Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including the growing concerns about AI agents, the media coverage of Donald Trump's arrest, and the 2024 presidential election.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Ad Break - Sierra.ai
Ad Read
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at TheGuardian.com.
Podcast Intro Music
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. Scott Galloway is off today doing bad things, I'm sure. But today I'm joined by Alyssa Farah Griffin, co-host of The View. Welcome, Alyssa.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Thank you for having me, Kara. I hope you know I'm a Pivot super fan, so this is thrilling.
Kara Swisher
Oh, good. That's what we like. That's how we like to have here. And you are on The View. You are the, what, the conservative on The View? How do you explain yourself?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Yes, I filled a conservative seat on The View. I joined in August, and a lot of women have held that seat. I've decided I'm going to make it my own.
Kara Swisher
Okay, good idea. Twitter right winger, but I am a conservative and I've been enjoying it.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Good, good. And it's supposed to be like a discussion, just like Pivot, where we don't get along and we try to talk things out. Various conservatives have been different than others and various liberals on that show have been different than others. But it's essentially we all talk out all the issues of the day, depending on what they are daily for people who don't watch, but a lot of people watch The View.
Kara Swisher
Exactly, exactly. I was joking with the producer before. I think the nexus of Pivot listeners and The View may not be that big, but I am one of them and my husband is one of them.
No, you'd be surprised. You'd be surprised. And you've been there for August. How did you get there? Because I'm sure it was like a bake-off, right, of conservative women.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
It was. The entire 25th season was basically the search for the new conservative host. A bunch of incredible women came out, came on. They had Essie Cup, Condoleezza Rice at one point, Gretchen Carlson. Fabulous women. And I kept getting called back. I think what they liked was I'm not just a professional opinion haver. I've worked in government. I've worked in politics as well. And it's a show that has to have chemistry. Even if I totally disagree with my co-hosts at times, we all generally genuinely like each other. So that helps. I never would have thought Joy Behar would be a friend of mine. But here I am. And she is. She's hilarious.
Kara Swisher
So you wanted to do it because why? Now, you had worked for people don't know in the Trump administration, but you also spoke to the January 6th committee about your former boss.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Yeah. So I worked in the Trump administration at three different roles. I was Pence's press secretary. I was the Department of Defense press secretary. And then I was the final White House communications director. Listen, I've been really open. I didn't vote for Donald Trump. I wasn't a fan of his, but I chose to go into service once he was president because I don't think you can give up on the American presidency for four years. When I joined him in the final stretch of the administration around the time of COVID, I was hoping to make a marginal impact on the way we were messaging it and trying to not politicize a virus that ended up killing over a million Americans. What I saw in that White House was a disaster. It was worse than what we were reading in the headlines, the infighting, but fundamentally the lack of character of the former president.
Kara Swisher
Mm hmm.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
So after he lost, I was the first senior official to resign and to acknowledge Joe Biden had won the election fairly. There was no fraud. It was not stolen. I hadn't planned to become like a vocal detractor of his. I was planning to just kind of move on with my life.
Kara Swisher
Because you wanted to stay in conservative politics.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Right. Exactly. The safest thing to do is kind of sit back and let him do what he does and pop up on Fox News and ride the right wing media train. But after January 6th, I was just horrified. I went on NBC, CNN and Fox News the next morning and said he should resign. He was unfit for office. It was anti-democratic. I'm close with Liz Cheney. I joked with her after the fact. I was like, I spoke out because it was the right thing to do, but I also assumed people were going to come with me. And she's like, yeah, Alyssa, think how I felt.
Kara Swisher
Well, why didn't that happen? Because there were a number of people who did speak out. A lot of women, actually, which is kind of interesting. Although there weren't that many. There are men, but inside the White House, it was interesting to watch. You're still conservative. You wanted to work in conservative policy. Is that possible if you're not a Trumper right now? You had a long history, right?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Right. I mean, I've worked for most big names in Republican politics now. Mark Meadows, DeSantis, McBulvaney, Trump, Pence, and so on. I don't think I have a place in working in Republican politics now. But back to your original question of why I wanted to do The View, I never saw myself doing it. Daytime made no sense to me. I didn't even want to, I never planned to get into TV. I kind of stumbled into it. But it's a huge platform. It's a lot of women. There are independents. I think there's a sense that the show skews left. But our data in the audience is there's a lot of undecided independents. My biggest goal and what I care the most about going into 2024 is ensuring Donald Trump is never president again. So if I can use that platform to communicate why from my firsthand knowledge, knowing him, I'm going to do that every day.
Kara Swisher
Mm-hmm. And the idea of what conservative politics is now, I went to Georgetown University. It was a very active conservative group there. It's very different than what it is today. It was more, obviously huge disagreements, whether it's abortion or whatever it happens to be, government size. How do you look at the GOP? And when you said independence, what do you mean by that? Do you think there's going to be another party? There is one. There's the No Labels party, I guess, that's starting. The last one I saw was on Madam Secretary, Tia Leoni won the presidency as the whatever party, the independent party. That was great. She was a great president. But how do you look at that? What happens to people like you who have been sort of – I know a lot of people like you, George Conway, a whole bunch of different people who don't know where to go.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
There are a lot of us. I think there's more than we realize and who are just everyday Americans, too, who aren't people with platforms. I'm still in the realm of I want to fight from within. I want to see the party course correct and change. Others have left. I think George has. But my sense is this. When you look at the Republican Party right now, it looks like a 1990s Pat Buchanan version of the Republican Party.
Kara Swisher
That's right. Yeah, it does.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Protectionist, anti-globalization, anti-immigration, also leaning super heavily into the culture wars. None of that defines who I am, what I believe in and what my values are. I think there are a lot of us, but we have to be willing to talk through what our values are and why they work better and why we want to be a party that, frankly, can win. We haven't won a popular vote in nearly two decades.
