Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics including the rise of AI, the impact of Elon Musk's behavior on his brand and businesses, the politics of the US, and the latest news in tech and business.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Tron Ares has arrived. I would like you to meet Ares, the ultimate AI soldier. He is biblically strong and supremely intelligent. You think you're in control of this? You're not. On October 10th... What are you? My world is coming to destroy yours. But I can help you. The war for our world begins in IMAX. Tron Ares. Rated PG-13. May be inappropriate for children under 13. Only in theaters October 10th. I agree with Marsha Blackburn. Whatever. I'm with you, Marsha, today. Just today. That's it.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot, New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. Scott is off today sailing in some place, maybe Ibiza, who knows. So in his place, I brought someone actually smart, a fantastic co-host, Kristen Soltis Anderson, who is a pollster, a contributing opinion writer for the New York Times and co-founder of Echelon Insights. I was on the Chris Wallace show with her and she is a Republican pollster. I am obviously, well, I don't know what I am. Anyway, welcome, Kristen.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Thank you so much for having me. I miss our weekly get-togethers with Chris Wallace refereeing.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I know. They're quite good, but you're never really like, you're always so reasonable and then you convince me of things I don't want to be convinced of. So that's why I'm having you here today. But there's a ton going on. What are you up to mostly right now? I mean, obviously, you've been inundated with information as a pollster, right? There's a ton of stuff going on. So you've got the tariffs that next week, we will see 90 deals, 90 days. Does that work out? So lots of people interested in what's public opinion on tariffs in the economy, everything that's going on in the Middle East. Do people feel safe? Do they feel unsafe? What's their reaction now that we've had a little bit of time to digest what happened. And then, of course, what's going on with one big, beautiful bill and the many different ways you can try to gauge, do Americans even know what this bill is? And from what they've seen, do they even like it?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Right. Which they don't, right? I mean, we'll get to that. We'll get to all those things. You have some things to talk about today.
Kara Swisher
Do you, right now, when you are doing polling, there's so much polling out there and there's so much internet polling and everything else. Talk just a tiny bit about the business because people like don't trust polls, but they're glued to them at the same time. So give me an idea of how you figure this out when you're in this pool of info.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
You're right. It's very much one of those like the portions are terrible and so small kind of situations where people will say that I hate polls, I don't trust polls, but they seem to know exactly what's going on in the polling averages. Look, distrust of polls or skepticism of polls is completely natural. I understand it. Oftentimes polls are used to do something they are not built to do. They are not actually great at predicting down to within a point or two how a fluid situation might turn out a week or two down the road. And so I get why people are skeptical.
The other challenge we're facing is technology makes it easier for me as a pollster to find you and ask you questions. And it makes it easier for you as a respondent to evade me, ignore me, block me, and so on. And then you add to that the way that AI is going to change our industry. It's going to make it so that you have more hurdles to jump through as a pollster to try to make sure, are the people that I'm contacting and surveying really legitimate? Or are they bots? Are they bots that look an awful lot like people digitally? These are challenges that we as an industry are facing.
And really right now, the big thing that I am watching is there was a great Atlantic article, I think a week or two ago, that was about how teenagers are asking for landlines again. And gosh, the return of the landline would be like the greatest thing ever for pollsters. Because people answer the phone.
Kara Swisher
No one answers the phone anymore.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
No one answers the phone. Not at all.
Kara Swisher
But when you have so many of them out there, too, when they're doing them online, Elon Musk just did one. We'll talk about that in a minute, like about whether you should start an American party. He did one around a lot of things this week. He does it all the time, but he's not the only one. Everybody seems to have a hot take or I've polled these people. How do you stand out as an actual pollster with actual standards?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
So there are a couple of things you can do to stand out. One of them is you're not just looking for the cheapest, fastest data you can find. The reason why these panels exist of people that you can survey is not actually mostly for political purposes. It's because every brand under the sun has a marketing department that's trying to gauge how's our new ad campaign going? What do people think about our new consumer product? And so on, so forth. So most of these polling panels that a pollster in the political space is using don't first and foremost exist for political purposes.
Kara Swisher
Right. It's like, how do you like this Clorox or whatever.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Yeah, you have to be good at knowing how to take these panels that are made mostly to gauge what do people think about bleach or sneakers or anything and make it into something that looks really like what an electorate will look like. What we do at my firm, we use the voter file. It's the publicly available list of everybody who's a registered voter. It's pretty frequently updated in most states. And that can at least give you some ground truth of who is and isn't registered to vote, how often do each of those people vote or not vote? And that can help you have some sense that the people you're talking to are real people, they're registered voters, and you have a good idea of how often they are a voter.
Kara Swisher
And let's question, you do this thing for the New York Times. You have the same people that you talk to. Is that helpful? Because you're trying to gauge their opinion over time, correct?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
So for the New York Times, what's really fun is that's qualitative. We are bringing in eight to 12 people, depending on the group, to just talk to them for 90 minutes about what they think about a key issue. And there, you're getting real people. You're not getting bots. You're looking at each other face to face. You can see how they react to each other. And what's neat there is we have, as you mentioned, had times where we bring the same people back a year later. We did one like that around January 6th. We had some Republicans come one year after January 6th and tell us, OK, a year later, how are you feeling about this horrible thing that happened in our country. And then we had those same people back a year after that to see, okay, how had the horror of the day converted into belief in a conspiracy theory or just a belief it's not that big a deal and so on and so forth.
Kara Swisher
Oh, that's interesting. Now, one more question. Is there beefs between pollsters? There's beefs between journalists, that's for sure.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
For the most part, pollsters are all friends and that includes pollsters across the political aisle. So Republican and Democratic pollsters, we generally all view each other as part of the reality-based community who are trying to live in a world that is driven by data. And so you find a lot of these fun partnerships between Republican and Democratic pollsters that do not exist anywhere else in the political consulting space. You don't find Republican and Democratic ad makers working together that often, but you will find that in polling. The beef is less, you're right versus left, and it's more quality versus people who are peddling garbage. And the folks that are peddling garbage make it harder for the good pollsters to do their job because they quote lower prices, they set different market expectations and then they're the ones that are out there pushing narratives that you either have to debunk or...
