Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode of Pivot, hosted by Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway, covers various topics including Elon Musk's Twitter verification policy, media layoffs and closures, and the future of AI.
Main Topic: The episode primarily focuses on the media industry, specifically the layoffs and closures of several iconic brands, including Disney, Lyft, BuzzFeed News, and Bed Bath & Beyond. The hosts also discuss the implications of these events on the economy and the future of media.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Ad break
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Intro music
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher with a blue check. Block the blue. Block the blue. Are you going to block me? Really? I don't want my blue check. I'm actually curious what you think.
Scott Galloway
I'm actually thinking. We're going to talk about it at length, but go ahead. What do you think about the idea of blocking people with a blue check?
Kara Swisher
Stupid. It's not their fault. I didn't ask for mine. I got taken off and put back on. As people may or may not know, there's a lot of blue check shenanigans going on over the weekend. Mine got taken off and then put back on. Scott's got taken off and then not put back on.
Scott Galloway
Correct. Is that correct?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, my understanding is it's people over a million that Elon likes. I guess he likes it. I don't know. All these celebrities who didn't have over a million. I don't know. Who knows? My sense of the people who have blue checks are either kind of red pill or selling me something. Right. And so I actually think my feed would be a little cleaner. And also, generally speaking, I don't like the man and want Twitter to be bankrupt and have a more responsible owner.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Okay. All right. So there's that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
But at the same time, I feel this is, in general, like a series of unwelcome sequels. Every time we're talking about this guy, I think it's like Paul Blart, Mall Cop 11. It's like, do I really need to be thinking about a blue check?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I agree. And how strange this individual is.
Scott Galloway
It is. And last night I got all hopped up on my own thought opium. I'm like, I'm going to block blue checks. And I thought, what would I do about Kara? And then I thought, why am I even thinking about this?
Kara Swisher
Right, that's true. I don't even know how you do it. How was your weekend? I was in San Francisco, you know, in Los Angeles. So my weekend, I'm glad you asked. My weekend was the best and worst of times. And usually both those things involve family. So I'll start with the best. My 12-year-old Kara is at the most lovely age. Right now, he's just fascinated by malls. In London, there's the Battersea Power Station, which was this old incredible infrastructure that's been converted for $9 billion in 20 years into this incredible mall. He was so excited about it. We went and got ice cream and went to the Nike store to look at football cleats and then do what we do when we go anywhere. We had to go to the top of it because when you go to the top of something, it's going to be cool, I guess.
Scott Galloway
Right. Yeah, apparently.
Kara Swisher
So I just had a wonderful week with my 12-year-old. On a more serious side, my dad's at that age where his cognitive ability is declining. He called me last night and said, "Can you come pick me up? There's people here with guns." He's imagining things that aren't there. And he's scared. There's not a lot you can do from eight time zones away. So that was upsetting.
Scott Galloway
Oh, dear. That's terrible. I'm sorry. What are you going to do for your dad?
Kara Swisher
Well, all I can do, and that's the problem, there's not a lot you can do, is I call the facility and then I call his health aide and I say, "Can you reassure him that, A, can you tell him I'm in London and unfortunately I can't get there? And B, that there aren't people with guns in the Wesley Palms assisted living facility and he doesn't need to worry." But there's not a lot you can do. All you can do is provide comfort. The reality is I have the resources to deal with this. I can't imagine what it's like for people who don't have resources.
Scott Galloway
Even with resources, it's hard. As you know, my mom, and I've been talking about this, my mom's as sharp as a tack, so she can call you if you'd like. If you want a tough parent calling you.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Yeah. It's hard. It's hard to figure it out. I think about that all the time. One of the things I do think about, I flew back and I made waffles on Sunday morning. I got back on an overnight flight and I made waffles and Claire's like, "This is so nice, mom." And I looked at her, I said, "You'll be taking care of me when I'm old. I made you these nice waffles. Now there will be payback at some point."
Scott Galloway
Anyway, we have so much time. We are going to talk about Elon's very bad weekend because I want to understand it from a business perspective. It's really in real time Harvard Business School stuff. Also, layoffs and closures hit some iconic brands. And we'll speak with Puck's Baratunde Thurston, one of Pivot's very best friends, about AI, climate, and hope for the future. But first, Fox News announced that it agreed to part ways with its most-watched primetime host, Tucker Carlson. His last show was Friday, and if you watch it, details are still coming at the time of this recording. It could be the Washington Post is reporting it was Carlson's comments about Fox management, as revealed in the Dominion case, that played a role in his departure.
He may be running for president. I don't really know. Nobody knows. The text revealed as part of the Dominion suit, Carlson said he hates Trump. Again, he might be preparing to run for office. His Friday sign-off was, "We'll be back on Monday," which really makes this look like it was Fox's decision, not his. A few days earlier, Fox parted ways with Dan Bongino. Interesting, neither Bongino nor Carlson were huge players in the Dominion case, as far as we know. Mostly focused on Lou Dobbs and Maria Bartiromo. She better back slowly from the room, probably. She's probably being eyed by Fox if this has happened.
Getting rid of your big star is a big move. The platforms, though, like Chris Cuomo was the biggest star on CNN. Typically speaking, personalities will overestimate their power and underestimate how much power the platform brought. There's just no shortage of McLean Stevens who are like, "I'm bigger than MASH. I should be in movies." Or Shelley Long.
Kara Swisher
That is true. I have a lot of friends who are partners at iconic investment banks and thought they were going to have these big careers in private equity and have boards calling them. They find out when they no longer have the Goldman Sachs or Bridgewater card that they don't get their calls returned quite as quickly. My first thought was the fact that he was doing a show on Friday and he's no longer there means it probably wasn't his idea. He also didn't get a final show as many people. Even Brian Stelter was commenting he got a final show even though he was fired. So the term that Logan Roy used was a blood offering.
Scott Galloway
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
I bet Rupert Murdoch at this point is like, "Look, boss, I'm a billionaire. I got a few years left. I don't need to suffer anyone regardless of how important they think they are." This is pure speculation. The other thing is I think by Wednesday there's going to be a poll showing he's at 15% for Republican nomination for presidency.
Scott Galloway
Could be.
