Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including the Olympics, climate change, infrastructure, and technology. The main topic is the intersection of technology and society, with a focus on the impact of technological advancements on our daily lives.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Overall, the podcast episode offers a thought-provoking exploration of the intersection of technology and society, highlighting the need for a more nuanced understanding of the impact of technological advancements on our daily lives.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher.
Scott Galloway
And I'm an Olympic hopeful.
Kara Swisher
No, you're not.
Scott Galloway
Why? I am as much an Olympic hopeful as anybody else. You don't need to fill out paperwork. You don't need to demonstrate any athletic ability. I take edibles, go into the jacuzzi, and I'm passionate about synchronized swimming in that moment. I am an Olympic hopeful.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God, Scott. You're not an Olympic hopeful.
Scott Galloway
Anybody can be an Olympic hopeful.
Kara Swisher
They cannot.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they can.
Kara Swisher
Literally, they can. They would wipe the floor with you, the Olympians.
Scott Galloway
The Olympians. I wouldn't call you an Olympian. I lived with Olympians when I was in college when I was an athlete.
Kara Swisher
How was that?
Scott Galloway
It's inspiring until you realize that most sports are kind of a... I don't want to call it a fraud. They're all calling me at 28 asking for help getting jobs. There's a half a percent of sports that is a pang, and the rest is... I wasn't planning to go here. The optimal athletic ability is to be just good enough to play sports in college, but to never have delusions that you're going to make a living.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Scott Galloway
And a lot of people go to the Olympics. I mean, it's an inspiring week, but I would argue a lot of them look back and go, "Okay, was that really worth it?"
Kara Swisher
Interesting. Well, they kind of have to do it. You've got to put your life on the whole thing. I had a friend who was a great skater, and she almost went that direction. She actually skated one summer, and there was another skater there, Dorothy Hamill, if you remember, who was also...
Scott Galloway
Yeah, Dorothy.
Kara Swisher
She was up in that league, and she decided no, she wanted a life, and she's very successful. She was a prosecutor. She runs Princeton University. You know what I mean? Anyway, she was a really good skater. She could have gone the distance, as they say. She could have been a contender.
Scott Galloway
Could have been a contender. Kara Swisher, never. Not once.
Kara Swisher
I hate sports, as you know.
Scott Galloway
I could see you on the ice.
Kara Swisher
No. I just like that image.
Scott Galloway
I like that image.
Kara Swisher
No, there's no Kara Swisher on the ice unless I'm wearing a furry costume.
Scott Galloway
What would be your dance routine? I like that. I like that. We could be pairs dancers. You and Oxana Byul. Obviously, you're the gay one.
Kara Swisher
You're the gay one. Oh, so, hello. Hello. I've got the outfit. Isn't he gay? My mother was here. I'm in Rhode Island on vacation. My mother was here. She's asking if you were still gay.
Scott Galloway
Still gay? Yeah. Yeah. Happy Pride.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, Pride took place this week. Thank you. I missed all of it. I'm in a closet right now broadcasting, as people know, on my vacation, which I enjoy. Happy Pride. I'm in the closet. So there's a lot of serious things going on. First of all, Tesla had to recall nearly all of its vehicles sold in China over concerns over its cruise control system. Not good. Big problem. Don't you think? Or not? These things are going to happen, but still.
Scott Galloway
I actually don't. You know, I think Tesla is, as I've repeatedly said, incredibly overvalued. But a recall... First off, I have a Tesla. I never used cruise control. It was sort of a gimmick. I used it a lot in the beginning. And I think there's something about having a steering wheel in front of you where it's so unnatural, you just can't get used to it. The idea of not being in control when there's a steering wheel.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I don't like cruise control. I don't like cruise control at all. I don't think it's... I think this is a bump. I really don't. I mean, if they continue to have recalls that reflects poorly on their manufacturing, I don't think it's a big deal.
Scott Galloway
All right. Well, okay, then.
Kara Swisher
And the antitrust bills that aim to break up big tech companies have passed initial hurdles and debates in Congress. There's some back and forth with the Republicans who still want more conservatism and who's going to fit in here and which companies. So it's actually moving ahead in Congress. We'll see how many of them actually pass, but they are moving forward, which is interesting.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, it's exciting, right? We've been waiting for this for 10 years. We'll see. We'll see. I think they're going to get a watered-down version of everything. Look what happened to the infrastructure bill, which was really heavy on EVs and everything else, along with everything else. The kitchen sink was in that bill. We'll see. I'm hoping for the best, but we'll see how much of it passes and how much it gets watered down. And then there's the Senate and it runs right into Joe Manchin, et cetera. We'll see how that goes.
Kara Swisher
Obviously, the biggest story this week is something down your way. You're not there right now, but an apartment building in Miami collapsed late last week, which I think is just shocking to many people across this country because it doesn't happen very often. The death toll is nine people and 150 people are still missing. It's an obvious tragedy. We're doing an event in Miami later this year, not far from where this is. What are your reflections from being a Floridian? There's obviously climate change issues. There's the sea and building so close and everything else, although this, I think, is a real rare occurrence.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, well, I think, look, I can't imagine a worse sort of tragedy playing out than having a loved one go missing. That's just not imaginable and just creates a constant, I imagine, level of slow-burn tragedy. Awful. So a huge tragedy. But in terms of its impact, I think its impact is on the brand that is the U.S., not brand Florida. And that is slowly but surely... or not slowly but surely, it's been leading up to lack of respect for government, the lack of respect for investing in our infrastructure and opting for tax cuts or opting to cut taxes on corporations. We have slowly but surely become a third world country. And that is what happened there. And we don't know the exact cause, but that wasn't us. That never used to be us. Shed buildings, buildings in the middle of a city just pancaking and killing people. That didn't used to happen in America.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and I feel it... This is so rare. This is shocking. I think when you saw that picture and you saw the collapse itself, because everything's monitored now, it was pretty... You've only seen it when they purposely do this, or you're from another country, really, from a third world country. It's true.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but whether it's shitty airports, whether it's homeless encampments propping up in our best cities or our most prestigious cities, or it's buildings just randomly pancaking, it reflects, in my opinion, that we've kind of lost the script. That we're no longer investing in our nation. And who I do think comes out of this a winner? I think Biden's infrastructure bill is now going to pass. Or people are going to go, you know, at some point, you've got to fix the fucking plumbing. Or you're going to start springing leaks everywhere.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. Unfortunately, that's what happened. Water was a big thing. And obviously, building along Miami, there are these continuing things, which we've talked to the different politicians in there about, is what they're going to do with seawalls and the expense that it's going to take. And that's one thing. It's not just that, but it's the building in these areas. I'm in Rhode Island right now, and all I keep thinking is, this is all going to be underwater. I don't know why it's so beautiful here and gorgeous, but the sea has been reaching closer and closer into the land. You sort of think about it in a very different way wherever you travel when you're in a low sea level area. And then there's the natural corrosion that happens when you're by the ocean. Obviously, in this case, that seems to have been an issue. It could be a building issue. It could be a lot of things. But you're right. There were some warnings, but not explicit warnings. No one thought that it would be that much of a collapse, that it might be things that they could fix. And a lot of it was put off because of the pandemic. It was the slowness of dealing with issues that were there in this particular building.
