Main Topic: The art of interviewing, particularly with difficult or high-profile guests, was the main topic of this episode of Pivot, a podcast hosted by Kara Swisher.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now.
Ad Voiceover
We work 24/7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Ad Voiceover 2
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. Welcome to Scott Free August. And aren't we relieved because we have no more penis jokes to hear. We're going to discuss that with him. He's going to have a little calm time during his time off and a little bit of deprogramming of that.
In any case, my co-host today has plenty of experience co-hosting because she does it for a living on the Today Show. I wanted to get the polar opposite of Scott Galloway. Welcome, Savannah Guthrie.
Savannah Guthrie
Thank you for having me, Kara. I'm excited and scared of you.
Kara Swisher
No, you're fine. Why are you scared? Why?
Savannah Guthrie
Because I'm familiar with your work.
Kara Swisher
Oh, okay, good. Well, I'm familiar with your work, and I think you're an excellent interviewer. One thing we're going to do is a little different today since he's away, besides not making dirty jokes. I don't think that's your forte. I'm not sure that's your forte.
Savannah Guthrie
It's really not an area of strength.
Kara Swisher
I want to give the audience a quick rundown of the big headlines. Then we're going to talk about interviewing. You and I, I think you're one of the finest interviewers. We're going to go through some of your interviews and some of mine. We're going to talk and trade tips and things like that.
So today I'm going to start with the platform formerly known as Twitter. It's now called X, which will now let paid users hide their verification checkmarks. Well, kind of. The company's About Twitter Blue page notes that even if you choose to hide your checkmark, it may be visible in some places. In other words, it doesn't work. I don't know why they want to do this. I guess people are embarrassed to have it. I still have my blue checkmark, even though I don't pay for it. If you have a legacy account, one that was verified before the blue subscription system, it should show the date you were verified to save you from the embarrassment so you know you're not paying.
Simone, are you still using Twitter? Are you?
Savannah Guthrie
I still belong to Twitter. I'm on it. I think I lost my blue checkbook and my checkmark. I don't use it that often. When I was the White House correspondent, I used it all the time. It was my news feed.
Kara Swisher
Oh, okay.
Savannah Guthrie
I loved it. I followed all the reporters and I tried to break news on Twitter. It was huge. And just more and more over the years, I don't. I think largely because it's less and less of that, less of a news feed. Sometimes things are coming up that it's like hours later. And also, I just feel that it's gotten so negative that I can get my news another way that doesn't feel like a punch in the gut.
Kara Swisher
I have a legacy account and I still have a blue check. It was taken off and then put back on. I have no idea why, but I did not pay for it.
Savannah Guthrie
They don't want to mess with you.
Kara Swisher
I don't think so. He wants to mess with me.
Anyway, another story. Hollywood writers and studio reps are expected to meet today for the first time since the writer's strike began three months ago. The Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers extended an invitation to the Writers Guild earlier this week. As of now, it's not clear what they will offer the writers to get them back to the negotiating table. There's been no similar invite to the Actors Union yet, which is the writers started first and had been striking for a while before the actors struck. Writers are asking for increased pay, contract changes, protections against AI.
I have had impact from it. Obviously the actors and the writers and the studios are the most impacted. It's gotten a lot of attention and you guys have covered it. I've covered it quite a bit. The impact for us is a lot of the people we have for interviews now can't do interviews like Greta Gerwig, Natasha Lyonne. We had a bunch of people signed up that had to cancel. And you have a show that has a lot more celebrities.
Savannah Guthrie
Yeah, we had a lot of gaping holes in our schedule and have had and will continue to have because we have a lot of people coming on to promote their movies. I was supposed to sit down with Robert Downey Jr. for an interview and then the strike happened. So yes, for Oppenheimer. So of course, we cover it as a news story, but we're also feeling the effects of it as well.
Kara Swisher
What do you do then? How do you fill it? Do you find a YouTube influencer?
Savannah Guthrie
No, no. It's the Today Show. They're so resourceful. We fill four hours of television every day. We have a lot of stories that are in the can. The producers are amazing on the Today Show. But we miss it. We miss having those stories. We like to cover Hollywood and it's fun to have a celebrity stop by.
Kara Swisher
The writer's strike, when you cover it as a news story, your company also has entertainment. Is there anything, what do you have to do when that happens?
Savannah Guthrie
Our parent company is a member of the Producers Alliance, which of course is adverse to the striking writers or actors. So we just cover it like a normal news story. We call them for a comment and we always disclose. There's always that. And by the way, NBC Universal's parent company, Comcast, is a member of the Producers Alliance or some such.
Kara Swisher
When you heard, I know the writers had said, the actors said, "Oh, they're in the can for them." How do you disabuse them of that? Because I think that's like a weird, it's like we do things for clicks online. Most people don't.
Savannah Guthrie
People are always making allegations like that, whether it's a writer's strike or politics. I think you have to kind of shut out that noise. I'm all for fair criticism. I think you always have to be looking inward and saying, "Are we covering this correctly? Are we giving it the time and energy it needs?" I think one of our hours, the Today Show just had Fran Drescher on for an extended interview. So I think we're covering it fairly.
Kara Swisher
Sometimes you probably notice that the subjects of coverage don't always feel that you're fair. We're going to talk about that because they get to say what they want and they still feel it's unfair.
I have to ask you the critical question. Barbie or Oppenheimer? You have to pick one.
Savannah Guthrie
Oh, gosh. Well, I know this is controversial. It may get you canceled.
Kara Swisher
It is.
Savannah Guthrie
Look, I saw them both. I had the privilege of seeing them both. I really loved Barbie. It was enjoyable. I would say it's frothy, but it's not. It actually makes them...
Kara Swisher
Substantive.
Savannah Guthrie
Very, very, but also quite enjoyable. I brought my kids, my boy and my girl.
Kara Swisher
Uh-huh.
Savannah Guthrie
They both liked it. My daughter said she thought it was a little unfair to boys, which I thought was interesting. I said, "Honey, I think the message of the movie is that boys and girls should be able to be who they want to be."
Kara Swisher
That's amazing.
Savannah Guthrie
I think she was trying. I think that was the message.
Kara Swisher
Yes, it was. She was also making fun of feminism. I went and watched it a second time. When you watch it the second time, there are a ton more jokes than you realize, digs, in a good way.
Savannah Guthrie
In a good way. It's very clever and multilayered. People were saying, "Bring your kids. It'll go over their heads half of it." I said, "I think some of it went over my head."
Kara Swisher
All right. Now, a more serious thing. The biggest headline of this week, which I'm sure you're covering quite a bit. Former President Trump's third criminal case this year. This is one about his alleged efforts to overturn the results of the 2020 election. Special Prosecutor Jack Smith unveiled a four-count indictment on Tuesday, all of which focuses on Trump's election-related efforts. Not anything related to inciting the January 6th insurrection. Trump has called the charges, quote, fake. One of his favorite words. I'm expecting to appear in court today.
Savannah, you had a big interview with his lawyer. I'm going to play a clip. This guy's been a lot of places. This is apparently the defense. Let's play it.
[Clip plays]:
John Lauro
Well, I assume you're confident you can win this case.