Kara Swisher
Right, right. And it doesn't really matter if they're right or not, right? They don't, they just move on to the next thing.
All right, so we've got a lot to get to today and you're bringing us some stats too. We're also going to talk about Paramount's settling with Trump and Trump's latest target, New York City mayoral candidate Zoran Mandani, who did spectacularly well now that the results are in. But first, so President Trump is hitting back at Elon Musk after days of Elon railing against Trump's big, beautiful bill, which just passed the Senate. Trump took aim at the government subsidies that Elon's companies received and said the country would save a fortune without them. He also threatened to sick Doge on Elon and said it would, quote, take a look at deporting Elon.
When asked about that, he also said Doge would eat Elon for some reason. I'm not sure why. After those comments, Elon said it was so tempting to escalate, but he would refrain for now. And I had predicted that he was going to slap back over this bill because he really, I know him pretty well previously, and this would bother him. He's been ramping up the rhetoric, posting on X that Republicans who vote for the bill will, quote, lose their primary next year if it's the last thing I do on this earth, okay? And after declaring that we live in a one-party country, the Porky Pig Party, Elon renews his calls to form a third party, the America Party, if the bill passes.
So we're going to talk about the bill in a moment. Let's start with the return of the few. Now, I am not surprised Elon erupted like this. I said he would when he did his first eruption and then apologized. But Tesla shares took a tumble on Tuesday, falling 5%. And this just came in. Tesla's global car sales fell sharply in the second quarter. Now he's expressing regret over his chainsaw stunt, saying it lacked empathy, you think. So he's threatening this third party. Let's start with this. You have some brand new polling on third parties in the United States, which has been tried and tried again, although it has happened in the United States several times.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Yeah, polling on this really shows that a lot of Americans don't think that the two existing political parties are meeting their needs, but there's really not a lot of consensus about what a third party would look like. And the bad news for Elon Musk is that this kind of libertarian type viewpoint is most likely not where you would find a real viable third party spring up. So I've been doing research at my firm for the last number of years where what we do is we ask people, do you think of yourself as liberal or conservative? But then we also ask them a bunch of issue questions to get their sense of, are you picking the conservative position on 10 out of 10 economic issues or 10 out of 10 social issues?
And then we kind of plot everybody out on a chart and we see where do people fall. And only 11 percent of voters are strong conservatives. They're picking the right wing position on almost everything. And only 13 percent of Americans pick the strong liberal position on everything. There's a lot of people that choose a little from column A, a little from column B. But the problem for the libertarians is only about five percent of people tend to choose a bunch of liberal social positions and a bunch of conservative fiscal positions. There are significantly more people who are the opposite, who take a more sort of socially, culturally conservative viewpoint, but then also believe that we should have robust government safety net and those sorts of things.
So the problem that Musk is going to run into is, yes, Americans don't love the two-party system. Yes, there's a hunger for a third party. But no, it doesn't necessarily look exactly like what I think Musk's politics look like.
Kara Swisher
Right. So what would that look like? Like they're socially conservative. That's interesting. Usually it was the socially liberal and fiscally conservative. That used to be kind of a thing from a lot of people in the center.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Right. And, you know, I do a lot of presentations to business leaders and I'll ask, how many of you in this room would describe yourselves as fiscally conservative, but socially moderate to progressive? And tons of hands go up. And the bad news for those folks is in the data, it's actually a very small portion of the electorate. We tried asking it a different way, where we gave people five different hypothetical parties to choose from. One is kind of a far-right nationalist populist type party. One is a more center-right, maybe old-school Republican party. One is a center-left labor party. One is a green party. And then one, we jokingly call it the Acela party, but that's not really what it's called. But it's this kind of Mike Bloomberg, socially moderate centrism. And that only gets 13% of voters.
Kara Swisher
Oh, wow. Which one gets the most?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
The most is the Labor Party.
Kara Swisher
To Bernie Sanders.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Well, so I don't know if I would say that's Bernie Sanders. I would think of it more almost as a maybe a John Fetterman setting aside. Like, I know he definitely has some views that are at odds with the Democratic majority on a couple cultural issues these days. But this idea of middle class economics, labor unions, tax the rich a little bit, support programs for those less well off. But it's not like break up big corporations like that's what we said for the Green Party. And that only got six percent in our polling. The more interesting thing, I think, to me, too, is that the right is really split. So while most Democrats coalesce into that kind of labor party type model, Republicans are very divided between this more old school, three legged school stool of conservatism, right? Strong military, strong families, limited government versus a like we're cracking down on illegal immigration. We're stopping political correctness. America first. That really does divide the right in our polling.
Kara Swisher
No foreign intervention, that kind of thing. So are they headed for a crack up in that way? It seems like once Trump is removed from the situation, there's a real crack up about to happen.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
It feels like Donald Trump is holding a lot of pieces together, that in the absence of a strong, dominating personality who has just captured this party entirely, those cracks would begin to show. A lot of this Musk feud reminds me of the Tea Party days. I think I described it on air once as like the reheated leftovers of the Republican Party's inter-family drama from like 2011. These fights feel familiar, but they feel old. They feel like they come from an era before Donald Trump came in and said, it's my way or the highway.