Scott Galloway
It's interesting, though, just hearing you, you went to climate change. And I'm not saying that's right or wrong.
Kara Swisher
No, I just was thinking about it.
Scott Galloway
I went to infrastructure.
Kara Swisher
Both.
Scott Galloway
And I've always thought, and I still believe this, that an investment in infrastructure is an investment in the middle class. Because if you're in Sao Paulo and the traffic is awful, you know what the rich do? The rich take helicopters. And so they're fine with shitty infrastructure. When you invest in great roads, bridges, tunnels, and infrastructure, you're saying to your middle class, "We want you to be productive. We want you to be able to get to work in 20 minutes, not two hours." And this just reflects, again, that we have decided not to invest in the middle class. I think infrastructure is a straight-line investment in the middle class.
Kara Swisher
The link I want to make to climate change is that we are going to have to really think hard about how we want to rebuild stuff with that in mind, as these things are occurring. Because why rebuild if we're going to have instant hurricanes or whatever? We have to be thinking about wildfires in California and hurricanes in Florida and increased leaching of water into things. So I think it's something we have to think about in tandem. And that's one thing that I wish people would discuss climate change away from politics. It's an economic issue, completely an economic issue. And I don't think this is a climate change issue. This is just a disaster. But you start to think about how we build things going forward. We've got to really think hard about it. But anyway, speaking of disasters, and it's not even close, because this tragedy is just really sticking in a lot of people's minds. But we're going to go on to the big story, which is...
Scott Galloway
Well, hold on, hold on. Okay, sorry. I'm going to have to do some good news here.
Kara Swisher
What?
Scott Galloway
You gave a commencement speech.
Kara Swisher
I did. Yes, I did to high schoolers. It's my old school that I went from kindergarten to fifth grade. And the Times published it because they like to publish those kinds of things when I gave a little advice to young folk.
Scott Galloway
Young folk. So give us the abridged version. What was your... Wait, I'm sorry, this was elementary school or a high school?
Kara Swisher
No, it was a high school. I didn't finish it. I went to another high school and they just asked me back. I only went there until fifth grade. But it was to seniors. I did not give an address to fifth graders. That would have been a huge disaster. But no, I gave them a speech and my speech was about something I kind of learned from you, Scott. It was called "Don't Do Your Homework." Like, don't put your head down and look at your screens and do your homework all the time when you have opportunities everywhere. Try to have agency in your life, the idea of agency and changing and shifting. And I ended up quoting a little bit of Steve Jobs, who talked about this in one of his famous speeches to Stanford University, but also a poem by Lucille Clifton called "New Bones." We have to always be growing new bones no matter where we are in our lives. It was all about new bones. And so it was good. They liked it. It was funny, too. I made some funny jokes and things like that. I think they didn't think I was too much of a square.
Scott Galloway
Have you ever done a commencement speech?
Kara Swisher
I was chosen to be the student... I was chosen or selected by my classmates to be the commencement speaker at the Berkeley graduation.
Scott Galloway
Oh.
Kara Swisher
So I gave the speech as the student speaker, whatever you call it. I remember it vividly. I remember looking up in the audience and... I don't even remember what I said. I remember seeing my mom in the audience. It was the Greek theater at Berkeley, which is this wonderful theater.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, beautiful.
Kara Swisher
Beautiful. And I remember seeing my mom. She was so proud. She literally was just uncontrollably waving her arms. Nice moment for us.
Scott Galloway
I know. What was your message? Do you remember? What would it be today? What would be your message to high schoolers today? Besides Chipotle and Cialis, what would be your message to them?
Kara Swisher
You should be a monster. You should be physically running long distances and lifting heavy weights mentally in your mind and in the gym. You should be focused on three things and three things only. Working your fucking ass off. This bullshit about balance is bullshit. We live in a capitalist society. If you want to have influence, you need to work your ass off and get great at something. Make small investments in relationships every day. They pay off hugely, like small investments when you're young. You know that whole thing you put 10 bucks away when you're a kid. So I think it's work your ass off, invest in relationships, and then invest in being a monster physically. I think physical fitness is really important for young people.
Scott Galloway
Interesting. I thought it would have been edibles, Cialis, and...
Kara Swisher
Okay. Enjoy that once you have a certain level of financial security.
Scott Galloway
I see. Okay. All right. Okay. Yeah. Anyways, that's... We're going to move on. I felt very challenged there. I was very focused on my answer.
Kara Swisher
I know. It was an excellent answer. And you too can be an Olympic hopeful in synchronized swimming. I'd love to see you with a little hat on, a little nose plugged.
