Main Topic: The episode covers various topics, including the advertising industry, social media, and politics. The main topic appears to be the intersection of technology, business, and society.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Scott Galloway
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24-7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Cara Swisher in France.
Scott Galloway
Wow. I'm Scott Galloway in Laguna Niguel.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I'm in the South. I'm in the Riviera, Scott.
Scott Galloway
You're the Cote d'Azur.
Kara Swisher
Whatever. I don't know. Whatever. Here I am with the French people.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah.
Kara Swisher
I am at Cannes Lions, which is the big advertising thing, which I wish you were here. I have to tell you. I wish you were here because we are very popular among the advertising, global advertising set. Very popular.
Scott Galloway
Is this the part of the show where you talk about how much people love us?
Kara Swisher
They do. It's really interesting. Je me carie, Scott. Wait. No, it's not all French people. It's all Americans. They really like the dating show, which was earlier this week. A lot of people told me they listened to it with their spouse and it makes them happy. And they all wish you were here. That is what they all wish. They wish you were here.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Where's Scott? This is actually, it's interesting that you're here. It's the first year I think I have not gone in about six years. I absolutely love it, basically kind of an extended last meal for the advertising industry. Think I'll be invited back next year? What do you think?
Kara Swisher
I don't know. They want you here. In any case, one of the interesting things is it's really packed. It's crazy packed. I was at this lunch today. It was on this island, and people lost their frigging minds. They were, of course, dancing to some of the songs from Mamma Mia while drinking rosé and throwing their napkins up. Apparently, that's a thing here. And it's astonishing how vibrant it is. Not just Google. Google has a beach. Meta has Meta Beach. There's Twitter Beach, by the way. Spotify Beach had Dua Lipa last night, and they have Post Malone tonight. And they had Kendrick Lamar. Last night I went to something with Sam Smith.
Let me just rewind a bit. So Cannes Lions used to be a very significant event because it was where all executives went to collect trophies and then find another better job. It was the ultimate networking event. And recognizing who does the best job of selling light beer or a Korean car.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. But it's in a beautiful part of the world. Everyone's very usually optimistic. It's a wonderful get-together. And I've always had a nice time there.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, a lot of yacht people rent yachts. Axios had a yacht. We need a yacht. That's what I was thinking.
Scott Galloway
Wait, hold on. Axios has a yacht?
Kara Swisher
They have a yacht. Like, not a big yacht, but they have a yacht. All these different people have yachts. That's ridiculous.
Scott Galloway
One of the things that's interesting, we were driving past all these yachts, and I kept going small dick energy, small dick energy, small dick energy.
Kara Swisher
There you go. And a lot of really interesting things. I've done some panels and things like that. A lot of people feel that at this point now, maybe Google and Facebook will lose their grip on the ad business.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, wouldn't that be nice?
Kara Swisher
I'm just telling you.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I love it there. Another bottle of rosé and also some meth, please.
Kara Swisher
Yes.
Scott Galloway
Hey, hey, rosé. What other hallucinations do you have on the menu?
Kara Swisher
I am having a lovely time. Very smart people. And they love a lot of selfies on La Croissette. Anyway, great time. They're very excited. And they're drinking a lot of rosé. In any case, I wish you were here.
Scott Galloway
Thank you. Thanks for saying that.
Kara Swisher
So we have a lot of things to talk about. And you know who else is here? TikTok has a big activation here. They say it's not sending user data to China, denying it, even as new report says otherwise. Also, Twitter's board gives Elon Musk the go-ahead. Of course they do. They want that price. They want that $54 price, even as the stock price stays low as ever. And also we'll speak to MSNBC's Katy Tur about her new memoir, which is a surprise. I read it on the plane here, and it was wonderful. And it's not what you think it's about. It's really interesting. We'll talk to her about that. And it has a tech angle too, which is interesting.
But first, Medicare could have saved $3.6 billion if it bought its drugs from Mark Cuban's pharmacy, Cost Plus Drugs, according to a study by Harvard Medical School researchers. You've talked to Mark about this. I've talked to Mark about this. Cuban's pharmacy buys meds directly from manufacturers, unlike Medicare. Researchers found jarring price differences, such as a 90-day supply of acid reflux treatment costing $160 for Medicare versus $17 through Cost Plus Drugs. Mark is really trying to push this through. What do you think about that?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I think it's really exciting. You wonder just how the system became so inefficient. It's supply chain. You wonder if there's corruption or monopoly power involved here. But it felt like this was written, and it wasn't, by Mark Stern, because it's basically just this giant — it's unusual for a medical journal to do a comparison and say, "If you'd used this private company, you would have saved this many billions of dollars." But look, anything disruption — if someone had read me this and said, "What company is disrupting?" I would have bet anything it wasn't a startup from Mark Cuban. I would have bet that it was Amazon. So I think it's impressive and obviously testament to Mark's vision and entrepreneurial skills that he's been able to get so much traction and so much visibility so quickly.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I think it's really interesting. You've interviewed him, but it's an interesting pivot for him because he thought about politics. He's been involved in all kinds of other things. It's the only thing he wants to talk about now. What's really interesting is you come to Europe, speaking of Europe, and everything's much lower. You go to Asia, everything is much lower. As you know, I got really sick when I was in Asia once. The bill for a very significant illness was $8,000 total. It was crazy low for all the things they did. They apologized for that bill. And I was hospitalized for two weeks.