Kara Swisher
Right. But is there a chance for him to have a party in here? What would it be? If he said to you, Kristen, I want you to create a party for me, what would you advise him? And he's going to give you a pile of money and you'll do it, right? I don't know if you would, but you should because you would be a good influence on him. What would you advise him? Elon, this is the party you need to start.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
So I think he's got some good instincts in the sense of being anti-establishment, right? I think the problem that too many attempts to start a third party have had is that they have been too captive by existing establishment or it's like elites driving it. And so your sort of average American is like, well, I want a third party, but maybe not that. He is, of course, an elite himself. But I think he is more comfortable breaking out of that sort of elite bubble. And so I think there's something about the anti-establishment vibe you would need to pull this off. But I do think that this idea of just slashing government and that being the main thing you're all about, that's tough to build a party around because, Republicans, they love to cut spending.
They love to talk about it at least, but the political reality of the popularity of cutting spending is very different. And so if you can talk a big game about it, but then when push comes to shove, what is it that you want to cut? Doge has already cut most of the things now that were politically low-hanging fruit. And I think we're going to see some thermostatic backlash to some of this, too. Like four and eight is something I've seen in poll after poll was pretty popular to cut. Well, now that we've cut it, we're going to see the consequences of that. Wouldn't surprise me if all of a sudden funding for foreign aid becomes more popular than it was five years ago, precisely because we've now cut it.
Kara Swisher
Interesting. So one of the things he said is he lacked empathy. Again, polling on him is terrible, right? Correct? The biggest brand Scott talks about this the biggest brand diminishment and it affecting his businesses. If you were hired by Tesla or Starlink or whatever, what would you say he do? He said he lacked empathy. That's a little step towards I was an asshole, right? I shouldn't have been such an asshole, essentially. What do you say to someone like that to get his brand back to where it was?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Probably never. Yeah, this is part of why I'm surprised that he's picking the fight again, because I think he had an opportunity to say, I went in, I was trying to do things that I thought would be good for the country. I made some progress on some things. I didn't get some other things done. I'm now turning back to my businesses and I'm gonna focus in on the core things that Americans thought were really cool about me before I got into politics, that they think I'm a really smart person. They think I'm really innovative. They think I'm building things that are cool and are going to change life on this planet.
I would encourage him to go back to those brand attributes like less chainsaw, more Mars. And that to me feels like it would be the smartest short to medium term play for him in order to kind of rebuild his brand. I mean, I don't know that he's ever going to be back to like strong favorables among Democrats, but I mean, we live in a world where anything's possible. People love reinvention. And I think if he goes back to the things that have traditionally made people think he is a voice worth listening to, those attributes can still exist. They've just been blocked out by so much of the noise and the insanity.
Kara Swisher
The insanity. But at the same time, right now, Democrats are not reaccepting him. And now Republicans, who we thought were his new customers, are now not accepting him because he fought with Trump. And he continues to fight with Trump. Even if he doesn't name him, that's exactly who he's fighting with. And he is going to, when he says, I can respond for now, he is going to escalate. There's no question in my mind he's going to escalate. What do you think escalation will look like from Musk? Because when he talks about how he's going to go primary every Republican that votes for this bill, that's a lot of people to primary, like the nuts and bolts of politics, of going in and finding a viable challenger, building their name ID, taking out an incumbent. That's hard to do in a handful of races, much less taking out almost the entire Republican conference. I think he's going to find that that's more challenging than he thinks if he really tries it. But what do you think escalation would look like from him?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I think he'll, like he said, he's going to back Thomas Massey. Where is he polling, right? He's the one that pushes back on Trump. He's been the one who hasn't backed down in that regard. And Trump has threatened him. Now, the other two Trump threatened are leaving, essentially, whether it's Tillis or Don Bacon or whoever. Trump definitely has levers he can pull. Trump can make Elon Musk's life very difficult. I am skeptical about how difficult Elon Musk can make Trump's life.
Kara Swisher
Right, right. That he could do something. What would, if he wanted to, what would be the best thing he could do? He shouldn't insult Trump, correct? I think he's not going to resist. I think he's going to go back to Epstein. I think he's going to go, I don't know. I feel like scorched earth is his kind of policy in lots of ways. He doesn't care.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I think the smartest business leaders in this crazy political moment are the ones that try to stay as far away as possible from anything partisan and from anything involving directly addressing Donald Trump. If the word Donald Trump is coming out of your mouth, you have created problems for yourself. The way I describe the Trump effect on everything is that science experiment you can do as a kid where you put a bunch of pepper into a dish and then you put like a drop of dish soap in the middle and all the pepper like flies out to the side of the dish. That's what happens anytime Trump gets involved in anything. Everything flies out to the side. And that's a terrible way to run your business when you need to be reaching customers across a political coalition, you need to be maintaining favorability from stakeholders. Donald Trump is the drop of dish soap that just makes everything fly to the sides. And so Musk, he has gotten himself tangled up in Trump. He had benefited from that by being a very powerful individual for a while. But there is a trade-off there. And that gamble does not always work out well for everybody.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So Trump can do him more damage. Eventually, he'll be able to do more damage. This guy didn't blow up rockets for no good. I'm just saying he's a blow up rocket kind of fella. That's my feeling is that he is, and he could do damage in the constant drumbeat of things. You know what I mean? Like, if he was a normal person and he cared about blowing up his businesses, that's one thing. I don't think he cares. Math is very important to him and this math doesn't work, right? And so he couldn't hold it in. You'd think he wouldn't say anything about the bail, but he can help himself. He cannot. You saw how little control he had over himself, right? Physically and mentally and everything else. But he really doesn't. And it's not a game. It's not a, I don't know. We'll see what he does. Eventually, he will cause damage to these people, because he doesn't care about the repercussions for himself.
So let's move on to where things stand with the big, beautiful bill, which in most Americans, according to several polls, I think some of your own, aren't exactly thrilled about. The bill narrowly passed through the Senate on Tuesday in a 51 to 50 vote with three Republicans siding with Democrats and Vice President J.D. Vance having to break it with a tie. As of the recording, the bill is now back in the House where Speaker Mike Johnson has vowed to get the bill over the line. He's been very successful previously in doing this. By the time you're listening to this, this may or may not have happened.