Scott Galloway
In the bathing suit? You look kind of good. You look kind of good in that.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I got more legs than a bucket of chicken. That's what you always say. I've got great legs for a woman. That's what you always say. We're not focusing on those right now. I've been clipping my legs, which I realize is a disturbing image. Time for the big story.
Scott Galloway
Time for the big story.
Kara Swisher
Data shows that car company Toyota is a company that has donated the most money to Republicans who voted against certifying the presidential election. A liberal watch group called Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington found that Toyota had given $55,000 to 37 GOP objectors this year. The Japanese car company has given twice as much to Republicans as the next largest company on the list, called Cubicor, and more than the Koch Industries. A Toyota spokesman told Axios they do not believe it is appropriate to judge members of Congress solely based on their votes on the electoral certification. And so it was interesting because a lot of companies ran away from these people and said they weren't giving. A lot of the tech companies. And here's Toyota who sells Priuses. Who do they think buys Priuses? It's certainly not... There's no Venn diagram of Priuses and these voters. But what do you think, Scott?
Scott Galloway
Look, I think you hate the game, not the player here. I think Toyota is just trying to spread it around so they can get, when they build a plant in Arkansas, they get the most subsidies. I think all these big companies play that game. I think they almost sort of have to. I think until we have some sort of campaign... I don't think Toyota decided "we like the insurrection." I just think it's oversight. And the examination of the data is important and holding them accountable. But at the end of the day, until we have campaign finance reform, until we stop having senators that are coin-operated, such as the senior senator from Florida, who is not only a whore, but an incredibly cheap whore. I'm talking, of course, about Senator Marco Rubio. He got that report released for aliens, but go ahead. He's doing that job, whatever.
Kara Swisher
OK. Yeah, look, I don't think it's awful. And it's awful. It's again, it's across our ecosystem. We have decided... I mean, did you see the shit on Roths, the savings accounts?
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
It now ends up the billionaires are using this vehicle. Lowered the Roths.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Middle class people were given a financial instrument to save $2,000 a year. And then billionaires have been selling themselves massive amounts of stock for less than $2,000 such that they can aggregate billions of dollars tax free. And then everyone... Senator Ron Wyden, Democrat, you know, claimed surprise and shock. And to his credit, he did propose a bill. But it's like they knew all this shit. They have been so co-opted by money. Peter Thiel is high-fiving himself for this. He thinks he shouldn't give money to these people. He doesn't think they deserve any money, the government. And so he's high-fiving himself for being able to pull this off. I don't think he cares at all.
Kara Swisher
The only one who cared was Warren Buffett, but he still did it a lot on his tech stuff. That was a different mechanism, though.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, but they have been overrun. They've been overrun with money, and they've been overrun with the idolatry, even worse than this, the idolatry of money. And that is they think billionaires are our most... I'm so sick of hearing people say "We've got to reward our most productive citizens." I'm like, okay, these are our most fortunate citizens that need to start giving back. But this notion somehow that money hasn't... We don't have a counterbalance to billionaires and money. And these corporate banks. Washington is supposed to be a counterbalance, not the whore. They're supposed to be the one that is keeping in check power.
Kara Swisher
I do. Besides the righteous indignation of people who own Priuses. I mean, I think people who bought that brand are like, "Wait a minute. Why am I...?" You know, I think there are more consumers. Where's my money going?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, where's my money going?
Kara Swisher
Just a minute. Because a lot of companies did say, "I'm not giving money, at least in this next election cycle." A lot of companies. It wasn't just tech companies. A lot of companies. To the people who voted against certification in this case. And you pay for your votes. That's it. If you don't... And a lot of companies did do it. And it might have been virtue signaling. But I think a lot of consumers... I tweeted, you know, I decided not to buy. You say you bought a Hyundai. What was your tweet?
Scott Galloway
No, Kia. I said I decided against the Toyota Sedition and picked the Kia Sorento because it had more USB ports and 100% less insurrection. And people went crazy. It was interesting. I was sort of surprised. I did it late last night just as a joke.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but when you buy a Kia, what you're really saying to the world is that you have a dependable, regular, consistent source of sex. Because you will never get new sex with a Kia. So what you're saying to the world, you're really bragging with a Kia. You're saying, "I have that part of my life taken care of."
Scott Galloway
The Kia is wonderful. You know, a lot of people... Kia is a wonderful car. I got a hybrid. I tried to get an electric. I couldn't get one. But let me just say, it's a lovely car. And in the parking garages, people are always like, "What is this?" All the parking guys are like, "What is this?" They love it. I was like, "It's $30,000 less than a Volvo. That's what this is." This is what this is. It's a hybrid. It gets amazing. It's like 45 miles to the gallon. It's great.
Kara Swisher
You should get Peacock. Peacock. I mean, literally. You're strange because on some levels you have fantastic taste. But Kia?
Scott Galloway
No, the Kia is a great car. You're excited about your Kia? You're going to be shocked by the Kia. I'm telling you, I get stopped.
Kara Swisher
Which model is it?
Scott Galloway
The Sorento. It's got three sets of seats. I won't go into why it needs three sets of seats. But I was not using a car, and now I have to. There's a reason.
Kara Swisher
My midlife crisis just won't let me get near a Kia. I can barely even say it.
Scott Galloway
You are going to love the Kia. We're going to go for a ride in the Kia. We're going to go out clubbing in the Kia.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, here we go. More empty promises. More empty promises. Me and you in the Kia.
Scott Galloway
Me and you in the Kia.
Kara Swisher
Nonetheless, I almost bought a Toyota Highlander, and I'm glad I didn't. Honestly, I'd be pissed.
Scott Galloway
You were going to buy a Highlander?
Kara Swisher
I was going to buy a bike. Jesus Christ.
Scott Galloway
Why don't... I mean, I'm not even going to go. It was $20,000 more than the Volvo. What, are you going to put a German Shepherd in the back and watch The L Word on streaming? I mean, Jesus Christ.
Kara Swisher
Let's get back to these people. I think you're going to see an uptick in money to these people again after Toyota decided to just forge ahead. And all the Prius owners are losing their ever-loving minds.