Kara Swisher
We'll be talking about one that you have. The Wisconsin one was a big sign. That was a big sign.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
So and again, though, a big part of this, you can't take Donald Trump out of the equation.
Kara Swisher
No, he's putting his finger on these elections and we keep nominating people who are poor candidates. The gentleman in Wisconsin was an extremist. It was a good thing that he lost.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
And if I could briefly tell you why.
Kara Swisher
We're going to get to it. We're going to get there. Save it. So let's talk about today. Donald Trump has been charged. You might have heard about it. A man from Queens was arrested. We'll talk about what comes next for him and his opponents. We'll also get to the 2024 race and make some predictions. But first, it's been another bad week for TikTok. The company has been fined almost $16 million by UK privacy regulators for failing to protect children's data. The authorities said TikTok didn't do enough to check who was using the platform, allowing over a million children under 13 to use the app in 2020. That's not a surprise for people with kids. And in another sting in the land down under, the Australian government says it will remove the app from all government devices. This is a trend that's happening all over the world. NATO has also reportedly banned the app on work devices. I happened to be at a breakfast this morning talking to a congressperson asking me, what should we do, Kara? I was like, take it off your device, Representative. But do you use TikTok on your phone?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I do not. So when I was at the Department of Defense, we banned it on devices. And that was reason enough for me, the concerns over national security implications. I believe I have an account that's managed by The View. I have huge concerns about TikTok, first and foremost, from the national security and data privacy side of things.
Kara Swisher
Let's talk about that. Listen, the moment to act on TikTok was several years ago. This came up in the Trump administration. What those of us who are proponents of banning it said is the more people you get, once this becomes the most downloaded app in the country, it's so much harder to pull it back and to create some kind of a ban. The Restrict Act in Congress is a surprising moment of bipartisanship when we don't see a lot. But I have concerns that it's not going to move. I've seen some right-wing detractors actually make valid points about how expansive this is for the executive. It gives them a lot of—
Alyssa Farah Griffin
It's a patriarch.
Kara Swisher
It is. It is. There's worries about, what could this be next? What are we going to ban next? But every American, if you cared—I think Scott might have said this—but if you cared about that damn Chinese spy balloon getting American data, gaining intelligence on us, you've got that in your pocket if you have TikTok on your phone.
So let's talk about that bipartisanship, because the original stuff started in the Trump administration, although I say I wrote about it three years ago, the problem of Chinese surveillance and propaganda. But it started there. Of course, they did it executionally incompetently. They tried to do these deals that aren't legal or anything else. Got stopped by judges correctly, because they did it wrong. And it never went anywhere. And of course, TikTok kept growing in size. And it's turned out it's 150 million American users, which is much higher than they had originally reported, which we thought they were much bigger in terms of making more money. Were you there during that time when they were doing sort of the TikTok screaming that wasn't really effective?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Yeah, this was probably the tail end of the administration. I think the former president had concerns over any kind of an all-out ban. There was this idea of, I believe, spinning off ByteDance.
Kara Swisher
That's right.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
And trying to have it completely U.S.-based so that they could give you a little bit more calm and sense of security that it would be based in the U.S. And it just never really got the comprehensive support that it should have. But I will tell you, the intel community and the national security community were always on the side of, aside from not having on government devices, we shouldn't even be using it in the continental United States.
Kara Swisher
And what were the national security issues? Correct?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Yes, it was all from the national security perspective. And now we know, I'm not a parent yet, but I have huge concerns also from the mental health side of things.
Kara Swisher
But that's all of them. That's not fair. That's going to be any app, yeah. It just happens to be, yeah. But national security issues are interesting because that's what they talked about in Congress. And a lot of us watch that, except they don't have proof. They need to show that it's a national security issue. Now, the Defense Department can just ban it, correct? You can just say we're not putting it on government devices. And that's been super popular. All the governments are doing that. And many school systems are doing that. And they certainly can. But the idea of banning something overall is incredibly difficult unless you had rock solid proof that there was something going on. And I think there's an obligation for the government to tell that story to the American public. Full disclosure, I intellectually am for a ban. I don't know what that actually looks like. I see the rationale for it. But when you have that many users on it, you have an entire industry built around TikTok. I hate the term creator, but you have creators who's a lot of leads. Have you seen their ads? They're on TV, which is really interesting.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Well, they have a very strong lobbying effort.
Kara Swisher
I get reached out to by the TikTok lobbyists constantly.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Oh, really?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, trying to drum up support.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
What do they say to you?
Kara Swisher
Hey, girl. Hey, girl. And actually, their big push right now is this argument that this is like the Patriot Act. It's going to become more far reaching. Rand Paul has made this case as well. So they're trying to reach the right with that argument. I'd be curious how they're approaching the left. Although Patriot Act and surveillance issues, I think, are where the right and left can sometimes meet.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Yeah, a lot of it is also small business. I've seen so many ads, TikTok. You know, I make soap. I never thought I'd make soap. But here I am making soap and selling it on TikTok. They're being very places.
Kara Swisher
So you've been reached out. That's interesting. Let me move on to something else. Tim Cook, speaking of children, himself is warning parents to limit children's tech. In a GQ profile, the Apple CEO said kids are now, quote, born digital, but should have what he calls hard rails on screen time. Cook said Apple doesn't want people using their phones too much, saying we're not incentivized for that. And that is correct. They're not. The profile also touched on his wariness to the data industrial complex, which Apple, of course, is a part of, although less so than a Facebook or a Google. Though a reminder, in 2021, the company implemented an opt-in or opt-out for sharing data on apps on your device. It really hurt the bottom line of Facebook and Facebook slash Meta and Snapchat and several others. What do you think of this idea? Is it too preachy coming from a tech company? Although Apple's done the most for privacy compared to the government. The government's done almost nothing. They talk, Trump again talked about this. Biden talked about this. They didn't pass the privacy bill. They didn't pass the antitrust bill. How do you look when a tech person says this?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
On the one hand it feels very like we created a problem and now we're encouraging you to solve it. It sort of parallels some of these tech giants coming out raising concerns about artificial intelligence and calling for this six-month pause. But at the same time, these are the experts in the field. These are people who have such firsthand knowledge of the technology and what the implications of it are. So I don't think we can tune it out. I do think we have to listen to it. This is echoed in so many studies. There's so much data that shows the mental health impacts of social media. We have no idea. It's the generation under mine that has come up in a world where this exists and they don't know when, where it does it. And we don't actually fully know how it's going to be impacting them, but it's not going to be good.