Savannah Guthrie
Absolutely. We're going to win. Would you, at a minimum, say you'd like to see this resolved before the election?
John Lauro
I want to get to all the evidence. I want to have a chance to present our case to a jury. This is the first time that the First Amendment has been criminalized. It's the first time that a sitting president is attacking a political opponent on First Amendment grounds and basically making it a criminal to state your position and to engage in political advocacy.
Savannah Guthrie
I've got to give you a little time out on that one. We've never seen that before. Well, the indictment specifically says that the president has a First Amendment right to speech. He even has a First Amendment right to lie. It says it right here.
John Lauro
Absolutely. This indictment is criminalizing conduct, not speech.
Savannah Guthrie
No, it's criminalizing speech for this reason.
John Lauro
What the president saw in the 2020 election was all these irregularities going on. Affidavits, sworn testimony, examples of instances where the rules were changed in the middle of the game. He had every right to comment on that and act politically. In a criminal case, what they would have to show is all of that speech was not entitled to First Amendment protection.
[Clip ends]:
Kara Swisher
Wow. That was, I've heard him say a version of this. This is John, is it Laura?
Savannah Guthrie
Laura, right.
Kara Swisher
So I want to talk to you about how we interview people. I think you did a good job there. Nonetheless, he gets to say this, stuff like that, which I think is outlandish, what they're trying, but they can try it. How we get an actual story out of them. We're going to talk about some of our most memorable interviews. I want you to talk about this one. You did push back right away. Talk about what you knew was coming, presumably because you saw him say it before. Talk a little bit about what you were doing here. I want people to understand you're trying to be fair. At the same time, you can't let something lie. It's a much more difficult situation than it used to be, for sure.
Savannah Guthrie
This is what's so tricky about these interviews because it's a balancing act. You are there, you've asked someone to come on to share their views. So it makes no sense to not let them share their views. On the other hand, you can't let statements that are demonstrably false or subject to challenge go unchallenged. Especially in a live interview, you're making that judgment call. How much is enough? How long do I let this go before I jump in here and try to bring some facts and information to the table for that person to react to?
So I let him say his piece. I was holding the indictment and it was just to say that the argument you're making has actually been contemplated by the prosecutor here. This is not a First Amendment case. This is about conduct. The longer version of that, he says, "Conduct can be speech. It's like a filibuster." And then I interrupt again. I said, "A filibuster is not illegal. Trying to send a slate of fake electors is. That is illegal conduct." So it's just that balancing act of letting them respond to the questions. That's what they're there for. That's what you ask them there to do. But also bringing up alternative information for them to react to.
Kara Swisher
But a lot of lawyers especially don't want to come off there. One of the things that I think Steve Bannon talked about and others is if you just keep repeating it, and Trump has said this to people, if you keep repeating something, even if it's a lie, it'll work eventually if you keep doing that. It's something I think about a lot. Two things: one, people are like, "You platform this person." I did Chris Christie today, for example. A lot of people don't like him, "You can't platform him." I'm like, "I can platform anyone I want." I don't even like the word.
Savannah Guthrie
Yeah, I agree with you.
Kara Swisher
What goes through your head? Is there a golden rule you follow in every single interview?
Savannah Guthrie
Fairness, precision, accuracy, preparation. That's the bedrock. That's the hallmark. Sincerity. That's something that I think about a lot. Before I approach an interview, I have to have my head on straight and know what the interview is for. It is to listen to information. It is to shed light. It is not for me. It is for the viewers. It's not to make me look good. I'm not trying to find some gotcha. Sometimes that happens. I find myself in those situations, but it's not because I'm showing off or because I want to get that person.
Sometimes I say to our young producers who might send me a research note and say, "I think we could get them on this or that." I say, "Does it matter? Are we dancing on the head of a pin here? Are we saying you should have used a comma, not a semicolon? Or is it something that goes to the heart of the matter?" If you're going to get into it with somebody, it better go to the heart of the matter. This interview you just played with John Lauro, this is a central issue to the case, this First Amendment.
I'm with you on the platforming thing. First of all, it's a crime against grammar. "Platform" is a noun, not a verb. So I take offense. But generally speaking, that is what we're here for. If the person is newsworthy and they are in a position to impact policy, they should be heard from and they should face questions. That is a service.
Kara Swisher
Do you worry, though? When he was saying this, it was interesting because I was trying to think of what would I have done. If I talk, these people won't talk to me because I actually might jump on them a little more. But I would say, "This is nonsense, what you're saying," or "Most people think it's nonsense." You can make any argument you want. How do you resist saying that? I don't know what you think.
Savannah Guthrie
Well, first of all, what I think in my own personal views are actually totally irrelevant to the job at hand, as far as I'm concerned, for what I'm doing. Our positions are a little different. So what I think is beside the point. Rather than say it's nonsense, I'd rather use facts.
Kara Swisher
Which you said. The indictment is criminalizing content, not speech.
Savannah Guthrie
Yes. And then I read another section from the indictment that makes that point explicit. And then when he brings up the filibuster idea, I point out the distinction: filibuster is legal conduct. Fraud is not. For me, it's just about facts. When you really are wed to facts and you have marshaled the facts, and this is part of preparation, thought about them ahead of time, that is the antidote. It's not emotional for me. It's just not. It's about the facts.
Honestly, I have a legal background. I look at it as sets of arguments and counter arguments. I'm interested intellectually in what the arguments and counter arguments are on the side of an issue. That's what I'm trying to bring out.
Kara Swisher
The lawyers can be very dramatic in court. They say, "Not nonsense," but they aren't always doing facts. They're also playing to the crowd.
Savannah Guthrie
Well, the lawyers are. They're totally different. They're advocates.
Kara Swisher
Right. Yeah.
Savannah Guthrie
So what I'm saying is I'm using something that I think I learned in my legal training to dispassionately look at arguments and sets of arguments. But if I were an advocate, it'd be a different story. And yes, lawyers are quite persuasive. This lawyer, John Lauro, was a pretty darn good advocate. He was very tenacious.
Kara Swisher
He has to keep repeating it. Does your legal background help you in that regard? I'm curious. I don't have a legal background.
Savannah Guthrie
I think so. I hope so. What I just said about analyzing arguments, analyzing issues, I think it helps that way. It helps also when covering legal cases. There's a certain familiarity. I've read one billion indictments in my day. I've sat in many, many courtrooms, not as a litigator. I was never a litigator. I went to law school. I passed the bar. I briefly practiced. I'm like a fake lawyer. I never passed myself off as a real trial lawyer.
Kara Swisher
What was your big case?
Savannah Guthrie
I didn't have any big case. I worked on the Enron case. I was at a big law firm and we had an Enron matter. We had one of the Enron defendants. But I'm not a real lawyer, but the background is real.
Kara Swisher
Right, right.
Savannah Guthrie
I paid, I just stopped paying my debt a few years back. So that's real.
Kara Swisher
That's true. Well, speaking of interviewing people who often employ a lot of verbal antics, I want to start by playing one of your Emmy winning interviews. This is a town hall with former President Trump in October of 2020, right before the election. Here you're talking about spreading conspiracy theories, something I know a lot about. Let's listen.