Scott Galloway
Wait, wait, I'm sorry. An uptick in money to who?
Kara Swisher
To these insurrection people. These people who voted for the insurrection essentially by voting against election certification. You think they're going to get more money?
Scott Galloway
I think they are going to... These companies that said they aren't going to give to them are going to start giving back to them if they need to.
Kara Swisher
Oh, of course.
Scott Galloway
I think Toyota is just doing what... You're right. Of course. But I'm glad that at least the people who buy Priuses know, the lesbians and the people from Berkeley know where their money is going.
Kara Swisher
Actually, lesbians buy the Subaru. So, anyway, Kia, it's the way to go. All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. We'll be back to talk BuzzFeed going public via SPAC and a friend of Pivot from Microsoft.
BREAK
Scott, we're back. BuzzFeed is planning to go public via SPAC. No surprise. We talked about this possibility several times. The digital publisher produces equal parts viral content and occasional hard-hitting reporting. They announced plans to go public through a merger with a SPAC that will be valued at $1.5 billion, quite substantively less than they were a while back, but nonetheless, it's a big number. It also announced it is acquiring Complex, a pop culture news outlet, in a deal for a total of about $300 million, $100 million in stock, $200 million in cash. So what do you think about this? This is the beginning. Obviously, Vox is right behind them, would be my guess. But nonetheless, what do you think about this SPAC situation for BuzzFeed?
Scott Galloway
I'm excited. There haven't been a lot of media IPOs. The digital media ecosystem is terrible. Kids come to my office hours and I think, "I'm thinking of going to work in digital media." I'm like, "Well, as long as you're going to work for Google or Facebook, otherwise it's a shitty business." And digital media companies, sans the triopoly of Google, Facebook, and Amazon, it's like joining the Yellow Pages. You're in a declining business. And it's nice to see BuzzFeed, 15 years old, a lot of pivots. I think they've got good leadership. I'm glad they're going public. I'm glad to see there's some oxygen in the digital media ecosystem.
I did look at their investor presentation. What's interesting is that media is really moving more towards e-commerce and affiliate deals as opposed to straight advertising. Advertising is a terrible business. Ad-supported media is a very difficult business. Where they're moving is where a lot of media players are moving. They're going vertical with their content and either doing affiliate deals. It's just like you write an article on cookware and they introduce their own cookware line or they just have an affiliate deal with Amazon. They're going vertical into these businesses. So at my online ed startup, Section 4, we use all our media to drive business to try and get signups for our online ed courses.
Because the reality is an ad-supported media doesn't work, but affiliate or vertical-based media does work. And I think that's where BuzzFeed is headed.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's interesting because the Los Angeles Times, the owner and the new editor, Kevin Merida, were talking about it not as a newspaper, but like a whole media conglomerate company, an entertainment company. It's just interesting. And the other thing is the buying of Complex, which is interesting. They obviously got some sort of PIPE that they could do this, which is the money they get also into the SPAC. But acquiring things when you're doing these SPACs to try to get stronger is one way of doing it. You have to bulk up and stuff like that. So what does it say about the popularity of SPACs?
Scott Galloway
Well, here's the thing. There's a massive amount of capital out there trying to find a target. And the adult in the room is, you brought it up as the PIPE. Because typically you raise around $200 to $300 million in equity. And if you're trying to get a billion-and-a-half-dollar deal done, you have to show up with debt financing or stable financing in the form of the PIPE. And there have been adults in the room saying, "No, this company isn't worth that. We're not going to do the PIPE." But a public currency, and then you go to Complex, which also struck me as an e-commerce company masquerading as a media company, again, around e-commerce. Merchandise. There's a lot of merch on that site. But if they can get out and have a public currency, which is very attractive to targets, this is going to be a consolidation play. I think there's a lot of broken digital media companies out there.
Kara Swisher
So what would they buy? What would they buy next? Complex is one.
Scott Galloway
Well, if we don't get out in the next six months, they'll buy Vox. That's the bottom line. You're either going to consolidate or you're a consolidatee. I mean, so BuzzFeed does about $350 million in revenue, $30 million in EBITDA. They say $1.5 billion. It'll be very interesting to see how this trades. If a billion-and-a-half-dollar valuation, that's 50 times EBITDA, which is a lot for a media company. It's five times revenue, which isn't a lot on revenue. But usually media companies are much more profitable than this. So it'll be just very interesting to see how this stock trades. So I know with Vox, we have lower revenue numbers, but we're more profitable. And it'll be interesting to see how the market compares and contrasts it to which it likes more. Does it like bigger revenue, lower profit margins, or does it like a smaller, more traditional media? That's always been the story between the two companies, honestly.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, but traditional media typically looks more like Vox, where it's very profitable.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, what do you think? What are your thoughts on BuzzFeed?
Scott Galloway
I think you're right. I don't think it'll buy Vox. I don't think that's... They've been sort of neck and necking it. That's been obviously bigger for a long time. But that valuation is quite a lot lower than in the salad days, same thing with Vox, I'm guessing. So what's interesting is who moves next? I would assume Vox will move next. There's a couple other companies that could, but they're the next one sort of in line to go, or get... Axios is selling. That's their move. It's all consolidating. And it would be interesting. What would be an interesting acquisition for Vox? Let's get Jim Bankoff some advice. What would he do if he had it?
Kara Swisher
I don't know. First of all, Vox is going to kick BuzzFeed's ass. I mean, just one question. How many at BuzzFeed, how many Olympic hopefuls in synchronized swimming do they have, Kara? How many?
Scott Galloway
You know, one of their high-profile reporters, Ryan Mack, just went to the New York Times, which is interesting. I would say there's a lot of interesting media companies out there for Vox, sort of the fancier ones that are around. There's some fancy ones that could be interesting.
Kara Swisher
Who are they?
Scott Galloway
It feels to me like podcasting is where we've kind of gotten a ton of traction. Podcasting. I mean, I see our numbers. We're ridiculously profitable.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
The Atlantic, things like that. There's a billionaire attached to that. You think Lauren Powell Jobs is going to sell the Atlantic?