Now, I want to note a few things about this Senate bill. The latest estimate from the Congressional Budget Office has it adding more than $3 trillion to the deficit over the next 10 years. The bill cuts about $1 trillion from Medicaid and other health care programs. It also makes cuts to SNAP. Nearly 12 million people will lose health care coverage if it becomes law. What jumped out at you over the last few days when we saw this debating and negotiating in the Senate? Obviously, Senator Lisa Murkowski, who I'm calling the quizzling, said it was an agonizing to vote for the bill, and yet she did.
She kept trashing it as she was voting for it, which is, of course, typical of her. Talk a little bit about what jumped out at you and then this data you have.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Yeah. So this bill is it was always going to be a massive challenge because it is the like cheesecake factory menu of conservative priorities that some people in the coalition love and some people in the coalition hate. But you're kind of asking them to eat everything on the cheesecake factory menu all at once. And so the thing you may love like I might love my 1600 calorie Santa Fe salad but like in order to get that I have to agree to try a little bit of everything on the menu and that's the legislative situation they've all found themselves in. There's three things that are making this bill move even though the polling isn't great.
The first is the power of Donald Trump. He says this is my agenda, this is my bill, you're with me or you're against me, and he's a very powerful force in the party. Nobody wants to cross him. He could, more so than Elon Musk, cause people problems in a primary. The second thing that's driving them is Republicans love cutting taxes. They like the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act from 2017. Their regret is only that they didn't do it earlier in that year, in 2017, that instead of doing it at the end of the year, they should have done it earlier so it could have, in their thinking, helped them in the 2018 midterms.
So they're like, we love this. We want to get it done, even if it is loaded up with all this other stuff that we might have questions about. The core thing is the tax cuts and we've got to get it done. And that's the carrot that's dragging everybody to this bill, even if they have other reservations. But the final thing is that I think Republicans, not incorrectly, believe that they will be able to turn these numbers around. So because this bill contains so many multitudes, in a poll, how do you even begin to ask about it? It is a Medicaid reform bill. It is a spending cuts bill. It is a tax cuts bill.
It, for one point in time, was an AI regulation or non-regulation bill. It's an EV tax credit bill. I mean, it is a child tax credit increase. It is the number of different ways you can describe this bill is almost infinite. And so the question is going to be Republicans have started to coalesce around. We're going to describe this as it's a tax cut and or preventing a tax hike. And it is focusing on making sure we're putting America first. And they describe that as we're funding stuff for border security. We are putting in these work requirements on Medicaid, which in and of themselves test well.
Kara Swisher
Lazy Medicaid people, right? That's the Republican message.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
The Democratic message, on the other hand, is you're calling these people lazy Medicaid people. In reality, it's going to be hardworking people who can't figure out how to file the paperwork. And they're going to get dropped from their health care because they can't navigate your new requirements. And that's going to be, as you mentioned, it's going to be 12 million people, many of whom you would say are deserving or are your neighbor or did vote for Donald Trump. And so the reality is, like, Republicans do have a message that can work. But if the reality of it is that the economy is not actually doing better by next November or that these policies in states that begin to try to implement work requirements earlier, if that creates snags and causes people who voted for Trump to lose health care, there could be really big backlash to that to create that would create problems in a midterm.
Kara Swisher
Why right now is it polling so badly?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I think it's polling badly because if you don't like Donald Trump, you know you don't like it. And so you're already starting off with almost half of America right there that's like, oh, it's Trump's bill. I'm out. And then of those voters who do like Donald Trump, there's not unanimity that it is a good thing because for some of them, they're like, well, I like Trump, but this has some things that I'm not crazy about. So it's easy for the opponents to all be unified against it. We don't like Trump. This is Trump's agenda. Trump bad. Bill bad. Done. But for the supporters of it, you've got the criticisms from the middle, the Murkowskis, the Mike Lawlers in the House. But you've also got attacks from the right, from the Chip Roy's, the Thomas Massey's. And so it's like a two front war this bill is fighting.
Kara Swisher
Right. What Marjorie Taylor Greene says is a shit show. Why is she doing that? Why are they all doing this from the right?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I believe a lot of them, again, to the extent that this is echoes of the old Tea Party moment, they want to be the one that says, I stood up for true fiscal discipline, but they don't want to be the one that sinks the bill. Like if the bill is already going down, they will happily be like, yes, I was part of helping to tank it because it's bad and we need to demand that we get a better deal. But like none of them wants to be the one that causes this to go down. None of them want that headache because if so, they're not just going to be held responsible for you tanked the things that are unpopular. They're like they're worried you'll be held responsible for making taxes go up. And that's not anything any Republican wants to do.
Kara Swisher
So the taxes is at the center of it, correct? The idea of giving these, even if the Democrats are putting it out as a gimme for wealthy people. Is that a good message from a polling point of view?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
It's one of those things where when you test it, should we cut taxes for wealthy people? Even a lot of Republicans say no. But the reality is that the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act from the first time around, the economy was doing pretty well under Trump during that first term. And so if Republicans say we just want to keep that going, we don't want to undo that. That's a way you message it that people say, oh, well, that actually makes sense. So just using the same messages against it that were used last time, I'm not sure actually moves the needle for Democrats. And it'll all also come down to what does the economy look like in November of next year?
If the economy is in the tank, then everybody's going to vote for Democrats and Republicans are going to be in big trouble. If the economy looks good, then it'll make Trump look like he was right.
Kara Swisher
So what would you advise Democrats to do at this point? Just keep pounding in on the people are going to not have their health care, the sort of scare tactics?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I think they need to coalesce around a message. As you noted, one of the downsides of the bill having a million different pieces is it is a target-rich environment for Democrats. But if they don't pick one or two main targets, that's going to be a problem. Right now, even though Republicans are having struggles, it is not as though the brand of the Democratic Party is great. It is not as though voters are saying they think Democrats have strong leadership and a clear vision. They need to sort some of that out as well if they want to have a chance at a really good midterm next year.
