway
Look, we don't have a monopoly on mental illness. We don't have a monopoly on disaffected young men, although this guy was unusual in that he was 58, who are looking to recapture social capital through what they perceive as some sort of heroic act of violence. But this is just happening too much. Whether it's school shootings, all roads lead to the same thing. When we were in Scotland, the guy who drove us to the hotel was taking everyone's shooting. I said, "Tell me about the gun laws here." He said, "You can get a gun here, but you have to take a psychological test, you can't have a criminal record, and then the local police officer can say no if they want.
They oftentimes come to your house to see where you're storing the gun." And by the way, after they had a horrible mass shooting at a school, within a couple weeks they passed laws outlawing assault weapons. I actually believe if we had fewer mass shootings in the U.S., there'd be more momentum against them because they'd be such spectacles. But because we have so many of them, what you said was actually really radical and kind of depressingly insightful: humans adapt. Americans have adapted to the steady state of mass shootings in a nation where the NRA and far-right folks claim there's nothing we can do about it, in a nation where it's the only place that it happens.
So for me, it all reverse engineers to guns. If you look at key moments in history, arguably the most seminal person of the 20th century was a 19-year-old man who joined a group called the Black Hand. When you're 19, you don't even know what that means. He ended up murdering Archduke Franz Ferdinand, which not only kicked off World War I, but set the stage for World War II. So if it's not school shootings, if it's not worrying about our kids being shot or cut up by hot metal, at some point you'd like to think we'll see that you destabilize the world when you have so much access to so many guns by people who are going through a mental health episode.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it seems like that. I was looking at the social media for this guy. It's typical. There are all these nutters online now. They're just nutty. His son said something lovely about him, saying, "I can't believe this is him." But he was just intense online and overstimulated. Speaking of overstimulated, after the last shooting, there were calls to dial down rhetoric, and Trump certainly has not done that. People have not dialed down rhetoric at all. Speaking of which, Elon Musk, because he cannot keep himself out of the center of attention because he's a truly heinous person at this point, had a horrific post on X after the incident, essentially encouraging violence against Joe Biden and Kamala Harris. He later deleted it. I'm sure his lawyers got involved and said what was funny in the room among his employees and paid people wasn't quite as funny online in text. What a fucking asshole. I don't know what else to say. He should be investigated. He has contracts with the government. He won't pay a price for it. But what a truly horrific person he has become.
Scott Galloway
My dad asked me once, a few years ago, he said, "As your profile is growing, have you found that you're more measured in your comments?" I proudly said, "No, I want to be authentic. If I'm thinking it, I say it." My dad said, "You should be more measured, Scott. As your influence grows, you need to be careful about shooting from the hip. You have an impact. If a few people who are unstable or extremists are listening to you now, now it's hundreds or even thousands. You want to be really thoughtful about the ripple effect of some of the things you say." I thought, wow, he's right. I hate it when he's right. There should be a different set of standards when you put out a communication to 175 million people.
Kara Swisher
Well, they don't. He essentially had a very rapey one at Taylor Swift, which was followed by Donald Trump.
Scott Galloway
I didn't interpret that as rapey.
Kara Swisher
I did. It was creepy, as every woman did.
Scott Galloway
Creepy, yes. I agree. It was weird.
Kara Swisher
"I'll get you pregnant." Like, excuse me? It was grotesque. Every woman I know was like, "That's really gross." And the other one was Donald Trump saying yesterday, just before this shooting attempt, "I hate Taylor Swift." I felt worried for Taylor Swift, who has so much security around her.
Scott Galloway
That was dumb. That was really dumb.
Kara Swisher
It adds up. She's a woman. In all caps, it calls out people to do something to Taylor Swift. It really does. What an irresponsible person. And then himself being the subject. I don't think the assassination attempt, if it is that, will have any impact on the election. Because we've gotten used to it with him and in general.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I don't think so. The first one, his political instincts with the blood on his face to pump his fist and the image of the flag in the background—that'll be the image of the decade. We were going into the RNC convention. The momentum was there. This is a bit of a nothing burger, other than at some point you'd like to think we're going to do something here. If a world leader is assassinated, it potentially can lead to world war. I don't want to be resigned about it, but when you have this many guns... This guy was convicted of owning a firearm in 2002. He's had run-ins with the law. In any other Western nation, if you have run-ins with the law, you don't get an AK-47. All roads lead back to the same place. I find the whole thing a bit of a distraction. I don't think it's going to have any impact on the race. But at some point, I'm a broken record here. There's no reason to have weapons of war in a nation with 350 million people. It just doesn't make any sense.