Kara Swisher
No, maybe go public. I don't know. I'm just trying... There's lots of things. There's things like that. There's a lot of media properties like that that are interesting. Obviously, I think the acquisition of New York Magazine was interesting for Vox Media where we are. And we were attracted to it, right? We were attracted to the quality and stuff. So anyway, it's an interesting time for all these companies, but things are going to be happening. We'll see if Vox does a SPAC, but they would be among the others. And we'll see where they go, where all of these go. It'll be an interesting IPO for sure. The numbers were, you're right. I was like, wow, that doesn't make... that's not as much revenue as I thought. And it's also not as much profit. In any case, it's a very interesting move. And we will see what happens, Scott, but we'll just continue to make fantastically profitable things for them. And we'll see where that goes.
Scott Galloway
Speaking of media. You're Lester Holt. I'm Katie Couric. Synchronized skating. Wait, no, wait. I'm going to bring Katie on as a co-host while you're away. By the way, Scott's going away for August, and we're going to have to send ideas for us. Give the people a break.
Kara Swisher
Lester Holt. He'd be awesome. Lester Holt? Okay. All right. I heard Ando was going to your other thing. You didn't bring Ando over here, did you? And you give me a hard time for all my famous people I bring over to the other podcast that I'm cheating on you with.
Scott Galloway
Some relationships are just so special.
Kara Swisher
Ando was supposed to come over here, and he did not. So I could ask him questions about your relationship, and it didn't happen.
Scott Galloway
Well, I called in a favor because he's a very close, close friend.
Kara Swisher
Not true. Not true. Just saying. But anyways.
Scott Galloway
You're whining. I'm not going to put up with that. You're whining anymore.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, meanwhile, you bring on Tim Cook. Don't even go there. Don't even go here.
Scott Galloway
You know what? Ando, I'm just saying.
Kara Swisher
All right. Let's bring on our friend of Pivot, who's someone I've actually known a long time. Yusuf Mehdi is the Corporate Vice President of Modern Life, Search and Devices at Microsoft. I've known him for a long time. Scott is already giving him a hard time. He's Chuck-totting him, as we like to say here. Chuck-tot.
Scott Galloway
Chuck-tot.
Kara Swisher
Yusuf, how are you doing? How's it going?
Yusuf Mehdi
I'm doing great, Kara. It's been a long time. It's great to see you, and it's nice to be talking to you again.
Kara Swisher
I know. So tell us, what have you been doing? Just so you know, Scott, Yusuf and I go way back. He was running... we ran everything at Microsoft, right? You ran their media stuff. You ran, what else?
Yusuf Mehdi
Oh, I like to joke, I'm sort of like the Forrest Gump of Microsoft. I've been here for a while, and, you know, how Tom Hanks kind of haplessly wanders into all the fun things that are going on. I've been on Windows in the early days, Internet Explorer, when we started getting into that. And then later, MSN started Bing, launched Xbox One, Surface Pro, and now it's all come back together. Now it's all back together with Windows 11.
Kara Swisher
Windows 11. Yeah. All right. So, interesting. So how is that Surface? How is the big-ass table doing, Yusuf?
Yusuf Mehdi
Well, I don't know about the table, but the Surface Studio is the one. And those are doing great. I mean, I love those products. They're niche products, but for those people who use them, they love them.
Kara Swisher
I love that big-ass table. Anyway, let's talk about Windows 11. And Scott will have a whole bunch of questions, but you just introduced it. Satya did it. So talk about what does it mean for app makers and how are you looking at it? Just give us, and try not to do talking points. But one of the things I noticed was Satya took a whack at Apple for a second there with the App Store. But talk a little bit about Windows 11.
Yusuf Mehdi
Sure. The whole genesis of Windows 11 really is trying to learn from all the things we've had over the pandemic, over the last 18 months, where the PC has become central in our lives for video conferencing, for teaching our kids, for doing hybrid work. What we've tried to do is improve the platform and improve the user experience so that you can do new things, whether that's text message off your desktop or video conference call or play richer games. And if you're a creator or developer, change the policies so that you can have more success on Windows as a platform and a creator. We talked a little bit about, for example, on the store, Satya announced the fact that we've got a new store. One of the things we're doing is we're changing the fees in the store so that as a developer you can keep more of the revenue. So as other platforms, you keep 30%... on our platform, other platforms.
Kara Swisher
Other platforms. Who are you talking about, Yusuf? Who are you talking about, Yusuf?
Yusuf Mehdi
A variety of other app stores and ad platforms. And then the other thing you can do that's unique is if you bring your own commerce engine, you keep all of the revenue. That's a pretty unique thing. So if you're an app developer, if you're like Adobe Creative Cloud, you want to sell subscriptions, you can do that on Windows 11, and you keep all of the revenue versus give up 30%.
Kara Swisher
Okay, Scott, you must have a question here.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, so nice to meet you, Yusuf. You've had a front row seat in terms of technology over the last, I don't know, 20, 30 years. Give us what technology you think is most underhyped, that we're not talking enough about, that you think is going to have a bigger impact. And also, the more interesting one, name a technology you think is overhyped.
Yusuf Mehdi
Yeah, good questions there. I wonder if it can be overhyped and underhyped at the same time. But I definitely think mixed reality is going to be the next major wave of computing. It'll change gaming. It's going to change how devices... I know you were talking with Evan Spiegel recently on Spectacles, HoloLens. I think that is a profound change to computing and how you connect, how you talk with people, how you do hybrid work. I think that'll be a pretty big change. And the other one I think that is probably coming a lot is quantum computing. I think quantum and its ability to unlock the next level of algorithmic AI machine learning will be pretty profound. Those are the two I would say that are out there that I think will have big impact on computing.
Scott Galloway
What about overhyped? What's like space, AI, wearables? What do you think is probably not going to live up to the hope?