Scott Galloway
It was interesting. So when I was researching my book, The Algebra of Happiness, trying to understand happiness as it relates to societies, the happiest societies — seven of the ten happiest countries are in northern Europe. And happiness is not only a function of what you have in your relationships. The number one thing is deep and meaningful relationships, but also an absence of fear of something being taken from you. Or an absence of fear of something terrible happening creates happiness. And what the Northern Europeans have, or an absence of, that unfortunately we have, is that if you find out your wife in America has lung cancer, there's probably a one in three chance you've also found out you're going bankrupt. It's the number one medical cause of bankruptcy filings. And not only that, for the first time in a while, I'm having some interface with our medical industrial complex. It is just so — let me use an academic term — it is just so ridiculously fucked up and overpriced and expensive and inefficient. And I don't know if it's regulation. I don't know who's making money here, who isn't. But it just feels as if — and I don't have any proposed solutions.
Kara Swisher
Are you getting your annual tummy tuck or are you okay?
Scott Galloway
I could use a little tuck. I could use it. I'm getting my third penile enlargement. The third one's going to do the trick.
Kara Swisher
Okay. From now on, I want you to call me Tripod.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no. Oh, my God.
Kara Swisher
Our last show, people were laughing with man gravy and the threesome sandwich. Anyway, this is interesting for Mark. Let's try to have him on and talk about it in a little bit. Obviously, pay too much. This is a big topic for so many people. And politicians should really respond to this in a much different way. I know they've tried, but whatever.
Anyway, the Obamas' production company, Higher Ground, has signed an exclusive multi-year deal with Amazon's Audible. They left Spotify, which has a concert going up by Spotify here. This comes after the end of their deal with Spotify. They've been in place since 2019 amid much jubilation. During the deal, Higher Ground staff pitched dozens of show ideas, but Spotify produced only a handful. Spotify declined to renew the deal. I heard from Obama's side that they weren't happy with it. A lot of rah-rah kind of stuff. So now Amazon's picking them up.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, so this is pure speculation, but when I saw this, in the go-go days of hedge funds in 2006, 2007, I was advising hedge funds on their tech and media investments. And the head of one of the hedge funds that I was close to said, "Could you put together an advisory board for our fund?" And I'm like, "Well, what are you looking for? Are you looking for domain expertise? Are you looking for connections?" He's like, "Well, we're just looking for visibility and credibility." And I said, "Okay, there's one name that's at the top of this list." And he had just left office, and I thought this is the right time to ask him to be an advisor for a fund like this.
So I ended up meeting with Prime Minister Tony Blair several times, negotiating a deal for him to become the advisor. And I think the initial ask on behalf of his representatives — I assume a confidentiality agreement expires after a decade — was around $10 million. And we ended up somewhere, I think, at around $3 million. And he was great. He's incredibly charming. He's incredibly smart, but he didn't want to ever introduce us to capital. He thought that would be a conflict of interest. Everything was kind of screened in terms of what he would participate in. And then after about 12 months, which goes really fast, and you decide, "Do we want to pony up another quarter of a million dollars a month?"
We decided, "You know what? He's wonderful. He's a super interesting man. We've enjoyed the partnership, but we're not renewing." And Cara?
Kara Swisher
Pricey show pony.
Scott Galloway
That's right, Kara. I think that's what happened here. And I don't know this. I think everybody thought, "Wouldn't it be great to have Michelle Obama do a podcast about women empowerment and to have Obama roaming around the hallways and maybe even introduce our lineup at our spring?" And the reality is these people are notably and understandably very prudish about what they'll be involved in and what they won't be.
Kara Swisher
Although, come on. Everyone's getting all those polls that are going to pay out. I think it's untoward. All of these deals from way back are bothersome to me. I find it slight. I don't mind people making money.
Scott Galloway
Well, okay, let me put it this way. This is show pony land. There's no way they didn't get tens of millions of dollars. And the next question is, do you think it's been worth it for Spotify? That's what it comes down to.
Kara Swisher
No, they need an Obama podcast. They needed something real big that makes a lot of money. My guess is he doesn't want to do that. My guess is he sees himself above doing what we do twice a week. And so at the end of the year, it's just a vehicle for other things. Look, I might be entirely wrong. Amazon might have called and there might have been a bidding war. What I think happened was they just said, "You're great. You're so expensive that we're willing to let you move on." I bet when the story comes out, and eventually it will, someone will leak or go on background. I think they're going to find out they were getting paid tens of millions of dollars. And it was a lot of fun to have them around. It was super impressive. And they weren't producing that much revenue.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. That's probably it.
Kara Swisher
You know, Jeff Bezos donated $100 million to the Obama Foundation last year. There's also these presidential foundations. I'm hoping they create something interesting. They certainly can attract talent to them. It doesn't mean they will. That's the thing — little scrappers like ourselves. You wouldn't find Obama dancing with a napkin to Mamma Mia amid the advertisers, for example, like myself, which I didn't do either. But nonetheless, it's interesting. We'll see where these high-profile celebrity deals go with these things. I think they're just a lot of money for a lot of nothing, unfortunately.
Scott Galloway
Well, I was just going to say, it's an interesting topic, what presidents do post-presidency. And Obama and the first lady are so impressive and so young and so attractive on a lot of levels. Their problem was not what to do, it was what not to do. And I think they've suffered from a little bit of paralysis the last five and a half years. I don't think they've done a hell of a lot. And more power to them. They all do books, which is kind of — their books were hits. I think Obama's — I think her book was a big hit.