Kara Swisher
100%. It's a shame. And stop with the fucking tweets. They're not funny right now. They're not funny ever, but they're really not funny right now. And again, Elon Musk is a heinous piece of shit. Thank you. All right. The Biden administration is proposing new shipping rules targeting Shein and Temu and Alibaba. A longstanding trade law allows low-value shipments to enter the U.S. without duties and fees. It's been abused by companies, the administration says. The new rule would prevent those exemptions. A report from the House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party says Shein and Temu are likely responsible for more than 30% of all packages within the exemptions. According to the committee, Gap paid $700 million in import duties in 2022, while Shein and Temu paid none. I think that probably needs to be fixed. What do you think about this?
Scott Galloway
It does make things more expensive for the American consumer. Just disclosure, I'm an investor in Shein. I think this is hard to argue for maintaining. Two things: they are taking advantage, as companies do, of a loophole. What I would like to see is these taxes done away with for everybody. I'm totally anti-tariffs, anti-taxes, unless it's used as a strategic weapon if we're outsourcing pollution or if the Chinese decide to dump steel. But Gap and H&M say they paid $700 million and $200 million respectively on this tax, because this is a loophole that says if it's less than $800 and it's going direct to the household, you don't have to pay import taxes.
I think it's hard to argue that this shouldn't be closed, or they shouldn't get rid of the taxes or import duties on the other brands. What people don't realize is this is only a small cost delta in what gives these companies such an incredible advantage. The reason I invested in Shein is that if you look at companies over the last 20 years that have added tens of billions of dollars in market capitalization, they tend to have one thing in common: they're asset-light. The really amazing thing, and the reason I invested in Shein, is that even if they have to pay these tariffs, they're still going to have an unbelievable advantage over these other players.
These two companies will be responsible for $1 in $5 spent over the holidays. Their advantage is the following: it's all software. They don't own a single factory, a single truck, a single plane, a single warehouse, or a single store. They use AI to examine activity on their site. With machine learning and AI, they can say, "We're going to need exactly 7,700 pairs of bell-bottom tie-dye jeans." Within a microsecond, the software goes, "These are the three best factories to produce it." Other pieces of the software start going, "This is the fastest way to get it to the consumer." Because of all this incredible demand estimation and low prices, there are fewer and fewer returns.
It's more efficient. They're able to charge a fraction of the price of Zara. It's what Zara did to everybody else. These guys are doing to Zara, and it's all with software. There are no assets here. As a result, Shein is going to be the second largest apparel company in the world, surpassing Amazon this year. Next year, they'll probably surpass Walmart with no assets. So this will hurt them a little bit. I think it's unfair. I think they should pay the tax. But be clear, it's barely going to slow their growth. That's not the issue. The issue is these other companies have an outdated business model, and Shein has a much better business model.
Kara Swisher
Walmart was ahead technologically. That's why they did so well. Technology always matters in these cases. But we'll see. They deserve to pay the tax. Sorry, companies. You have to pay the tax. That's fair. All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about some big changes coming to OpenAI, and we'll chat with our friend of Pivot, Evan Ratliff. He'll share what it was like to create an AI clone of himself. I think we need an AI clone of Scott Galloway.
Ad break
Scott, we're back with more news. TikTok is heading to court to fight for the right to remain available in the U.S. as we tape on Monday. The case stems from the law signed in April, which would require ByteDance to sell the app to a non-Chinese owner or face a U.S. ban. ByteDance sued to block the law in May, arguing the ban would violate free speech rights. The court ruling will not likely be the final say, as legal experts expect the case to go to the Supreme Court. Is there anything TikTok can say that would be impressive enough to get them out of the ban? Obviously, it's going to probably be a stay and back and forth, but it looks like they have to do something now.
Scott Galloway
I don't think this is going to get solved. My guess is TikTok is doing everything it can to try and delay, hoping that Trump gets elected or hoping that after the election, people get distracted. They're hoping it's Trump because even though Trump has now turned and says he's for TikTok because he hates Facebook, they're hoping that similar to other issues, we're like a cat chasing a light and then we get distracted with something else. I think on the eve of the banning, the White House and the folks at TikTok, including the CCP, will come to some sort of accommodation. A decent way to bet on anything is just to follow the money.
I think they'll come to some sort of accommodation in terms of spending or divesting. There is a face-saving element with China, though. They feel they are bigger than the U.S. They aren't going to act like they acquiesce to the U.S. It would be interesting if Vice President Harris is part of this. She has legal skills, and this is a dicey thing. She's been sort of in the middle, saying there should be a ban or a new owner. I think she must be fully aware of the constitutional issues around free speech here. It'll be interesting if they sort of gave her a gimme here and let her be the face of a settlement where everyone gets to keep their TikTok and U.