Kara Swisher
Well, this is true. I think it's Fox's move because he thought he was coming back on Monday. Apparently he didn't know this until after the show. Someone who saw him on the weekend said he knew by the weekend, but he didn't know until then. So it wasn't his idea. That said, with DeSantis flaming out, there's got to be a move for someone, right? There's a move. The ones currently there don't seem to be lighting the fires. Pompeo dropped out. So there's room. There's certainly room for him.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I agree. There's no question. There's no reason why he wouldn't run. That would be a move for him, essentially. But I think he was fired here. That's what it looks like. It does not sound like it was his idea. He's had a long storied career there with a lot of fans. I'm shocked they didn't give him the opportunity to do a victory lap. The fact that this was lawyers and them saying, or on a Friday after the show, the head of legal called and said, "This is happening."
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Or they planned it. That's how they plan these things. They really do plan these TV departures. It'll be interesting. I was thinking, oh, maybe Elon's giving him money or will give him money or he'll do something on his own. But it hasn't really worked out for Bill O'Reilly.
Scott Galloway
You're right. They just go and they're not that big. What's his name? Glenn, whatever his name is. Anyway, no one's as big as they were when they were on the network. That's for sure.
Kara Swisher
These platforms are powerful. They can be, yeah. Especially in TV. For TV, 100%. Not for everybody. Not for everybody. I think we've done rather well without necessarily being attached to anything. We've done well with them or without. But TV is a whole different animal, I think. Sorry, Tucker. We'll miss you.
Scott Galloway
We will miss you. Tucky. I'm really curious to see what his next thing is. What do you think he's going to do? He's really rich. He also comes from a rich, elite family.
Kara Swisher
Oh, really?
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Swanson. The Swanson frozen food.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, he's a fancy San Francisco. In fact, we were talking about him because I was actually at dinner with Paul Pelosi over the weekend, who looks great, by the way, who looks amazing, and with Nancy Pelosi. It was at a Georgetown University dinner. We, weirdly enough, were talking about Tucker Carlson's family for four seconds. So Paul Pelosi is doing great.
Scott Galloway
I know you. Good. That's good to know.
Kara Swisher
He looks fantastic. He's so good. I got to say one thing, this point is, he's one of these dudes, of course he gets attacked with a hammer. He gets attacked with conspiracy theories, including by Musk and others, about this being a gay trope or whatever. They had all these things about his attack, which was just an attack by a crazy person who himself was radicalized online with crazy conspiracy theories. Instead of being traumatized, he's like, "Yeah, I'm good." I know he could hide trauma, but he's one of those old time guys who are like, "Yeah, I got hit."
Scott Galloway
I do believe, though, just back to Tucker Carlson, if I were in charge of his business career, I would have him start a TV show called "I'm Not Racist, But."
Kara Swisher
That was good.
Scott Galloway
No. "I'm Not a Transphobe, But."
Kara Swisher
Yeah. With Tucker Carlson. Okay. Yeah, sure. We could change it every day.
Scott Galloway
So just as we're talking about this, what Tucker's going to do, Don Lemon is out at CNN. Lemon wrote in a tweet, "I am stunned after 17 years at CNN. I would have thought someone in management would have had the decency to tell me directly." But in a tweet, CNN's communications department said, "Don Lemon's statement about this morning's events is inaccurate. He was offered an opportunity to meet with management, but instead released a statement on Twitter."
Kara Swisher
Oh, this is not going to go well.
Scott Galloway
Oh, you know what happened there.
Kara Swisher
What, they're going to do a show together? Oh, no, I don't think they're going to do a show together. I can't. I mean, unless it's pay-per-view, like wrestling, unless it's like one of these boxing matches. Wow, Don. Don is gone. Wow. This is like the TV guys must have been like...
Scott Galloway
And then, of course, the guy at NBC, Jeff Shell, who was running NBC, was out because of a relationship that he'd had for 11 years with someone within the company, a reporter at CNBC. So it's, wow, these companies aren't kidding around. They're knocking these people down and out.
Kara Swisher
That's a surprise, too. I mean, Don had been a subject of a lot of criticism because of a bunch of things he said, including women in their prime. There was an article in Variety that seemed a little thin, but it was about he was mean to a bunch of women a couple of years ago. Though that doesn't seem to be a crushing blow, that one. It's an interesting move. I'll tell you that. TV is very sensitive. I had a program canceled before it even aired.
Scott Galloway
Oh, that's true. That's right. You've had several kids.
Kara Swisher
So, Scott, what are Don and Tucker feeling right now? What are they feeling right now?
Scott Galloway
Just take a long walk on the beach, have an edible, pull up the Mandalorian, let your dogs and your kids lay on you and realize it's just not that important.
Kara Swisher
Okay. All right. Well, here we are. Hey, Scott, I think they can hire us. What do you think? One of us should go to Fox, one of us to CNN? They're running out of options.
Scott Galloway
I know. I'm like the hottest girl at 2 a.m. at a fraternity party.
Kara Swisher
No, let's go. We could totally do that. Then mom would really like that. She watches Fox News. We could go on Fox News.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, we got Lucky. Lucky. Viewer number one. We bring a viewership.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, we bring Lucky. Alex would come.
Scott Galloway
Alex would come. That's two. Okay, we just doubled our audience.
Kara Swisher
We just doubled our audience. Well, okay, we're going to update it some more. You have this itch. See, it's funny. I've been totally burned by TV. I scratched that itch and it turned into an infection.
Scott Galloway
You keep saying we need to do a TV show. I'm like, I'm not doing a TV show. I am telling you, I have this feeling we could be super famous.
Kara Swisher
I think we have faces for podcasting. I just don't work on TV. Let me just tell you, I was inundated by people in San Francisco talking about you and us and our show. They hugged me. I had a firefighter who scared me a little bit. I had a lovely trans man who just hugged me and hugged me and said our show changes his life. I'm just telling you, we should be on TV. And then we should have a disastrous end in a firing like this, I think. That's my feeling.
Scott Galloway
You'll see.