Kara Swisher
Right. Those are sort of the go-to kind of thing. It is interesting because even — I don't keep compared to here, but there's a lot of celebrities here. There's a lot of different things. Ryan Reynolds was here. Snapchat did an incredibly creative thing on La Croixette with Vogue and all these fashion designers, which I thought was pretty wonderful. I met a couple of them. But they've got to have an ROI, as they say, somehow, in some way, rather than just, "I hung out with President Obama, had a beer."
Scott Galloway
Well, okay. You want to know who's next, right?
Kara Swisher
Who?
Scott Galloway
Netflix is going to announce that after a wonderful partnership, they are parting ways with Meghan and Harry.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, maybe. What the fuck have they done?
Scott Galloway
Yeah. A whole lot of nothing. These high-profile, big-burst celebrity things. They've cut them back. They've cut them back, as you know, the animated series, if you remember, we talked about it. You're just going to see a lot of people decide to give up these kind of high-profile celebrity feel-good partnerships because all of a sudden, shit's gotten real in the market. And there isn't any way to get around it. Everyone is looking at their numbers in a much harder way for the first time.
Kara Swisher
Gotta sign workhorses like ourselves. We're workhorses. You know that. We pitch that. We shovel those ads. We do. In any case, it's an interesting time.
Lastly, interesting story. I don't want you to have any thoughts on this, but I thought you might. Kellogg's is splitting into three independent public companies separated by its cereal, snacking, and plant-based brands. Shares rose by 8% in pre-market trading. They closed just a little bit up, but 80% of its net sales came from the snack division. CEO Steve Cahillane said he's exploring a potential sale of the plant-based businesses. Nonetheless, why are they doing this?
Scott Galloway
It's too big. They don't make any sense together. These conglomerates — there's a lot of them here, too. Unilever, those kind of people. I love this. And of course, the CEO said that this would give each business a chance to focus on realizing their full potential. This is exactly what happened here. A forward-looking investment banker or the CFO said, "Okay, all our peers are up 20 to 30% over the last 36 months. We're up eight. The NASDAQ, the S&P, even with these drawdowns, are up 20 to 30%. We are an underperformer. We are an enormous Battle Creek Michigan dinner bell. And if we don't do something, somebody like Nelson Peltz or Ackman is going to come in here and do what we need to do ourselves."
So what they're doing is they're breaking themselves up because what companies do when they're out of ideas is they start acquiring firms or doing stupid things. And actually, maybe that's not even fair here, but what you have here is a low growth slash declining business, Cereals, that probably still produces a ton of cash flow. Kellogg's Frosted Flakes — the most expensive thing about Frosted Flakes is the box. And they still get three bucks for it to families who are stuck in the 50s. But the business is declining, but it spins off a ton of cash. Then you have the snacks business, which is not only growing, but it's big.
It's growing high single digits. That's an amazing business. And then you have their cool, growthy Tesla, the one that got the crazy valuation, Impossible Foods. So they're smart to split all three of them up.
Kara Swisher
Can I give you some of their brands? I just looked it up. Obviously, Special K. Eggo. Pringles. Cheez-It. Cheez-It are quite good. Cars, Table Water. Mini Wheats, Frosted Rice Krispies. Garden Burger, they bought. That's one of their things. Froot Loops, Corn Flakes, Coco Pops, Corn Pops, all those. Anything if you're looking to consistently and crisply take 10 years off your life.
Scott Galloway
Cocoa Pops are not good for you? What?
Kara Swisher
The plant-based thing is called Morningstar Farms. Not Impossible, by the way. But they do have Garden Burger, which are pretty good. But they also have some healthy stuff. And also, snacking is an enormous trend in America. Younger people are replacing at least one meal a day with snacks.
Scott Galloway
It's a well-run company. They've always been great brand managers. So what happens in a conglomerate when you end up with a bunch of different divisions is the market looks at the shittiest business and assigns that multiple to the entire business. So if you're a newspaper business like New York Times and you own the seventh-tallest building in America, it doesn't get valued as real estate. It gets valued as a newspaper company, which was trading at four to five times EBITDA. So what the market was doing here is it looks at Kellogg's and says, "Okay, Kellogg's is cereal. Cereal is a shitty declining business. So it gets X multiple." So the disposition or the spin of assets is accretive for shareholders. This is a really smart move.
Kara Swisher
So Pop-Tarts get screwed. I love strawberry Pop-Tarts, but I don't eat them anymore. Nonetheless, they have Eggos too. I'm saying the Swisher children eat quite a few of these every now and then. They definitely eat Froot Loops. Hello. They love Froot Loops. Froot Loops. I really like them. It's disgusting. They're disgusting. Anyhow, we'll see what happens with Kellogg's. I think they'll probably get sold off those pieces, but just me.
Scott Galloway
It's too small. They'll take the plant one public and hope for a crazy valuation.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, something like that. We'll see.
Okay, let's get to our first big story. It's about TikTok and China. In leaked audio from internal TikTok meetings, employees indicate that engineers in China have access to the data of American users. That's according to a report in BuzzFeed News. TikTok previously said that U.S. user data stays in the U.S., and last year a TikTok executive told Congress the company doesn't share data with the Chinese government. Shortly before the article came out, the company announced that U.S. user data would be handled by Oracle, which is interesting — one of the people that were vying to own TikTok in that weird VIG deal that Trump was proposing.
