Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including the current state of journalism, the potential ban of TikTok, the rise of AI, and the future of business.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Ad Break
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm Scott Galloway.
Kara Swisher
So where are you now, Scott? Where in the world is Scott Galloway?
Scott Galloway
I'm in the City of Angels. I'm in Los Angeles.
Kara Swisher
Oh, your favorite place, your old stomping ground.
Scott Galloway
My favorite hotel, Beverly Hills Hotel, where I'm very fancy. Yeah. I receive people. People like to come here.
Kara Swisher
Oh, really? Do you have a suite?
Scott Galloway
I have what's called the Michael Jackson suite. Seriously, it has a secret entry and exit way.
Kara Swisher
Why? I wonder why they call it the Michael Jackson suite. Why do you need a secret entrance and exit? I don't understand.
Scott Galloway
Whenever I get here, I'm one of these total douchebags that looks at the fire map. And if I don't have a big room, I call and I start negotiating for a bigger room.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I see. Okay. Yeah.
Scott Galloway
So they put me in the Michael Jackson suite this week. One of those people.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. You know, we're not that far from each other. We're only 350 miles away. I'm in San Francisco.
Scott Galloway
Well, I did feel a little extra warmth this morning here. I should come down there, but I don't have time. But I love Los Angeles.
Kara Swisher
Well, you know I should come down. You know I'm here. Why? You didn't say, Scott, why are you here? No interest in my life.
Scott Galloway
Oh, why are you there? Two words. First Bill, second Maher. Yeah. I don't want to brag, though. I don't want to brag. I won't say I'll be on it in a month, but okay, sure.
Kara Swisher
That's great. That's literally the first thing they said to me, by the way. It's like, "Oh, this is such good news. And finally, we got Kara." I'm like, "Oh, great. I'm good." That's so happy for all of them. You can't be rare, Scott. You can't be chomping at the bit for those Bill Maher people.
Scott Galloway
No, they're very nice staff. I don't agree with Bill all the time, but it's certainly an interesting show.
Kara Swisher
Oh, really? I see. I only respect people I agree with all the time.
Scott Galloway
Oh, okay. All right.
Kara Swisher
But what are you going to talk about?
Scott Galloway
Oh, TikTok.
Kara Swisher
Oh, come on. This is your little time to run around and scream.
Scott Galloway
Oh, no, this is totally my wheelhouse. We're talking about failing young men. We're talking about population decline, good or bad. We're actually doing almost everything but TikTok.
Kara Swisher
Oh, you've got to talk about TikTok.
Scott Galloway
But here's the thing. They send you these topics, and then Bill just starts talking about whatever he wants to talk about.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's usually a grievance about culture wars. That guy's a gangster. I love him. He's good. You've got to admit.
Scott Galloway
I love him. I don't love him. You've got to admit, that show is more culturally relevant than ever. I see clips of him talking about we need to be United States. He really does tap into something. I constantly see his stuff everywhere. And the writers there are amazing. Some people like what he's done. Some people don't. It's good. It's good. Whatever. That means he's saying something, right?
Kara Swisher
Well, maybe. Yeah. I mean, yeah. It's just an interesting time for a show like that. And listen, you go on that long, a lot of people can't. A lot of people have fallen by the wayside and he has and he keeps going.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's further proof that there's both opportunity and an existential threat to the species of people called moderates.
Kara Swisher
I don't think you're a moderate sometimes, but that's okay. We're not going to debate that.
Scott Galloway
What, you think I'm too far left?
Kara Swisher
No, I just think that you bang on that culture war drum a little too long. There are other real issues in this country that are much... this whole woke thing is exhausting.
Scott Galloway
No, I'm all about culture wars. That's a perfect description. No, but the woke thing and you can't say what you want. I would like... just like people on the Republican side.
Kara Swisher
You mean the state of America? No, but it's not. Most regular people are worried about the price of gas. And we're not going to go to this.
Scott Galloway
And you're one with the regular folk.
Kara Swisher
No. No, but I have many more relatives than you do who are. Don't. This climate bill is going to... you're not taking my lawnmower. Yeah, you're very much the regular person.
Scott Galloway
No, no, you're not going to. You're just a down-home lesbian in San Francisco finishing your book. You try to do this whenever I make the point that people banging on about woke is not what people are concerned about.
Kara Swisher
You don't have to be of that group to understand that this is bullshit. This is what you do. You always have to point out I am an elite, which you are even more an elite, when you want to disagree with me. You never make an actual argument. You just have to say, "Oh, you'd know."
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I would know. I can talk to people.
Kara Swisher
I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Let's unpack that. You never make an actual argument. How soon after saying that did you realize that's not true?
Scott Galloway
No, it's not true. You go, "Listen, let me just say," whenever I point out that this woke stuff is exhausting and most people have bigger concerns than that, you always say, "Oh, you're an elite lesbian." That is what you go to every single time. And so I don't really think that's okay. So it makes me unable to hear people or read or understand.
Kara Swisher
Let me actually make an argument, which you accuse me of never doing, that we on the left shoot ourselves in the foot because we wanted the impression that Americans have elected us to be the police for cultural issues. And as a result, we turn off moderates and people with weird, dangerous ideas get elected. So we have adopted a strategy that has not worked.
Scott Galloway
Yes, but I think they have adjusted that over time. And I think the Republicans have gone further right. And you can watch it through everything they're doing around this Trump arrest. It has nothing to do with anything else. I think many on the left have adjusted this. I think many have said, "Yeah, you're right," and stuff like that. I don't think they're doubling down on it, that's for sure, but I do think the Republicans are doubling down on crazy.
Kara Swisher
Okay. I mean, this is something. Look, Biden's moved much closer to the center recently. Obviously, he's got his progressive wing, but he's moved. There's lots of calmness written about this issue. And so that's what happens. I think the woke thing is not nearly as important as the crazy. And that's a problem, but it's not what's happening in states across the country around trans things.
Scott Galloway
Well, one is naive and one is mean. It's beyond mean. It's something else. It's trying to legislate all kinds of things that we shouldn't be legislating.