Kara Swisher
No, I think I have faces for podcasting. I've been right so far in our careers. So anyway, enough talking about us. Another person who's trying to keep his career going is President Biden. He's expected to announce his re-election as early as today, Tuesday. That's when this will appear. We're taping on Monday. The president's team is reportedly planning to release a video announcement. That is true. I know that is true. Though the timing is not yet solidified, but that's how they're doing it. They're not going to a place. They're just doing a video announcement. Along with the announcement, Biden is expected to tap White House official Julia Chavez Rodriguez to manage his campaign. She's the granddaughter of Cesar Chavez, I believe, but also a very well-known political organizer. Rodriguez was deputy manager of the president's 2020 campaign. What do you think? You're the one that says he's too old, but he's going for it. He's going. He's moving in.
Scott Galloway
I think Joe Biden, I think President Biden is going to go down, tell him Joe Biden. Joe Biden. I think he could go down as one of the great presidents. I think especially if he helps convince America to stay the course around pushing back on a fascist, a murderous autocrat in Europe. I think this is a great moment for him in the West. I think he could cement that legacy by saying, "I was here for a reason. I pulled us back from COVID. I've tried to be a responsible steward. My defining moment is to ensure that the West is secure for another 40 or 50 years and say to autocrats all over the world that our reach is far and our memory is long." And then say, "It's time to bring in new blood." I think he would cement himself as one of the great presidents in history if he did that.
Kara Swisher
Well, he didn't take your advice. He's going to be announcing he's running again. It was interesting because when I interviewed Ron Klain, one of the things I asked him was the age thing, which he acknowledged is an issue and he's got to address it. He essentially said he was running again and that this announcement was happening this week. But I did press him on the age thing in which he said he thinks he's perfectly capable of doing it. But then when I did press him to come up with Democratic contenders who would be promising, he did quickly mention Gavin Newsom and Gretchen Whitmer. Those are the two people he mentioned, which was really interesting, I thought. He's been a big supporter of Kamala Harris. He was sort of the biggest internal supporter of her when he was running, being chief of staff, and was a very good chief of staff, by the way. A lot of stuff happened during, that's a critical role in administration. If it's done well, you don't see any problems, right? You don't see them sweating. But he mentioned those two people, which I thought was interesting. So anyway, he's running. You think it's a mistake?
Scott Galloway
I think, I don't know, especially with Trump as a frontrunner. One thing Ron said is he's the only person to beat Donald Trump, not the other Republicans. That's why everyone's lined up around him. Here's the thing, if you really look at it, he's had fewer press conferences than any president since Reagan. They're now unfortunately going into Reagan mode where they're surrounding him with people. I think they're hoping Trump is the nominee because you know what they'll do? I believe, if Trump is a nominee, I think they'll refuse to debate him.
Kara Swisher
Oh.
Scott Galloway
I think they'll say this guy doesn't honor the decorum of a debate. It's a waste of time. He's an insurrectionist. And they won't want to subject President Biden to that type of risk.
Kara Swisher
Wow. That's interesting. I think we are so, I don't know what the term is. It's a combination of wanting to beat Trump, the fact that he's done a good job, not wanting to put in play the riskiness of an unknown who hasn't beaten Trump before. But also the sensitivity around ageism that doesn't acknowledge that biology is politically incorrect. It just strikes me as borderline insane that we don't acknowledge how ridiculous this is.
Scott Galloway
Well, Dianne Feinstein is still the senator. And she shouldn't be.
Kara Swisher
I mean, we keep having this conversation. I know. There is a bit of politeness around it, too, though, that people feel like you shouldn't. But I agree. When it comes to the presidency or fighter pilots or surgeons, polite doesn't cut it.
Scott Galloway
You're right. You're right. I don't disagree with you.
Kara Swisher
What do you think? I think he's in much better shape than you think. I don't think that being that old means that much. I know lots of very sharp people.
Scott Galloway
What about in six years? How do you think he'll be doing in six years?
Kara Swisher
My mom's as sharp as a tack at 88. Let me just say she's not moving around as well. But trust me, she knows. I back out of rooms with my mom.
Scott Galloway
Would you want her running the country?
Kara Swisher
Well, never. Not when she was 40. So no, that's not. But I'm saying...
Scott Galloway
Okay, but imagine she has...
Kara Swisher
I think she had a cognitive decline a little bit maybe. So have I. So you know, I think it... I'm just saying there are a lot of very... and he's in excellent shape. He's in physical shape. I don't worry about that. I don't think he's creaky. I don't think he's Reagan. I always thought Reagan had cognitive problems from a very early time. I think the country is really at a point where it needs someone like a Kennedy or an Obama. When I think of the presidents who really were able to capture imagination and get things done, for their ages, they brought a youthful perspective. The average age of Americans is 38. Can an 82-year-old represent that? There's a lot I just really don't like about this.
But you know who's gotten the most done? Joe Biden, of all the presidents.
Scott Galloway
Fair point.
Kara Swisher
Joe Biden has really done a really good job. But let's get to our first big story. Blue checks are back for some users anyway. On Thursday, Twitter removed verification checks for users who hadn't subscribed to Twitter Blue. More than 300,000 verified accounts lost their check marks, including mine and Scott Galloway's. But over the weekend, check marks reappeared on many celebrity accounts including LeBron James, Stephen King, and Lil Nas X. Also on many previously verified accounts with more than one million followers like MIT and Kara Swisher. The only problem? We never paid. Most of us never paid.
MIT put out things saying I didn't pay. So did King. So did James. So did Ian McKellen. Now Chief Twit Elon Musk says he's personally covering the bill for a few celebs, but I guess he's covering my bill. I didn't ask him for it. He's also sporting blue checks. Some deceased celebrities, including Anthony Bourdain, Kobe Bryant, even Jamal Khashoggi, the murdered Washington Post columnist. Someone was calling it Twitter mortis, which is a pretty good joke for that, a dead joke. This is just the same thing. Back in November, Musk called Twitter verification a "lords and peasants" system. In March, he wrote, "There shouldn't be a different standard for celebrities, in my opinion."
But now he's giving them back because I don't know why. No one knows why. People inside have told me it's just pure chaos. They didn't sell any Twitter Blue, a very small amount of Twitter Blue. They were surprised they didn't sell more. And as you say, Scott, it's now a signification of dumbassery. So what do you think? Talk about the branding issue here. Is it just another put it on the pile, the log pile of shitty management?