S. security is protected. That seems to me what will happen. If not, it's going to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court will decide what's a national security issue and whether we can do that as a country. We do it in other areas.
Kara Swisher
It falls under the same rubric of we've decided that anything communicated digitally can be categorized or immunized from any scrutiny, whether it's a defense threat or hostility or crime, if we just call it speech. We have consistently, frequently, early and often decided that defense trumps free speech. I believe the Supreme Court would find that here. Certainly there's precedent with broadcast networks, magazines, other media. They can't really own it in the same way. Any remedy would probably involve a divestiture of ownership. To your point about China not wanting to save face, I think that argument would have held more water two years ago because in the last two or three years, the Chinese stock market has shed...
Scott Galloway
That's a very good point. The Chinese stock market is literally off by a third. It's been cut in half. When the economy goes really bad and people's quality of life goes down, in most democracies, they vote in the other party. Voting in the other party in China means revolution. Granted, they're autocrats, but to not think they're very sensitive to what people are thinking... China has to keep pulling about 30 to 50 million people out of poverty into the middle class each year, or there's going to be a revolution. Things do not end well. They end up getting killed when they're overthrown. Xi cannot kneecap his thoroughbreds economically. The really tough line he's taken with Didi and some of these companies—Alibaba's been cut by 60% because of what they did to Jack. There are analysts now saying Chinese companies are uninvestable. This is a big issue for their economy. Remember all that bullshit that China was going to overtake the U.S. economy by 2028? We're absolutely beating the shit out of them. My point is, I think they need to come to some sort of accommodation. They're hoping that, like so many other issues, our attention span is that of a cat.
Kara Swisher
It's got to be done very deftly, with cooperation from decent Republicans. I think Harris is going to be right. Just like the hostage negotiations with Russia, I think she might benefit here from it looking like she handled it. That's a strong thing with minimal criticism. It is better to get it out of the way than have it go to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court will rule in favor of defense, especially this Supreme Court. Although it has done a lot of free speech stuff around companies and has ruled against Missouri and Texas. So who knows? Next, speaking of people that are killing it, Sam Altman has told OpenAI staff the company's nonprofit structure is set to change next year, according to *Fortune*. An OpenAI spokesman responded to reports saying the nonprofit is core to our mission and will continue to exist. How much it exists, we'll see. But as we discussed last week, OpenAI is now in talks to raise about $6.5 billion. It would value the company at $150 billion. That was a big leap from $100 billion. It's doing very well. It's selling a lot. It has a really good strong balance sheet right now.
Scott Galloway
Things cost a lot. That's the problem.
Kara Swisher
Microsoft is set to participate in the funding round. Apple and NVIDIA are also in talks to invest. They already need money from all over the world for this kind of funds. Talk about the new funding. What do you think of these numbers and what's your latest prediction for when OpenAI goes for an IPO?
Scott Galloway
It's difficult to predict when companies go public because they can now raise $7 billion in the private markets. The reason you went public was a fundraising event to raise capital and provide liquidity to existing shareholders. You can do both of those things now in the private markets. Unfortunately, what that's led to is the siphoning of all the upside to private investors, VCs, and institutions. If OpenAI goes to $150 billion, it might even go to $500 billion. When these companies decide to go public, oftentimes it's because they think it's gotten so expensive that the only people they can convince to invest at a higher valuation are retail investors. A lot of the real value gets siphoned out in the private markets. I don't think they could stay private. The question is, why would they go public unless they thought retail investors were the only ones dumb enough to keep bidding this thing up?
Kara Swisher
And at $150 billion, we said this the last time, relative to other AI companies, I think it's undervalued because if these other companies are raising at what they're raising at.
Scott Galloway
Right, and spending.
Kara Swisher
Right. With a fraction of the strategic assets, the leadership. I mean, Sam Altman really is kind of the Bill Gates or the Elon Musk, whatever the analogy is of his generation. He has managed this thing really well. They're pulling away. They're raising a ton of capital. The new feature where it thinks longer — I think that's brilliant marketing. They have more capital to spend. But I wouldn't expect an IPO anytime soon. They don't need it. Why do they need to go public?
Scott Galloway
Well, it's interesting.
Kara Swisher
Well, because they've got competitors everywhere. I mean, Larry Ellison just gave an interview at Oracle. His best buddy, Elon Musk, said that—
Scott Galloway
All-time lie, by the way. Oracle just said an all-time lie.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I know, it is. He's become the second richest man for, I think, briefly. I think he's probably down again. But he said that vast AI-fueled surveillance system can ensure citizens will be on their best behavior. Thanks, Larry. We should be watching you. Jesus, tomorrow belongs to me.