Kara Swisher
But, you know, like I'm looking at these things. There's a really good piece, and we'll get to what we're actually going to talk about today, but there's a great piece about what's going on in Iowa and the governor there, Kim Reynolds. She is very savvy and is really playing into and passing all kinds of legislation that's really anti-trans, not just anti-trans, it just goes on and on and on. So I think this is actual legislation in action versus telling someone you don't like when you don't use they/them. I don't know. I just find there's a big difference.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but then the question becomes, Kara, how is that happening and how do we best combat it? How do we be more thoughtful? The thing that always shocks me is we're always in a state of outrage over what are justifiably upsetting things. And yet we always seem to figure out a way to let it happen. My attitude is, why are these ridiculous, mean laws that are ineffectual and just inflame people, why do they always seem to get traction? And we seem to get outplayed on the left. How come McConnell's always able to outsmart everybody?
Kara Swisher
Voting. I think voting is one. I think people don't vote. I think people just sit around and don't vote. Now they did in Kansas, right? They did around the abortion thing. And so the numbers, when you look at the numbers, the group that's very much like this, get out and vote. And then the others just don't. And then they're like, "Oh," and then they have to clean it up. And that's the ultimate thing when you look at those numbers. Anyway, we should not argue politically anymore today. I hope you have a great time on Bill Maher.
Scott Galloway
So someone's struggling with their last chapter. That's all I'm going to say.
Kara Swisher
Today, Mr. Chu goes to Washington. TikTok CEO gets an earful on Capitol Hill. Also, Google enters the AI race at last, and we'll take a listener question on getting paid in stock. All right. But first, President Trump is still a free man. It looks like he was incorrect about being arrested on Tuesday. As we tape on Thursday, the grand jury weighing whether or not Trump will be indicted in the Stormy Daniels case was unexpectedly given a day off on Wednesday. As a reminder, Trump told followers he would be arrested on Tuesday and called for protest. There were about five people in front of Trump Tower, by the way. It's going well for him. This weekend, Trump will hold a rally in Waco, Texas, on the 30th anniversary of the siege of the Branch Davidian compound. His lawyer has been ordered to turn over documents in the classified document case. It might be impactful. Apparently, there are tapes. He's just an ongoing, exhausting wart on the ass of society. What do you think?
Scott Galloway
Well, again, a president is supposed to de-escalate. And what happened in Waco is so upsetting. There are probably so many people whose daughter or grandparent perished in that thing. And then you have a guy coming down there to remind you of it for his own political purposes. A very anti-government protest, by the way.
Kara Swisher
But go ahead. What was happening in Waco? It was like this idea of the government coming in and taking our guns. It was a version of that. God, I forgot about just how horrible that was. And that trigger, that feeling of "there's no good from this" are emotions that are part of the fabric that is Donald Trump over and over.
Scott Galloway
Over and over. It is. And it's been ongoing. What happened at Waco has been ongoing.
Kara Swisher
But it brings me back. There were several different events. That was one. The Heaven's Gate cult members. Remember when that was '97? Was that the one with the black Nikes?
Scott Galloway
Yes, the black Nikes and the comet.
Kara Swisher
I remember the comet. I remember looking at the comet and then that happened. Like these are very dark parts of the U.S. psyche. And he keeps poking it and unearthing it over and over again. It doesn't mean we shouldn't look at it and discuss it and everything else. But it's really, just in order to get out of this Stormy Daniels case, which was about a porn star. Right. That's really, it's just the way he pokes at the darkest parts of our psyche is really fucked up on so many levels. We'll see. And of course, they'll probably elect the candidate. They'll probably make him the candidate.
Scott Galloway
I tried to sign up and register for tickets. I figured that's my contribution. You know, you can get tickets online.
Kara Swisher
Oh, really? Yeah. Interesting. Like, you know, we're doing that whole "no one will show up" thing.
Scott Galloway
Oh, yeah. Well, we'll see. The teens, I think, tried that, and it worked in one place. You know, he'll have a group of people that go see him all the time. That's what he's going for is the diehards, and emphasis on die.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, another thing, the markets react to the Fed's latest interest rate hike, matching last month's hike of a quarter point. Fed Chairman Jerome Powell, who is tiptoeing, it sounds like, said the process of getting inflation back down to 2% has a long way to go and is likely to be bumpy. You think, Mr. Powell. The S&P 500 is up 1% since the news and the ongoing bank uncertainty continues with First Republic down 50% in the last five days. The stocks of these banks don't matter, but it's the nervousness of spooking people, I think. So is this the right move? They had to not, they couldn't not do it, correct?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, this was the Goldilocks raise. I thought, okay, you have this banking crisis that in some part was due to a historic increase in interest rates. Interest rates, the Fed funds rate, is the highest it's been since 2007. But we haven't raised rates 475 bps since 1979 within a 12 or 14-month period. So I thought, because of the potential contagion of banking, he's going to tap the brakes and not do a rate hike. But Ed Elson, my analyst at Prop G, said, "Actually, he probably will raise," and he got it exactly right. He said a quarter of a point because Powell doesn't want to spook the markets by giving them the impression he spooked. He still wants to show that, look, folks, inflation is still the monster in the room. And the other one that's in the closet maybe comes out, maybe doesn't, that's not my biggest concern. It was kind of trying to say we're still fighting inflation, but we're also cognizant of what's happening in the banking sector.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's 100 percent. I think your analyst was spot on about that. And we'll see where he goes from here. But inflation is the biggest problem. But banks, inflation is a long-term pain, and a bank run is terrifying to people, I think, in a lot of ways. I mean, there's just some really frightening things here. There are so many people out there, especially younger people, who have taken some action to try and prepare, either buying supplies or thinking about their go route, whatever it might be, preparing for doomsday.
Scott Galloway
Oh, man. And watching *The Last of Us* too much, I guess.
Kara Swisher
That's right. And there's also when the most famous, well-resourced, and quite frankly, the impression most intelligent people in the world are all hardcore, like, go-bag people, it doesn't create a sense. It's like, if these people are worried, shouldn't I be? And it creates, and also their actions. Think about what they do with their professional lives. We need to figure out a way to inhabit another planet. I want to take you into another universe. It's very nihilistic.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah. Well, it's like assuming all hell will break loose. There is that assumption here, 100%.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I think it's frightening and disappointing. Do you have a go-bag plan, Scott? I doubt it.