And the author of this thing also used to work for Facebook, which is interesting. In 2019, Amnesty International said that Facebook and Google's user data posed a "systematic risk to human rights." There's a big move. Actually, this is one of the topics. I talked to the CEO of Trade Desk about this open internet where you can really track this stuff much more, and they're getting rid of these black box algorithms, especially for publishers and advertisers. In any case, why is that important, do you think? If TikTok keeps American data on American soil, you still have an issue where they can influence what content the algorithm surfaces.
I'm not sure how powerful that is. So what is the power here from your perspective? Name, date, location, viewing history. They can buy all that stuff on the open market. So what do you think the power of this is and why it's important?
Scott Galloway
Oh, it's not identity. It's not names. It's not Social Security. It's not hacking. It's very simple and it's a huge threat. And that is, I think people under the age of 15 or 18 in the U.S. are now spending upwards of 60 to 90 minutes a day on TikTok. As you noted with your kid, yeah. And it's very simple. It's a few small, discrete tweaks to the algorithm that says content by thoughtful people, even Americans talking about the issues and the externalities of capitalism and how maybe we're a little bit hypocritical or we've lost some moral authority or how capitalism isn't working for the working class, how our government is bought and paid for — let's just put a thumb on the scale of that content in terms of small tweaks to the algorithm. And you have what is potentially one of the most dangerous, damaging weapons in the history of mankind.
Kara Swisher
For propaganda. A hundred percent. But if you think about it, the vast majority of Americans don't have a passport. And the same is true of other people around the world. So when our impression — why we go to war — is a function of perception and brand. Propaganda. We declare wars on nations all the time. We've never been there, never met these people. By the way, Ukraine has done a great job of that in terms of propaganda. Or they can just say, "Play a bunch of videos by thoughtful people who claim that January 6th was just a dust-up." Just favor those people saying, "Well, it really wasn't that big a deal."
Scott Galloway
I realize I'm being really boomerish here, but first off, as it relates to this specific complaint, it's kind of a bullshit complaint because that's like saying, "Oh, Google has access to Chinese information if a Google engineer saw data from Google China." But as has happened, China has kicked all these companies out because they realized the danger. And the danger to China, it's the same danger to America. And that is propaganda has become the nuclear threat. It's a question of how you solve for that. I just don't — how you solve for it is going to be a very interesting thing. And this idea of Oracle keeping the sign — there's very few companies who can do this. Microsoft and Oracle were the two companies at the time. "We're the only two capable of doing things like that." But it's very difficult. And the Chinese government doesn't necessarily want that to happen.
Kara Swisher
Well, how are you? But let's try and answer that question. I think there's so much money on it. And I know this is what TikTok is. They should spin the American division of TikTok. And they should basically invite — be very transparent and say, "We are absolutely red, white, and blue, up and down."
Scott Galloway
Well, I think I talked to a lot of people who are experts. This stuff has been built and the software has been made. It's almost impossible to redo. They'd have to build it from the ground up. That's what everyone from Microsoft and Oracle told me — that the people who created it and who created the software, there's just too much there to understand why certain things are there or what they're doing with them.
Kara Swisher
One big thing is no matter how you slice it, everybody has all this information on you across the world. Your movements and everything else are being tracked by all these massive stores. And then they bid on them and things like that. The US government collects enormous amounts of data on you. And I think Google, less than Facebook, is being really disingenuous saying they're scared. Mark Zuckerberg raised this with me eight years ago, and he was scared about the competition, not national security. And they aren't exactly stewards of privacy. In 2018, Facebook announced that malicious actors obtained data of two billion users. So the data isn't as important.
Scott Galloway
You're right. It is something else. It's the tonality of the thing.
Kara Swisher
And the U.S. government, of course, collects so much data on people. As you said, are they undercounting their influence? I suspect they are. You have talked about that.
Scott Galloway
I think TikTok is the most ascendant tech company in the world. And I think it's the only tech company in the world that sandbags their numbers. Everyone else lies, uses accounting tricks, invented metrics to try and turn chicken shit into chicken salad. I think they've been downplaying their numbers. And going back to this notion of a threat, there was some research done on TikTok. And it's the same confirmation bias that exists across all social media. But when young women went on, they had fake accounts with young women talking about how depressed they were. Within 45 minutes, they were being served just a ton of content around depression that was not helpful. Other people talking about how depressed they were, why they should be depressed, why it's understandable that they're depressed. Nothing around remedies, nothing around how to get out of it.
Kara Swisher
Although many people say TikTok is quicker to take action. I think that's true.
Scott Galloway
But as long as this problem exists, here's the thing. All social media, or almost all social media, has shown no regard for the commonwealth or for our children's mental well-being. The majority of them, or really all of them, have done it under the auspices of a private motive. They're not malicious actors. I don't think the people at Facebook wake up in the morning and say, "I want more young girls to be admitted to the hospital for self-cutting today." No. I don't think they're like that. What they do is they kind of ignore the research and the signs because they're making so much bank, similar to what the cigarette companies did.
Kara Swisher
That was disingenuous. They lied. But go ahead.
Scott Galloway
They knew. It's sort of like Trump in this hearing. They knew it was illegal and they did it anyway. But the cigarette companies knew it was a problem and did it anyway. And I suspect a lot of these companies either aren't looking closely enough, but they have some awareness of the problems, whatever they happen to be. And they're very different depending on what they're doing. And so ignoring the data is what they do.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. But back to TikTok.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. TikTok might have an additional menacing incentive here. And that is you might have the CCP saying, "The quickest, most efficient way to undermine American society is to make young people just feel really bad about capitalism and democracy. And we can do that really easily because guess what? They're listening to us in their ears 90 minutes a day."