Kara Swisher
Right. So the best message for them right at this moment?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
It depends on the economy. It's the economy, stupid. I do think that the Medicaid message is potentially potent, in part because of the new coalition Republicans have put together that includes a lot of people who are on Medicaid. They may think of themselves as hardworking people who nevertheless find that the new work requirements catch them up in a paperwork problem and suddenly they're without healthcare. That is a huge, huge potential problem if that's how this comes to pass. That's the leopard-ate-my-face argument.
Kara Swisher
So one of the big points of contention in the bill, as you just talked about, was something we've been talking about here a lot on Pivot: the 10-year moratorium on state laws regulating AI. The Senate voted 99 to 1 to strike the provision from the bill. They also got rid of the one about selling off public lands. The lone holdout was Senator Tom Tillis, who's not running for re-election as of a few days ago. OpenAI and a few other big names in Silicon Valley have been lobbying for this amendment. I find it to be a silver lining in this whole mess. But how does that poll? Like, states should be able to do it. Green was on board for that. Lots of people, Democrats and Republicans.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Yeah. So this is an issue that I did some polling on for Common Sense Media, which is focused on kid safety online. They came to me because I can help understand Republican voters. They wanted to know how this actually tests with the GOP. This provision was really unpopular. It was unpopular on the left. It was unpopular on the right. If you just ask people, "Do you think states shouldn't be allowed to regulate AI?" that tests terribly. But I wanted to really pressure test it because at a policy level, I understand the instinct to say it's really bad if you have a patchwork of 50 different state laws all telling tech companies what they can and can't do.
We're in a race against China. We need to be able to survive and be competitive. We can't do that if states red and blue are passing all kinds of nonsense legislation. I get the argument. So I wanted to test it. We pitted the strongest possible case for this legislation up against an argument that basically says it should be states' rights. States should be able to do this. We need to be able to protect kids and families. Even when you pit those things together, you still find a huge number of Republicans saying, "Yeah, I get the arguments that we need to be competitive on AI, but that doesn't mean you just handcuff states for 10 years."
That's how you get to 99 to 1 in the Senate going, "Yeah, let's take this one out of here."
Kara Swisher
So they just said states' rights always prevails.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I don't think a states' rights argument in and of itself gets you all the way there because it's kind of wonky. It's process. I think the thing that added to this and made it so powerful was the safety of kids online. It is possible for the federal government to pass legislation or for there to be regulation that people really like around AI—things like the "Take It Down" act around revenge porn or AI. That kind of stuff gets really popular. But when we presented the reason why you don't want to have too much regulation on AI and spelled it out for people, we still had by a 12-to-70 margin people saying, "No, a blanket preemption on states goes too far because it could roll back these red and blue state protections for kids from tech-related dangers."
Kara Swisher
There was an attempt at a compromise where Senator Marsha Blackburn from Tennessee tried to come up with language that would be a carve-out to exempt kid safety-focused stuff from this blanket preemption. But ultimately, she decided the compromise wasn't worth it.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Yeah. She's got to stick to it.
Kara Swisher
I agree with Marsha Blackburn.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Oh, yeah. Wow. You bring a Republican on the show and all of a sudden you're agreeing with Marsha Blackburn.
Kara Swisher
You know what? Everything else about her is a hot fucking mess. But this one, when someone's directionally correct, Kristen, I'm going to go with them. She's directionally correct.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I appreciate that about you, Kara.
Kara Swisher
All her reasoning is like anti-gay. It's always something terrible. She goes, "It's because we have to protect ourselves from the gays." And I'm like, "No, that's not why." But I'll bring you along, Marsha. Anyway, whatever. I'm with you, Marsha, today. Just today. That's it. I was kind of pissed she was actually trying to make it a five-year compromise. I thought, no, either stick to your guns or you don't. And I'm sure she has plenty of guns.
Break for ad
Kristen, we're back with more news. And actually, this is what you were dovetailing: it's better to keep your head down. Paramount has agreed to pay $16 million to settle a lawsuit with President Trump that alleged a 60 Minutes interview with Kamala Harris was deceptively edited. The settlement does not include a statement of apology or regret. Paramount had said this is just a ridiculous case, as did most lawyers. Aside from legal fees, the payment will go towards Trump's future presidential library. The settlement comes as Paramount seeks to complete a merger with Skydance Media, which requires approval from the Trump administration. Reminder that ABC News agreed to pay Trump $16 million to settle a defamation case late last year, which is a much stronger case. This one is not. Talk about this, the repercussions. Obviously, they want to get this deal through. It has the feel of a shakedown and bribery. It feels very Orban, autocratic, very strange. And lawfare, which is something conservatives complain about. It's heinous on many levels. Your thoughts?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I can't help but think about this in the context of a couple of other lawsuits that have proceeded further down the road against media organizations, not necessarily from Trump himself. I think a lot about the Fox News defamation case and how much they had to pay out regarding Dominion and Smartmatic. And then CNN, where I'm a contributor, where we met doing the Chris Wallace Show. They had to settle a case around some stories earlier this year about someone who was trying to evacuate refugees from Afghanistan. A lot of these media organizations feel nervous about what happens even when you feel like you've got a really good case and you're just doing good journalism.
It's not fair. You shouldn't be in this position. It feels like the climate is not on your side. So do you just do the settlement, save yourself the embarrassment of discovery and going through a trial, even though it's going to cost you a pretty penny and you have to swallow your pride? Which is the least painful path forward? But I also think things like this are part of why, if you look over a long enough trend line, trust in the news media has been declining. Most recently, the decline is not actually coming from Republicans. It's coming from Democrats. It's coming from Democrats who think the media has become too soft on Trump or has normalized Trump or is too sensationalist.