Scott Galloway
Well, I don't know if you saw it, but my blue check experienced a rapid unscheduled disassembly before stage separation and spun out of control. [Makes a rocket reference to the blown up Starship] Look, a move to subscription was the right move. It all comes down again. It's not what you do. It's how you do it. A move to subscription is the right move, and given that the advertising business is imploded, it's the right strategy. But as always, it's how you do it. This is no longer verification. It's just who is willing to pay eight bucks a month, taking away verification. He has diminished the entire value of the blue check. You've seen these things, the city of New York's Twitter is now got a fake one saying, "We're the real city of New York." Then to go back and offer some people, including people who have passed, a blue check, the whole thing just makes no sense. There's no crisp communication about it. It says that we pay for it if you click on it. And I'm like, I didn't pay for it.
Kara Swisher
Anyone who said, "Oh, I didn't pay for it," all these Elon stans started attacking lots of people and saying you should say thank you. I'm like, why should we say thank you to have some shitty thing shoved down our throat? So the stans then attack you. And then there's the legal risk giving checkmarks to users who don't want them, didn't want to pay for them. Some people think they could open them up to lawsuits under the Lanham Act. Twitter offered a checkmark to LeBron James, for example. He declined, but they gave him one anyway after he declined. So it could look like a false endorsement, I guess.
I don't know who would sue, but I'm sure the FTC is scrutinizing this. They're also issuing gold checks to organizations, including the New York Times, which previously said it wouldn't pay. They took the blue check off of the New York Times. And they also gave a gold check to the far right Britain First Party, whose leaders were previously banned. Now they're removing the "government funded" and "state affiliate" labels from media accounts, including Russia's RT News and China's Global News. It also lifted its visibility filtering rules or shadow bans on government accounts from Russia, China, Iran, according to NPR.
So they're moving in with the autocracies and communists.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, look, I think it'd be a great sequel to Matt Damon's movie, "We Bought a Zoo" — "We Bought a Checkmark." The thing that hurts the brand here. I was actively considering this "block the blue" thing because the people I've seen with blue checks so far are kind of red pill or they're trying to sell me, get me to schedule a call for their new scheduling SaaS software. I'm like, do I really need any of these people in my life? Then I thought, okay, but at the same time blocking people because they decided to pay eight bucks a month, am I part of the problem? But let me contrast this. When that Starship rocket took off...
It had 10 million pounds of propellant. There was so much thrust taking off that the reinforced concrete launch pad was ruined, set off car alarms for miles. When I was watching that thing, and granted it blew up, I thought it's amazing. That is putting America back in the space race, putting them back ahead. It's incredibly hard, incredibly expensive, incredibly visionary. The people at SpaceX and Lon Muck, as I'm now changing his name, it's inspiring. And then there's this shit. Who is coaching this guy to say, "Boss, focus on what is just incredible and what is awesome"? But you taking away and giving back people's blue check...
Kara Swisher
I know.
Scott Galloway
And then he was insulting them for refusing. George Lucas deciding to make Howard the Duck. It's like, what are you doing?
Kara Swisher
Yeah. What are you doing? He also spent time insulting people like Stephen King and others online. And Paul Krugman, he had a crying baby. It just was like, really? Like, I have time to troll him, but he has better things to do. I'm on a plane, so it's very easy to do so. But yeah, I agree. I think that's the contrast I was trying to draw in that Time 100 thing. I said, all these amazing things. And this is what we have. It's like, what are you doing? I think that's where I've come to at this point. Especially because now I think what has happened is everyone realizes maybe he's not so smart. He's becoming a laughingstock. I don't care if he says, "Oh, it's all the elites." It's not. Everyone's like, what the hell?
People are confused and the brand has taken such a hit. And of course, it leaks over into the rest of his brands. It's just so stupid. It's so stupid.
Scott Galloway
You're right. It's so, so stupid.
Kara Swisher
In any case, here we are. One of the things he was doing was, of course, giving a lot of ability of China and Russia to just run rampant because at one point he had said all news to some degree is propaganda. In text to friends, he called Russian news quite entertaining. He had some good points. But I don't think he understands the depth of their, especially Russia, their thuggery. Maybe he does and doesn't care.
Anyway, speaking of China, for example, one of the other stories that was kind of interesting, it was by Emily Baker White, who we had on the show. TikTok's Virginia data center suffers from weak security, according to a report that she did. We were so impressed with her reporting before. Boxes of hard drives were left unattended in the hallways and visitors were free to roam. There are also reports of employees using servers to mine cryptocurrency. Feels a little negligent, although Bruce Schneier, a famous security researcher, has quoted the article warning against reading too much into it about poor data security. It might be just one thing, but it's not a good look for TikTok, for sure.
Scott Galloway
Everyone's piling on TikTok now, and I'm not sure that anything that TikTok's guilty of, all the other platforms either are guilty of as well or have been guilty. I think it's a separate issue. I don't think it's a data thing. I don't think it's a privacy thing. Or it's no greater a data or a privacy thing than it is for the other platforms. It's about national security. And I feel like something needs to happen here because it's becoming a distraction. I do believe the firm could build a ton of shareholder value, be a viable competitor to what has been a largely uncompetitive sector. But I think they need to, you know, pass this or move for this act to be put in place, force their hand, have it spun, and then hopefully TikTok can thrive again.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it can start. It is thriving. It's still thriving, you know.
Scott Galloway
But it's this like a bird in midair flapping its wings. It can only do it for so long. I would agree. You know, in place so let's get on with it. Let's figure out what, you know, let's either ban it or spin it. Let's get on with it because I would like to see a TikTok that spun it to Western interests. The people who built that company deserve, including the Chinese, ByteDance, deserve to be very wealthy and it should be a great competitor. But it has to be, we have to address the national security concerns.
Kara Swisher
And you've always said that we need to separate the ownership from the product. Well, we'll see. But it's something they should be very careful right now because people are scrutinizing them. All right, Scott, let's go on a quick break. We come back, more layoffs and closures across the board. We'll speak with friend of Pivot Baratunde Thurston about AI.
Break
Ad break for LinkedIn
Scott, we're back. Disney began its second round of layoffs this week. Those were previously announced, but it's a capstone to a turbulent week for many companies. Layoffs and bankruptcies across different sectors paint a rough picture for the economy. Bed Bath & Beyond filed for bankruptcy on Sunday. I'm surprised it took so long. Its stores will remain open for now, but the company plans to wind down operations. There are 360 locations. It's going to really hit a lot of malls. Speaking of malls, Scott, as well as 120 Buy Buy Baby. I've spent so much money at Buy Buy Baby.