Kara Swisher
Yeah, or their entertainment. Although, we watch any movie. There's so much propaganda coming at people on all sides now. It's really hard to understand.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but there's a diversity of it. It's fairly transparent. But TikTok — I think you're going to have — look at it this way. I believe TikTok, other than school and maybe a kid's friends, is going to be the most influential thing in a young man or woman's or a boy or girl's life. At this moment, it certainly is one of them. Are we comfortable with the notion that the CCP might have some influence over your kids' views of the world?
Kara Swisher
And we're not talking about a cartoon or a show or media, because we're talking about 90 minutes a day. Yeah. So I think it's a real issue.
Scott Galloway
All right. Well, we'll be talking about it more. In any case, it's going to be interesting what happens to that company if they continue to stay as creative as they are, by the way. They're very creative also.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. And when we come back, Twitter's board gives Elon Musk a green light. And we'll speak with friend of Pivot Katie Tur about cable news, Trump and her new memoir.
BREAK
Scott, we're back. Twitter's board is all in for the sale to Elon Musk. The board unanimously voted to recommend the shareholders approve Elon's offer of $44 billion. Of course they would. Musk said this week there are still a few unresolved matters in the deal. He cited shareholder approval, which has to happen. Questions about bots still and whether the debt portion of the deal will come together. Oh, no, I might not have enough money, I guess.
Scott Galloway
This could be summarized very easily. Boss, you broke it. You bought it. He has been shitposting. He has been distracting them. He has been violating all their agreements. Fine. You want to fuck with us like you own us? Guess what? You got to pay for it. I met a prostitute. I fucked you every which way but loose. Now the prostitute wants their money. Pay me. Pay me. Your thoughts.
Kara Swisher
A prostitute. What can I say? They want the money. It's a great deal. It's a big spread there. So he's going to have to pay it. That's really it. Of course, they're going to do everything to say you're buying this puppy right here. I think you broke it. I would bet that the last couple of board meetings of Twitter have been the most enjoyable they've had in a long time.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, a lot of lawyers in there doing nothing but saying, "How can we back this bitch into a corner and make life really, really uncomfortable?" They know exactly what's going on here.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they're doing a good job here. Also, the Qatari minister was supportive of it. Anyway, go ahead.
Scott Galloway
They're all going to be in six months or less in a Delaware court and they want to see this guy squirm. Team Musk and Team Twitter now are entirely performative around making their case to a Delaware court judge. He owes us $45 billion. No, I should be able to exit this deal with no breakup fee. This is a courtroom drama playing out right now.
Kara Swisher
The people of Twitter that I've talked to recently are very jolly. They were agonized, but now they're jolly. It's interesting. Also, Musk can't say much. He posted a thing where he showed the Hulk, Elon on Twitter, and Elon in real life, which was Bruce Banner and the Hulk. Because what would a narcissist do? So narcissistic. One of the sad stories that came out this week, one of his children, he has two 18-year-old twins, filed to legally change her name to Vivian Jenna Wilson. Vivian says she wants no association with her father or his name. It puts into interesting new light some of his tweets. A couple years ago, I absolutely support trans, but all these pronouns are an aesthetic nightmare. I don't, can you say more?
Scott Galloway
I don't know what you're talking about.
Kara Swisher
He was tweeting some really stupid things. I've known him as a supporter of gay and trans. I talked about it with him extensively on the phone at one point, when he then started tweeting stupid things. Like, "I don't like to say they, them." Like a 12-year-old got a hold of the keyboard. I was like, "Why did you just tweet that?" It was weird. So I don't know if it's anything related. It's just a sad situation when your child says they don't want your name. And there's obviously some trauma there. So I try not to talk about people's personal lives, but I didn't love his tweets.
Scott Galloway
You're right on both counts. I generally believe that President Trump and Elon Musk and a variety of other people would rather say outrageous things, maybe they believe them, maybe they don't, knowing they'll offend people just so they have attention. It's just like my 11-year-old. A few weeks ago, I had this wonderful moment with him. We were talking about when my mom and my dad met, and he smiled. I was about to turn the lights out, and he ran into his brother's bedroom, hit him in the mouth, and screamed, "No one likes you," and then ran out for no real reason. My 11-year-old regularly decides, "I must have the entire household's attention regardless of how I get it." I feel this is what Elon Musk goes through every 30 seconds. It's really... I don't know if it's psychopathic or what the term is, but this stuff makes no sense. He's a smart guy. He knows this stuff is not right.
Kara Swisher
In any case, let's not talk about it. I don't want to talk about that. It got a lot of attention. I agree with you. I think that's off limits. He should stop tweeting stupid things about trans people. It would be really nice if he would cut the shit. He can make as many stupid meme jokes as he wants. But these are kind of really hurtful. Anyway, let's bring in our friend of Pivot, Katie Tur. She is an anchor at MSNBC's *Katie Tur Reports* and the author of *Rough Draft*, a memoir in which she traces her career from its beginnings, watching car chases from her parents' news helicopter, to reporting on the 2016 Trump campaign. There's probably a chapter or two about Phish shows, one of Katie's favorite bands. Hi, Katie. How you doing? Welcome to Pivot.
Katy Tur
Thank you for coming on.
Kara Swisher
Let me just say, I read this on the plane here and I did not expect it. I hadn't opened it. I didn't read about it. It's not your... You were the first member, unbelievable, in 2017, which really focused on Trump, the situation with you and President Trump when he was certainly rude to you. But this is about your dad, who is, speaking of trans issues, a woman now, correct?