Kara Swisher
When you think about how the government thinks about why the government, Trump tried to do this with Section 230. Biden has tried to say this around Section 230. They've tried to pass bills. They never get passed. Is it just when you're in communications, is it just like just say it and then do nothing? It seems like this is what they do. They hold a hearing. They get all angry. It's all performative. And then nothing happens. And then the tech guys go home and get richer and richer. In this case, Apple is a little different. I would say they have done a lot of stuff around privacy, but it's not his job to be regulator in chief for the United States or the world.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
No, you hit the nail on the head. It is largely performative. Listen, Congress hasn't enacted sweeping tech reform in ever.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, ever.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
And if you've ever watched one of these major hearings, whether it's TikTok, even Ticketmaster, we have a lot of members of Congress who don't even understand the basics of how the tech they're trying to regulate works. I think that in my experience, at least in the Trump administration, there were a lot of ideas that sounded good in theory, except, for example, reforming Section 230 or even reversing it. It's completely unfeasible, though. That's just my personal perspective.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it is.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
And I think it's something you can rail about so you sound like you're doing something. But Trump has no plans to actually take on big tech. He has a lot of plans to beat the drum of taking them on. And Congress is to some degree in the same boat. This has come up in Energy and Commerce. Kathy McMorris-Rogers has been talking about the reforms that need to happen. But I don't think I see something major. Marsha Blackburn, many others.
Kara Swisher
Is it a good thing to do this to say, oh, big tech? Isn't it really do people not really care when you're saying it?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
So much of our policy making or lack thereof is simply throwing around buzzwords that we've made kind of pejoratives. And big tech is something that plays very well on the right. If you're going after the Googles of the world and so on, that's interpreted as a righteous war that you're taking on. But I don't know that there's really much plans to actually make changes. And you've seen it even with the Elon Twitter takeover. Twitter was the enemy, but now you've got a far right leader running it. So suddenly Twitter's not the enemy of the right wing anymore.
Kara Swisher
Now they embrace it. He wasn't far right. Only a couple of years ago, he was at this breakfast morning. Someone said to someone who had voted for a Republican or Bush or one of them. And he goes, how could you have done that? Not voted for Obama. Like he was mad. I'm dying to know that villain origin story there.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I had the... I met him only once down at NASA and saw some of the incredible stuff that he's doing. And I had such admiration for him. I talk about changing the trajectory of humanity.
Kara Swisher
This was with the Defense Department when you were at the Defense?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Actually, Vice President Pence, because he was the chair of the National Space Council. So Elon was a kind of outside unofficial advisor. And I just found him so impressive. But I'm shocked that someone so brilliant could have so much time to engage in such unserious discussions.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Well, there you have it. Welcome to my world. Space Elon is good Elon. Tesla Elon is OK Elon. Twitter Elon is a really bad Elon. There's a lot of Elons. Anyway, let's get to our first big story, which you know a lot about. Donald Trump has officially been charged with 34 felony counts of falsifying business records. Trump reported to a Manhattan courtroom on Tuesday to plead not guilty. A trial won't happen until January if it happens at all. Trump's lawyers have previously discussed filing for dismissal, though they haven't said much since Tuesday, and it's unlikely it'll be dismissed from what I understand from most legal scholars.
The team Trump could haggle over evidence, venue and statute of limitations. They're not going to get it moved. There's not going to be such. Anyway, it's going to trial unless they settle. But in the meantime, the case will definitely be tried in the court of public opinion, obviously. Let's review some facts. The hush money payments happen. There's no dispute there. Trump's lawyer, Michael Cohen, had already pled guilty to making these payments and violating campaign finance law. The company behind the National Enquirer, which is sort of an interesting new wrinkle here, has already paid a fine to the FEC over one of the payments to a second woman.
Trump doesn't deny making the payments, but he said it was his money, not campaign funds. He does deny having an affair with either woman and says their requests for money were extortion, except there's some facts where he says, let's wait till the election because he thought he wasn't going to win and then he wouldn't have to pay. So that's another thing. So talk to me about whether these charges will help or hurt the Trump campaign. I'd love you to sort of, since you're in comms and how people are perceived, what is the perception game going on here?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Oh, well, listen, happy belated Trump arraignment day to all who celebrate. It was unequivocally a bad day for Donald Trump. He is a man, despite many of his out there bad actions, who is consumed by legacy. He cares about how he's perceived and how he'll be remembered. And he will be remembered as the first former president to be indicted. That's just a fact. It was a bit surreal to watch. I say that just because it's a historic moment. But this is a man who's in denial about the fact that he even lost the 2020 election. He actually still has staff refer to him as president. He's made his Trump Force One look like Air Force One.
So he has been living in this world in which he gets to kind of cosplay president still. But that all ended the minute his plane landed. He was in a much smaller motorcade than a former president. And then the minute he steps into the courtroom, he's in custody and he's basically alone, aside from an attorney and an advisor. And knowing him, I think that hit him. You could see it on his face, the pictures that came out of the courtroom. There was a sobriety and a somberness to that moment. Apparently, he said to someone, you're really going to arrest me. He couldn't quite believe it.