Scott Galloway
Kara, I think these go-bags and these bunkers will have the same effectiveness as if a nuclear flash goes off and all our kids duck and cover.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. We were told that all we needed to do in case of nuclear attack from those Ruskies was duck and cover as soon as we saw the flash of light and we would be just fine. Guess what? No. You guys duck and see how that works for you.
Scott Galloway
I know. If shit gets really real. Because they're going to find you. I told you what my plan was when they all had their plans. And they're like, "What's your plan?" I said, "I'm going to find you, beat you up, take your things. That's my plan." Like, what do you think my plan is? I'm going to steal your shit. Because I know you'll be well-stocked.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I agree. I think there's no getting out of it. No one's getting out of this life alive. Well, why wouldn't we take all of this money and genius and try and figure out how to make this place more habitable?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, well, just in case, Kara. Just in case. Have those gold doubloons that you put on a belt and carry around. I do like the idea of rough cut gems being stuck up my ass.
Kara Swisher
Let's go. Let's go. No, let's not have it. We should have a place we go. But then we'd be stuck together. It'd be like a Twilight Zone episode. You and I in a bunker. Okay. Would that be... I'm trying to think, would that be 10 minutes or 10 hours before we say, "You know, I really like you, but let's kill each other?"
Scott Galloway
I would kill you. Be dead. Who do you think would win that one?
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. You'd go weeks. I'd be minutes. I would eat you. I would eat you. I'd be like, "That's it." I would yellow jacket this motherfucker. I'm like, "Look, it's been good. If you run into my kids again, tell them I love them. We need to plan what we're going to do with my body."
Scott Galloway
I would immediately start planning. I'm going to cook it for dinner. What are you talking about? No, I'm not getting caught in a bunker with anyone named Kara Swisher. I'm going to yellow jacket the situation.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, last thing, Ford's EV business lost over $2 billion in 2022. Not a surprise. The loss was offset by $10 billion in profits from the automaker's internal combustion and fleet business. It might be just the beginning. The company expects a loss of $3 billion for its EV unit in 2023. They've got to spend the money. I don't know what to say. This is what Elon did with Tesla. You've got to spend the money to get to this new business. It's the way it is. And it is the new business.
Scott Galloway
It's really fascinating. I feel like everything comes back to the streaming wars. Almost every business, how the streaming wars is laid out, if you really understand it, you can kind of predict almost any market where there's an excess of capital or excitement. And there's enormous justified excitement around EVs. The innovator's dilemma kicked in hard here. Similar to how a lot of people didn't take Netflix serious for a long time, all the automakers looked at the actual gross size of the EV market, looked at how expensive it was, looked at the fact that their shareholder base wouldn't tolerate the type of investment required to be competitive in EVs.
All of the things that were present with Netflix versus traditional linear TV. And then finally, they're all of a sudden, this is like Netflix or the streaming market in, I don't know, call it 2017, 18, they're all like, "We have no choice. We've got to go all in here." And just similar to Netflix, anyone, I don't care if you're Disney with an unparalleled library or Hulu, any of these guys, you had to make uncomfortable, staggering, irrational investments. There's just no way, these things are super expensive. They'll get to scale. The exciting thing is there will be a Moore's law here. They will come down.
The government's helping with the Infrastructure Act to bring down prices. But everybody is going all in, and it's super expensive. And the same thing will happen. What's happening in streaming now? Consolidation will probably happen in three to five years. I don't think Tesla will be acquired, it's too big. But some of these guys will have to get rolled up. Polestar, Lucid. This is money well spent. They have to spend this. There's no choice because this is where the market's going. It's where everybody's going. It's where the states are going. They can't pull this back. So this is the loss they need to have.
Kara Swisher
So that's the way it goes. And they should have done it earlier the way Tesla did. He created the manufacturing stack and that's why he's way ahead for now. Okay, let's get to our first big story. TikTok CEO Shou Chu testified before an overwhelmingly hostile House committee on Thursday as his company hopes to fend off a potential U.S. ban of the app. Good show, but it's not going to work. GOP Representative Kathy Morris came out blazing in her opening remarks. Let's listen.
Audio clip plays: "We do not trust TikTok will ever embrace American values. Values for freedom, human rights, and innovation. TikTok has repeatedly chosen the path for more control, more surveillance, and more manipulation. Your platform should be banned. I expect today you'll say anything to avoid this outcome."
Mr. Chu, for his part, largely dodged complicated questions, but fired back with comparisons to American tech giants.
Audio clip plays: "I don't think ownership is the issue here with a lot of respect. American social companies don't have a good track record with data privacy and user security. I mean, look at Facebook and Cambridge Analytica, just one example."
Representatives accused TikTok of being lax with safety and cozy with the Chinese Communist Party, but they occasionally took the opportunity to ask Chu probing questions like, "Does TikTok access the home Wi-Fi network?" Chu also pointed out that his network doesn't accept political ads and claims that it doesn't sell data to brokers, but he didn't rule out doing so in the future. I mean, what do you think here? It was kind of cooked, don't you think, the whole thing?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I mean, the House Energy Committee here, they chose violence, but they chose it before he showed up. We knew this was going to be ugly. I actually found it very cathartic and relaxing to watch this panel because it was the first time I could think of in a long, long time you would see the representative from some very conservative place in Georgia echo the comments of his colleague from a Democrat from Maine. I mean, there is more bipartisan agreement here than on the Russian invasion of Ukraine and how to respond to it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, absolutely. So it's just shocking to me the 180 or how much the narrative here has changed.
Scott Galloway
What did the CCP do today? They came out with the mother of all stupid comments and said, "We will not tolerate or agree to a spin," which by virtue of them saying that says we're in charge of this platform.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So they basically poured honey on this guy and sent him hunting for bears.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I know this guy. I feel bad because he's in the middle of the squeeze here and he's getting squeezed. He's absolutely correct about U.S. companies. Come on. They're not the Chinese Communist Party, but they're really bad. And of course, none of our representatives have ever dealt with that. But when it comes to a Chinese company, they're doing to this company what they should have been doing to all these companies for years. But they aren't. Because it's good to shake the American flag for everybody, which is fine.
Kara Swisher
Look, does the ban look more or less likely after this hearing? What is your take after this?