[Clip plays]:
Savannah Guthrie
Just this week, you retweeted to your 87 million followers a conspiracy theory that Joe Biden orchestrated to have SEAL Team 6, the Navy SEAL 2-6, killed to cover up the fake death of bin Laden. Now, why would you send a lie like that to your followers?
Donald Trump
You retweeted it. That was a retweet. That was an opinion of somebody. And that was a retweet. I'll put it out there. People can decide for themselves. I don't take a position.
Savannah Guthrie
You're the president. You're not like someone's crazy uncle who can just retweet whatever.
Donald Trump
That was a retweet. And I do a lot of retweets. And frankly, because the media is so fake and so corrupt, if I didn't have social media, I don't call it Twitter, I call it social media, I wouldn't be able to get the word out. And the word is, and you know what the word is? The word is very simple. We're building our country stronger and better than it's ever been before. And that's what's happening. And everybody knows it. You know what else the word is? We're winning in a lot of states. We're winning in a lot of states.
[Clip ends]:
Kara Swisher
Wow. I just don't listen to that. I talk about interviewing him because I have not. I have asked many times. I've even said I'd love to do it right at Mar-a-Lago in the lobby just to make him feel safe, which of course he wouldn't be, but he would be safe physically, but from an interview. Talk about your strategy going into this interview because he shifted three or four times. Listening to it, it was really something. He's not really answering your question and then he shifts to something else. Then he starts doing a stump speech right in the middle of it. And of course he never answers your question whatsoever.
Savannah Guthrie
Well, he is an interesting figure to interview. Many people you interview will do a version of that thing where you start on one thing, and then they shift the topic. My husband does media training, so I sometimes overhear these on the conference call. That's kind of what they tell these business executives. If you're very good at it, you would sort of answer the question and then pivot, to borrow a word, over to what you really want to talk about. So it's a common practice and an effective one.
In that particular case, people have asked me many times whether I planned to say "that's what a crazy uncle does." No, I did not. Absolutely not. I was in the moment. It's kind of horrifying to me.
Kara Swisher
Really? Tell me why.
Savannah Guthrie
Because it's so casual. But at the same time, my whole attitude in entering that interview, and actually I think most interviews, is common sense. As a parent, you know this. It's not emotional if you're being a good parent. It's like, "Why did you do that? Why did you say that?" "Oh, I didn't do it. I didn't write on the wall." "Well, it's in red crayon." "Well, it wasn't me." "Well, it says your name." You're just kind of dispassionately stating the truth.
In the case of the SEAL Team 6 conspiracy theory, I can't say to John Lauro, "Your First Amendment argument is nonsense." It's not nonsense. I don't know if it's going to prevail in court, but he's got an argument. Telling me that SEAL Team 6 conspired to cover up the bin Laden, that is a lie. So in that case, I said, "It's wrong. Why are you doing that?" It's trying to go behind the, not just, "Did you do it? Was it right?" It's just saying, "Why do you think it's okay to spread a lie?" And then he said, "I got to get the word out." The word is false.
Kara Swisher
Right, right.
Savannah Guthrie
In that case, he uses that as an excuse to say terrible things by saying, "I just retweeted it. It wasn't me." It's the "just asking questions" thing.
Kara Swisher
"I'm just asking questions."
Savannah Guthrie
Yeah, well, that wouldn't work for a mom. And it doesn't work for this. You don't just throw things out into the world and then go, "Gosh, I wonder what will happen" when you know that you're the president and you have a responsibility. That's all I was saying. This isn't something that happens without any ramifications.
Kara Swisher
No, not at all. So when you interview him in particular, what is the strategy? It's really difficult.
Savannah Guthrie
What's difficult is that you want to be fair. It goes back to what we talked about. You invited the person on and you want to give them a chance to answer the question. It's their choice how to answer it. Sometimes you let the question go, you let the answer go. You have to trust that the viewer knows and can understand that you asked a question and that question is not being answered. So sometimes it's a matter of that. An egregious false statement, you want to be trying to call that out in real time.
For him, my general approach is to really try to know the issues, know what he's likely to say. I do a lot of, not just for him, this is really true for any interview, I do a lot of thinking beforehand about what my question is. I don't just write my questions. I don't just think of questions. I imagine the answer. I go through the whole process. "I'll ask this. They'll likely say that. The response to that is this. The response to that is that." I just try to go multi-level deep thinking about it.
Kara Swisher
It looks a lot like anxiety.
Savannah Guthrie
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
See, I have a total opposite. I do not do that. I prep and I have some idea, but the difficulty I think of Trump is the constant lies and the fact that what you do is you spend your entire interview fact-checking someone, which is not a successful interview because you are on your back foot of always checking. And then it's not really what you're trying to accomplish there, right?
Savannah Guthrie
No. And then it can really devolve into this overtalk. It happens. I hate that. I find myself in these situations where I interrupt.
Kara Swisher
You insert it, which I thought was fine.
Savannah Guthrie
I hate interrupting. It's not my personality. If you and I were having a cocktail, I would try not to interrupt if you were telling me a story, but sometimes you have to. At the same time, you're thinking about the listener's experience. If you're too overheated, if you're too overtalked, if you're jumping on every last little thing, now they're starting to think you're the one with the bias. You're the one with the problem. You and I, we all get accused of that all day long from all corners of the political realm. So there's only so much you can do. I think it's just a super delicate balancing act. How much to let someone say what they have to say and trust that the listeners will see it for what it is. If we just interrupted everything, then why even have them on?
Kara Swisher
That's true. But I think some people are more cynical. I think someone like Donald Trump really knows what he's doing in terms of he assumes our fairness and uses it as a weapon.
This is on the long lines of social media misinformation, because I think that's what it is. This interview I had with defunct social media platform Parler's CEO, John Matze, in the immediate aftermath of January 6th. I taped it on January 6th. I had emotion happen when I was a mile from the Capitol. I don't think I had out of control emotion, but it was very upsetting to see what was going on in the Capitol. Let's listen to that.
[Clip plays]:
Are you actually neutral? Are you seeing right now as a right-wing publisher? All the people affiliated with you are more on the right. How do you change that? And tell me about the ownership structure.
John Matze
Well, today, a lot of people on the platform are on the right. We have appealed to people on the right because they are primarily the victims of online censorship right now, the way I see it.
Kara Swisher
There's no actual evidence of that happening, just them saying it.
John Matze
There's also no actual evidence of it not happening either.
Kara Swisher
Oh, my God. Come on. Neither. That's Loch Ness monster. You can't say that, though. I would like to see evidence of it, just like I'd like to see more evidence of widespread election fraud, which, of course, you don't see in courts. Courts have already...
John Matze
Well, yeah. So, I mean, I don't want to get into the election thing, but let's put it this way. People feel that they are being censored online and they can't get their voice out.
Kara Swisher
But okay. They're over there. They've moved over there. They're hurt by something that Twitter's done, although they certainly can't resist it on many levels.
[Clip ends]:
So I thought "my feelings are not facts" was fantastic, I have to say.
Savannah Guthrie
I have to say that was my favorite part too. I like it and it's the right response.
Kara Swisher
I'm curious if you think that's too, I wouldn't see this on a network television thing, this kind of back and forth, or maybe you might.