Kara Swisher
That's what one of the reporters said. He was like, yes, I am. I don't know what to say. I am.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
But I do think that the campaign allegedly raised $10 million over the past week. And every prominent Republican, elected Republican, I should say, came out and essentially defended the former president, said these are trumped up charges. It's a minor offense as far as it's a witch hunt. And the one that stood out to me was Mitt Romney, who's a Trump detractor, has said he's unfit for office, but even he said it felt political. So my sense is this is going to be a boon to him in the polls. I think significantly so. And I think Ron DeSantis, who's been kind of nipping at his heels in the polls and is kind of having a moment, he had to come out and say he wouldn't extradite him and this was wrong and is in a position where he's having to defend Trump. When he was speaking at Mar-a-Lago after the arraignment, it very clearly felt like a campaign speech. And I think in some ways it was a stronger moment for his reelection campaign than the actual initial launch.
Kara Swisher
Which was a dud.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Which was a dud. A total dud.
Kara Swisher
Right. Were you there? No, you weren't there. You wouldn't have been there.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
No, I was watching from CNN and we were all like, well, this is very anticlimactic. Very low energy.
Kara Swisher
But so this was the energetic one. This is what gets him going.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
It is. When he's defiant and he's on his heels, he's actually stronger with his base. And I say all of this, though, I think he has a very, very strong shot at getting the nomination. But an indictment does nothing to get you new voters. Nobody is coming around saying, actually, I changed my mind about the man who allegedly paid off a porn star and committed campaign finance violations.
Kara Swisher
He's been through a lot of that. People sort of have porn star baked into Donald Trump, don't they? I mean, they've accepted it. That's the fascinating thing is the deal with the devil that was made back in 2016 for a lot of Republican voters. You accepted it then you decided, these things are probably true. I'm OK with it. I'm going to take that bargain. So then it's hard to, for many of these people to feign outrage now. So now a majority of Americans support the indictment after a search of Mar-a-Lago. Trump-backed candidates didn't fare so well in the midterms. Outside the courthouse, Marjorie Taylor Greene and George Santos tried to speak at a sparsely attended rally, driven out. So it's kind of a mixed bag. There's also things behind this indictment, Georgia, the possible federal one. There's a case in New York, the rape case, essentially. So does this build up or does it just do people keep calling it political when it may not be?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
So my fear, I've been a bit concerned with this indictment coming down first. It's my perspective as a non-attorney, more as a communications person who thinks about the court of public opinion, that it is the weakest of the cases. And I say that because it is seven years old. Cy Vance chose not to take it up.
Kara Swisher
Although he says he would have had bar. Anyway, it's complicated.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Yeah, that's fair. I mean, there's, and listen.
Kara Swisher
He couldn't take it up. He couldn't take it up.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
And then, even this next hearing being scheduled for December 4th, so eight months from now, I think that there's a lot of folks who are going to hear that and they're going to be like, this doesn't seem like justice should move swiftly. It's not. This is going to drag on into the middle of a primary season.
Kara Swisher
I was February 5th.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
And then if that's a hearing, the trial could be mid-late next year. So I think most people don't think this is going to be Trump's undoing. But what is coming could be. I've sat down with the Department of Justice in the January 6th investigation. They're pulling a lot of important threads there, and it seems like they're moving quickly. The Mar-a-Lago investigation, the documents, this is incredibly important. These are national security secrets. Had I walked out of the Pentagon or the White House with any one document marked TSSCI, I'd be in federal prison right now. And then I think Fulton County is very interesting. This is the infamous, I need just 11,000 votes. So there's more coming for him. I do worry about indictment fatigue with the American public, but he knows this is the beginning, not the end.
Kara Swisher
And so when you say indictment fatigue, although it could be like, oh, it's this guy, he got indicted again. To me, the weak one coming first is actually stronger because then the next ones get bad. Like, then they become more and more. Or you could say maybe they're just out to get him, right? That's the tack they're taking.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Yeah, my fear is the latter. If I was still, if I had my hyper-partisan Republican hat on, I would say, why are they waiting until right before the primary season to have the next hearing?
Kara Swisher
Well, he wants that, too. He wants it. He could have asked for it to be expedited, but he didn't. He could have.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
And listen, Trump is actually, one of his talents is the ability to spin very negative things in his favor. And I think his campaign is going to be on overdrive to frame this as political and as a witch hunt. And they're going to use this to try to undermine the other, in my opinion, much more serious investigations.
Kara Swisher
I see. So if you were working for him, I'm going to put you on the spot. What would you put your Trump hat back on? What would you do to defend him? What would be the messaging you would use?
You go after the DA, of course. Let me be very clear, not in the horrific way that he has, which is highlighting his family and his daughter. That is just outright intimidation. You talk about the fact that, you know, New York City, we do have growing crime here. This is a DA who's downgraded a number of misdemeanors from felonies to misdemeanors, including trespassing, marijuana offenses. So this is a guy who doesn't want to be tough on the actual crime that affects people, but is coming out after someone over campaign finance. Right. That's a New York argument. That's a New York argument.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I mean, listen, nationally, he's going to pull the witch hunt. It's a liberal DA. They've been trying to come after me since 2016. Soros, Soros.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, with all the anti-Semitic undertones of the ongoing Soros attacks. And that's effective? Or is there some other novel thing you would say?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
It's hard because I'm so emotionally invested in him being held accountable. I think he does need to try to frame it as partisan. I think that's the only thing that breaks through with people who, the general average American who actually believes in the legal system. I don't like when he's had something on Truth Social about defunding the Department of Justice. That stuff doesn't play. Most Americans generally trust cops and law enforcement. So I think you try to knock away at the credentials of the district attorney.
Kara Swisher
All right. On the other side, what's the way to fight it? You criminal. You fucking criminal.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I know. The most simple thing is, Michael Cohen did time for this. If Michael Cohen's going to get locked up for it, then Donald Trump is. No one is above the law. Minor offenses, if a court of law, a grand jury of his peers decides to convict him, then he needs to serve just the way anyone else would. So smoke and fire, that kind of thing.