Katy Tur
Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. It's partially about my dad. It's about my childhood, the way I was raised, news family, and how it informs everything I do now and how it informs the business in general, because they did some pretty revolutionary things.
Kara Swisher
Talk about what they did, because they're very well-known, your parents. They sort of pioneered this era of live video in the moment.
Katy Tur
My parents were helicopter news journalists. They pioneered the form. They weren't the first helicopter up in the skies, but they were the one that made it useful to a TV news audience. They covered, if not the first, the very second live police chase in real time. The station broke into daytime programming. It broke into *Matlock* and the chase beat *Matlock*. The station said, "Oh, wait, this is good for us. People will watch. Let's put this on whenever we can." So they started putting on police chases all the time in LA. You can thank my parents for that or blame them. They also covered OJ. They found him first on the slow speed pursuit. They covered the LA riots and most notably the Reginald Denny beating, the guy that got pulled out of the red truck and beaten within an inch of his life. Malibu fires, Madonna giving the camera the finger.
Kara Swisher
That was your mom's camera, right?
Katy Tur
It was my dad's camera at the time. That was not my mom in the helicopter.
Kara Swisher
One of the things that's interesting is you talked about the tragedy of technology and what happened here. Your dad did a stream of consciousness kind of reporting as he looked, right? He wasn't just saying, "Oh, look, there's a crash on the 405."
Katy Tur
No. My dad was better than everybody else for two reasons. He was a good storyteller and he could tell the story of what was unfolding. I'm using "he" in the past because my memories of my childhood are of my dad a certain way. My dad, after 2013, when she came out to me as a transgender woman, I use "she." So I hope you understand how I'm using the pronouns. Back in the time, he was just better at storytelling and live breaking coverage than anybody. It was because he was a good storyteller, but it was also because he knew the US penal code by heart. He knew every code on the fire or police scanner by heart. He understood what they were saying. So he'd listen to the police scanners and he could tell you what was happening in real time. And because they had a helicopter, they were really good at developing sources within official capacities because, "Hey, you want a helicopter ride? Oh, now we're friends. I'm going to call you for source information." So he just had an inside scoop on a lot of stuff. And my mom, the two of them together knew the city better than anybody. They could draw you a map with their eyes closed of the city from overhead. It was remarkable.
Kara Swisher
So you became a journalist, not a helicopter pilot. What was it about your parents' job that obviously inspired you or played a role in what you decided to do?
Katy Tur
I didn't want to do what they did. My parents' worlds fell apart in 1998. They lost the helicopter and my dad lost his health. My grandmother died. She was a part of the business and very much the glue of the family. It felt like news really tore my existence apart. I wanted no part of it. They would give up everything for a story. I just wanted to be normal. I felt we weren't normal. So I wanted to be a doctor or a lawyer. But I quickly realized I couldn't be a doctor because I failed out of calculus, and I didn't want to be a lawyer because I didn't want to keep going to school. Then one day, I was in college, driving back from Los Angeles to Santa Barbara, and I found myself drawn to a fire in Malibu. I just needed to be in the smoke. I needed to be surrounded by the flames.
Kara Swisher
That was your dad's thing, running into flames, correct?
Katy Tur
It was my dad's thing, exactly. I just wanted to be a part of it. I found that there was nothing in my life that was more adventurous and more exciting and more thrilling than what my parents did. I wanted to see the entire world and this would let me do it.
Kara Swisher
You ran up to the Boston bombing. That's when you got one of your first big breaks. Would you call yourself an adrenaline junkie? And what effect does it have on news, this idea that local news has always been "if it bleeds, it leads"? Do you think it got further in that adrenaline fear kind of thing?
Katy Tur
There's two questions there. Am I an adrenaline junkie? I think to a degree. When I thought about being a doctor, I wanted to be an emergency room doctor. I wanted to be in the middle of the chaos. It's because I grew up in chaos and I feel most comfortable in chaos. I feel most calm. Even now, when there's a breaking story in front of me, say there's a subway shooting like the other day in New York or there's the insurrection, I find myself very calm but also thrilled internally by reporting it in real time. That was partially the Trump campaign as well, reporting in real time the country changing in a really dramatic and sometimes very scary way.
What my parents did and that adrenaline that they chased, while at times they covered important news that was revelatory and necessary, they uncovered stuff that would not have been uncovered had they not been there. They covered the CHP just beating the crap out of a bunch of immigrants on the side of the road. Nobody would have ever known about that had my parents not trained a camera on it. Same thing with the riots. There were other instances which made them an enemy of some local officials in Los Angeles because they felt they were being intrusive, spying on them. But in covering these live police chases, they essentially made TV news at the time into reality TV news.
Watch it. There's no context. It's all happening now, now, now, now. You don't know how this is going to end. Oh my God, is he going to crash into something? And oftentimes it would end in tragedy. It would end with the driver crashing into a bus or the cops shooting the driver to death on live television.
Kara Swisher
It becomes like network. Yeah.
Katy Tur
People were just fascinated by it and they tuned in in droves. The TV news business is a business. In order to do any sort of news gathering, you have to have people watching. You need to sell advertising. You need the money. So it becomes a vicious cycle. Kara, we talk about the way politics is covered today, kind of like a horse race or just put it on the air, we'll figure it out later. I think you could draw a straight line from what my parents did with these police chases to the way we covered Trump in 2015 and 2016, the way we cover things now.