Also last week, new Lyft CEO told employees that a significant number will lose their jobs. He didn't specify how many, but the Wall Street Journal reports it could be 1,200. Lyft currently employs over 4,000. And BuzzFeed News shut down last week. The company laid off 180 staffers, moved some others to its other news brands, the Huffington Post. Insider, home of Business Insider, also announced layoffs. Three sectors, different sectors, goods, services, media. What do you think? Do they have anything in common? A coincidence? I interviewed Ben Smith today on On. He has written a book called Traffic, but the news, BuzzFeed News' shutting down came. He was the founding editor-in-chief. We talked quite a lot about it. Do you have any thoughts on all these? Because they're different sectors, retail services and media?
Scott Galloway
Well, look, we're just saying the economy is doing what it's supposed to be doing. And companies that aren't working, bankruptcy is traditionally a great... bankruptcy laws were sort of invented for retail or retail was invented for bankruptcy because traditionally what you can do is you can go through and cherry pick the stores that are working. And the most dangerous thing about brick and mortar retail is you have to enter into these 10 year agreements called leases. And if the store doesn't work, it's a weeping wound for the next nine years. And so when you declare bankruptcy, you can go through and cherry pick which stores you want to hold on to and then get rid of the leases. And you have your inventory. What's interesting here or surprising is they're planning on closing all stores. But I was shocked that they wouldn't have certain stores that they would decide to recapitalize.
Kara Swisher
I was too.
Scott Galloway
I mean, it was the comp where I mean, they had competition from Amazon, although I went to them a lot. They weren't great online. Target and Walmart are doing a really good job online. There can only be a few. But yeah, I was surprised they closed them all. It's going to really have repercussions from a commercial real estate.
Kara Swisher
Well, it impacts me personally because people have said that they're uncomfortable with me masturbating in front of a mirror.
Scott Galloway
And I say, well, then you can find a different Bed Bath & Beyond to shop at, Pat.
Kara Swisher
How do we get it? That's good. Can you please give me an insight? I'm going to move on to Lyft. Okay. No penis jokes.
Scott Galloway
The most disturbing part of that joke was Bed Bath & Beyond.
Kara Swisher
Yes, probably. But they're just close. It's a big name. It's interesting. I guess retail names just come and go, I suppose.
Scott Galloway
Look, Sears at one point was one of the most trusted brands in the world. Retail brands are usually not that enduring. And one of the most valuable brands in the world right now, Lululemon, especially retail segment, and also luxury. If you look at this step blew my mind, Hermes now has a larger market cap than Nike. So it's retail being reshaped.
Kara Swisher
I would argue that through COVID, there wasn't a ton of innovation on the front end. Like if you really think about like a Sephora or something that does something inspiring or different, there hasn't been a ton of innovation at the store level. Because I think a lot of retailers were like saying, we need to wait and see what the world looks like post-COVID. We're not going to make these big bets until... I mean, they probably weren't even sure how many people were going to come back to stores, right?
Scott Galloway
Yeah. And also they had issues of employees. They hadn't been looking so well.
Kara Swisher
I was a pretty avid Bed Bath shopper.
Scott Galloway
I'm so glad I never ran into you there. So Lyft services, obviously, shortage of drivers. They started covering the cost of rental cars and throwing bonuses to drivers to get more on the platform. And could be a lot of things. There could be inflation. It could be competition. The business just has never been good. That's my feeling. And the one that's the weakest animal in that particular sector of a business that's never been good has to get cut out. This has been a business that has never... the sector has never made money. And so if you're the number two in a business that's never made money.
Kara Swisher
And now it's expensive.
Scott Galloway
Now it's expensive. Well, it should be. The reality is, you know, a 28-year-old who designs websites and makes 110 grand a year probably shouldn't be taking an Escalade to JFK. It probably should be too expensive.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
And for a long time, they priced it below its cost. And unfortunately, you know, they use software to circumvent minimum wage laws. But Uber has the scale. And you have to give Dara Khosrowshahi his props. He went into food. He made a very bold acquisition there. He's raised prices. He has scale. He got out of things.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Lyft either needs to sell. Lyft is on a slow march to zero right now.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And so they either need...
Scott Galloway
He got in scooters.
Kara Swisher
They both got in scooters, right?
Scott Galloway
They've actually got a decent bank of IP around autonomous driving. So you could see an automobile company maybe buy them. But every day they don't sell, they're going to sell for less.
Kara Swisher
I agree. I thought they should have sold a long time ago.
Scott Galloway
And my guess is...
Kara Swisher
They both should have sold.
Scott Galloway
So let's play. Let's turn this back to the history of Scott's failed business enterprises. About 15 years ago, I raised 60 or $70 million and I bought 17% of Gateway Computer. Remember them? And I went on the board and I went in guns blazing and said, this is a great brand. The computer hardware industry is, other than Apple, in structural decline. We need to sell. We have great shelf space at Best Buy. We have a good brand. Now is the time to sell. The stock had gone from 60 bucks, I bought in an average price of a buck 80, presented to the board, sat down feeling good about myself. And the chairman of the board who went on to be the governor of Michigan said, Scott, we've engaged Goldman Sachs two years ago and have been trying to sell the company for 24 months. So my guess is that, and it's a good lesson and the lesson here for all our young viewers, is that whenever you go into a strange situation, you should assume that you're not as smart as you think and they're not as dumb as you'd hoped. And I would bet, I mean, as I lecture Lyft to sell, I would bet Lyft engaged bankers a year ago and is trying to figure out a way to sell.
Kara Swisher
I think they had offers before that. I always thought they should be the reservation system to one of the car makers, you know, a reservation system. That's in place and that's something that's hard to do and good engineers. I don't know. I just feel like they've never been... they've always sort of been flagging compared to Uber. They're the number two. They're the distant number two in a sector that doesn't make money. It's the worst of all worlds.
Scott Galloway
And even still, this is how crazy it is. Even still, it got a billion market cap. So the founders who are of that generation that feel like they still...