Kara Swisher
And this guy keeps piling on the... "Enough is enough" would seem to me. Is that worth it? Because there is a weariness of Trump himself.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
There is. I think, listen, Trump does himself no favors. I mean, talk about the worst client for any attorney. Or PR person.
Kara Swisher
Or PR person.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
But part of why the arraignment dragged on for so long, the actual proceeding in the courtroom, was because the judge took a moment to encourage him to not be engaging in rhetoric that could amount to inciting violence and other things. And then he went on to attack Alvin Bragg and his family, as well as the judge. So I think he's going to make plenty of missteps that reveal his character and his rage that will influence people's opinion quite a bit. Opinion, but not necessarily an actual case.
Kara Swisher
Now, if he is convicted, should he be banned? Speaking of banning, banning TikTok, should he be banned from office? Now, legally, he'll still be allowed to serve, but should he be?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
So I think if it's a federal crime, yes. I think if you're convicted of a federal crime, especially these two, both the Mar-a-Lago documents investigation and January 6th. On January 6th, if they're able to make the case, which I think is there, that he incited a violent mob to attack the Capitol and try to halt the democratic process, that should preclude someone from ever holding office again, hands down. And then on the Mar-a-Lago case, part of this is trying to try him under the Espionage Act. Mishandling of classified secrets is not a small offense in any sense of the word. He has no way of being able to claim that those documents couldn't have gotten in the wrong hands. Just the chain of custody alone, them being moved, there was a lock in the door, there wasn't. You've been there. You've been to Mar-a-Lago.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Do you like it?
Kara Swisher
It is the tackiest country club I've ever stepped foot in. It's got to be your thing.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
It's got to be your thing. Listen, it's pretty, but it's a weird place.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. It's right on the intercoastal. It's very pretty. Where it is, it's very beautiful. But you know, a lot of Palm Beach is like that. You're like, really, people? What are you doing down here?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
But they like it. They like it.
Kara Swisher
I shouldn't judge. I am judging really hard.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I know. I feel bad.
Kara Swisher
I really don't judge. That's okay. That's okay. It's all right. So one of the things that you mentioned is he brought a lot of people along with him. So why is the conservative having such a hard time breaking up with him? He doesn't win elections. Trump-backed candidates lost competitive races in 2022, including Dr. Oz. They just lost these. We'll talk about the ones they lost yesterday. Trump-backed candidates didn't fare well in 2018. His candidates lost two special elections in Georgia. Of course, he lost 2020. He has the legal problems. He's got the civil suit, Nat Worth, two lawsuits by E. Jean Carroll accusing him of rape and defamation. Why? What?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I know. We just can't quit him.
Kara Swisher
No, it's a fear factor.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
So on a more individual level, he has the ability to destroy any Republican politician's career if he decides to turn on them. He does have that hold on the base. But then more broadly for the party, the fear is that if it's not him, he'll burn the whole thing to the ground. The problem with Donald Trump, and I think my friend George Conway would agree with this, is he's going to burn it down anyway, whether he intends to or not. And to rip off the Band-Aid is the only way to deal with him. The folks who want to have one foot in Trump world and appeal to him, think that they're going to keep his base on board, but then keep one foot in the world of people like me. It doesn't work. It didn't work for my friend and old boss, Mike Pence. I see Nikki Haley, who there's a lot I really like about her. It's not working. You've got it. I would rather go down in a blaze of glory, polling at 2%, saying the right thing and calling him out, than just help glide him to the presidency again.
Kara Swisher
So people said there isn't anyone to do that. No one. That there's a real opening to do that, but nobody capable of doing it.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I think probably the most capable person, but I don't know that I think he's going to get in, would be Governor Chris Sununu of New Hampshire. Mostly because he's not brash, but he can throw a punch. He has his own record to run on. And unlike many of the candidates we assume are going to get in, and the announced ones, he never worked for Trump. So he's got his own thing to run on. He's a popular governor in a purple state. But he seems to be chomping at the bit to go after both DeSantis and Trump. He's got some ideologically different views than DeSantis, like I do. I just don't know that he gets in because he's also a young, highly popular governor. He could coast and wait till another cycle to run.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
But trust me, I'm waiting for someone to be the hero.
Kara Swisher
Right. Nobody is. All right. We'll take a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about how Trump's rivals could use this moment and more about the media fallout.
Ad Break
Alyssa, we're back with more on the fallout from Donald Trump's arrest. Let's talk about the media coverage. Trump thrives on it, good or bad. We saw Tuesday networks gave this wall-to-wall treatment. It was ridiculous at one point. Like, now the car, the car, the doors, there's going to be doors. They could open in this door and this door. They made a joke of it on late night television. Talk about the media coverage without making him into the legend. How do you cover a narcissist without feeding his ego? Because literally it was back. I felt like I was back in 2016 again. It really did. Honestly, parts of it remind me of OJ. Like we have the aerial shots of the motorcade and the plane landing.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
It's a tough balance. And I don't always know the answer because there's such a vital public interest there. I found myself, I mean, I was sitting on set for most of it at CNN on a panel just watching and I couldn't take my eyes off of what's going to happen next. The unpredictability of Trump is excellent TV. But Rachel Maddow went on a really interesting rant where she essentially said she's not going to cover Trump's full speech. There's no news value in it. It's the same airing of grievances. And I think there has to be a balance of that. There's a conversation we constantly have at CNN.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, because he's good for ratings, right?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Well, he's good for ratings. People want to know, they want to see, but how do you not just boost his public persona the way that many in the media did in 2016? And I don't know where that fine line exists.
Kara Swisher
But of course, you guys had wall-to-wall coverage, right? You were on top. CNN cut out of the speech, which I definitely think was the right call. Simply because, A, he's impossible to fact check. We aired a fact check afterward that wasn't even able to get to all of the untruths that he shared. But it was a historic day. So I do tend to think that you've got to show it, but contextualize it. And I really want to shout out to some of the legal analysts at CNN, Ellie Honig, somebody who was able to offer insight into what this meant, why it mattered. The contextualizing and the fact checking is key.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
And except it's then about him.