The decline in trust from Republicans happened a while ago and has bottomed out. The declines we're continuing to see overall are actually being driven by Democrats who say, "I don't know that I trust that these organizations are doing the right thing either."
Kara Swisher
Right. In this case, I get the idea of just letting it go away. In the case of Fox, they had a bad case. There were so many emails. It was frightening how badly they behaved. They knew they had all the elements of proving it, and they'll probably lose their next several cases. That was really egregious behavior on the part of that news organization. In the case of ABC, I suspect there were some emails or texts that weren't so great. There was an obvious mistake. Whether they could have proved there was malice is a different situation. In this case, it's just not the case. And they have a brand, 60 Minutes, where two people have left the company. The staff is obviously upset. It's a real problem of collapsing what is a trusted institution over something that isn't a problem. Is that dangerous in the longer term, or does it not matter at all?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I never love the use of lawsuits to try to achieve an end, especially if it's potentially going to have the effect of chilling free speech. This is one of the things that frustrates me a lot about the right these days. Over the last decade, there have been a lot of very legitimate questions raised about the protection of free speech in this country, especially when conservatives say they're being silenced. I'm sympathetic to those charges. You need free speech, and that has to include even speech you think is offensive. But then once you get the reins of power, deciding you actually do want to stop speech you don't like or chill speech, that makes me very concerned.
Another case that is very personal to my industry is the lawsuits against Ann Selzer, the pollster in Iowa, and the lawsuits against the Des Moines Register. The federal case was dropped, but it was refiled as a state case. It was done a day in advance of the anti-SLAPP laws coming into effect in Iowa that are supposed to protect against lawfare. That's a case I'm watching very closely. The idea that someone can come after you and sue you because they think your poll was wrong and it was reported on in a way you didn't like is very, very concerning.
Kara Swisher
Where does it go from here? Does this embolden Trump? He's doing it all over the place. Anything he doesn't like, he threatens. He threatened CNN the other day for reporting on the existence of an app. Does this... what happens here? Is there a point where people say no more, or do they not, if it works?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
If it works and these people want something from the government, or once it stops working, it's going to be hell to pay for Republicans. I don't know where this ends. This is where not being a lawyer, I'm unsure of the strategy in terms of continuously trying to push people in courts and how much pain you incur if you try to fight back. But if you look at Trump's target list, he is picking targets that are not beloved by the general public: the media, Ivy League institutions, big powerful law firms. He's picking targets that your median American goes, "Yeah, I don't really like them that much anyway." That has been a savvy political strategy on his part.
Kara Swisher
Is there any chance the media's image will bounce forward? What would happen to do that?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Much the same way we were talking about with Musk earlier—he lost his credibility with Democrats and now he's picking fights with Republicans, but he's unlikely to see a resurgence of love among the Democrats he has alienated. I feel like this may be the same way. By doing this, it's not as though you're going to suddenly have a bunch of Republicans who are like, "Fantastic, these news organizations have all made big donations to the Trump library. We love them." In the short term, it just means everybody's mad at you, even if for very different reasons.
Kara Swisher
Absolutely. You don't win at all. I think fighting is probably better. But they want this deal to happen. There have been threats to go back at them as a bribe someday. I doubt they'll get to that. They're making the calculation that Democrats won't wreak revenge once they get back in power. But we'll see. Maybe they will. They have long memories.
Break for ad
President Trump says he also has a buyer for TikTok. Let's listen to a clip of the announcement on Fox News in an interview with Maria Bartiromo.
Clip plays: "We have a buyer for TikTok, by the way. I think I'll need probably China approval. I think the presidency will probably do it. Who's the buyer? I'll tell you in about two weeks. A big technology company? Very, very wealthy people. It's a group of very wealthy people."
The Pencil reported the same investor consortium before the first bid stalled amid trade talks: Oracle Corp, Blackstone Inc., and Andreessen Horowitz. The president recently signed an executive order extending the deadline for a third time. The law requires ByteDance to divest from the platform. Polling a few months ago showed support for TikTok bans standing at 34%, not great. But where are we in polling? Have people forgotten, given all the other news?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Polling on the TikTok ban has been fascinating. A couple of years ago, when you did polling around TikTok, there were real concerns. Is this Chinese propaganda? Is it warping kids' minds? Is it taking too much of their attention? When this was initially proposed and passed by Congress, it was reasonably popular. The only people who were particularly mad about it were the kids who used TikTok. But TikTok very smartly was able to marshal their users to make the case, "How can you take this from us?" Because Donald Trump perceives that he won his election in part by doing well among disaffected Gen Zers who may be using a lot of TikTok, he is not inclined to tick off that constituency.
He loves to be viewed as a dealmaker. His position on China is fascinating because he likes to talk about being tough on China, but he also likes to talk about coming to deals with Xi. This is ready-made to be the kind of thing where, even though being tough on China is almost never a losing position within the Republican coalition, the very particular constituency of who really loves TikTok is a group Trump is trying to win over. So it's good if he comes to a deal, even if he hands it over to his friends.
Kara Swisher
If he doesn't, what happens? If China says, "Fuck you, no way we're doing this." I'm curious about how legally this can all proceed. My understanding is that Congress was pretty clear that this has to happen. How much longer can he keep saying, "Yeah, yeah, Congress, you passed this law, but I'm kind of not going to follow it because I don't really feel like it"? At a certain point, doesn't the court have to intervene?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Congress is saying they already did their job. They passed a bill saying Trump has to do this. But he doesn't listen to them otherwise.
Kara Swisher
It'll be interesting to see if he gets a real bump if something really comes off. Even if he's handing it over to his friends, whether it's Larry Ellison or Marc Andreessen, nobody cares that these rich people are getting another break. He will just love that he can say, "I made another deal." It adds one more piece to the puzzle of his brand image.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Right. That works more than the particulars.