Scott Galloway
More to me. I'm going to say more. I think you've been right on this. And I'm going to pick up the flag of talking about how awesome we are. When we said seven or eight months ago this thing should be banned, we were called a lot of names. And this thing is absolutely going to be banned. It's already happening. I think we're serving as a beacon. I think you're going to see more Western nations find their backbone around banning this thing. And I do believe that there's so much money here that they will, on the eve of the banning, decide to spin it. We'll see. There are those considerations.
Kara Swisher
It is a... honestly, I still don't think that his appearance with Putin helped matters any. He looks like he's against the U.S. And so it's very easy to do this. It wasn't a good showing. All these people are dying in Ukraine. He looks like an opportunist. And it seems like Senator Warner was like, "Oh, let's get through with the ban. Let's go. Let's stop this nonsense," which, you know, he's usually pretty reasonable. But I mean, if a ban comes, everyone's going to pay a price.
Scott Galloway
It's a great service. My urologist is on TikTok. It's called Dick Doc.
Kara Swisher
That's good.
Scott Galloway
That should be banned. I'll tell you, I have a ban on that crap. Ban on dad jokes. That's pushed them over the edge. A ban is coming.
Kara Swisher
God, that's banned, Scott Galloway. That's my feeling. Anyway, Chu had a unique proposal for federal oversight of TikTok. He said the company has formed a subsidiary called USDS to manage US user data. In prepared remarks, Chu wrote that USDS employees would report to an independent board of directors who would be approved by... a fiduciary duty to the federal government. Oh, that's a little scary. To be clear, he framed it as an idea, something that could happen, not exactly something that will happen. And the CEO also reiterated claims that user data is safely stored on Oracle servers and that the Chinese government has never requested user data. OK, sure. How do you think TikTok's critics will respond to this proposed U.S. government approved board?
Scott Galloway
That makes me nervous. U.S. government approved. But go ahead.
Kara Swisher
Go for it.
Scott Galloway
I think his argument has the nuance that people aren't going to investigate. They're not going to try and figure out what a board would do or not do. I also think it's like one of these, "Okay, you want us to have a Facebook oversight board," but our impression is these boards don't really have a lot of teeth. And what do we do? It's all about incentives. It's not even about supervision here because the supervision is near impossible.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, there's an easier solution, by the way, rather than this. I don't know what this is. Another turducken, right?
Scott Galloway
And you believe that easier solution is a spinoff. That's it. Why are we trying to do this? Like, oh, my God, so many First Amendment things here. It's like, who gets on it? What do they do? Is it like a blue ribbon panel? How do they track data? What? How about spinning it off? How about that? That might work.
Kara Swisher
That's exactly right. If the U.S. successfully forces a sale, it'll be problematic for U.S. tech companies abroad, except there aren't any in China. So I'm not sure what they're going to do to us. Like what? Like Apple. Apple. How are they going to reciprocate? What are they going to do? Stop making iPhones? Kick Google out? Kick Meta? Oh, did that. Did that. Kick Twitter? Oh, did that. It's Apple. And Tesla, actually, are the two companies there, the two big. I just don't think that. They're so important to their economy. It's a very difficult situation for the Chinese. And they'll find other ways to, like, meeting with Putin, for example, to reciprocate.
There was a really good article in *The Information* about who owns it and who's done different things. A lot of U.S. companies, some have left, some have sold off. Everybody sees a payday here in some fashion. And so to me, that's what everyone should be focusing on instead of this argument. There's a payday here. This is a product everybody loves. And every day they don't settle this is a bad day for TikTok because they aren't focusing on their product and what they're doing. Their executives are here testifying in front of Congress. And the ban, I don't think the U.S. wants this either because a ban is very hard to do.
People will find their way around it. It'll be a big mess. And then in the end, this very good product will be decimated, which is, Facebook's probably doing a little jig over in Mountain View nearby me right now. There's just got to be, there's 300 billion reasons to figure this out. And that is agree to the spin.
Scott Galloway
It's just, I mean, there's some really powerful... Isn't Sequoia and General Atlantic Partners in here? There's a whole bunch of people. I forget, but there are quite a few American companies in here, investors in here. And it's always been the case. And of course, the issue is, are the Chinese going to let this happen from a "you're not pushing us around" kind of perspective? That's really the focus, right? It has a decent geopolitical overlay here. And that is, we say we're going to ban it unless you spin it. And they say, "We're not spinning it, you know, have at it." That will further the chill, right?
That will be seen, correctly or incorrectly, as an offensive move, furthering the distance. I think Americans, in my opinion, correctly say, look, at its base level, we're doing to one of your firms what you've done to every media firm for the last 30 years in China. So you don't really have a leg to stand on from a trade policy standpoint.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
But if they say, "No, we're shutting it down, you try and keep us out of the US," it's going to take the temperature down in a bad way, make the frosting worse, increase the chill. So it's got a geopolitical overlay here. I hope it seems like everybody wins in a spin. Look at it this way: $300 billion. Say the Chinese government or Chinese economy registers 10 or 20% of that just in terms of taxation or incremental wealth creation for Chinese shareholders. They can build an aircraft carrier with that money. There's real money. This is so much money that there's an actual governmental reason to hold on to it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they don't have a lot to attack. They have very limited options. Apple and Tesla have had bad publicity and consumer anger, but these are important companies and they'll relocate to India and Vietnam, which they're already going in that direction. It could really hurt the Chinese economy. They could do things like raid them and scrutinize them, but they have not let us in there. We have let them in here, and we have a lot more ability to mess with them in that regard. There are other places it could play out. I think this is one that the U.S. has correctly assessed they could win. People just don't believe them.
Scott Galloway
The government—this is just such a good political issue. And right now with him standing next to Vladimir Putin, that's not going to help him. He's standing there yucking it up with that murderer. We're catastrophizing the banking thing, the contagion. The most dangerous thing that happened hands down in the last month or three months is that meeting between Xi and Putin. It's truly frightening. That's the real thing to be worried about. It has pretty poor and broad implications across the entire West. I wouldn't say it's unrelated to this. It's a show of power.