Kara Swisher
But I want to play a clip from Fox News, actually. I won't set this up too much. So let's listen.
Clip plays: "So the government has a very, very strong case. What is the crime here is the use of funds which were told under oath to the federal government that they were legitimate campaign funds in order to pay off someone, his mistress, to remain silent. And he conspired with others, the people who contributed the money. So he's facing two five-year charges. The guilt, the evidence of guilt on both is overwhelming. It is an incredible fall from grace for John Edwards."
So that's Judge Andrew Napolitano. This is 2011 discussing the indictment of John Edwards, which people are comparing it to. Now, of course, they were against John Edwards. The Republicans were. Didn't really work in general. He managed to prove that he was doing it to protect his wife who was dying. Trump has tried the Melania defense. It's not quite as strong here. When you look at stuff like this, this is the equalization. Is that PR thing to do, equalization, that then brings down the argument of the other side, presumably?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I think so. I saw a lot of folks invoking the John Edwards example. And he did ultimately get off. His political career was over, though.
Kara Swisher
His political career was over.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
And he was somebody who also never had that staying power that Donald Trump does, being a former president. My concern there, though, is everything with him defies norms. This goes further. And I just keep saying this is the least relatable crime, paying off a porn star hush money to try to hide from both your wife and the American public. And I do think it's one of those areas where your mind's made up about it. You either have decided you're not with Trump or you've decided this is a witch hunt. And I'm not sure I see this changing a whole lot of hearts and minds. Can I ask you, Kara, though? What do you think about the media coverage?
Kara Swisher
I think it's been terrible. I think it's been terrible. I have to say, once again, it's the same old, same old. And they're just following the cars and the doors. I was sort of like, you're kidding me. We're watching his motorcade, right? Why? Him getting there? It was strange. And then it creates, because they want to create a sense, I know what they're doing. They're creating a sense of tension. And here it comes. It's like a Law & Order episode. But it's not a Law & Order episode. And so it just was, he coming out door. Some of the coverage was, this is what's happening. And that's absolutely news. It's a historic event. It is, because he's the first president to be criminally indicted. And so that was important. But all the rest around it and the endless chit-chattery was really, I think, untoward. I think it just plays right into... I don't know if it'll get him elected, but it plays into this weird relationship that the United States has with this man. And I think that's what it really is. It's not just Republicans. It's everybody. They can't quit him. And so the media can't quit him. And of course, there is financial benefit from it. There just is.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Of course.
Kara Swisher
They said it out loud a couple of years ago, but now they don't say it out loud.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
No, it's undoubtedly a factor in the $10 million that he's raised. I mean, he got close to that in earned media coverage in the past couple of days.
Kara Swisher
Oh, sure. A hundred percent. And so, whatever. It's just we're not talking about other things. And speaking of other things, how should presidential hopefuls, say you work for them, manage this moment? On the Republican side, declared Nikki Haley and Asa Hutchinson. How would you handle it?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
You don't beat Trump by not taking him on directly. Hands down. Listen, if you can see the Grateful Dead, you're not going to go see a Grateful Dead cover band. So the kind of running as mini-Trumps, as I would say Ron DeSantis is, people are going to want the original if that's what they're looking for. So you need to identify the voters who aren't looking for that and offer them something different. I briefly got excited about Nikki Haley. I liked her as governor. I really liked her as UN ambassador. But it's like she's running a traditional Republican campaign and ignoring the fact that the front runner is Donald J.
Trump, a man who defies every norm and takes up all the oxygen in the room. DeSantis is trying to outstunt him, even though he's an undeclared candidate. And Asa's, it's interesting. I applaud him for at least being willing to say Trump is unfit for office and he wouldn't support him. That's going where few elected Republicans or former, in his case, will go. I have a hard time seeing how he could ever get significant steam. I'm holding out for some kind of a dream scenario where someone gets in and says, I want to go toe to toe with him on a debate stage. But at this point, it almost feels like people are running to be VP than running against him.
Kara Swisher
Yes, that's true. So you have DeSantis is the cover band, presumably. Mike Pence, Mike Pompeo, who may or may not run now, apparently.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
And the thing there is, and I worked for Pence, I think highly of him. I'll always be grateful for his heroism on January 6th. But he and Pompeo were in the same boat, and to a lesser degree, Nikki Haley, where it's hard to run against someone who you served under, and where a lot of the things you want to tout are from their administration. I do give quick props to Mike Pompeo, though. I'm really disturbed by some of this anti-Ukraine sentiment that's ginning up on the right. You know, we shouldn't be supporting them. It actually goes further, but I'm not even going to echo the pro-Putin propaganda. And he made a point to go to Ukraine and to express his unwavering support. So it's a good juxtaposition, but it's not direct enough and it's not going to break through.
Kara Swisher
OK, what about Joe Biden? What should he do?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Just nothing. Say, get a load of this guy.
Kara Swisher
I think he won by saying, get a load of this guy a lot, right?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Well, OK, I'm going to say what he should do, which isn't going to happen. And my apologies to my friends in the Joe Biden White House, if he decided not to run for re-election, he would go down in history as one of the most consequential presidents in the 21st century. He became that stopgap that we needed at a time where our nation was helplessly divided. He has a legislative record that Democrats can be proud of and some big bipartisan wins: CHIPS, infrastructure. I think that would be powerful. And knowing when to pass the baton is a lost art in American politics. I don't think that's going to happen.
Kara Swisher
Washington did it and he did really well for doing it. That is true. He's emulated it. Yes. No, nobody's emulated it. Just him. That was him the last time they did it.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
So he should step aside and then get out of the way for a much more vibrant candidate. That's my sense. The problem is the Democrats have a strong bench for, let's say, four years from now. I don't know that they have a strong one right now. Wes Moore in Maryland is incredible. They've got some of these rising stars. I don't know that they have the heir apparent. Respectfully, I do not think it's Vice President Harris.