Scott Galloway
I know, I know, I know.
Kara Swisher
I was like, maybe we should watch Larry a little bit. On their best behavior? Define best behavior, white man. What does that mean? Between you and Musk, God, we really do need AI to watch you too. But he also said they begged Jensen Huang for GPUs over dinner in this interview. People are really spending here. So I would suspect they absolutely have to be geared to compete with these people who are spending money all over the place. And Musk — he did some questionable things about the power grid in Tennessee. He put in methane things, hurting people there. They're all in the race. Ellison talked about nuclear reactors that he needs to build to create the energy necessary. The costs are massive. Even though I think fewer players will win here than others, the race is on. Sam Altman's got to be as strong as he can against these competitors. He needs as many allies. There is sort of an Ellison-Musk team and a Microsoft-Altman-Apple team. NVIDIA is sort of in the middle, but I suspect they will probably invest here too, which I think the Justice Department has to look at. So there's enormous money happening here.
Scott Galloway
One guy, Ellison, is probably the billionaire no one's talking about in AI. I think their AI group is growing really quickly.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, talk about their stock. Their stock is on it too. Their stock just hit an all-time high.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, that's because he said AI several times.
Kara Swisher
But it's more than just AI washing. They are actually the fastest growing. I think their revenues are 6% or 7%, but their AI group is exploding.
Scott Galloway
Just this week, it started September 9th, and now it's gone from around 139, 140 to 173 in the last couple of days.
Kara Swisher
It's a really well-managed company, and no one ever — quite frankly, he's the billionaire. There are very few people that are as powerful in executing and as rich as him that get this little press. You don't really hear about him or Oracle a lot. And they are executing really well. He saw AI. Microsoft was obviously the visionary in terms of existing companies around this. Alphabet, you would argue, has been slowest. But he has, to a certain extent, turned the tanker. And you could argue maybe a little bit less Dell, but the stock's at an all-time high. He's an outstanding manager, and the team there has done a great job.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, he's also an older gentleman, speaking of age.
Kara Swisher
He's an older gentleman. Salesforce stock has gone up too, even though it's down for the last month. It's been moving since September 11th or 9th from the 240s to the 260s. Anyway, it's interesting to see what's happening with all these shares in that genre area. But yes, Larry Ellison's a very sharp cookie. So we'll see what happens. I think they need to go public. They need as much howitzer power — we're using too many shooting metaphors. They need as much power as possible. They need as much whiskey power as possible, Scott Galloway.
Scott Galloway
[with a bad Scottish accent] Do you like that accent?
Kara Swisher
Your Scottish accent is worse than mine.
Scott Galloway
Do you like it?
Kara Swisher
That sounds like a language that twins speak to each other. Yeah. Anyway, let's bring in our friend of Pivot. Evan Ratliff is a longtime tech journalist and the host of a new podcast, Shell Game. He's been a great podcaster for many years. So, Evan, tell us what this new podcast is about. We sort of previewed it as about AI capabilities. But give us your elevator pitch.
Evan Ratliff
It is about AI, but it's taking AI from a very personal, immersive approach. For the show, I created a clone of my voice. I attached that clone to a phone line. I attached it to an AI chatbot to power it. I created what's called a voice agent, which is basically a semi-autonomous AI voice that could be set out into the world. Then I let it loose. I let it talk to people. I had it call people. I had people call it. I set up a line for it to talk to telemarketers and scammers. I talked to my friends and family. I was doing a combination of things, seeing where the technology was when it comes to voice AI and also how people reacted to it. I think what I was most interested in was just sort of...
Kara Swisher
The reaction.
Evan Ratliff
The reaction.
Kara Swisher
Knowing it wasn't you, correct? It wasn't tricking people necessarily.
Evan Ratliff
It was tricking people. Sorry to say. Some people. It had varying success at tricking people. I called my friends and family from my phone number, attached to my own phone number, without them knowing that I was doing any such project.
Kara Swisher
Right, right. And most of them pretty quickly realized it wasn't you.
Evan Ratliff
They realized something was amiss. Or something was wrong with me.
Kara Swisher
Let me just say, it's called Shell Game. So after making the show, are you more or less worried about it? One of your friends said he felt so lonely talking to the AI. Do you feel more or less worried about the capabilities?
Evan Ratliff
I would say more worried than when I started, although I was fairly worried at the beginning.
Kara Swisher
Why is that?
Evan Ratliff
I think partly because there's a lot of talk about the big AI safety issues, the more doom-related issues or the kill switch, but less about the daily infiltration of AI into our lives and what that's going to mean for us to be human. Voices actually brings that to light in a way that just typing into a chat box or sending an email that ChatGPT has composed doesn't. You're going to be interacting with AI voices. You're going to be hearing AI voices that are almost real, sound real, can fool you. The question is, how much of that do we want in our lives? That discussion is not even happening. There are AI therapists out in the world right now.