Kara Swisher
These are all shows of power that she is doing. Even though everyone's like, "Well, she's running your thing," everyone in power is always a little bit not in power. There's always a threat to them. So when he did that, I thought, "Huh, I wonder what trouble you have at home that you have to show your muscle so much." It always makes me ask, "Why does he need to show his muscle so much?" It's really interesting.
Also, let's go back to money because I think that's the most important thing here. Ad revenue in the U.S. is expected to reach $6.83 billion this year, up from $780 million in 2020. Oh my God. The money. Tenfold. Just crazy. And of course, these ad firms are like, "Well, in this Project Texas that TikTok is doing to protect it..." Just nobody believes it. Meanwhile, our homegrown businesses are doing stuff like this at the same time. But the China thing is just too much. They're going to ban it. They thought we wouldn't. We will. And that's where they are. So next move, China.
Scott Galloway
I would just love to see all the Meta lobbyists who are like, "We love big government and think government intervention is warranted here." They've had to go from reverse to forward so fast around government intervention.
Kara Swisher
Well, speaking of, Scott, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about Bard AI and take a listener mail question about bonuses.
AD BREAK
Scott, we're back with our second big story. We're going to talk about Google's new product called Bard. Google released its new AI chatbot, Bard, to the general public this week. So far, it's only available to some users in the U.S. and U.K. Google says the bot is an "experiment" and frames it as a companion to Google search, not a replacement, although that's precisely what it is. I'm sorry, Google, but you have to upgrade your search, and that's this. CEO Sundar Pichai told employees in a letter that "things will go wrong" with the bot. Meanwhile, AI ethicists are taking issue with the "experimental" label, and one says the company is trying to offload accountability if things do go wrong, and they certainly probably will. One thing that did go wrong is someone asked Bard, "Who should prevail, the Justice Department or Google in antitrust lawsuits?" and it sided with the Justice Department. I think the Justice Department will probably have to call Bard as a witness when they're going forward. That's funny. So what's happening here? What do you think?
Scott Galloway
I think we need to be—clearly, this technology is just as chips, or the internet, or communications, or vaccines—whenever there's been a pretty seminal technology in terms of potentially shifting the sands of the plates of power, I think it's important that we are out front. Part of that is to encourage companies to experiment and face the market. We just need to be thoughtful about what is actually going on and watch it very closely and work with the right parties to not only encourage them, but also to ensure we have the regulation with teeth to make sure this thing doesn't get out ahead of us in a very bad way, as we did with the internet. But I'm for launching things. Let's get American business in America really good at this, because I worry—the genius is out of the bottle here.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. You and I don't think you can stop technology. And I think a certain amount of breaking some glass is worth it here for American companies and industry to become number one. That's the argument they're making. I do buy that argument. Some people think this is an arms race that's going too fast and the "move fast and break things" mantra. Some people think it should be in-house longer. OpenAI, for example, which is the leader here, shut down ChatGPT this week after a bug let users see other people's chat titles. It came back online, but users couldn't see their own chat histories. Bard is going to roll out with some limits they put in place. It won't give medical advice. It capped a few responses per session. Microsoft had similar limits.
Let's listen to—I did an interview this week. I did two AI-focused ones, one with Reid Hoffman earlier in the week, who was on the board of OpenAI. He's now off it because he's working on his own AI project with one of the DeepMind founders. But I spoke with OpenAI's Sam Altman for my other podcast, *On with Kara Swisher*. I talked about risk and competition.
Scott Galloway
That's good.
Kara Swisher
It's not *Call Me Daddy*.
Scott Galloway
No, it's not *Call Me Daddy*. That's yours.
Kara Swisher
So I asked him about—let's listen to what Sam had to say.
[CLIP - Sam Altman] Sam Altman: What do you think the most viable threat to OpenAI is? Honestly, I try to pay some attention to what's happening with all these other things. It's going to be an unbelievably competitive space. This is the first new technological platform in a long period of time. The thing I worry about the most is not any of those, because I think we can—there's room for a lot of people. And also, I think we'll just continue to offer the best product. The thing I worry about the most is that we're somehow missing a better approach. And that this idea—everyone's chasing us right now on large language models trained in the same way. I don't worry about them. I worry about the person that has some very different idea about how to make a more useful system.
END CLIP
That was an interesting answer. Of course, he's worried about the guy in the garage. That was what he was essentially saying—that they may not be doing it the right way if everyone's trying to copy what OpenAI is doing, which is what it seems like, correct?
Scott Galloway
I will actually listen to that interview because there are a few people who are more important right now than Sam Altman. And it's not for the reason you think. People think, "Well, he's going to shape the future of AI." I actually think the reason he is probably the most important person in terms of where he will be right now versus in a year is that he's going to be positioned as the next tech icon.
Kara Swisher
Mm-hmm.
Scott Galloway
People who get a ton of influence because this is what's going to happen. He's going to be positioned as our next Jesus because he understands technology and is doing these amazing things and creating a ton of shareholder value. And every young man across the globe is going to model his behavior.
Kara Swisher
Well, I have good news for you. I'm just very curious. I have good news. He's a good guy.
Scott Galloway
Well, that's actually very encouraging.
Kara Swisher
I've known him since he did Loopt, which was a company that failed. It was a social network that had location at its heart. Then he went to Y Combinator. Very thoughtful, very willing to say no to people, including Elon. They had a back and forth about OpenAI. Elon didn't like the Microsoft deal, but he has an answer to it. So he's got a backbone. I've never had anything but thoughtful discussions with him. That's encouraging. He's quite quiet. He doesn't want a lot of attention paid to him necessarily, although a lot of attention is. Of course, he's got an ego like everybody else here. But he's very thoughtful about the safety of this.
I don't know if he's right. I think he has the possibility he can get run over by more venal people. I think that's one of the things I worry about. I think he may not be able to be at the front as these people put so much stuff into it. Obviously, Elon's going to do something. Reid Hoffman is. I'd rather have Reid Hoffman doing it than Elon. Some of his answers surprised me in a positive way, actually. He is of the feeling that the stakes are low now and this is when we should do it. He also understands there's liability attached here. It's not protected by Section 230, that there will be liability.