Break for ad
Kara Swisher
Official results are in for New York City's Democratic mayoral primary, and Zohran Mamdani took it away with a massive 12% lead. Mamdani still faces a general election, which will include incumbent Mayor Eric Adams and potentially Andrew Cuomo. Meanwhile, President Trump was asked about Mamdani at a press briefing on Tuesday and made some pretty bold claims. Let's listen to a clip.
Clip plays: "Well, then we'll have to arrest him. Look, we don't need a communist in this country, but if we have one, I'm going to be watching over him very carefully on behalf of the nation."
Clip continues: "A lot of people are saying he's here illegally. We're going to look at everything."
Mamdani was naturalized as a U.S. citizen in 2018. He responded on social media saying, "We will not accept this intimidation." Any big takeaways from Mamdani's official win, Kristen, and also these threats, which are troubling to say the least?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
In terms of the win, first, I cannot imagine why the Democratic establishment thought that selling Andrew Cuomo with all of his baggage was going to work. It is appalling and an indictment of New York's Democratic establishment that they couldn't come up with a better alternative. But I don't want to take anything away from Mamdani. Making the number one issue the number one issue—cost of living, stuff costs too much and it should cost less—is the right strategy. He paired it with something that AOC is so good at. Despite the fact that I don't agree with her on a ton of policy, I rate her very highly as a political communicator. She's very good at showing up where voters are and speaking to them the way voters want to be spoken to. It's not condescending. It's not overly fancy or overly technical, but it's not dumb. It's just speaking normally. Most politicians are allergic to doing that for reasons I cannot comprehend. And Mamdani is very good at it. The video of him talking about "Make halal $8 again" was a really great video.
Kara Swisher
You liked him a little bit, didn't you?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Look, I think populism plus media savvy is a very potent combination. I think he has it. But I would also say there's a lot of over-reading into this about what it means ideologically. There was a quote from a Democratic strategist the morning after the win that was something like, "Our base, they're always voting for these insane ideas and these far-left lunatics." It was this real contempt for the Democratic base. But I don't actually think the Democratic base on the whole is super ideologically to the left on economic issues. They are very open to a robust role for government, but I don't think the majority of the Democratic electorate is truly DSA-aligned.
What works in a Democratic primary in Manhattan is not necessarily transferable anywhere. The other thing that is very valuable to learn from Mamdani's win: if you looked at the age breakouts of people who voted in this primary, younger voters were the biggest group of voters. That almost never happens, especially in a primary, which is always a low-turnout thing. It's exactly the kind of contest young voters typically sit out. He turned them out. So I take nothing away from him on those grounds, even though I disagree with him on a lot of policy.
Kara Swisher
What about this feud between him and Trump?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
It's probably going to benefit both parties involved. As much as I think the whole idea of trying to denaturalize someone because you don't like what they're saying is terrible—everything I said earlier about free speech—we should not be in the business of trying to punish people's speech. That does not poll well. People do not want people deported because you are left-leaning or you said something offensive. If you are a naturalized U.S. citizen being deported, I cannot imagine it would be popular. At the same time, Donald Trump is going to love the elevation of Mamdani as the face of the Democratic Party.
He will think that is a very advantageous dynamic for the White House. At the same time, it's probably good for Mamdani politically to be coming under fire from Trump. To the extent that there were wavering establishment Democrats or centrist Democrats who were like, "Maybe we just vote for Eric Adams because we can't with this crazy guy," if all of a sudden he is the poster child for "I'm taking the fight to Trump," that probably unifies the Democratic base behind him as he moves into a general election in November. To the extent that there are independent challenges, it's probably good for Mamdani to be in the line of fire from Trump.
The ratings are good, as Trump would say.
Kara Swisher
Talk about where he did well. He did well with young people. What kills me is that they're like, "Young people don't vote." And then they voted, and they're like, "We don't like how young people voted." It's up to them to decide what they want. The Democratic reaction has been really interesting. They're largely upset around "globalize the intifada." That seems to be the focus. But they were shocked by this in a way that I wasn't. It's really interesting. When you look at voters, they complain about young people not voting, and then they did, and they didn't like it. The same thing was with Sanders, with AOC. They're hugely popular. Why the response of the Democratic establishment?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
This reminds me a lot of the freak-out that a lot of Republican strategists had when the Tea Party movement was getting going. It felt like, "Oh, these people are off-putting to me and they're going to drag our party in a direction that makes it impossible for us to win elections." That wasn't 100% true. I think the same thing is the case here. There are certain positions the further left wing of the Democratic Party takes that have been a big political problem for Democrats. I think it is true that they pulled Democrats too far to the left on a number of things that gave Trump this big opening. But in the case of New York City, the idea that suddenly somebody like Mamdani is going to win a primary for the South Carolina Senate seat—if that happened, then Democrats aren't winning the South Carolina Senate seat. That's true. But you also have to adapt to what's the right candidate for your area. Who are the voters there? What do they care about? Something that is OK in New York may not be OK for trying to pick up a swing congressional seat in Iowa. Smart parties understand that different electorates exist in different places.
Kara Swisher
Right. So Mamdani's approach can be used by a centrist. It just depends if you're genuine. The qualities here are genuineness. One of the things I was struck by is Bill Stepien, who's a very well-known Republican campaign person, said, "Don't make fun of this guy." He said, in a similar way, "I used to say, don't make fun of Trump." Trump is interesting, right? Do you see that at all? It was interesting that he said that when they were touting, "Oh, now we've got them." I'm like, "Do you?" Because he's really attractive in so many ways.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I 100% agree with Stepien on this one. Communication savvy, genuineness—that matters so much. There is so much noise and so much stuff that politicians say and do that just sounds the same. It washes over people. People can pick up a talking point from a thousand yards away. If you are able to communicate in a way that does not sound like you're just regurgitating talking points, that you haven't just been fed it by a consultant... The thing that makes Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders similar is that you actually believe they believe the things they are saying at some level. That goes a long way. I believe Mamdani believes the things he says. So even if I don't agree with them, you get points for that.