Yusuf Mehdi
In terms of... let's see, that's a good one. I think that, I mean, I would say space is probably one where we're going to put a lot of money out there for a long, long time. And I don't know if it'll get the returns. We could spend some of that money more effectively in the near term to improve the planet we're on. But, look, I know a lot of people have excitement and passion for it, and it's a thing that gets people lit up.
Scott Galloway
Is it okay if I have another question?
Kara Swisher
Oh, yeah, go ahead. Go ahead, Scott.
Scott Galloway
I get the sense Yusuf and I are bonding.
Kara Swisher
I see. Okay. All right. Just bond with Yusuf. Go ahead.
Scott Galloway
So, look, people talk about great turnarounds. They talk about Apple. They talk about IBM. I think Microsoft, it never did poorly, but it kind of went flat for a good eight or ten years, at least at stock price. And then all of a sudden, just this unbelievable, I don't know if you call it renaissance, but most valuable company in the world for a brief time last year and is doing incredibly well. If you tried to distill down the secret sauce or the culture of Microsoft that you think if you had to point to one thing about the culture that has created this, the most valuable company in the world or one of the top two or three in the last, it's really been over the last five or seven years. It seems like it's really kind of out of resurgence. What would you point to in the culture of the people?
Yusuf Mehdi
Well, I think the big one, Scott, and it's really under Satya's tutelage now as CEO, was a move from a kind of know-it-all culture to a learn-it-all culture. And it came about pretty quiet but pretty fast right from the get-go. He just started embodying it in all of the meetings and all of the product reviews where he would come in and he would just start asking questions, "Hey, how are we doing this? Why is this working? What do we need to learn?" If something went wrong, he'd say, "What did we learn?" He had a much more open, inclusive culture, much more about accessibility and his sensibility of where to focus and saying, "Look, it can't just be about the broad business we're trying to drive.
How are we helping individual people?" It took a little while, but that changed. The other part that changed was, Microsoft is a very competitive place, a lot of smart people, a lot of people trying to be the best at what they do. And he instilled a, "We're all going to work together. We're all going to work on making others great. And we're going to build on the ideas of others." Two things that historically is not something that you do a lot in tech companies, right? There's a lot of "not invented here." "I'm going to rewrite the thing that you did." He would push constantly against that. If someone did something great, use that code, use that idea, build on top.
And I think that's changed the culture. And so the level of innovation, the culture, how we approach new problems. I mean, it's night and day.
Kara Swisher
So, Yusuf, when you're thinking, speaking of night and day, Windows 11. Now Windows used to be this sort of scary operating system, attracting the attention of government, attracting the attention of the press and everything else. And now when you're introducing this, you're talking about open, you're talking about freedom, you're like, "Free us from the platforms," which were Google and Apple, essentially. When you look at how Windows fits into the ecosystem now, it's not dominant for sure. How do you look at what Windows is going forward? Where does it sit in the stack, I guess?
Yusuf Mehdi
Yeah, it's a great question. I'll say something, and maybe this will sound a little corny to you, Kara. Maybe you'll give me some grief on it. But I think one of the things that we've prided ourselves on with Windows is that it is this platform for creation. Satya talked about it being the platform for platform creators and a stage for creation. Our aspiration is that anyone can come and write a great new app, a great new service, and they can go on and become a platform. And maybe that platform becomes bigger than Windows. It's kind of good to go back through history and realize, look, Google happened on Windows. The ads platform that they run, which is just dominant and hugely successful. Facebook grew up on Windows. Now it's big on mobile, but it started on the PC. Amazon. And all of these things have become platforms in their own right. And they started on Windows. And in some ways, they're bigger than Windows. I think our aspiration is that continues to happen. But that we are the best platform. We are the place that creators do want to come first. And that's kind of our goal and our desire.
Kara Swisher
It's also a particularly good message right now with regulatory scrutiny. Microsoft seems to have gotten out of quite a bit of it, including some of this new antitrust legislation. It's focused on mobile. It's focused on a lot of things where Microsoft had a big miss in the mobile space with its phone. How do you look at how you all stand in terms of regulating? You're just as big. You're the second $2 trillion company. You're very powerful in your sectors, whether it's cloud or wherever, gaming in different places. How has Microsoft escaped that? And actually, you were front and center of regulatory scrutiny, and now you're seen as not that. How do you look at that? And are there things to be worried about with Microsoft?
Yusuf Mehdi
We feel very much that, look, we're in the mix and we're in the conversation on all these things. We're not in any way sort of immune from review. I think the role of big tech is being asked, and those questions are rightly asked, whether it's what's the role of responsible AI to, is big tech fostering the appropriate amount of innovation? And look, we're part of that process. And so we have a role to play. Probably the only difference is that we've gone through this cycle. We've been through it where we had regulatory review. We had to kind of work through all that process. We had to take painful change, as I think was talked about in the past. And I think we've gotten to the other side. And we know the benefits of working with the government, working with regulators, and delivering on these things because it's the right thing to do. And so I don't think we're immune from things that people are talking about, but I do feel we're down the path.
Scott Galloway
Along those lines, do you think that we need more stringent antitrust?
Yusuf Mehdi
The thing I do think, let me answer it this way. I feel like we need more competition. We need more competition in all parts of the industry. And so I know Brad talked about, hey, we'd love to see more competition and more choice on iPhone with search. And we think that would be good for everyone. Obviously, it'd be good for Microsoft, so there's no question about that. But I think it'd be good for everyone. We'd love to see more competition in app stores. We'd love to be able to see people be able to bring different types of capabilities to the platform. And so, you know, we need that. How you go about that, I'm less expert. But the fact that we need it, we absolutely believe we need that. We need more competition everywhere.
Kara Swisher
So I want to pivot over to the game space. One of the areas you've worked on is Xbox, obviously. Now, one of the things Microsoft is doing is much more in the cloud gaming and different aspects of gaming. Obviously, you still have Xbox itself. This has been a big priority for the company. You've bought things. Where is it going? Do you see yourself buying more? Could you buy Epic, for example? Where do you see, where's the priority there?