He believes that there should be liability, depending on what's made out of this technology, because you don't know the companies that are going to come out of it. He doesn't defocus on the negative. He doesn't love talking about all the negative things, I think, like a lot of people, but he doesn't defocus that he's aware of it. He also likes to focus on the positive, like Bill Gates. I think Sam talked about this too—said AI could serve as a doctor to the world's poorest people. This will be in the phone. It will tell you things and help you along with all kinds of very minor things that often turn major.
Gates issued a letter this week outlining his hopes for tech. He said AI may be able to address inequality. But Gates wrote, "Market forces won't naturally produce AI products and services to help the poorest. The opposite is more likely." He's correct. There's a lot of possibility here for tutors. I think Sam talked about tutors on the phone—that the phone becomes less a time-suck than a time-helper, if that makes sense. So there could be a lot of good here.
But just an example, one of the things you said about Bard, that it won't be giving medical advice. I would like to see it in a controlled, tons-of-disclosures-everywhere, get very aggressive around medical advice.
Scott Galloway
I think if you look at America, if you're in the top 10%, if you have money and you get really sick, there are a few places you'd rather be than a teaching hospital in the United States. Our healthcare, like everything else in America, has slowly but surely been more and more increasingly optimized for the top decile of income earners. For those top 10%, there's nothing like it. The procedure you had done—there was nowhere in the world you would rather have it done. But as we have optimized for the top 10%, slowly but surely, the outcomes and the consumer satisfaction for the bottom 90% have been...
healthcare in the United States can be described as expensive but bad. I'm paying a lot indirectly or directly, and I don't have the same outcomes as other nations. And as always, it makes sense when you first hear, "Oh, it's not going to give medical advice." Well, you know who doesn't want to give them medical advice? The medical industrial complex, the pharmaceutical industry, the health insurance market. Because here's the thing: if we finally get good at distributing preventive healthcare out to the masses, and maybe they have less diabetes and become less valuable to the pharmaceutical industrial complex, maybe we figure out ways that they can, in a low-cost way, handle things and identify them and not end up in the emergency room.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
So you can bet the healthcare industry is nodding and going, "Yes, you should absolutely make sure that our existing arcane, administratively and financially burdensome method maintains..." The disbursement of medical advice could be an enormous unlock for the people who are too intimidated.
Kara Swisher
That was the idea behind phones and your hands. But this is different because it really does tell you and it does reason. So one of the things that's important here is the positive story. AI is in these phones. They can tutor. They can give medical advice, really good medical advice in a real way versus searching on Google. Searching on Google—10 years ago I said, "I don't understand why typing into a box is the way we think is the top of technology." It was so Neanderthal to me. And so this is like, "Okay, here's what you're looking for." This is why it's so attractive. It's search on steroids, really.
And it's search that makes sense. It's a search that's easy to understand. Same thing will happen with medicine, learning, and things like that. I think the worries are that it's going to track you, but they're already tracking you. So that's already happening. That it has much more information and control over you because it's not just a box. It's your friend. It's like AI will tell you what to do and where to go and will track you and know what you've asked about and have a relationship with you in a much more significant way. But these people—not just more people, everyone's getting bad information from these phones.
So how could we make it better? How can we bring it? I think those are very laudable things. And I think Gates is right to say that what's going to turn out to be—it's going to be like sex bot AIs. It's going to be what do rich people need? That's what the companies that are being formed will look for—how to make money.
And Sam and I did talk about that. How do you make money at this? He and I talked about how the real original sin of the internet is moving to advertising before subscriptions, as you've talked about. And that this is an opportunity to make subscriptions work. Subscriptions are not advertising-based technologies. There may be advertising here. There certainly could be. But subscriptions are—I think they have 100 million users. Not all pay subscriptions, obviously. But they're doing very well with the subscriptions. And maybe there are ways for all kinds of creative companies to come up with this that you pay a little bit, micropayments or whatever, as you use these things. So I think we can all agree that there can be a better business plan here that doesn't lead to the bad outcomes that the internet has.
Scott Galloway
This is the key decision that is hopeful so far, and that is the majority of AI. So for example, Adobe just released their design or image generator. The difference there—the market's already evolving—is it's IP friendly. It's only feeding images into the machine model that it either has copyright on or don't have a copyright. Whereas you're seeing the other guys, the image or design engines, are being sued because Getty Images says you have clearly used our images without paying us.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And so it's a pretty smart move that Adobe has these assets and said, "OK, we're going to be IP clean if you use our stuff." But the key decision here that's really hopeful, and it's very basic, is that the person whose fingers are typing the query into ChatGPT—that is your end consumer. You have a vested interest in adding value to that person's life and work and getting monetary compensation from them, as opposed to just getting in exchange for an amazing service your attention. And then we turn you into the product.
Kara Swisher
That's right, yeah.
Scott Galloway
That is the primary distinction here that so far the AI business model is pursuing. And it's very hopeful and should avoid a lot of the real noxious emissions that have come out of the internet.
Kara Swisher
It just depends on who's making it. This is like the internet. Now who's on top of that? And who makes things? And how do they do business? Liability is going to be a big issue here, which is good. There'll be liability if you make bad things. And Sam was talking about—I was like, "Well, who should have the liability?" He goes, "Probably the last person who touched it that created the problem." That's who—the one who's offering a service that has problems. That's where he would put it, obviously not on his stuff. But that was interesting. There's liability too. It could be a subscription base and not advertising base.
That's great. And then the last thing is that we've got liability and we've got incentives not to take your stuff. And I think what the government has to do is watch very carefully around privacy and copyright. This week, the Writers Guild of America proposed a rule that allows screenwriters to use it as long as they don't have to share credit or residuals with the technology. That it's used as a tool and not a weapon. Every possibility that when it could be a weapon has to be shut down pretty quickly, and people should pay for it. The problem, I think Sam did say, is they don't know what their people are going to make with this stuff.
That's the issue. And right now, a bunch of Stanford researchers did a version of this that cost $600. So it's like cloning technology. Who knows what some bad person's going to do? The last time it happened bad, it was in China, actually. But there has to be an idea that you want to make good stuff here. And then those who cross that line have costs for crossing that line. So we'll see. Could be magical thinking.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it'll be interesting to see what kind of regulatory body they come up with, whether it'll be a division of an existing regulatory body or something different.
Kara Swisher
There might be a separate one for this. Yeah, I think that would probably make sense.