Kara Swisher
What about freshness? Is that something that's important? Do you think—they're calling it an earthquake for the Democratic Party. Do you think that's the case?
I would caution everybody from reading too much into a primary election in New York. But I think it ought to be a wake up call for anyone who thinks that you can just defend the status quo. That this is a wake-up call that in order to win elections in 2025, you have to be the candidate of change. You have to be. You had to be the candidate of change in 2024, which was a big reason why Joe Biden was in trouble and then the handoff to Kamala Harris was ultimately unsuccessful. You have to be the candidate of change. You have to be the candidate of what's new. And Mamdani was able to channel that very, very, very effectively.
Now, last question, what would you advise him to do now if he, you know, he's going to do what he wants to do, but what's the most important thing he'd do?
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I would advise Mamdani to focus in on the cost of living question relentlessly. Do not get pulled in these other directions. He has said and done a lot of things in his past that his opponents did not dredge up in the primary that are going to get dredged up now. But I think if he keeps his message focused on cost of living and does not become over-consultantified and keeps his message pretty focused on "we need New York to be a livable city again," I think he will succeed.
Now, if he ultimately becomes mayor and he tries to implement these policies and things like city-run grocery stores or rent freezes have all of these second and third order negative effects that folks on the right think are inevitably going to happen, then the backlash will come. But for the moment, I do think that Republicans should be wary of thinking, "Oh, let's just elevate this guy and it'll be great that he's the face of the Democratic Party." I think media savvy populism really sells and be careful of thinking that you can make that really, really, really unpopular.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I always see them put up lists on Fox News and I'm like, that sounds good. It was just I'm like, are you trying to get him elected? It's kind of funny.
All right. One more quick break. We'll be back for predictions.
Break
Okay, Kristen, let's hear a prediction.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I predict that the F1 movie starring Brad Pitt, which came out a week ago and did very well at the box office, both domestically and globally, I think it's going to have legs. I know this weekend it is going up against a new Jurassic Park movie, but I think this F1 movie is fantastic. I'm a big F1 fan. I saw it last week. I almost never see movies in theaters anymore, but it was so worth it. My prediction, this movie is going to have legs.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I'm sad to see it. And Apple finally has a hit. They've done a lot of great movies, but they haven't had a big hit like this. And people were worried that F1 had jumped the shark a little bit, in terms of expanding too quickly. But it's really good. I'm excited to see it.
I'm excited. I may have to go with you because my wife doesn't want to see it, Kristen. I may have to go.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I'll go back and see it again.
Kara Swisher
All right. I would love to go back and see it again. I'm excited to see it.
My prediction has to do with Mark Zuckerberg's creation of Meta's superintelligence labs this week. This is a group that will be focusing on Meta's AI efforts. He's been on a hiring spree grabbing top talent. Zoe Schiffer from Wired had a great scoop. Zuckerberg offered pay packages up to $300 million over four years. One OpenAI staffer told Wired, "That's about how much it would take for me to go work at Meta." Though Meta is saying the size and structure of these compensation packages have been misrepresented all over the place. He is trying very hard to do this.
I do not think he's going to be successful. I mean, I don't think they did a lot of due diligence on Scal.ai as much as they should have. I think it's a lot more internally kind of a chaos. I think there's going to be a lot of chaos here. And just grabbing all these people and creating like an Avengers team, that's what they're calling it. I don't think it always works. I don't think doing that is particularly smart.
He has had a lot of misses, although the stock is at an all-time high. Let's be clear, they're doing great in the areas they've always done great in. But he renamed the company Meta in order to go into the metaverse, and that was a $10, $20 billion disaster, and they can afford it. I just don't think he has the same sense of innovation that someone like Elon Musk or even OpenAI or other companies has. So I think this might be... I think he can afford to do this, but I think it's really the wrong way to go about doing innovation. So I'm not so sure it will pay off in the way he thinks it will. We'll see.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
How does he poll, not well, I guess, correct? Do people like him?
Kara Swisher
I think most of the tech billionaire type folks have not polled particularly well. I think like 10 years ago, there was a sense of cool and excitement around them that now has sort of faded.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Has waned.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah, I know he's leading the way. And the Bezos wedding, I'm guessing that didn't poll well.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
I have not. You know what? I haven't polled on it, but we're actually putting a survey in the field next week. If you think of any question you would want me to ask the American public about this wedding, you let me know.
Kara Swisher
Is this a heinous display of wealth in the most grotesque and tasteless way? There's my question right there.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
If you had gotten invited, would you have gone? That might be an interesting question.
Kara Swisher
You know, of course. Of course. You want to see this ridiculous traffic accident up close. I mean, for the bag alone, the swag bag alone, I suppose, I guess. I don't know. I'd want to see it. But I would be terrible and take pictures and put them out the whole time. I'd be terrible. I'd be the worst guest ever.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
You would break the rules right away.
Kara Swisher
You remember Wedding Crashers? That's Kara Swisher.
Anyway, we want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business tech or whatever's on your mind. Go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT.
Okay, that's the show. Kristen, thank you so much. I find you to be so smart. I could almost become a Republican.
Kristen Soltis Anderson
Oh, thank you for having me. It's an honor to be on the big show.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, the big show. You're on the big show. You delivered with all kinds of information. Scott should hang his head. You have so much good data. And that's what's important to our listeners to get the real deal and to really say what's happening, which is really important.
Anyway, thanks for listening to Pivot. And be sure to like and subscribe to our YouTube channel, which is fast growing, actually. We'll be back next week.
I Will Read Us Out. Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman, Zoe Marcus, Taylor Griffin, and Kevin Oliver. Ernie Enderdot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Kate Gallagher. Nishat Kerwa is Vox Media's executive producer of podcasts. Make sure to follow Pivot on your favorite podcast platform. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. You can subscribe to the magazine at nymag.com slash pod. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.