Kara Swisher
Many people don't think that. Yeah. She's just struggled to get a real policy portfolio and wins on the books. And I actually expected her to be a lot more formidable than I observed she has been since being VP.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Not Newsom? So I'd be curious. Your thoughts on this?
Kara Swisher
I'm not sure I think Democrats can elect a wealthy cis white male in this era. And Biden's an exception because he was Obama's VP. And he's so popular in somewhere like South Carolina. But I don't know that the progressive left gets behind Newsom.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I don't know. It's interesting because he's super aggressive. I like what he's doing in terms of aggression, and he's making a name for himself in that regard. And he does run the state that's bigger than most countries, right? So it's not like he doesn't have the experience. And, you know, handsome, tall man, that never hurts. I hate to say it, but that's who... Trump is tall. People don't realize Obama was very tall.
Kara Swisher
Then there's Mitch Landrieu down in Louisiana. That's another person. I actually love him. I saw him speak once. He's hilarious. He's a Joe Biden type of person. People love him down there.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Well, and you know who my money was on? Pete Buttigieg. But he's had so many infrastructure-related issues.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, probably transportation related issues. Not his fault, but still his fault. So that's the problem.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Exactly. You own it if that's your title.
Kara Swisher
All right. So the last one would be Joe Lieberman and Joe Manchin involved in the group No Labels. They raised $70 million from undisclosed donors. Could Republicans like you go over there, or more centrist Democrats move over there who are irritated by the far left?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I would love to see a vibrant third party, but the problem is what it does is it tends to boost one side or the other. And I think that the fear factor, Liz Cheney's talked about this before, is you run somebody to the middle and you actually risk taking more votes from Joe Biden and boosting candidate Donald Trump to the nomination. I don't think we're in a place where a third party does much beyond raise a lot of money and create headaches for the existing parties without actually having a path to victory.
Kara Swisher
Well, that's what Pat Buchanan did back when, if you remember. That is so. Yeah. That's what he did. Throwback to Pat Buchanan. I have never forgotten Pat Buchanan.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Well, but I do think our primary system is doing such a disservice to the country in both parties. Especially on the right. I mean, we nominate the least electable person in a general election. But someone like a Manchin in a general, I bet could get 60 percent of the country. I could vote for Joe Manchin. There's things I disagree with him on, but I could vote for him. You'd have a ton of Republicans who'd be willing to vote, especially if it's him against a Trump. But he'd never get through a Democratic primary.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Could have to be a third party run. So I'm going to push you one more time. If it's Joe Biden, what would you do if you were him? OK, he's not going to resign, say he decides he's fit as a fiddle. What would be his message?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
He's got legislative achievements to run on, but he's got to do that. I'm the president for all Americans. I actually thought his inauguration was extremely powerful. What he said. I, as a Republican, have seen a little less of trying to reach the Republican side or the middle since he's been in office. But I think reminding folks that there are certain American values that are more important than partisan politics. Our democracy being number one. In the alternative, assuming it is a Trump, which, hey, it may not be, but it's going to be Trump. The alternative is a threat to our underlying democratic values, to our institutions and to the future of the free world. You need to make it a "time for choosing" kind of moment. I think he's capable of doing it, but the age factor is not a small deal. And by the way, Donald Trump is old, too.
Kara Swisher
They're both old. Yeah, they should have new ones for everyone. All right. One more question. The results in Wisconsin last week elected Democratic-backed Judge Janet Protasiewicz for the state Supreme Court, giving the body a liberal majority for the first time in 15 years. It was the most expensive campaign for a state Supreme Court in U.S. history. It's an important one. The court will rule on abortion rights. The newly elected judge made women's rights a focus of her campaign and won the endorsement of Planned Parenthood. She won by a lot. It wasn't a little. By roughly 11 percentage points. That is a big win. Many people, including a friend of Pivot, Rebecca Traister, argues that abortion rights is a winning issue in these elections. You've seen it happen all over the place. You saw it in the midterms, possibly. And not just that. It was, I think, a surprise. Same thing in Chicago, the more progressive candidate won. That's not as much a surprise, I think, to most people because it was a close election in that case. Law and order person versus a more progressive, socially expansive one. So what does Wisconsin mean if you're a Republican strategist?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
It's a huge deal. I mean, first and foremost, candidate quality matters. And once again, we ran someone so far to the right that they lacked the ability to have that statewide appeal. But there's, sorry to keep going back to him, there's a Trump factor to this. So in 2016 or 2017, Republicans held the Supreme Court in Wisconsin in a 5-2 majority, which was seen as insurmountable, that that would be a Republican-held Supreme Court for some time. They've now lost the court in two governors races.
Kara Swisher
Yep.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
So this is a swing state, a very important one, by the way, electorally in a presidential election, that we are bleeding support in because of the kind of people that we're choosing to run. But there's also something more important about this race. So my apologies if you don't follow far right leaders, but Ali Alexander, this guy who was one of the January 6th organizers and he's under investigation for his role there. He posted something, I believe, on Parler that basically said the quiet part out loud after the results came in. He said, "We lost the Wisconsin Supreme Court. I do not see a path to 270 in 2024."
So what he means by that is the reason that MAGA people, Trump people want these Supreme Courts is they're getting ready to challenge the results of another election. And they want favorable courts that are going to weigh in in their favor and say, yep, we're giving this to Donald Trump. It's a big win for Democrats, unquestionably. And so they will be able to push back, push abortion rights back to the front. But it's a winning issue. It seems to be a winning issue because they've taken it too far. Look at DeSantis in Florida, six weeks. I didn't... I was pregnant till seven, eight, nine weeks.