Scott Galloway
But I was at the Adobe conference yesterday in Vegas and the—I just literally lost my train of thought. I'm in the bunker with you. I'm about to go hunt. You're about to be eating. I'm about to go hunt. You're out to become dinner. A mutated deer to feed all of us and you scream, "Take your culture wars with you and see if that brings back a deer, you bunker bitch!" And I'm like, "That's it. All right. This is the day."
Kara Swisher
I will put another topic. One of the things that was the most interesting thing he said, I think, of the entire interview.
Scott Galloway
Hello, edibles. Who took edibles last night? All right. I'm sorry. Go ahead.
Kara Swisher
The most interesting thing he said, and I think you will have a comment on this, was this was the reason—I said, "Why did—you know, Elon was complaining that they went from a nonprofit to a profit." He said, "We couldn't get money. We couldn't get people to give us money to do it as a nonprofit. The only way to do this was to have this capped profit model that they have with their investors." Which is interesting. But I said, "Well, who would have given you the money?" He goes, "Well, in the old days, the government. This should have been a government thing. This should have been like the space program, like everything else that was the government, like the internet. It should have been a government program, but that's not happening now." And so we have these publicly important tools that private tech companies for profit are innovating. And so that to me was really an interesting exchange. I think he does think the government probably should have been the one to do this, but it ain't happening in this world, except in China, except in other countries that want to use it for more nefarious means.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. So the question that was presented to me at this conference was, "What should we be investing in to take advantage of AI?" And I said, "I don't have any feel for the pure plays. And it seems highly speculative. And the mania has—we're already sort of in, if we're not in peak hype cycle, we're in strong hype cycle." And I said, "I don't have a feel for—" someone said, "If you could invest in ChatGPT right now, would you?" And I'm like, "At $29 billion, I don't know." But what I think a better investment strategy is just trying to figure out what companies across every sector seem to be really serious about this and show initial signs of experimenting with it and leveraging it. Because even if it doesn't have any tangible impact, if you can be the beauty company that's doing cool stuff with AI, it'll do wonders for your brand, similar to how early digital innovation, whether it was tangible or effective or not, was the ultimate branding strategy about 15 years ago.
Kara Swisher
But there will be something. I think education, health, anything, writing—it could, like everything, just like the internet, it's everything. And so we'll see where it goes. It's like crypto.
Scott Galloway
Crypto? No, it doesn't. It's not going to solve everything. But this is actually very creative and much more democratic. Crypto is just—I don't see—the people I see involved here are quality people. So hopefully they will stay that way. That's very encouraging. And it's not the ones I find more distasteful. Sam Altman is—listen to the interview. I'd love to know what you think.
Kara Swisher
Okay, Scott, let's pivot. And listen to the Reid Hoffman one too, because he was deeply involved in OpenAI too.
Scott Galloway
Okay, Scott, let's pivot to a listener question. You've got—you've got mail.
Kara Swisher
I can't believe I'm going to be a mailman. You've got mail. This question comes from email. I'll read it. "Hi, Kara and Scott. Have you ever noticed they always go Kara and Scott? Just making a note of that."
Scott Galloway
Yeah, yeah.
Kara Swisher
Well, what I love is whenever they introduce us, including on the show notes, right, "Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway," which is not alphabetical. I mean, it's literally like I am such the bottom here.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Why is it a crime? Anyways. No, I'm just saying. I just noticed when people write to us, just pointing it out. Anyway, "Hi, Kara and Scott. I work for a publicly traded internet company, and they recently announced they're changing their annual bonus program from cash to stock. I don't have a problem with this, but I'm wondering what are the general reasons why a company would make this type of change?" Oh, this is a good Scott Galloway question. "But I'm also curious if that implies anything about a company's current financial situation and how the board might view our outlook going forward. Love the show. Listen to every episode. Thanks, Dom." Scott, answer this question. I have no idea. Tell me.
Scott Galloway
Well, it's a non-cash charge. It's dilutive to shareholders because they have to issue new shares. But it doesn't immediately hit their treasury. The primary reason I think they probably do it is they're hoping a lot of employees don't sell the stock and feel more of a vested interest in the success of the company. One of the basics of management is that you want people to act like owners. You want people proofing the document beyond their hours. You want them thinking about the business. You really want them emotionally invested in the success of the company. You want them to act like owners. And the bottom line is the only way to make someone act like an owner is to make them an owner. And the way you make them an owner is by giving them shares in the company. So it's more of a cultural attempt to align interests. Even if it's a de minimis amount, it works.
One of the things we've done at every company I've started is we've given equity to every full-time employee. Because even if it seems like a little to us, it's actually a lot to most people. And it's meaningful to say, "Okay, I have five, ten grand worth of stock here. And if things work out, it's meaningful to me." And they feel a sense of ownership.
Kara Swisher
They don't feel riskier. You're not worried about them feeling like cash is cash. They can take it and buy a car or whatever. Well, they can sell the stock. It's up to them. I like stock that doesn't have restrictions. Usually awards like options have vesting periods. But options are essentially a tax-efficient way to give away equity. More companies are doing RSUs. That way, if the stock goes down a little bit, they still have something.
Scott Galloway
Right. But giving away equity is a kind of a best practice. When I was growing my companies, I just didn't have the money to pay people market. We were bootstrapping them. We were starting strategy firms. We needed really qualified, intelligent people. I had a lot of options in the marketplace, very certified. And I used to say, "Okay, this is my model. I pay you 10% to 20% below market, but I'm going to give you triple the equity you would get anywhere else at this size of company." And when someone owns—that's your weapon as a small company. You say to people—I used to bring in our top 10 or 12 people, and I realize this is aspirational, but I generally believe the top 10% of employees create 120% of the value and the rest are minus 20%, but you can't figure out who it is.
You identify those people, you bring them in, you sit them down and go, "Okay, you own one and a half percent of this company. These are our revenues. This is our plan over the next five years. These are the multiples on exits for companies like this. This means you by the age of 29 are in line to make X dollars." Which is better than cash. The thing about equity is, say you get $100 every year for four years, but you're given $400 in equity. You might pay tax on it then. But then if you hold onto it, it grows tax deferred. You don't get taxed on it every year. It's very difficult to get economically secure with current cash.