Kara Swisher
There you go. You said something that piqued my interest. What are your observations or what surprised you about your father's relationships after your father began identifying as a woman?
Katy Tur
I don't feel like I'm in a really good position to answer that. The reason is my dad and I are estranged. We had been on track for estrangement before she told me she was a woman. We had a very strained relationship because of some of the things that happened while we were growing up, some of the emotional turmoil, abuse, and some physical abuse that I had been carrying with me. I was running away from all of it. When my dad called me and told me that she was a woman, part of the conversation was that she said, "This is where all the rage comes from and the rage is going to disappear. Bob Tur is dead. I'm now..." At the time it was Hannah, now it's Zoe. I used that as my opening to say, "Okay, great. Let's do that. Let's move forward. I'd love to have a better relationship. I'd love for the rage to be gone." The rage haunted me.
Scott Galloway
No, no, no, no.
Katy Tur
The conversation didn't go well. It ended okay, but it didn't go well. The next one we had really didn't go well. We've tried, we started and stopped a bunch of times over the years, and it just ends the same way with her getting really angry at me. I don't really know how things have changed.
Kara Swisher
Let me shift, speaking of anger, to Trump. When you covered him, you were right in the middle of that, and you were subject to a lot of it. Just this week, the really brave election workers were subject to anger brought on by Trump. You were in the middle of a rage machine covering the Trump campaign. Can you talk a little bit about that and what you see? There's such a bright line between that campaign and what's happening right now in the hearings. This sort of free rage all over the country, including about trans issues. Let's talk about the rage that I saw back then.
Katy Tur
It was very strange for me. I came back from being a foreign correspondent just for a few days to say hi to folks. In the time that I was back, Donald Trump announced he was running for president. Everybody thought it was a joke. But also, the Supreme Court said that same-sex marriage was legal and constitutional. I remember in that moment feeling so filled with pride and joy for our country and being so optimistic about the future. It surprised me how happy I was. Then it felt like that was ripped away from me when I started covering Trump, because all of that joy and happiness and acceptance was nowhere to be found.
While I was covering these rallies, instead it was rage. It was anger. "You're taking something from me. You're doing this to me. I like this guy because he's pushing back against you. You're not on my team. He's on my team." They would take it out on the media. They'd come up and they'd spit at us and give us the finger and yell and call us names. Not everybody, but a good portion. It was shocking to me, and it didn't get better after Donald Trump was president. People seemed to get angrier and angrier. Then it wasn't just Republicans and Trumps who were angry. Everybody got angry. That led to where we are today.
Looking back on these January 6th hearings, all the lies that fueled the violence of that day and the violence that I think is still hanging over us, it's a hard thing to reckon with.
Kara Swisher
CNN's new boss, Chris Licht, says he wants to rein in opinions. Cable gets blamed for this. He says he wants room for nuance. Is there room for nuance, not just in media, but in politics and everything else?
Katy Tur
I think there should be. I think some things are black and white. Some. But I think most stuff has some nuance to it. I do think there's more room for being able to have a conversation. I think there's a desire for that within the country. We talk about cable news. There's a very small portion of the population that watches cable news. There's a very big portion of the population that is out there to be gotten, to be consumed. We have to find a way to convince them. We've done research on this. We know there are a lot of people out there looking for news and analysis that isn't hit-you-over-the-head biased. I'm certainly drawn to that. I don't need to be screaming from the rooftops about this side being evil or that side being evil. I think there's room for it. Is it going to fix our problems? It remains to be seen if we can figure out a way to talk to those people.
Kara Swisher
If you go back to 2014 and we're 20-odd months out from an election where Trump is elected, it feels eerily similar. Is it happening again?
Katy Tur
I don't know. I have a hard time believing that Donald Trump, just knowing his personality, would want to hand over the power of the Republican Party mantle to Ron DeSantis, which is what would happen if he did not run. So I think he's going to run again. I think it'll be different because he won't be on Twitter or Facebook. So it'll just be functionally different. I think we've learned some lessons in the press, but I don't have hopes that it won't be violent.
Kara Swisher
Wow. Well, I think we'll end on that. Your book is very... I was surprised and moved by it at the same time. It felt... not hopeless, but I was so surprised. Not that you're not sunny and bright whenever you're on cable, but it was the difficulties, the way you reflected on the relationship with your dad was also the relationship we all have with everything. It's like we've gone down some hole of some sort.
Katy Tur
I wouldn't say it was hopeless. I think it is just accepting. I write about this: it's everything and it's nothing all at the same time. I'm hopeful that stuff I've been running away from, getting it out there is going to bring me some peace and make me a better mom. It's a good story. I'm proud of a lot of it. I'd like to be able to share it.
Kara Swisher
It's a great book. It's called *Rough Draft*, a memoir. I think you will really enjoy it. It's beautifully written. It's out now. Thank you, Katie Tur.
Katy Tur
Thanks, Kara. Thank you, Scott.
Scott Galloway
Thanks, Katie.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, I recommend you read it. It's a really, really good book. It was so surprising. The stories about the helicopter stuff were astonishing, and the abuse. It was real. It was a real eye opener. Anyway, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
BREAK
Okay, Scott, let's hear some wins and fails. Just so I can alienate the left and the right.