Like, I don't remember, but it wasn't six weeks for sure. I think the midterms showed us that Republicans taking too extreme of an approach on abortion rights is an unequivocal loser. And I don't think that we've properly measured the sentiment around it. I'd be curious, actually, as a Republican, to get some real data on how Republicans feel on this issue post-Dobbs. Because I think in the Roe v. Wade era, it was easy to... I'm Episcopalian, so it's easy to be culturally pro-life. You know, I'm against abortion. That's kind of what we were taught. But you said it knowing that it was a legal right that women were able to have.
And that wasn't a discussion. If they so choose. It wasn't something that you were actually actively seeing being taken away in different states. Now that that's changed, I'm constantly hearing from Republican girlfriends who are saying, you know, I'm concerned about this. I think where the states should be is much closer to Europe. We actually had much more liberal abortion laws under Roe than a lot of European countries do. But it's unequivocally going to be one of the most defining issues.
Kara Swisher
Which they didn't think it would be in the election. Actually, Trump said that. That's one thing Trump said is, what are you doing? He was right on it.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
He was. And he probably understood it, given he probably knows a little bit about it.
Kara Swisher
Allegedly.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Allegedly.
Kara Swisher
Allegedly. But I think he did understand that this is one of the biggest issues and it has a staying power that is not going away at any time soon. All right. When we get back, we're going to have you make a prediction. So one more quick break and we'll be right back with Alyssa Farah.
Ad Break
Okay, Alyssa, you have to make a prediction. You can make a prediction.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I have a depressing prediction.
Kara Swisher
Okay, go ahead.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I predict, since we're talking politics a lot today, I predict Donald Trump is going to get the Republican nomination. I also predict that Ron DeSantis is going to flame out in the next quarter. Not completely, but he's going to lose his number two kind of spot.
Kara Swisher
And why?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
He's charmless.
Kara Swisher
My feeling, charmless.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Nixonian. Charmless. There's not a whole lot of personality there. I think you can't just live by governing by owning the libs. And I think that's kind of been his approach. He doesn't engage mainstream media, so he doesn't take a lot of tough questions that are required to be able to defend your positions. And some of the unforced errors, I mean, the mistake he made on Ukraine was incredible. You saw a ton of prominent Republicans coming out and it looked amateur. That said, he has an incredibly strong team around him and he's raised a lot of money. But I just don't think the... there is... charmless. I find him...
Kara Swisher
Yeah, he's not like... Even they said about Hillary, she's likable enough. He's not even likable enough. That's... he's not likable.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
So who replaces him? If I'm going to make you make that prediction more significant... You know what?
I think wait for Pence to get in. I think Pence is going to have a moment. He does retail politics very well. So when he starts hitting Iowa, South Carolina, which he's really going to prioritize, he likes to shake hands and kiss babies. He knows how to talk to Republican base voters because he's actually a true conservative, unlike someone like Donald Trump. I think he'll have a moment. I don't think it's enough to pull it off, but I see him going up in the polls once he's in.
Kara Swisher
Anybody else? Stick out?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Chris Christie? Chris Christie. You know what? Hey, props to Chris Christie because he does want to take on Trump. But I think that moment would have been several years ago.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
So anybody else? Nobody else. So that's it. I'd like to say, listen, if Governor Sununu gets in, I think that could be a moment. And Tim Scott's testing the waters. I don't know. I really think the only person I see breaking through in a significant way would be Pence. Nikki Haley is going to be slow and steady. But I get the sense, and I hope I'm wrong, that she's running to be Trump's VP.
Kara Swisher
Okay, I'm going to make you make one more prediction. I'm going to ask you, VP of Trump, is it Kari Lake or the one from Kansas? The one from Iowa, the Iowa governor.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Kim Reynolds? So, if it were up to him, it would probably be Kari Lake. But I do think smarter advisors, I think Susie Wiles, who's around him, is going to say it needs to be somebody who's going to appeal to moderates and to independents. That's where I actually think a Nikki Haley is central casting. Woman of color, personal story, former governor, UN ambassador. Kim Reynolds is good. I think Nikki Haley actually makes more sense and has more of a national profile. But his instinct is going to be like Kari Lake or Marjorie Taylor Greene. And his people are going to be like, no, no, no, no. It's got to be someone saying...
Kara Swisher
Wouldn't that be a gift? Wouldn't that be a gift? Marjorie Taylor Greene. Any predictions on your end?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
No, I think that... I think he's not going to be the nominee. How about that?
Kara Swisher
I love it. Let's put some money on it.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Yes, let's put some money on it. A hundred bucks.
Kara Swisher
I think he's... Let me just ask you, did you watch all *The Apprentice* like I did?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
I did for a while. I watched a few seasons, but not to the end.
Kara Swisher
I watched all of them. Everyone. He has an ending. He gets tired. People get tired. You're like, oh, him again. I'm just telling you. I hope that series finale is coming for America.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
You know, if the right Republicans get to the primaries, it doesn't have to be just the crazies. You don't have to leave it to the crazies. If you want to take it back, you can move them to vote.
Kara Swisher
I don't know. Who do you think might be able to step in?
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Sununu.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Oh, good. I love to hear that. I was just in New Hampshire for a couple of weeks finishing my book. And I have to say, they love him there. They love him. He's fantastic. I love him. He seems reasonable enough. And he's interesting, actually, as opposed to... I know you like Mitt Romney, but Mitt Romney's also not interesting.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
You know.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Well, and Sununu would be our first Lebanese president as a Lebanese American. I love it.
Kara Swisher
Okay, on that note, that's the show. Also, Pivot is nominated for a Webby Award and you need to vote for us. We'll put a link in the show notes. Anyway, thank you, Alyssa Farah Griffin, and we'll be sure to find you on *The View*.
Alyssa Farah Griffin
Well, thank you so much for having me.
Kara Swisher
Today's show was produced by Lara Neyman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Endrodat engineered this episode. Make sure you're subscribed to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business.