Kara Swisher
But your friends were not fooled, necessarily. Correct? Because it doesn't really mimic you that well.
Evan Ratliff
It mimics me well. Not for my oldest friends. I had one friend who spoke to it for 10 minutes, believing that it was me, but that I had had a mental health break.
Kara Swisher
Okay. And on that note, Scott?
Scott Galloway
Nice to meet you, Evan.
Evan Ratliff
You too.
Scott Galloway
My sense is the entertainment community is really worried about AI replacing actors and podcasters at some point. They listen to Kara and me and then start mimicking. We feed into the LLMs today's or this week's news, and it throws in a dick joke. Kara gets angry at me. Kara talks about somebody she knows. Then boom, we put out a reasonable facsimile of Pivot. Pretty soon, Vox no longer needs Kara and Scott. I have found that is not the case, that it is shockingly anodyne and so far hasn't made the progress that everyone was worried about. A, do you agree with that? And B, what advice would you have for creatives who are looking to inoculate themselves as this gets better? Is it being more salty, differentiated? Advise your kids, if they're creators, on how they stave off the advances in AI.
Evan Ratliff
I would agree with you that it is fairly anodyne. The running joke of the show is that when you have them speak at length, it becomes incredibly anodyne. For instance, we have them talk to each other. They have these conversations that are unbelievably mundane. But on the other hand, for many people in podcasting, there are so many people speaking into microphones now, and many of them are just mimicking each other. When the content being created is itself anodyne, it's relatively easy to replace. I think part of the problem is we've dumbed down much of what we consider journalism on the internet to a level that it actually is replaceable by an anodyne LLM or a voice-powered LLM.
If I was giving advice, it would be to try to find unique ways to express yourself that are not based on everything you hear every day. People are just mimicking what they're hearing. You can go on Instagram and the algorithm just feeds you clip after clip of people saying literally the same thing in different forums. Uniqueness is going to be at a premium because even if it can replicate your voice, it's going to have a much harder time replicating that creativity. The more creative you are, the safer you are. The more anodyne what you're doing is, the easier it is for it to be replaced.
Kara Swisher
Right. But it's like the emails you get that aren't very good, right? They're not interesting as writing yet, at the very least. You wish it could do something else?
Evan Ratliff
I was surprised. A lot of people who have listened to the show are surprised at how good it is, actually. As much as tech journalists write about LLMs and OpenAI and the new model, most people are not consuming all that stuff. When they find out that you can make a voice clone that sounds reasonably like you, powered by AI that can have its own conversations, a lot of people are quite shocked and concerned. In that sense, it's actually more powerful right now than a lot of people think it is. We say, well, it can't do this, it can't do that, it can't act in a movie, it can't actually be a journalist. But it's pushing the boundaries of those things too. I had to conduct interviews that I would have conducted. Some of the questions that I would put into a document for myself to ask — it's pretty good at asking those questions. It's not very good at following up. But even some of the people I talked to didn't know it wasn't me, because they're expecting a journalist to ask questions, and that's what they got.
Kara Swisher
But that's being you. I would like it to be like Jarvis on the Avengers movies, where I have a discussion, do this for me, do that for me. I could see that being much more attractive than it being me.
Scott Galloway
Like a digital assistant kind of thing?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that seems very logical to me and very helpful, actually. You produce this show independently. I'd love to know a little bit of why you decided to do this. You were the longtime host, along with others, of Longform. You also did Persona, the French Deception. And you also did a very famous thing way back when, about 12 years ago, where you vanished. You vanished and Wired had a reward when you worked for Wired. You were off the grid communicating, which I remember. They eventually found you in the challenge to get you. You left a coded message, et cetera. You've done a lot of different things. That was honestly my favorite, The Vanishing.
Evan Ratliff
You and many people.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, talk about why you decided to do this independently and about the end of Longform, which was, I think, in June.
Evan Ratliff
It was, yeah, right at the end of June. There's a long answer and a short answer when it comes to doing it independently. The shortest answer is I knew what I wanted to do, and I wanted to have complete control over how it was made. If you listen to the show, a lot of it is very weird and very funny because we push the boundaries on these strange ways you can use it, like having it talk to therapy or having it talk to itself. In this day and age, when you do a podcast with a big platform, a lot of people get involved and they have a lot of opinions and they're very institutional. Some of those opinions are that they're not really willing to take risks. I was very happy to take risks that I didn't want anyone telling me not to.
Kara Swisher
Well, welcome to our club. That's what we don't like.