Savannah Guthrie
I would say the first part I wouldn't necessarily, but the second maybe, because he just asserted a fact. "They are bullied online or they're censored online." You said, "That's not true. But where's the evidence of that?" I think for us, it'd be more, "Where's your evidence?" as opposed to saying it's not true. "Show me some facts." But I think you saying "feelings are not facts" is the right response, especially since he asserted it as a fact and now he's changed it to, "Well, they feel that way." That's fine. Then you should have said that in the first place.
Kara Swisher
Right, right. Absolutely. But that's why I said feelings are not facts. He ended up getting fired after this interview.
Savannah Guthrie
Oh, wow.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, because of several things he said, including that he didn't feel responsible for inaccuracies on the platform at all or that things were wrong. I kept saying, "You have people who will kick you off for this, either Amazon or Apple." And he kept saying it. He felt no responsibility for violence and he felt no responsibility, which was interesting that he said it. I was sort of surprised.
Savannah Guthrie
Well, there's a lot of candor there, I guess.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I guess. People tend to do that with me. I don't know why, but he did actually get fired in the wake of this. I don't think I caused it. I think he said it, right?
So is there someone you wouldn't interview? I talked to, of all people, so opposite from you, Piers Morgan, and he said he wouldn't interview Marjorie Taylor Greene, for example. I don't know if I would either. Not because I don't like her, for one, and I'd be happy to say it, but also the persistent lies are almost impossible. It's an impossible interview, that kind of thing. I know Leslie Stahl did, and she is a friend of mine, and she got some blowback for that interview. Do you think about that at all?
Savannah Guthrie
All the time. The list of people I don't want to interview is long. I'm not naming names, but I do think about it. I also think about it in terms of our show, what's good for our show, what are our viewers interested in, and also whether it's valuable, whether it's worth it. Sometimes every once in a while you have these cultural stories that are really controversial. And it's like, do we need to be in that game?
I don't know. Sometimes I have. We have been. And yeah, sometimes I do interviews that I wish I didn't have to do, honestly. I wish I didn't have to, but I know it's my job. So what am I going to do, sit around and cry? They write me a paycheck, I cash it every two weeks. This is my job, right?
Kara Swisher
But would you say absolutely not to someone? If you said no, you can. I would, and I do. I feel supported by my bosses, and I think they listen to me because I wouldn't say no for a stupid reason. If I said no, there would be a rationale behind it, because I understand that I'm an employee and I understand what my job is. But if there was something that I just didn't feel I could do morally or journalistically, I wouldn't do it. Not worth it. I had that situation—I'm blanking on who it was—but it was a right-wing figure at our Code Conference. They had just done something virulently anti-gay. I said to Walt Mossberg, who was my partner, we were supposed to do it together. I said, "I cannot sit on the stage without lunging across and slapping them." I wasn't going to, but that's the right call. In that case, you're saying, "I can't be objective." Well, that's exactly the moment you step aside.
Savannah Guthrie
Although sometimes, even if you're not objective, I see that that's the interesting thing. I show my opinions a little more. It was sort of the famous "fuck fair and balanced." I don't think there is such a thing. I don't think they are.
Kara Swisher
I think one of the things I appreciate is they know exactly where I'm coming from. I don't hide it. When journalists say, "I'm completely objective," I'm like, "You're not." Not just politically, but where you came from, where you were born, everything. It's aspirational.
Savannah Guthrie
That's the thing. Of course it's aspirational, but I cling to that aspiration. And that's the other thing. We all have so many detractors that depending on who's listening, they could marshal all kinds of evidence where they think I'm biased this way or that way. I just have to carry on. I'm not a perfect person, and I'm definitely interested in fair criticism.
Kara Swisher
Have you ever had a moment where you're like, "I just can't do this" and then burst out? I don't think I've ever seen you do that. I think you're quite controlled in the interviews, which is what I like, actually.
Savannah Guthrie
I try. I really do try to be professional. I'm inside—if you had a soundtrack to my internal dialogue, you would run screaming. I'm the opposite of you, Kara. You know what I love about you? You're like, "That was great. I loved that interview. I crushed that." That is the—you and I were talking about our graduation speeches. You're like, "Oh yeah, the kids were loving it." We could not be more opposite. I sometimes cry from stress before an interview. My internal dialogue is a terrifying place. They should make a horror movie out of it.
Kara Swisher
Oh, really?
Savannah Guthrie
Yes.
Kara Swisher
Oh, God.
Savannah Guthrie
But when push comes to shove, it's time to sit down and get down to business. That's the job.
Kara Swisher
My friends joke about it. They're always like, "Kara's always like, 'Oh, that's really great.'" Someone asked me, "How'd that go?" I'm like, "It's fantastic." They're like, "Do you ever not say it's fantastic?" When it's not fantastic, but it's so often fantastic, I don't know what to say.
Savannah Guthrie
That's what I love. I don't know if it's offensive to say this, but you have some—it's like a good—you're like men.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I am. I am like men. It's like men, they're always like, "Damn, I'm so good."
Savannah Guthrie
And then women are like, "Why are we like this?" It's true.
Kara Swisher
So I'm going to get my inner Kara up. Unless you live in Barbie Land, and then you're really good, with them all clapping for each other. Oh, I loved it. Hi, Barbie.
Savannah Guthrie
You're not afraid to interrupt either. I did interrupt that interview, and I thought it was appropriate, but you're not afraid to interrupt. Let's play this clip of you and Vice President Kamala Harris. You landed after her first year in office and one month before the Ukraine invasion.
Clip plays
Kamala Harris
I am often in the Situation Room with the leaders of our military and our intelligence community. And of course, the president of the United States. And on the subject of Ukraine, I will tell you that the president has been very clear, and we as the United States are very clear: if Putin takes aggressive action, we are prepared to levy serious and severe costs, period. And I will tell you that part of the posture that we have taken is grounded in the respect and the value we place in sovereignty and territorial integrity.
Savannah Guthrie
Madam Vice President, I'm sorry to interrupt. Sovereignty and territorial integrity of Ukraine, of course. And I'm sorry to interrupt, but it is less than clear because 30 minutes after the news conference, the White House press secretary had to actually clarify the president's remarks.
Kamala Harris
Savannah, I'm being clear with you right now.
Savannah Guthrie
Yes.
Kamala Harris
Okay. And so if you're interested, I'll continue to be clear.
Clip ends
Kara Swisher
Oh, wow. Testy.
Savannah Guthrie
Testy.
Kara Swisher
It got worse then.
Savannah Guthrie
Yeah, it did. I remember I was fascinated by it. Talk about what happened there. She was trying to do cleanup, right? And of course, she also said, "I'm in the room. I'm very important. I know of what I speak." That was that whole windup she was doing. I would have probably in that moment said, "I know you're important. Got it. Let's go right to the question." She probably thought you were trying to do a gotcha with Biden, right? "Now you've had to clean up for Biden." What went through your head?