Yusuf Mehdi
Well, we look at gaming as a company as probably one of our most exciting growth areas. We think that, as you know, gaming is the fastest growing segment of entertainment. It's growing faster than movies, music, TV, you name it. And it's growing in such a rapid way. When you look at the market, we think there's three billion gamers out there on the planet, a huge part of the population. It's a $200 billion TAM. And as I said, it's growing faster. Right now the gaming world has been segmented into three buckets: console gaming, PC gaming, and casual tablet/phone gaming. And those have all been distinct. We want to break that apart. We want to bring those together. We want you to be able to game with the people you want on the devices you want, from wherever you want. And with Xbox Game Pass and with this new xCloud game streaming service, we think we can bring that to bear and have that work. You're starting to see some of that now with the announcements we've made that 27 of the 30 games we announced at E3, you'll be able to play on the PC and they'll be in the Game Pass. So you'll be able to play them on PC and console. We think that's a big opportunity.
Kara Swisher
Does that mean consoles don't matter anymore?
Yusuf Mehdi
No, no, consoles absolutely still matter. And for many people who love console gaming, it will be the most immersive, rich place to play. So there's no doubt about that. But we do think this idea that you can game on any device and you can game on your PC and on your console. A big part of where we think the innovation goes is it's less about the hardware and more about the user experience, more about the gaming community, Xbox Live as we have it, and the actual games, the content studios. And as you mentioned, Kara, we've been excited to welcome folks like ZeniMax and Bethesda and a bunch of other gaming studios now. We've really grown the gaming studios at Microsoft to bring these great games for people.
Scott Galloway
So Yusuf, you can't get to the point you're at at Microsoft. You're a good manager, for lack of a better term. When you look at other companies, what company would you argue is the best managed company? Not necessarily the most successful, but has the best culture, best management? Outside of Microsoft, obviously.
Yusuf Mehdi
Let me think about that one. And I know you're a professor here at a university, so I feel like I'm getting quizzed here. Let me think about who would be a good managed company. I would say that...
Scott Galloway
Who else would you want to work for? If you were going to leave Microsoft, what company would you want to join?
Yusuf Mehdi
That's a good one too. I myself, this is not necessarily why I think it's a better game, but I love just the creation of stories. I love the way Pixar and movies are created. I love what they've done to tell stories, but use technology and animation to tell them in much, much richer ways.
Kara Swisher
So Disney?
Yusuf Mehdi
Yeah, yeah.
Kara Swisher
Disney? You just asked, does that... Yeah, Disney.
Yusuf Mehdi
Yeah. Disney, yeah.
Kara Swisher
Okay, I have one final question, and Scott might have one more. So this pandemic, as we're moving through it, all the tech companies have done well. You've had this massive growth with Teams and different things and people, as you were saying, using Windows and everything else. What do you see coming next? What is happening post-pandemic, both for Microsoft as a company in terms of presence, whether you're going to do a hybrid system or in-person or remote? And then what do you think the big important things going forward are going to be for tech in general? They've done great in the pandemic, and so has Microsoft. I hate to say that, but it's fair. It's a fair assessment of how you all have done.
Yusuf Mehdi
Yeah. So I think that we very much envision a hybrid work environment going forward. We think that it was a very painful period with the pandemic, but we've learned some important things. The benefit of being able to have meetings where meetings are more inclusive because in the Teams window, for example, anyone can ask a question. People can chat. You can have sort of background conversations. That's a fabulous thing that we learned from hybrid. The ability to be able to be more informal, be able to kind of blend work and life. We think that's a super powerful thing. I think that's going to continue forward.
The software that we will build, the services we will build, are going to be built with that in mind. So that when you roam from device to device, your files can roam with you automatically. When you undock your Windows tablet and you connect it to a big screen, all of the state of what you were doing on the big screen can go small and can go big again. We're going to do a lot of work in that software to enable that hybrid environment. I think that is a big part of the future of where we'll go. And not just in technology, but in that inclusivity in terms of how we're bringing different people into the conversation.
We think that's a big part of where we'll go. And then, over time, the thing that we talked about, HoloLens, the ability to work remotely, to be present, whether someone's getting dialed in virtually or in an augmented way, I think that's a huge part of the future of where not only work will go, but gaming will go and social networking, social media.
Kara Swisher
HoloLens, finally, it will be its day. Scott, last question.
Scott Galloway
What do you think is the biggest challenge facing America right now? Do you think it's climate change? Do you think it's income inequality? Do you think it's tech overrunning D.C.? If you were just as a citizen, what are you most concerned about?
Yusuf Mehdi
I'm most concerned about our educational system and how we're preparing kids and students to learn and to grow. When I look at other countries, I think they're far ahead in terms of how they're helping students learn, how that curriculum. And I feel that we need to do a lot more to help our kids really get their brains around all of the things that are happening, not just in technology and in STEM, but just broadly through citizenship. And so I think education is an area where I feel I would love to see us as a country do more.
Kara Swisher
All right, Yusuf, it's good talking to you. Thank you for coming on. Good luck with Windows 11. Are you ever going to buy a phone company? Do you think? Do you feel like you all need to have one? You've got your consoles, you've got your operating system on PCs. Do you all need a phone?
Yusuf Mehdi
I think right now our focus is really to make our devices, our software and services work great with other phones. I think there's a lot more we can do there.
Kara Swisher
I heard Motorola's for sale.
Yusuf Mehdi
I didn't get... Motorola's for sale?
Kara Swisher
They've been down that road. Remember Nokia? That was very passive-aggressive. You know what? I like the Microsoft phone. I did. I thought that was a good phone. It just was too late. That's the issue.
Yusuf Mehdi
Yeah. Yeah, I agree with you, Kara. We were late. It was a good phone.
Kara Swisher
Do you remember when Ballmer used to say, "Put down those iPhones!" He would scream at people.
Yusuf Mehdi
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
It's early, but have you tried a Surface Duo yet?