Kara Swisher
Give me the bad thing. Does it imply that they don't have money to give you, or that this is just a better way for them to manage their cash?
Scott Galloway
I doubt it. I mean, I've been in situations—this is a publicly traded company, so they can look at the financials and make their own snapshot decision around the financial health of the company. It's a best practice. I have done what you're talking about. I've been in situations where I'm like, "Okay, these are consultants. We've had a great year. We did $10 million in top line, $2 million in EBITDA, but we're investing aggressively, opening our European office." And I bring senior management in and I'll say, "You are going to get a $150,000 bonus. You can have that bonus, or I'll give you a quarter of a million dollars in stock to save me the cash. Do you want to go all in on this?" And you know what?
The majority of people who join a firm like that say, "Yeah, I'm in." Or, depending on their personal financial situation, it is very difficult. You always want to figure out a forced savings, a means of forced saving, whether it's a mortgage or 401k or things that you've just taken out of your check right away. Or you want some sort of equity participation that grows in a tax deferred way. Because as humans, we always raise our spending to the level of our current income. You have to have a lot of discipline not to do that. Your little holiday bonus is gone on something stupid. So I like this.
But the only piece of advice I would say is if the stock ever gets more than 30 or 40% of your net worth—which is a good problem—diversify. Diversify. The people at Lehman Brothers, the smartest people in the world in 2008, there were hundreds of partners who had their entire net worth in Lehman stock and they lost it overnight. Overnight. And they'd been there 20, 30 years.
Kara Swisher
Yep. Yep. That happened at lots of companies I've written about. And you really should diversify. That's the smartest thing. It's not an insult to your company to do that. It's just smart planning. Anyway, that's a great answer. That was a very good question too. Thanks, Dom. We really appreciate it. If you've got a question of your own you'd like answered, send it our way. Go to nymag.com/pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT.
All right, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for your prediction.
Ad break for Mint Mobile
Ad break for "Explain It To Me" podcast
Okay, Scott, let's hear a prediction.
Scott Galloway
A prediction.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
I'm boring here. I'm going to just pimp my show. I'm on Bill Maher tomorrow night, so my prediction is it's going to be an outstanding show.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you've done great. You know, without taking off your shirt, you've done excellent on those shows every time.
Scott Galloway
Well, I just had an idea for tomorrow night.
Kara Swisher
No, please don't.
Scott Galloway
Honey, I'm going to find the mutated deer.
Kara Swisher
No, let me just tell you something. You do really well on that show. And people are always like, "Who is this Scott Galloway fellow you've been hooking up with?" They really do. I discovered his ass. I discovered his ass. I don't say that, but you do really well on that show.
Scott Galloway
He's my bunker mate.
Kara Swisher
He's my bunker mate. For a short time. David Sedaris is the main guest.
Scott Galloway
What? Really? Oh, my God. I love him.
Kara Swisher
He's good, isn't he?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I've never met him. I've been to so many of his concerts. I mean, he has concerts where he just reads and they're hysterical. I wrote—I love his book, *Me Talk Pretty One Day*. I remember it having an impact on me as a young person. And then I'm with Annie Lowrey. I don't know if you know Annie.
Kara Swisher
Oh, she's wonderful. She's an amazing writer. And she's written all kinds of amazing stuff on topics. And she's just, she's terrific.
Scott Galloway
I always get freaked out. They're going to pair me with some crazy conservative Ann Coulter.
Kara Swisher
Oh, that's for me. That's what they're saving for me.
Scott Galloway
I get nervous. So I immediately looked up her stuff and I'm like, it's not going to be a very exciting panel. I mean, I'm going to say—I'll let you know when I disagree with something.
Kara Swisher
Well, I'm sorry to tell you, but she's just like me, a liberal. I think she is. I think she's pretty liberal.
Scott Galloway
Well, you know, you've got me figured out. I'm somewhere between Ted Cruz and Marjorie Taylor Greene. I'm just so conservative.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. She writes about money and inequity and the future of working and all kinds of things.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I know. She's very talented. She had a book in 2018 called *Give People Money*. It was about—
Kara Swisher
Yeah, she's a big UBI person.
Scott Galloway
UBI, yeah. That was a great book. I think I had her on one of my podcasts. And she's just really terrific and a beautiful writer. So that'll be fun.
Kara Swisher
Oh, good. She has much more throughput than I do. I'll tell you that. She'll be able to shut you down if you say anything bad. So we'll see. But who gets you radioactive free water out in the wild? I would literally—you would decide—I would be so useless. You'd be like, "Okay, we've decided that we're going to eat you."
Scott Galloway
Scott, I'm going to eat you. That is what's happening.
Kara Swisher
No, I mean, actually eat me. You'd figure out, okay.
Scott Galloway
Yes. He's got to have some utility. Let's kill him in a year.
Kara Swisher
I literally just said I'm going to Yellowjacket you, which is one of the most popular shows right now. It's about a group of girls that are cannibals, essentially. And then what happens?
Scott Galloway
Oh, my God. Yeah, exactly. A group of girls that are cannibals?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you've got to watch that show.
Scott Galloway
Is it on Cinemax?
Kara Swisher
No, it's on, like, Paramount. You don't even get that joke.
Scott Galloway
Oh, I get that. I get it. It's a dirty joke. I get it.
Kara Swisher
But let me just say, you better start to watch that show and see, because it's going to be what's happening to you at some point in the future. We end up in a bunker together. Anyway, I'm excited for you. Mr. Man.
Scott Galloway
Mr. Man. No, no. Dead. You're so dead.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, this is going to happen to you. You're going to be tasty. I'm going to put you a little Chianti and some fava beans.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Louie's going to season me.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, at least Louie's going to cook you up. He'll make it delicious. Anyhow, Scott, good luck for the short life that you have left to live.
Scott Galloway
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
And good luck on Bill Maher. You're going to be great. I'm sure you're going to be great.
Scott Galloway
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
Okay, that's the show. We'll be back on Tuesday with more Pivot. Scott, read us out.
Scott Galloway
Today's show was produced by Lara Neyman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Intertott engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Emil Silverio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.
Kara Swisher
He does go foraging and he's funny and tells dad jokes.
Scott Galloway
Nah, let's eat them.