Honestly, I thought she'd get right to the cleanup because she's coming in the day after—it was a big deal. Later in the interview, I say, "I'm sorry, let's be clear, because right now there's a hundred thousand Russian troops amassed at the border and people are hanging on your every word. So we have to be clear." I thought she would just right away say—I said, "Did he just give a green light to take a tiny nibble? Don't go a big one, but a tiny nibble?" Because that's what it sounds like. I thought she'd say, "Of course not," and then we'd be off to the races. This whole windup—I let it go. That's one of those things where it speaks for itself. So I let it go. But then when the answer wasn't clear—"aggressive action"—well, that was the issue. What counts as aggressive action? What's aggressive enough for us to respond? So that's where it got.
Kara Swisher
I have to tell you, I don't enjoy these moments of confrontation. This is not pleasant for me. I don't like how it makes me feel. I don't like what people, especially partisans, say about me afterwards, although I try not to look at it. But sometimes it has to be done. That was a fight worth having. Is it okay if he does a little something over in Crimea or over in the Donbas, but a full-scale Kyiv is not okay? That's what the issue was. And that's what we were grappling with. Be clear. And she was doing cleanup, so it was probably irritating for her. They had to send her out.
Savannah Guthrie
Yes, correct.
Kara Swisher
But if you're going to clean up, to me, I'm like, sweep it up and move on.
Savannah Guthrie
Exactly. I'd have been like, "Of course not. Next."
Kara Swisher
When you were waiting for that moment, because I could hear you waiting while she was doing her windup—which it was long. She's a lawyer. She likes to be a lawyer. She's very—I've been in that situation with Vice President Harris. She has a lot to say. But when she said, "If Putin takes aggressive action, we're prepared to levy serious and severe costs, period," which is unspecific and specific at the same time—probably poll-tested, exactly what she was going to say to you. The problem with that response in that moment was, what is the definition of aggressive? That was the very issue we were grappling with. Biden says, "It depends on what it is." And then she says, "If it's aggressive action." So I'm saying, "Well, what counts as aggressive? Is any incursion aggressive?" That's what the whole debate was about.
Savannah Guthrie
So do you feel that was a successful interview?
Kara Swisher
I think she's in a bad situation herself. She's been put in a bad situation. And at the same time, she can't go out on any limb either and be more specific.
Savannah Guthrie
Maybe she could have said, "He can't set one foot. He can't put one toenail into Ukraine." That's what I thought they'd say.
Kara Swisher
Did you expect that or not?
Savannah Guthrie
I didn't know what their position was going to be. But if you're coming on and you know that there's been a controversy—the president made this statement, the White House had to clarify it 30 minutes later, and the next day the vice president is doing the "Rile and Robin" on all of the networks—you know she's going to be asked. To me, I would have thought they wanted to dispatch this one once and for all. "Of course not. Y'all are reading into this too much. Putin can't set one tiny fingernail into Ukraine without getting the full-throated response of the U.S." That isn't what we got. So do I consider it a successful interview? I don't know. The issues were litigated. She got to say her piece. I don't like the confrontation. I don't want to do boring interviews, but I'm not trying to entertain. I'm trying to get the info.
Kara Swisher
That's true. What was the fallout from that?
Savannah Guthrie
I don't know that there was any. I don't think there was any from the White House. People talk about those interviews. I have learned finally—I don't have a thick skin at all, as we've discussed—but I don't read the comments. People will say, "Oh, great," and people will say, "You're the worst." The people who liked the Trump interview would have hated that Kamala one, and vice versa. These days, people say, "Oh, you're so biased." What I find is often they're not from the Pew Institute looking for some bastion of neutrality. They want your bias to match their bias.
Kara Swisher
A hundred percent. I refuse to talk to anyone who doesn't listen. A lot of people do that now. That's what I love about you. Next time somebody's mean to me, I'm going to say, "Call Kara. Kara Swisher is my representative in this matter."
Savannah Guthrie
All right, we go on a quick break. We'll be right back with a whole bunch of stuff around tech, because Savannah's done a lot of tech interviews.
Ad Voiceover
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin, or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Ad Voiceover 2
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports to discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person-to-person; it's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing—finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority, skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivotpod. That's linkedin.com slash pivotpod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
Kara Swisher
Savannah, we're back. Let's talk about Facebook and Meta, whatever they want to call themselves. Both opportunities to sit down with the top brass there. Let's start with your interview with Sheryl Sandberg, someone I know very well and someone I've interviewed many times too. Setting the scene: it's 2018. You're asking about Cambridge Analytica and the data the company gathered from Facebook. Very controversial. People feel that it was overblown. At the same time, it was indicative of the problems we had with Facebook. Let's listen.
Clip plays
Savannah Guthrie
This first came to Facebook's attention in December 2015. That's two and a half years ago. And only now is Facebook taking these serious steps that you've announced this week. What is the reason it took so long? You could have done all of this two and a half years ago.
Sheryl Sandberg
You are right that we could have done this two and a half years ago.
Savannah Guthrie
So why didn't you?
Sheryl Sandberg
Because we thought that the data had been deleted, and we should have checked. You are right about that. What we're doing now—we thought it had been deleted because they gave us assurances, and it wasn't until other people told us it wasn't true.
Savannah Guthrie
But why go on Facebook as someone who's already violated, in spirit if not in the letter, Facebook's principles?
Sheryl Sandberg
We had legal assurances from them that they deleted. What we didn't do was the next step of an audit, and we're trying to do that now. We thought the data had been deleted. That's why.
Savannah Guthrie
But that doesn't mean you don't tell the users, "Hey, this was stolen from you."
Sheryl Sandberg
Yes, you're right, and we should have done that. We should have done that as well.
Savannah Guthrie
Because it feels like Facebook was trying to get away with it.
Sheryl Sandberg
I don't think that's true, but of course you're right.
Clip ends
Kara Swisher
Well, that's a Sheryl special. That's a Sheryl special. "You're right. You know what? I agree with you." That was classic. I think you did a great job there. I remember paying attention to this. I thought it was one of the much better interviews with these people. Talk about this. What's the trick here to get her off? She's obviously talking points. She's like the Olympic talking points person in Silicon Valley.
Savannah Guthrie
I haven't thought about that in a long time. I was thinking about it as we were getting ready for this today. What's interesting is she was there to fall on the sword. Clearly she was there to say, "You're right. We did it wrong." And that's fine because that was her purpose. But I think my approach was, you can't just say "I'm sorry" and it's over.
Kara Swisher
Oh, that's a Facebook special. That's another "I'm sorry."
Savannah Guthrie
So I think that's what that exchange is really about. She said, "We should have—" "Well, why didn't you?" And then I think it goes back to the common sense thing where at the very end I'm saying, "It almost looks like you were hoping you could get away with it."
Kara Swisher
I like that. I love how you—I think this is very Kara. It's just call it what it is. Sometimes there's too much politeness or illusion. I think it's more effective and an opportunity for the person being interviewed if you just flat out say, "This is what people think. They think you did it on purpose and you didn't do anything till now because you were kind of hoping no one would ever find out. Is that true?" And then it gives them a chance to answer that criticism.
Savannah Guthrie
And then she goes, "Let's move fast forward to now." She wanted to get you off of it. Pivot. Pivot.