Scott Galloway
What?
Kara Swisher
That's what we say. We often are like, are you speaking to us? Because we're not listening to you. So I did, we built a Pivot AI. One of the things I found, I'm curious if you believe this or found the same thing. I find that AI is progressive or woke is the wrong term. It's politically correct. It's been trained on — because these companies are worried about everybody trying to get it to say racist things or say stupid things.
Scott Galloway
Which it did, which it did.
Kara Swisher
But as a result, it's built in so many protections that I find it errs on the side of being very overly sensitive. I found that it's over-correcting. Your stepmother or your mother-in-law doesn't want to say anything that might offend people. Occasionally Kara and I will say to somebody, "That's just fucking stupid." It would never say that. Did you find that it kind of errs on the side of being over-mannered or politically correct?
Evan Ratliff
It's certainly over-mannered. I didn't really explore the political correctness or the wokeness aspect of it. That's not a big interest of mine. But it did, when it came to being well-mannered, I would take it even further. For instance, when we had two of them talk to each other — two AI versions of me in conversations with each other — I would prompt one to be angry at the other. I would say, "You're angry at the other one. You're angry at this person you're about to talk to. The reason is up to you." They would resolve their differences within a minute or two of the conversation. I believe that's because the training data tends to center on mental health terminology. There's so much discussion of mental health now, so much discussion of mirroring back what someone says, that it would use all these techniques. I would have to really prompt it very severely for it to stay mad. I literally have to say, "There is nothing that will make you let go of this anger." Then it would do it. But short of that, they would always come to an agreement. It was actually quite lovely, but there was also something very strange and funny about it.
Scott Galloway
Although I would argue if you had real people not on Twitter and you had them in a room, that's exactly what they do. People will do it on a social network, start going down a rabbit hole of anger and rage. But when you have two people in a room, they tend to try to come to an agreement. I've always noticed that, which I think is the difference between online and offline sometimes.
Kara Swisher
Certainly in person.
Evan Ratliff
Yeah. It all highlights the value of in-person communications. The whole thing points to what you get when you sit across the table from someone.
Kara Swisher
Right, right. It's very hard to get people, except if you're on Jerry Springer's show, but that's all designed for bullshit. But I have one more question. What will you have the AI do in season two of this?
Evan Ratliff
I'm not sure yet. The question is, will season two even be AI driven? The premise of the show is it's a show about things that are not what they seem. That covers a lot of my journalism over the last 10 to 20 years.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it does.
Evan Ratliff
It may be AI. I was surprised the extent to which people love the AI agent. They want to hear more of it. They want more calls. They want it to be prompted in different ways. People want to call it. Now I have people who can call it and talk to it, and people love doing that. There's something in that that I might explore further. But I also don't want to be the AI voice guy forever either.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's true. I mean, it's interesting for now. In 10 years, I'll be bored with it. Sort of trying certain things. Scott, last question?
Scott Galloway
Curious after getting deep here, what jobs do you think are most at risk? And what businesses would you advise people to consider starting leveraging this technology?
Evan Ratliff
The most obvious thing that's immediately at risk is all sorts of call center-based telemarketing stuff. That's the stuff it's used for right now. So that's an obvious one. But I think anything where people are just reading off a script. A lot of the advertising you're going to hear is going to have AI voices in it. I'd be surprised if you're not hearing that already a little bit. You both probably know there are podcasters who use this to fill in parts of podcasts using clone voices. That is already happening right now. There's a major podcast platform that tried to launch an AI-hosted podcast. This doesn't mean podcasting is under threat necessarily, but I think they're going to infiltrate. It's going to be much less like everyone getting wiped away in an industry and much more like little places where it starts to infiltrate and then it kind of grows out from there.
Kara Swisher
We were thinking of translation, right, Scott? The idea of translating.
Scott Galloway
Well, that's an easy one. You can now put almost any podcast and even the video. It doesn't get the eye movement right, but you can do it with other languages.
Kara Swisher
But the customer service is really what Evan was talking about. It's just crazy how much more efficient I've been using all these bots for airlines or whatever you call them, chat agents. It's been really striking. Do you think there really is a threat? Do you think the fear of the writers unions about AI in these writers rooms — we're putting together a writers room and the showrunner said, "Should we have AI in the room?" And I said, "No, you should have people know how to use AI in the room just for brainstorming." Do you think their fears are overblown, underblown?
Evan Ratliff
I don't think they're overblown. I think it's very smart to try to have discussions about this before it's absolutely everywhere. The risk is it's being put into the market without any of these discussions.
Kara Swisher
Wow, that's never happened before in tech. But go ahead.