Kara Swisher
Lovely guys, by the way.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. They want $5 billion. They'll want a takeover premium and no one wants to pay that. No one wants to pay $5 billion for a company that's losing money. So even if you had, say GM, right? Their market cap's $48 billion. They don't want to be diluted by 10% on a flyer with Lyft.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
So the unfortunate thing here is until it gets down to probably a billion, which it will do, it's too expensive to be acquired.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, by the players that would acquire them, 100%. Now, BuzzFeed News, lastly, again, I interviewed Ben Smith today. He noted a number of things, but fewer ads, of course. Social media users, they had bet hard on that compared to other publications. Going public was a big problem. Doing an IPO was a big problem. Spending, I've always thought they were very spendy. I would watch them for my tiny little company and think, wow, they're spending a lot of money. That's a lot of money they spent during the salad days. They had announced they're using AI tools to help generate quizzes and personalized content. But any thoughts on this?
Scott Galloway
BuzzFeed should have never been a public company. BuzzFeed has, I sold my analytics company or my business intelligence firm for $160 million. BuzzFeed has an $81 million market cap here today. Our company, Vox, sold or raised money recently at a $500 million market cap. And what's the difference? And unfortunately, BuzzFeed doubled down on journalism and also kind of digital marketing and these lists and everything. And Vox doubled down on podcasts, and it has an iconic property of New York Magazine.
Kara Swisher
Subscriptions.
Scott Galloway
Subscriptions. Yeah, subscriptions. And so, you know.
Kara Swisher
And didn't go public.
Scott Galloway
And didn't go public. And so he can kind of weather. He can still weather these storms. But podcasts, although a small medium, are growing and is profitable. Whereas if you're trying to create lists and get traffic to a site to sell, to sell, God, banner ads. Jesus Christ, that's an awful business. So BuzzFeed.
Kara Swisher
Never made money, the news part. Sometimes it's an elite thing so that you bring in advertisers. You know, I think that was the argument is that you had this. And they, you know, they won Pulitzer Prizes. This is not, was not a shitty, it wasn't just quizzes.
Scott Galloway
Go woke, go broke, go Pulitzer, go broke. I mean, that's just not... I hate to say it.
Kara Swisher
But I'm saying that was the argument, I remember.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. You know, the elite, it'll create a thing that then they'll buy the rest of it, essentially. This thing... this is another thing. It probably goes to $30 or $40 million. Some Democrat with a lot of money who is excited about owning a media company says to them, fire half your staff, and the next day I'm going to announce I'm taking it private and buying it. There's value there. I think they actually have a decent culture. They have some really talented people.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
But it's going to need to get cleaned up. They're going to have to do the dirty work. And there'll be an acquirer in the wings that will say, OK, if you lay off all the people, I don't want to do the dirty work. You do it.
Kara Swisher
If at all. Why would you? Look, Puck is doing it. It's very small and tight, right? All the ones that are doing well are small and tight, like Punchbowl News, like 3P. I forget. It's real small. You know, whatever of these new groups, information, they're either subscription or if they're advertising, it's not big. It's very digital. And it can be made bigger or smaller very quickly compared to these other things. Both BuzzFeed and...
Scott Galloway
BuzzFeed has 1,400 employees.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I know. I mean, think about it this way. Yeah, it's a lot. It's a lot. I remember. BuzzFeed is now close to the number of employees Twitter has.
Scott Galloway
Yep, yep, yep. And Twitter has, even after 60 or 70% decline in revenues, right? And it's really shitty revenue. It's very low margin revenue.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Scott Galloway
Lyft and BuzzFeed both go away. They will both...
Kara Swisher
Well, they are. It's going away.
Scott Galloway
It's going away.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they're going away. Their stocks are going to go down another 50% or 70% until they're affordable, and someone's going to come in and take them out. Although they were saying they could probably do pretty good business. Ben was saying with HuffPo front page, it attracts a lot of traffic. It doesn't mean like... Oh, BuzzFeed owns that, doesn't it?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, so HuffPo is the one staying around.
Kara Swisher
That's the brand they're putting all the news under. So that makes sense. That makes sense, it turns out. They bought it for like almost nothing. Anyway, let's bring in our friend of Pivot. Baratunde Thurston is an author, founding partner, and writer at Puck, as well as the host of the How to Citizen podcast and the host of America Outdoors on PBS. He is multimedia. Welcome to Pivot, Baratunde. Always a pleasure.
Baratunde Thurston
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
Baratunde, I see you do not have a blue check on Twitter. Can you prove to us you're the real Baratunde?
Baratunde Thurston
I can give a blood sample. I can rewind the clock with access to my actual long form birth certificate. I have lots of photos of me as a baby. My validation does not come from the man who needs extreme amounts of validation.
Kara Swisher
Yes, that's true. And there's not enough hugs in the universe. So we were talking earlier about Tucker Carlson, all this media stuff going on, Tucker Carlson and Don Lemon, et cetera. But you've spent a lot of time writing about AI for Puck. I'd love you to sort of give us where you fall on the optimist pessimist spectrum.
Baratunde Thurston
I'm looking at it from every angle. I don't have a fixed position on the spectrum. I'm like an example of quantum physics where I can occupy multiple positions at the same time as particles tend to do when we really understand the nature of the universe. So that's a cop out, but it's really true. I am nervous and worried about the flood of bullshit coming our way when we sort of industrialize content production. I'm worried about the rapid pace of change. We've not proven adept at adapting to technological revolutions once in a generation, much less three, four, five times within a single generation. That's for social cohesion. That's really, really risky.
I'm also excited. I think there's something kind of intrinsically beautiful about the idea that how you prompt the system, you know, Midjourney, ChatGPT, DALL-E 2, whatever. We're becoming wizards or magicians. We're like casting spells. And so the power of your magic depends on the quality of your spellcasting. So we all got to go to Hogwarts and kind of up our magic game. And I think if we could use these tools, not just to maximize profit and efficiency of productivity, that just makes us automated worker bees. I'm not interested in being automated as a human being. But if we could use sort of the pattern matching, the corruption spotting, the way radiologists find cancer, right? If we could find corrupt policing, if we could find abuse of political or executive power of some kind, then that's more interesting to me than merely speeding everything up.