Kara Swisher
When she is doing this, I'm curious what went through your head. I've had her do that to me. One of the things I do just to get her to stop is I'm like, "Stop saying I'm right. I know what you're doing here. It's super manipulative. So stop doing it." I often call that out. Silicon Valley people are very talking points. I actually point out the talking point before they can do it. In the case of today with Chris Christie, I said, "You have four answers to this question. You have three answers." So I put him on notice that I've listened to everything he said. And then, "I'm not interested in your talking points because that's the way you answered every time. I would like a different answer or a different word."
Savannah Guthrie
That's my favorite, Kara. But when she was doing this, I want to know what you were thinking when she was saying "you're right about that." What was going through your head? Do you remember?
I must not have been surprised, but I think what my goal was to not drop it. Apology is the beginning of the interview, not the end.
Kara Swisher
Very good point.
Savannah Guthrie
That's what I was thinking. So you still have something to answer for. "Thank you for the sorry. But we still—" It's like if you were in a relationship and you got in a fight and the person said, "I was wrong for doing X." You'd say, "Thank you for saying that. I feel like we still need to address how it is we got here."
Kara Swisher
People often use the sorry as an excuse.
Savannah Guthrie
Well, there's no worse than "I'm sorry that you feel that way." That's not an apology.
Kara Swisher
That's on your relationship podcast. I could feel your annoyance when I was watching this.
Savannah Guthrie
Oh, really?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I could. I could tell that you're like, "Oh, come on." You could see it physically.
Savannah Guthrie
I don't feel that way, but maybe I was. I was watching all these interviews because I was going to do some of my own. They're not talking to me anymore. That's their new policy. I guess that's a compliment to you.
Kara Swisher
No, I've actually tried to get Sheryl for a new interview. I talked to her PR person, someone I've known for years and I really like. I ran into him at the dry cleaner in the Castro. I said, "All roads lead through Kara Swisher for Sheryl Sandberg's redemption." And he's like, "She's not going to do it." I said, "All roads. She wants to come back, she has to go the highway through Kara Town."
Savannah Guthrie
Well, I love it. And as I told you, one of the first times we texted, I said, "I will never do an interview with you."
Kara Swisher
Yeah, okay, here you are.
Savannah Guthrie
And here you are.
Kara Swisher
But we're not really interviewing you.
Savannah Guthrie
Yes, that's true. Fair. Chatting with colleagues.
Kara Swisher
In this case, it's really interesting when you do that. I'll tell you one very quick story. A similar thing happened with Barack Obama when I interviewed him. He's super smooth, obviously, and very talking points. One of the things that happened is they cut my time. And you know that when they cut your time, doesn't that suck?
Savannah Guthrie
Big deal. Yes. Time is the hardest part of those interviews.
Kara Swisher
Exactly. Which is why I make these interviews long. So they cut my time and they gave it to a YouTube star, which made me even more furious because I was talking about very serious issues. Apple had just had this issue around the phone that they were trying to decrypt. So it was an important time, and I was doing an actual serious interview. At the beginning of the interview, I leaned into him and I said, "Listen, they cut 10 minutes from my interview, and you tend to talk a lot. You talk in paragraphs. I get it because you're president and everybody listens to you and nobody pushes back. But I'm going to interrupt you, and you're not used to it. I know you are—you're on your sixth year and you don't get interrupted. I'm going to interrupt you quite a bit if you keep yammering on." He goes, "I know." And he goes—this was before it started, and we were very close to each other because we were in these chairs—he goes, "I heard you were obnoxious." I go, "Yes, I am." And then we went, and it started, and it was really interesting. He was much more pithy. I put him on notice that I didn't want—
Savannah Guthrie
I think that's amazing.
Kara Swisher
It was an interesting thing. But speaking of which, here's somewhere I didn't talk a lot. We're going to play an interview I did with Mark Zuckerberg. I've done many. Not the sweating one, where he sweat too much. But when we famously talked about content moderation, here's the clip.
Clip plays
So I'm Jewish. And there's a set of people who deny that the Holocaust happened.
Mark Zuckerberg
Right.
Kara Swisher
I find that deeply offensive. But at the end of the day, I don't believe that our platform should take that down because I think that there are things that different people get wrong. Either—
Mark Zuckerberg
I don't think that they're intentionally getting it wrong, but I think that they—
Kara Swisher
In the case of a Holocaust denier, they might be. But go ahead.
Mark Zuckerberg
It's hard to impugn intent and to understand the intent. But I just think for as abhorrent as some of those examples are, I think the reality is also that I get things wrong when I speak publicly. I'm sure you do. I'm sure a lot of leaders and public figures we respect do too. And I just don't think that it is the right thing to say we are going to take someone off the platform if they get things wrong, even multiple times. So what we will do is we'll say, "Okay, you have your page. And if you're not trying to organize harm against someone or attacking someone, then you can put up that content on your page, even if people might disagree with it or find it offensive." But that doesn't mean that we have a responsibility to make it widely distributed in News Feed.
Clip ends
Kara Swisher
Oh, that was quite a moment. And here's why. This is what I did. When he said, "I don't think they're intentionally getting it wrong"—first of all, we were talking about Alex Jones, and he moved into Holocaust deniers. I kept internally, "Oh no, sir, don't do that, dude." He was using it because I'm Jewish. He was trying to say, "Even I as a Jewish person can talk about Holocaust deniers and let them say what they want to say." And when he said, "I don't think they're intentionally getting it wrong," right then in my head, I was like, "You fucking idiot." That's what I thought at the time. How?
What? I normally would have said, "Are you kidding me? You cannot be saying this. Of course they're intentionally getting it wrong. They're malevolent players. There's a difference between someone who gets it wrong and someone who's malevolent." I could have gone on there. I didn't. I remember saying, "Control yourself, Kara. Let him talk. Let's hear what he has to say so everyone understands how incredibly nonsensical his argument is. Let him lay it out in all its terribleness." So I said—I did put in, "In the case of Holocaust deniers, they might be," because I wanted to put a pin right there that they're malevolent.
And then I later went back and said that. He later had to clarify his remarks because I knew that it would blow up like a Roman candle. I left that interview as fast as I could, and we got up as fast as we could before they realized what had happened. He clarified his remarks later saying, "I personally find Holocaust denial deeply offensive. I absolutely didn't intend to defend the intent of people who deny that." I remember thinking that was one of my best interviews because I didn't say something.
Savannah Guthrie
I know. And it's true. And you said enough in that moment. So no one could say, "Oh, Kara, you just let this nonsense go unchallenged." No one could say that. But it is true. You allowed him to complete his thought. There's a good Latin phrase from law school: res ipsa loquitur. It speaks for itself. Sometimes the best thing to do is get out of the way.
Kara Swisher
Get out of the way. Do you find yourself when you're in interviews like that? Because I always interject. I'm a very interjecting person. But in this case, I thought, "You must understand that this person running this company doesn't know what they're talking about. This is the person making the decisions." Two years later, he took Holocaust deniers off the platform. Two years of damage. He kept saying I was wrong, and of course I was right. And he did it later. I wrote a column later called "The Expensive Education of Mark Zuckerberg," which was expensive for us, not for him.