Scott Galloway
My win is I thought that the International Federation for swimming, FINA, handled the situation around transgender athletes well. I think that's a really difficult issue. I think we're having an overdue and wonderful conversation around gender fluidity and the rights that people should be afforded and the grace they should be afforded. But this quickly presented a very unusual situation with women who had gone through puberty as men and were competing against female athletes. I think deciding that you have to transition before puberty, otherwise you have to compete as the gender you were born, was the right call. I think it was a difficult call. They could have sat on their hands. I think they handled themselves well. The majority of these athletic bodies are corrupt. They operate in this nether-netherland where they can just make a shit ton of money and not be subject to any audits. I was impressed with the way they worded this. I liked the release. I thought they showed leadership. My win is FINA and how they handled a difficult issue. Do you have any thoughts on that, Kara?
Kara Swisher
It's interesting. So many people have mentioned it. I don't know why it's become such a huge topic. It seems to envelop people's brains for some reason. I thought they handled it well. I'm of many minds on this stuff because I think transgender people have suffered so much pain and so much abuse by our society, and it's inexplicable. It isn't, but it is. I see why people... It's the same thing with racism. I get it, I see it, but I'm also like, "How can this be at the same time?" I'm not naive. But in this case, I thought they handled it correctly. It's still hard.
Like, if you feel like you're a woman and there's all these arguments about words, I'm just like, stop, just try kindness. Let's try to all figure this out. Kindness has not been tried against this group of people that deserves much more dignity and has been much abused. Society's real punching bag. I think most people, if they are allowed to be decent, can be decent. Maybe that's not right, but it's a difficult one.
Scott Galloway
That's a good one. I think a lot of local school districts too will decide that they want to let their kids, whatever they identify with, play that specific sport. And I think that's up to a complicated issue.
Kara Swisher
My fail is just in case if you were worried that Florida was fresh out of crazy. Once again, we've cemented our role as just batshit crazy. We've decided that we're going to be the only state in the nation not to pre-order or distribute the Pfizer and Moderna mRNA vaccines. And he was obnoxious about it. He was a douche about it. Ron DeSantis, his speech was so obnoxious.
Scott Galloway
But one of the things I love about the GOP ideology is there's a power to people get to decide that we shouldn't infantilize people, that you always want to err on the side of letting people have liberty and have domain over their own decisions. And what he's decided is he's going to make it harder for state-sponsored health clinics and doctors to let parents who decide to vaccinate their kids find a vaccine. That couldn't be more anti-GOP.
Kara Swisher
No, he's so government-sanctioned. He's such a communist.
Scott Galloway
But go ahead, sorry. Yeah, it's so... I'm a former Navy lawyer, and I know better than the CDC, the National Association of Pediatrics, every health commissioner on the planet except for the whack job we have in Florida, because I know better. What's going on here is the same thing that always goes on here and is the reason why I believe we are in such a bad place in our nation. Everything right now is an attempt to get press. And the press is, "Hey, far right voter in Iowa, I am crazier than the next guy." That's become how you win elections. The more bad shit and extreme you can be, that's been conflated with leadership. Because people are so upset and so angry and so polarized now. They want someone who they see as fearless and macho. And the way you demonstrate your fearlessness and your macho is you make these batshit fucking crazy decisions that impact and hurt people on the ground.
Kara Swisher
I think he's just playing for the cameras. But honestly, the whole pack of people around are a bunch of loons and they love government overreach. I don't know how else to put it. Government overreach into people's lives. That's what they become.
I would give – on the other side, there are public officials who really do the right thing. I would point to two, three, actually. Arizona House Speaker Russell "Rusty" Bowers couldn't be more different than me. He did his duty under enormous, enormous difficulty. He walked in and did the right thing. They tried to make him say the election was rigged. He refused to do it. Trump put out a statement asserting that Bowers told me the election was rigged and that I won Arizona. Bowers chuckled at the absurdity. Other officials, Brad Raffensperger, these are all Republican officials, and Gabe Sterling faced similar pressure. And these two election workers, I urge you to watch their testimony. Former Georgia election worker, I think it's Wandrea ArShaye Moss is her name, really resisted. The kind of attacks were just astonishing. The attacks that he and she and all of them got in Georgia were really disturbing. And of course, the clown prince lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, who I hope gets all his licenses revoked, said, "We've got lots of theories. We just don't have evidence." What a terrible person that man has become.
In any case, I find that really shows how thin the defense is for our people that stand up and say this is bullshit. I really appreciate their work. I think that's a powerful testimony. I thought that was really powerful. So did she, and her daughter. These are election workers. What the hell is wrong with you? Honestly. Anyway, very, very moved. I know people don't want to support Republicans who finally came around and told the truth about Trump. These people at the time when it mattered most absolutely did their jobs. I know it's a low bar, but it's the right bar.
Anyway, those were my wins and my fails were the people that attacked them. We're speaking on Wednesday night. Tomorrow probably is Roe versus Wade. It'll probably somehow be destroyed by the Supreme Court. That's obviously a fail. This idea of government not letting people do the things they want to do with their own bodies. It's really sad. Taking away people's rights that they've had, I think they're going to rue the day they did it, and we'll see what happens. But it's not a particularly good sign for our democracy for this to happen. So that's on that note. That's probably going to be my fail this week.
Okay, Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Friday for more. Can you read us out? And I'd like you to do it in French, please. I feel as if we need to end on a brighter note.
Scott Galloway
Did you know right outside of Cannes, a huge cheese factory exploded? All that was left, Kara, was a bunch of debris.
Kara Swisher
That's good. That's good cheese humor. That is good French humor. There you go.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie and Jatot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Mille Silverio. Make sure you're subscribed to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thank you for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Kara, have a great time in the South of France.
Kara Swisher
Thank you.