Evan Ratliff
Right, exactly. Anywhere where these discussions could be had, whether it's around trying to ban it from writers rooms or whatnot, it doesn't necessarily mean it has no place there or it has no place in getting you past a writing block or prompting creativity. Without condemning the technology, I feel like having the discussion — "What do we want out of these rooms? What do we want out of human writing?" — those are discussions that are worthwhile to have.
Kara Swisher
Yep. That's a fair point. Anyway, does your voice have another name? Evan 2? Evan AI?
Evan Ratliff
For the purpose of the show, it was always me. So it's just AI Evan Ratliff. But oftentimes, it was just operating under Evan Ratliff until questioned.
Kara Swisher
All right. Okay. Evan Ratliff. That's interesting. Anyway, we really appreciate it. It's a really cool podcast. It's called Shell Game. Listen wherever you get your podcasts. Thank you, Evan.
Scott Galloway
Thanks, Evan.
Evan Ratliff
Thanks for having me.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, what'd you think of that?
Scott Galloway
That guy's impressive. He should be on TV. He's got a great voice. He's very handsome. Obviously very talented.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, Longform is amazing. But I found it really interesting what he was saying about trying to get the AIs to be angry at each other.
Scott Galloway
But what people don't realize, there's only three things you need to have in your arsenal for all conflict resolution. When things get really heated, you pick one of the following three things. You just pause, you look at them in the eyes, and you say, "I'm taking the kids, albeit my sister's." That's number one. Number two, man or woman, you pause, you look at them and you say, "Is that the menopause speaking?" Question mark. And then the third thing, if things get really heated, you look around and then you look at them and you go, "Wait, you can see me?" Boom, conflict over. World peace, Kara.
Kara Swisher
I have to say, I like Scott in this seventh decade of his life.
Scott Galloway
Fifth. I'm serious. I'm done. We need to stop. The scrotum lift is kicking in.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, whatever you do, whatever you want. You're 29. Okay.
Ad break
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails. Shall I go first?
Scott Galloway
Sure, go ahead.
Kara Swisher
The Emmys were delightful. I didn't watch it in real time, but I thought the outfits were great. And I thought Steve Martin, the group from Only Murders in the Building — Selena Gomez, Steve Martin, and Martin Short. By the way, he's dating Meryl Streep.
Scott Galloway
He's dating Meryl Streep?
Kara Swisher
But not dating? I don't know. It's not confirmed. Whatever. They seem like they're dating.
Scott Galloway
You mean actually in real life?
Kara Swisher
Yes. Just rumored.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no.
Kara Swisher
They're sitting together all the time. They're out all the time. Martin Short and Meryl Streep?
Mm-hmm. I don't know how I feel about that. But I know that's what's happening. They were sitting together. They've been going to things together. I'm sorry, Sophie chooses Martin Short. I'm just not... It's a rumor, but I'm just telling you.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, the Emmys were really delightful. There's so much good television. Baby Reindeer won. They both won.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Jean Smart winning for *Hacks*. I just love it. She gave a great speech. TV is really... even though the economics of it have changed drastically and not for the better, it's great for consumers.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it is.
Kara Swisher
I got to say, *Hacks* is so good. Gene Smart, that's my win. My fail is Elon Musk and Donald Trump tweeting very dangerous things around people's... I hate Taylor Swift and the threat against Kamala Harris and Joe Biden. It's repulsive. You cannot... you need to stand the fuck down. I don't think you will because you're both toddlers, but it's dangerous. It's actually dangerous. We can make as many memes as we want about this thing, but it's not funny. You're not funny. You're only funny to the people you pay, and they don't think you're funny, really. And they have to laugh. They're forced to laugh. So that's my fail.
Scott Galloway
Nice.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I wanted... I was really excited about Richard Gadd. If I think about all the artists who have really changed the world or I admire, they're just sort of fearless and they do something they could easily be mocked and they show a level of vulnerability and courage where it's like, okay, no one ever thought of that. And this guy Richard Gadd, I thought his performance, because his autobiographical show was just so raw and so... I just thought it was so powerful. I couldn't... anyway, I'm really happy for him. And also I believe his counterpart, the woman who plays the stalker, I believe she also won. And Hiroyuki Sanada won for *Shogun*. By the way, *Shogun* record 18 Emmy wins, just so you know.
Scott Galloway
Oh, it did. I didn't know that.
Kara Swisher
But what people... we talk, we should post a lot about how stupid the union is, or I do, or how these companies are becoming a shadow of themselves and consolidating because Netflix is running away with it. But what we don't mention enough is that the biggest winner here are the consumers, because the quality and depth of original scripted television right now is just insane. It's just incredible because they're all in a content war and they're all basically putting each other out of business, quite frankly, with the exception of Netflix.