Savannah Guthrie
Do you ever find yourself wanting to jump in and then not doing it? You're very controlled in interviews, which I do like. I do watch you because of that. I don't have a particular occasion that comes to mind like that where I'm thinking, "Oh, just let this go." But I'm always very mindful of being fair enough to let the person say what they want to say. They did not sign up for a debate. They signed up for an interview when they came on our air. Even though sometimes it does feel like I'm debating when you start having to go back on facts, it's always that balancing act. It's really delicate. Sometimes I'll listen back to some of these clips and think, "I really let that go on for a long time. That was maybe too generous." And then sometimes I think, "God, I was a little hot-headed and over-torqued. It's a little too much." I'm critical of my technique, but I know what I'm thinking in the moment. Sometimes I'm trying to give them a chance to say what they have to say.
Kara Swisher
100%. That's what I say. "You'll be able to say what you think. It just doesn't mean it's going to come off well." I do think one of the good things about what I like about your news is they're longer and they're more substantive. A lot of stuff on TV today is so short and reductive. I do think these longer interviews—I trust the listener to know these things. We tend to dumb down and think our listeners are stupider than they are, and they're not at all.
Savannah Guthrie
All right, Savannah, one more quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about some of the more emotional interviews we've done. Kara can be emotional.
Ad Voiceover
Mint is still $15 a month for premium wireless. And if you haven't made the switch yet, here are 15 reasons why you should. One, it's $15 a month. Two, seriously, it's $15 a month. Three, no big contracts. Four, I use it. Five, my mom uses it. Are you playing me off? That's what's happening, right? Okay. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 per three-month plan. Per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. Mint Mobile.
Ad Voiceover 2
The Smuckers Uncrustables podcast with your host, Uncrustables. Okay, today's guest is rough around the edges. Please welcome Crust. Thanks for having me. Today's topic: he's round with soft, pillowy bread, filled with delicious PB&J. Are you talking about yourself? And you can take them anywhere. Why'd you invite—and we are out of time. Are you really cutting me off? Uncrustables are the best part of the sandwich. Sorry, Crust.
Kara Swisher
Savannah, we're back. We've talked a lot about getting people to reveal information, advance the story, and sometimes about getting them to reveal and process emotions. I want to talk about—I don't want to say "regular people" because we're all regular people—but the people we often interview are pros, just like we are.
And say they know the game and everything else. Your interview with the parents of the Louisville bank shooter, which I thought was really—I love this interview. I hate to say I loved it, but I did. It was very moving earlier this year. Let's play it and then let's talk about it.
Clip plays
Parent
There's no comprehension of him doing an act like this to others. So our issues are around the minutiae of little things like, man, we didn't see that. Even little things like, as men, we don't always verbalize things to each other, but...
Parent 2
I think I'm going to pull the parachute out of that answer and walk away from it. I do want to say, though, I had no idea. And even when he was telling me that he was sort of in a crisis, we thought we had it handled. We thought it was being managed. He does not fit the profile. He wasn't a loner. He had a job. He had a girlfriend. He was successful. And he only had anxiety. He only had maybe panic attacks. That's it.
Savannah Guthrie
And what happened to you is unthinkable, but you also did lose a son. And your son also did a terrible thing. And I just wonder how you deal with that.
Parent
It would have been bad enough if we had just lost our son, but for him to take others with him. It's just beyond what we've taught him, the way we live. We're always saying, do no harm. He didn't do that.
Clip ends
Kara Swisher
Well, this was a gut punch, Savannah. And especially that question where you are clearly yourself emotional, which was appropriate. When you said, "You lost the son, but he also did a terrible thing. I wonder how you deal with that." I thought that was one of the most perfect ways to ask that question. Talk a little bit about how you got this interview and how you approached it.
Savannah Guthrie
Well, first of all, I have to say that the Sturgeons are incredible people and incredibly courageous to sit for an interview like that. Unfortunately, we cover a lot of school shootings. I've been to too many to count. It's just common practice that after these shootings, our bookers, producers, for all the networks, for all the newspapers, everyone, they'll always put in a request to speak to the family of the shooter. It is almost never even answered. In this case, after a few days, they responded. And we spoke a few times before.
Kara Swisher
You were in that.
Savannah Guthrie
Yes. I talked to them about what it would be like, what they were hoping to accomplish. I always tell people before doing an interview, I'm very upfront about this: "This will not be easy. There will be hard questions. You just have to know that." I never want someone to feel like, "Oh, she led me down the primrose path. I thought this was going to be a cakewalk." I'm like, "This is your—there are things that are hard. We're going to talk about them, but I promise you it'll be fair. I promise you you'll get an honest conversation." So we had those kinds of discussions.
Honestly, I was kind of afraid myself to even do it because I felt like, gosh, I just kept thinking about the victims. And they did too. The Sturgeons were like, "We don't want to do anything that will hurt them and make it worse. At the same time, something's got to change. This can't just keep happening. And if we can add our voice and explain what happened to us so that people understand this is how it happens, it can happen to anyone. If it could happen to us, it could." I mean, they really were better parents than most of the parents I know in terms of being on it and paying attention. So I was really nervous about doing it.
One of my approaches was, I think the first question I asked them when I sat down was, "What makes you nervous about doing an interview like this?" And it gave them the opportunity to say, "We're so afraid of hurting the victims. That's our biggest fear." And then the moment you just mentioned—and there was another—I felt like I have to ask what they did, ask about Connor. You don't want to platform someone who did such a horrible thing. So I felt like it was important to just state the fact: you lost a son and your son did something horrific. And these two things can coexist. And how do you hold those two things in your hands at the same time?
Kara Swisher
Right. I thought this was gripping and also terrible. It was a terrible thing to listen to. One of the things that I think is difficult, and I don't know if I could do an interview like this, is because I would think of the victims almost the entire time. And at the same time, as a parent, you brought that here, whether you realize it or not. Can you imagine putting yourself in that situation? It's hard to have empathy for them, and you managed to do that, which I think is difficult.
Savannah Guthrie
I think as a parent—you're a parent too—that's just so part of the fabric of who we are. I think about myself as a parent of a child who was shot, and I think of myself as a parent of a child who did something horrible. I could see the pain and torment of being in both of those positions. So you can't help but bring that. And they also were particularly—there are different scenarios and different situations where it's harder to have as much empathy. These were parents who by all accounts really did the best they could. The minute that he even expressed feelings of having a panic attack, he stayed home from work. She got him a therapist appointment. They joined the therapist appointment. They spent the whole weekend with him. He had a roommate, he had a girlfriend. They just never thought he had guns. So it was a valuable perspective that they brought.
I sometimes still keep in touch with people I've interviewed just to check on them, see how they're doing. I don't think she ever watched. She couldn't bear to watch. But I think she felt like something's got to change. And if it means I have to be courageous, then I guess that's where I'm at now.
Kara Swisher
And then the last question—so many of these interviews, they sound the same, right? They ultimately—and you get people used to them. Is that ever a worry of yours?
Savannah Guthrie
Well, in the case of the Sturgeons, this was a very rare perspective to have. But in the case of, for example, heartbreaking parents who are in grief because their children have been the victims of a school shooting, I hope we never get numb to it. I think it wouldn't be right, though, if somebody wants to tell their story, to not let them share their grief, let the world see what they lost in particular. It's unfortunate that people shrug it off or say, "Oh, I can't watch that. It's too much for me. It's too sad." My view is, if that person in their grief has the courage to tell the story, then we better have the courage to listen.