And then, and most devastatingly, I think most concerning, we're creating more layers between us and an embodied existence of the world. We used to spend a lot of time with life, with dirt, with animals, with people. And all that's running through a screen and it's being heavily mediated. So we're kind of trusting the GPS over our own eyes. And some people will follow that GPS off an unfinished bridge because the screen told them to. And so not trusting our own knowing is a really deep question and concern of mine. I'm not really to say it's going to be the end of humanity, but I think it's a good moment to reflect on what is humanity.
Kara Swisher
Right, although it does it really well. I mean, a song that AI, they cloned the voices of Drake and The Weeknd, and they had been removed from streaming services after Universal Music Group said it violated copyright law. But the song went crazy viral. It sounded like a Drake Weeknd song. It sounded pretty good.
Scott Galloway
It sounded good.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And the statement, UMG said, AI begs the question as to which side of history all stakeholders in the music ecosystems want to be on, the side of artists, fans, and human creative expression, or the side of deepfakes, fraud, and denying their artists due compensation. At the same time, you couldn't help but be excited by it. It was like, wow, that's pretty cool. Should these writers whose data is used to train AI really be compensated or is it too late?
Baratunde Thurston
I don't think it's too late. I think this all brings a lot of intellectual property considerations about consent, about control, and about compensation. Look, I'm talking to you now with a lot of augmented technologies. Right. We're using a cloud based service. My voice is being compressed. When I write emails, they're auto completed already. So none of us is like a fully grounded analog human anymore. Most of us would probably be dead, you know, and certainly the jobs we do are heavily assisted. However, we have a sense of agency and control in that. And so I think we're going to need some new systems of almost literal accounting and accountability.
If you are an artist like Drake or anyone, it won't just be the output that matters. It'll be certification of the process. Dare I say, maybe blockchain has a use here in terms of proving that that was Drake in the recording studio, that his lips were moving. And so that metadata gets attached to the streaming file and a service like Spotify only accepts validated creative output or at least documented. So they use autotune. Cool. But they announce it. And so a third party can't just rip a voice and upload it without the proof of provenance and sort of creative process.
Kara Swisher
Right. But they can't.
Scott Galloway
Yeah. Yeah. I'm just curious your thoughts on the difference between you work at Puck, but you also, you got your fingers in a lot of pies. You do stuff with traditional media still. I'm just curious how you feel about working for a kind of a startup, one of these kind of startup, cool, buzzy, written word media companies versus traditional media. Any observations around what it's been for you, what it's been like for you personally and how you, you know, any broader implications around the state of media?
Baratunde Thurston
Oh, man. Thank you for that. I do have my hands in a lot of pies. And so, yeah, Puck has been... I'm thinking out loud here because I really haven't been asked that before. With Puck, I get to stretch my brain on a screen or on a page. Like writing is the medium. And I have a set of colleagues that are pretty inspiring in terms of how they approach. When I read Julia Ioffe or Bill Cohan, I'm like, yo, they're smart. I got to step up my shit. And my editors, I can actually feel them enhancing, right? In the way that some people feel enhanced by a mech suit or ChatGPT, the humans are enhancing in that kind of colleague environment.
I think the other end of the spectrum is, you know, I work with PBS. My America Outdoors show is, it's not government funded, but it's backed by viewers like you. And so the idea of making something almost the opposite in some ways, Puck is privately funded and subscription-based. PBS is somewhat publicly funded and open to all. And so I get a different hit of satisfaction and a different sense of belonging from both of those. I'm in this kind of VIP velvet rope club at Puck, which is all about power explicitly as the mandate. And then I'm kind of like rolling with the people on PBS. And I just spent a week in Arkansas talking with folks about their relationship with nature, kind of the opposite of an AI conversation. But a lot of them said, I would only do this because PBS is coming. I wouldn't talk to any other media outlet. I still trust PBS. And so I get the benefit of kind of learning from all this. I don't have a concluding thesis on the overall future of media from this, but I like diversification. As with investment in stocks, also with my attention and with my voice.
Kara Swisher
I won't speak for Kara, but we're all in different mediums and I have favorites and things I like more and things that I think are less rewarding or harder. Do you have one specific medium where you enjoy more or you think it's more rewarding?
Baratunde Thurston
Yeah, my gut answer is the stage. So I did stand-up comedy for a decade. I've done a number of TED Talks. The past weeks, I've been on a kind of a tour, heavily of the South, it turns out. But public events, companies bringing me in to talk, speaking at various TED-like conferences. And I appreciate the high wire act of the real-time nature of crafting something in the room. It will never be the same. Even if I said it again, there'll be different people. The barometric pressure would be different. You know, my mood would be different. My diet would be different. And so I love the realness, the real timeness of being on a stage in a room with other human beings. That is the toughest by far. But when it works, it blows the magic of all these other media out the water for me.
Kara Swisher
Interesting.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I find speaking magical too, but the magic for me is mostly about the money. Talk to you, Gary. Some of these people have budgets. It's nice.
Kara Swisher
Okay. I'm going to ask you the actual things you make. So your new season of How...
Scott Galloway
Did you hear about me at Bed Bath & Beyond?
Kara Swisher
Okay, no, don't. I'm sorry. Go ahead, Kara.
Scott Galloway
Don't.
Kara Swisher
Are you the reason they're declaring?
Scott Galloway
No, no, no. Say nothing. Say nothing. Let me just say nothing.
Kara Swisher
Oh, I shouldn't encourage him. You're right.
Scott Galloway
You have not seen Kara. They're scared. Look at her. She's turning red.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, the newest season of How to Citizen is about democracy. I want to get to both things because you're talking about nature and democracy, two of Scott's favorite things, getting out into nature. But, you know, you talk to a lot of people on that. How do you feel right now? I know everyone decries like the end of democracy. It seems to hold on pretty well, although declensions everywhere. This has been a particularly bleak few weeks with shooting people shooting their neighbors when they show up at the wrong door. A bunch of laws passed all over the country that are pretty horrible. How do you feel about it now when you're talking about how to citizen? So how do you citizen right now?
Baratunde Thurston
I feel impressed that you threw the word declension into the conversation, Kara. You get points for that from the vocab guides.
Scott Galloway
I got 700 on my SATs, but go ahead. No idea what that means.
Baratunde Thurston
Go ahead. I've inferred it from the context, Scott. We can check it out. We can huddle later on our study group with Kara.