Yusuf Mehdi
No, but I perhaps I shall. People love it.
Kara Swisher
Perhaps I shall. People love it. By the way, no one should know this, but Yusuf actually had an iPhone when you're not supposed to over there at Microsoft. He snuck one, as I recall. Yusuf.
Yusuf Mehdi
I did.
Kara Swisher
He's a rebel.
Yusuf Mehdi
I'm a rebel.
Kara Swisher
He did. He's a rebel. No, he's not. Anyway, Yusuf, thank you so much.
Scott Galloway
Nice meeting you, Yusuf. Good luck.
Yusuf Mehdi
Nice to meet you, Scott. Thank you, Kara. Great to talk to you.
Kara Swisher
Okay, Scott, one more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Ad Break
Okay, Scott, wins and fails. I'm going to go first. Fast and Furious 9 is doing well at the box office. I am going to go see it this week, I think, collecting $70 million over the weekend in the United States. Obviously, I love all the Fast and Furiouses.
Scott Galloway
Good. I think movies like this will do well at physical movie theaters. I would agree. I just still think it's a small business, and it will only be these big mega-blockbusters. I don't think people are going to make it. People like working from home, just like they do with work. But I'm glad to see these mega ones work really well in physical spaces. You heading to Fast and Furious 9 in your Kia Sorento and your Nokia phone sends a lot of mixed signals. It's very hard to understand what you are trying to say to the world.
Kara Swisher
Fast and Furious. Because I'm complex.
Scott Galloway
You're unexpected.
Kara Swisher
I had a minivan when I was in my 20s, Scott. I'm not even going to go into it, but I had a minivan.
Scott Galloway
A minivan in your 20s?
Kara Swisher
Before I had my 4,000 children, yes, indeed I did. I had a minivan by myself. I used to like pushing the button and saying, "Get in," to people.
Scott Galloway
That's right. That's interesting. I'm a complex... I contain multitudes, Scott Galloway. You'll find out.
Kara Swisher
No, you're complex. We're going out in the Sorento. You and I are going. Here we go. We're going to play some Katy Perry. Perhaps some Nicki Minaj. And we are going to have some good times together. Alright, what's your... That is my win. And you're going to introduce me to the hot one from The L Word. What's her name again? I forgot her name.
Scott Galloway
Jennifer Beals. Perhaps.
Kara Swisher
Probably not. I'm inviting her to Code, so I will see if she will speak to you, but you need to not stalk her in any way. Code's on fire. Am I speaking out of school here? On fuego. Scott, you're sold out?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, we're selling out. Yeah.
Kara Swisher
Congratulations on that. It's back. The United States is back. I wonder how much of that is people just want to get out.
Scott Galloway
Yes, exactly right. And it's also a good program. We have a lot of good stuff going on. The last day is all the digital body. We're going to do things too, Scott. We're going to experiment on Scott. Someone's going to shoot me up with tea. There's going to be psychedelics. There might be some marijuana. It's going to be good.
Kara Swisher
It's going to be good. All right, Scott, what is your wins and fails? I've heard that stuff is good. I wouldn't know, but I've heard it's pretty good.
Scott Galloway
Okay, my win is BuzzFeed. They've been around 15 years. I think they've persevered. I think it's nice to have other... they really haven't been many media IPOs. I'm trying to think, well, it's Snap. I mean, it's been kind of a desert. So I think it's great. I hope they get out. I hope the stock trades well and good for them. They've been around 15 years.
Kara Swisher
Very nice. Yeah, right? Good for them. Entrepreneurs, they seem like smart people. They pivoted a couple times, so good for them.
Scott Galloway
My fail is sort of what I would call, you know, this isn't us. America is supposed to have the best airports in the world, the best CDC in the world. When hurricanes happen, we rescue our citizens. We don't put them in stadiums. And our buildings don't pancake. And it's just America is less American right now than I think it's been in a long time. And we need to stop this what I call reallocation of effort and capital and love from the middle class in America and our infrastructure to corporations and the wealthy. And I know that sounds like class warfare, but rich people aren't getting pancaked.
Rich people get the vaccine. Rich people, corporations are doing just fine. It's America and the pillars. We just don't seem to want to pay for anything anymore because the people who control the government can opt out of roads. They can opt out of health concerns. So it strikes me that the tragedy in Florida, I think, is another example, a very stark example of how America is becoming less American. We make forward-leaning investments in our bridges, in our tunnels, in our airports, and we stop doing that. And we need to start again. Anyways, I really hope this pushes the infrastructure bill over the finish line because you go to other countries now and you're flying to China and you see the incredible airports.
Kara Swisher
I think it will. But again.
Scott Galloway
Well, that used to be us, right? That used to be us.
Kara Swisher
That's true. But I got to say, climate change still. I don't care. Right now, Pacific Northwest, speaking of Microsoft, where Microsoft is located, expected to reach 114 degrees in Portland, Oregon. That is craziness. 114? 114 degrees. 108, 114 Seattle, all of these places, which really, it's crazy what's going on. It may be 102 degrees on Saturday at Seattle-Tacoma International Airport, setting a record. And that means wildfires. That means everything else. And so, it's fascinating because they don't have air conditioners in Seattle. And same thing with San Francisco. I didn't have it. I'm going to have to probably buy an air conditioner for my house there because it's these excessive heat warnings for Washington, Oregon, California, Idaho, Nevada. These are the new normals. And we have to think about it. Biggest fail of the human race is not to address this one really in a really significant way. So anyway, that is the show, Scott. We'll be back Friday for more. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit your question for the Pivot podcast. The link is also in our show notes. Scott, you Olympian, read us out.
Scott Galloway
Olympic hopeful, Scott Galloway. Why not, right? Why not? Today's show was produced by Rebecca Sinanis, and Andrew Todd engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts. I'm out of breath. I'm at 5,000 feet and I can barely breathe. Or if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts. If you liked our show, please recommend it to a friend. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Silver medalists in synchronized swimming. Fantastic legs.