Scott Galloway
Anyways, I'm like you. This is a weird one, but I wanted to share it because I thought it was interesting. There's this wonderful TikTok or Reel of this woman who has alopecia and she's talking about going out with a wig on for the first time. She does a 30-second video showing her hair loss. And she's very emotional. And she's saying that this is the first time in a decade I've gone out without a wig to run errands. And I'm not going to let alopecia change my life. It's really a wonderful, very gripping TikTok. Or I can't remember if it was TikTok or Reel. And I remember thinking, I was looking at this woman. She had this most beautiful skin, a great smile. And it's like, yeah, people are going to look at her and think, oh, okay, she has hair loss. But then they really look at the whole thing and they think she's an attractive woman who looks nice. She had the great nails. And what I would say... I so related to this because I remember when I was a young man when I started losing my hair and it was like five years of just ridiculous stress. Because for me it meant my manhood, my youth. My hair was something I took a lot of pride in. I had a ponytail.
Kara Swisher
You had spectacular hair. I was amazed by those photos.
Scott Galloway
I did. And when you start losing it for a lot of reasons, it's just devastating. And like so many things, what I realize now and what I would want to try and communicate to people, especially young men and also especially young women, a lot of whom experience hair loss but they have to wear wigs because it's unforgivable for a woman to lose her hair in the eyes of a very lookist America... I can promise you the thing you're going to regret is how upset you were about it. And that people, when they look at you, they look at the whole thing. You can be in shape. You can take great care of your skin.
You can dress interestingly. People look at the entire thing. And anything to do with my looks or insecurity, my acne when I was younger, my hair loss when I was a little bit older, the thing I really regret about it is how upset I was. I don't regret the acne. I mean, I would rather not have had it. I don't regret the hair loss. Yeah, I would rather have George Clooney-like hair. But what I regret is how upset I was. And I wanted to reach into TikTok and tell this woman, let me be clear, guys look at you and they think, oh, there's a nice woman that I would like to know or date. Yeah, you have hair loss, but that's it.
They look at the whole package.
Kara Swisher
Hair is a lot of power. It does, but let me just tell you, I think you look very good without hair.
Scott Galloway
I appreciate that. You're very complimentary.
Kara Swisher
I think you look very stately. Patrick Stewart... think about all the people who look fantastic.
Scott Galloway
I so look like that alien from *Close Encounters*. I look so like that guy.
Kara Swisher
Whatever. I think you look great. I think you look great. And go ahead.
Scott Galloway
I have hair transplant in the form of money. I have long flowing locks.
Kara Swisher
Scott, that birthday just showed that's not why people like you.
Scott Galloway
Go ahead. You're being generous. But what I want... it's impossible to communicate this to people. You can tell them until you're blue in the face. But anyone who's struggling with something about their aesthetics, that's not what you're going to regret. You're going to regret how much you beat yourself up over it. And there's so many different ways to be attractive. Unfortunately, there's more ways for a man to be attractive. If a man is funny, does well professionally, it is interesting. Unfortunately, women are mostly evaluated based on their aesthetics. But there's so many different ways to express aesthetics. It was this TikTok really moved me. And I thought I can totally relate to this woman.
Kara Swisher
Okay.
Scott Galloway
All right. Well, we will watch this. I guess I did two wins. Baby Reindeer and *Shogun* and this young woman's courage. And I wanted to wrap my arms around her and go, trust me on this. People look at you and think you're an attractive woman and I'd like to know you or I'd like to date you. And that's all you got to be focused on. That's it.
Kara Swisher
All right. It's so interesting what affects you, Scott Galloway. I have to tell you, you're always a surprise to me. By the way, I forgot one win and fail: you're cheating on me with Jessica Tarlov, and I love it. See, that's a win and a fail.
Scott Galloway
That's generous of you. You're being very supportive. I think people are... I mean, I know people are tuning in for her, but...
Kara Swisher
Yeah, we talked about it last week, but it's done very well. People seem to like it. So tune in. Tune in, *Raging Moderates*. We're raging. We want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business, tech, or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to send a question for the show, or call 855-51-PIVOT. Okay, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Tuesday with more *Pivot*. Please read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show is produced by Lara Naiman, Zoe Marcus, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie and her Todd engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Mils Severio. Nishat Kerouaz, Vox Media's executive producer of audio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to *Pivot* from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Young people, if there's something about your physical appearance that's making you insecure, that keeps you up at night, trust me on this: you're going to look back and the only thing you're going to be upset about is how upset you were. Figure out a way, and there's a million different ways to be attractive to others and, most importantly, attractive to yourself.