Kara Swisher
And I don't know if it makes a difference. Everyone's different. That's the next thing you hear a lot in our business. You're like, "Oh, it's awful that you talk to those parents. It's so exploitative." Some people say no way and some people say yes. Some people want to speak. I don't know. I think I'd be the kind of person if something like that happened to me, I think I'd shut that door tight and say, "Go away." But other people want to speak and they have their reasons. And our job is to ask them if they want that opportunity. I don't judge whether it's right or wrong that they do it. I think it's mostly people chasing people that is not okay. We don't do that. We're not here to further traumatize people who are in the midst of incredible trauma.
Savannah Guthrie
Absolutely.
Kara Swisher
I did an interview with one of the Sandy Hook parents and I decided to take a different direction. Rather than talk about the tragedy that was many years on, I wanted to focus on social media because this kid's picture was all over the place. He couldn't get the social media people to take it down until he sued them for copyright. I wanted him to talk about that because I was like, "Let me just show you a tactic this guy is using." And in showing that, it shows what he had to do to get people to take down horrific pictures. I decided to go in a different direction. I thought that was successful.
Savannah Guthrie
Well, it is. And it's also a different facet of his grief. And it's valuable to people. I don't think most good-hearted people have any idea what some of those families have had to contend with.
Kara Swisher
Which I thought—people were like, "I never heard about that." I was like, "That's what I was going for." You've heard the tragedy. Now hear what it's actually like on a day-to-day basis.
All right, last one we're going to play is one of—I can have feelings, Savannah. I can. One of the more poignant interviews I've done with Monica Lewinsky. I think this is my favorite interview, largely because I wanted people to reevaluate her. I think she's had a lot of grace. I know she made a mistake when she was 20, but she was 20. Who didn't? Who didn't, right? And she made it on a big scale. But of all the people involved in this, she's the only one who hasn't dropped a dime. She hasn't taken advantage of it. I've gotten to know her and I like her. I now consider her a friend after this interview, where we talked about alternate endings. Let's listen.
Clip plays
The name of your production company is Alt-Ending. What would your Alt-Ending be if you had to rewrite it?
Monica Lewinsky
Oh, gosh. Again, back to maybe the boring or the banal, my Alt-Ending would have been I left my internship, I went to graduate school, got a PhD in forensic psychology, got married, had kids.
Kara Swisher
You can still have all the endings, you know?
Monica Lewinsky
Yes, I can. This one's a good one. I have had—the last seven years for me have been nothing short of a fucking miracle. And so I feel like, all right, well, if I've had one miracle, I could have another. And I have—as Pollyanna as my mom can be at times, I think she prefers "sanguine"—but she's always saying, "You never know what or who is around the corner." So I know.
Kara Swisher
Well, you can look out for my next boyfriend.
Monica Lewinsky
All right. I know some people, but they're not going to be assholes.
Kara Swisher
You're not going to have a bad boyfriend.
Monica Lewinsky
First, my therapist says, "We just need to find you a kind narcissist who's a little less broken than some of the others."
Kara Swisher
There'll be no bad boyfriends for Monica Lewinsky.
Clip ends
I thought this was really great. When she said—except for my Brenda Vaccaro voice, I was sick. And I thought being accessible to her was really important. I was surprised when she started to say that. It really affected me emotionally. When she said, "I could have had kids, I would have had a career," and none of this was available to her because of what happened. Again, she took responsibility for her part. But for the most part, she was taken advantage of by everybody—not just Bill Clinton, but the whole media, everyone on every side of it. I just felt like it was okay to be a little emotional in this one.
Savannah Guthrie
Well, first of all, I teared up listening to it. I know Monica a little bit too. I find her to be extraordinary—the way that with her intelligence, but also her wisdom and grace, never shirking her responsibility and her role, never playing the victim, but just marching forward valiantly. In a news interview, that distance and objectivity is obviously required. Sometimes I feel this way about a celebrity interview or something that's a little softer. For me, the goal is connection. And that's what you accomplished there. You connected. And in connecting, it was revelatory. And that's the mission of the interview.
Sometimes it's less about "what's your next project" or this or that. Sometimes it's just about connecting because you can see something in the way that if you click with the person or you share a joke or a laugh, it's revelatory. You learn something. And that's for the viewer. We're doing this for someone else. We're not doing it for ourselves. We're doing it because someone's listening or watching and they want to learn something and come away with something. There's got to be some value added. So for me, I like that approach with Monica. It's appropriate to the interview and it was revealing.
Kara Swisher
I sometimes fear wanting to like someone. And now I've sort of shifted after that. I shifted. It's like, if I like them, I'll say I like them, and I don't care. Or if I don't like someone. It's okay to like people.
Savannah Guthrie
I know it is.
Kara Swisher
I know, but I also don't like people. And I think it's okay to say, "I don't like you." But even before an interview, or change my mind because I think you're a jerk, that kind of thing. So it's an interesting approach. And I really thought this was an important one.
Okay, my last question, then I'll let you go, because I know you've been working very hard all day. This is a long day for you, right? Last question. Any absolute favorite interview?
Savannah Guthrie
I mean, I have one, but it's so weird.
Kara Swisher
Go ahead. I want it.
Savannah Guthrie
You're going to cut this out. And that's fine. A long time ago, there was a man on trial in the death of Michael Jackson, Dr. Conrad Murray. I got an interview with him. For some reason, he agreed to an interview while he was still on trial. The jury was about to go out, so it was just after the jury comes back, then you can air it. So maybe it was a day or two before the verdict. I do have this legal background, but as I confess to you, I'm not a real lawyer. I'm a totally fake lawyer. But I learned that case backwards and forwards. And he never took the stand. So I got to do a three-part interview. We went through every fact. And it's the closest I'll ever come to doing a cross-examination. And I kind of enjoyed it. So it was the moment I was the lawyer that I never got to be.
Kara Swisher
Alternate ending, Savannah. Alternate ending. I love that. We're leaving that in.
My favorite of these were Steve Jobs, always, because he always gave as good as he got. He was an adult. And even after I gave him a hard time, he was just great. He was like, "Okay, that was good." And a lot of these people that feel upset, I'm like, "Oh, come on, you big baby."
Savannah Guthrie
Well, you know what? I think it makes them look good when they're fearless.
Kara Swisher
Right. Well, he answered the questions. And when he lied, he said he lied. Like when I asked him questions a year later, I'm like, "That was a lie." He's like, "Yeah, I lied to you." I kind of was like, "Okay, okay, we know where we are."
Anyway, Savannah, I have so much regard for you. We'll be back on Tuesday with more Pivot and guest host Teddy Schleifer. We've got a lot of people coming on. So it should be a really great Scott Free August, but you've started it off perfectly and I really appreciate it. And I will read us out. Thank you, Savannah. I'm honored.
Savannah Guthrie
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
Today's show was produced by Lara Neiman and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Enderdot engineered this episode. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business in this Scott Free month of August. Bye.