Yeah. Citizen is more than this kind of legal status. That's the premise of our podcast. It's a verb, and we all are invited to shape our communities together. It's a hard time, and I don't want to understate the negative impacts for women and what happens if they become pregnant and don't want to be by so many means, for LGBTQIA people, for all kinds of folks. I will also say that democracy has never been fully realized in the United States. We have a great marketing department, but if you inspect the product, there's got a lot of faults in it. And so this thing that feels like it's dying was never fully alive. And death is also an opportunity to give birth to something and maybe try to realize the whole liberty and justice for all thing, the whole self-governance thing and people power thing. So I tend to, I try, and I don't always succeed. I try to put my attention and give my power and the process to things that are indicators of that new life.
Kara Swisher
So give me an example on your latest show.
Baratunde Thurston
Yeah, so we've had a back-to-back conversation with people about polarization and division. Tim Phillips from Beyond Conflict, which is bringing kind of cognitive neuroscience to the field of like, why are we at each other's throats so much? And Priya Parker, who wrote this book, The Art of Gathering. Both of them are circling around how do we make space for, and see people as opponents and not enemies. How do we hear each other without agreeing, right? Acknowledgement doesn't have to be endorsement. How do we acknowledge things historically that created the devastating situation we're in without receiving that as a personal attack on us as individuals?
And we can do all that. I think the good news from Tim with his scientific studies is that we're not as divided as we think we are.
Kara Swisher
That's correct.
Baratunde Thurston
So as a left-leaning person, I think a right-leaning person hates me 100%. Turns out they only hate me like 40%. That's a huge delta. That's a huge gap. And in that gap, there's an opportunity to find some ground. I think the way we ask questions of each other, we have a kind of a binary like, for, against that we're forced into playing because of the way media amplifies discord. Most of us are somewhere in some nuanced path in between. Or what I care deeply about, Kara, you don't care so deeply about. So even though we disagree, you don't care as much. So you're willing to give on that little piece of the puzzle. Our politicians don't talk that way. They're incentivized to behave like algorithmically driven influencers rather than facilitators of the will of the people.
So there are other methods. Citizen assemblies, deliberative democracy, sometimes it's called. These experiments, which go back to the way the Greeks initially intended it, are happening all over the world. And when people come together with great facilitation, not just like, "I'm in a room with someone I disagree with, hope for the best." That's not a process. So we need someone there to expose folks to all ideas, to expertly facilitate, bring humanity into the room, and then people end up on their own behalf. It's almost like jury duty for electoral politics. It's democracy without politicians. It's the people. Those outcomes last longer and they are much more representative of what our actual will is. So when I see that stuff happening in the US, in Belgium, in Paris, in Australia, then I think, all right, we got some possibility here.
Even the AI thing, there's a company, Disclosure, my wife and I invested in this company called Future. They incentivize us to reduce our carbon through purchasing. It's basically a credit card rewards program. But when you lower your carbon footprint, you get paid. They've made Green GPT. So they've built on this interesting, sometimes problematic, undoubtedly impressive technology to optimize the use for helping me find incentives for solar power, for finding personal and collective ways to green. That's great. And that's so much faster than I would do manually Googling things.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I keep trying to figure out how to recycle by using Google. But anyway, Scott?
Scott Galloway
Baratunde, last question. Do you have any predictions? Do you think, I'm just curious what you think about the AI pause movement and if you think it's a good idea, a bad idea, and generally, are you optimistic or pessimistic about generative AI?
Baratunde Thurston
You know how I feel about binary questions, Scott, but the pause movement, I respect the intention. I suspect it is just not a well thought out concept. And rather than a pause, I would nominate engagement. I would encourage everyone who thinks this has nothing to do with you, to get engaged, to play with these things, to ask questions of it, to build things yourselves, to challenge them when they create errors and problems and flag that in whatever systems of democracy we have, whether it's in your company, in your county, in your country. But I don't think we have an ability to literally pause it. And I suspect some of those who are requesting it are doing so in bad faith because they missed out. Hello, Elon.
As far as optimism versus pessimism, I think we have the ability to unlock something really beautiful with this. We can have conversations with sets of data. We can talk to our younger selves if we ingest our journals. And we can create time for ourselves as technology always promises, but never really delivers. And so we get another shot. We get another bite at the apple here to say, okay, if a spreadsheet can analyze itself and a meeting can attend itself and a photo can take itself, then what are we supposed to do with all that time? And I hope we choose it to invest in relationships, to spend time in the ocean, to spend time with each other. That's not our default setting right now, especially because all this comes out of a kind of return-driven capitalist environment. But I just think it's part of my deep desire to remind us that we always have that choice. And so I want us to exercise it as much as we possibly can and wield this magic for our collective benefit, not just to work more.
Kara Swisher
Magic. You sound like a techie, Baratunde.
Baratunde Thurston
I appreciate it.
Kara Swisher
I appreciate it. It's the hope. I think, look, the other side of this is that this obsession with intelligence that's artificial in nature separates us from our deeper, most compassionate human nature. And that we just become, we work for machines. Could go either way.
Baratunde Thurston
It could be.
Kara Swisher
But deeply, Kara, it's not decided yet.
Baratunde Thurston
No. No matter where you lean, we can't give up and be like, it's all over. Then it really is all over.
Kara Swisher
I'm only concerned with who's deciding. That's all. So who's in charge right now? Just pay attention to that.
Baratunde Thurston
Absolutely.
Kara Swisher
Speaking of which, your other show is about outdoors, right? And you talk about, and one phrase that keeps getting thrown around is "touch grass," meaning go offline and go outside. Would it be better if people like Elon touched grass or the outdoors? You mentioned it several times, people getting out and away from things. Obviously, you talk about climate change on the show and other things, but it's one of the things that I think people, I think about getting outdoors a lot more than I do. And Scott certainly talks about dating and getting outdoors and being in real time.
Baratunde Thurston
I mean, your question connects with a lot. I hear Scott talking about relationships, right? That's the quality of life. And in our How to Citizen work, we have this pillar of citizen as a verb, invest in relationships with yourself, with others, and with the planet around you. So it's not just a prescription for Elon. We are as human as he is and vice versa. Sometimes it doesn't seem that way, but we all have our stuff. And so I worry, but I also see the benefits of we need to spend more time with living things. We need to spend more time with living human beings, with animals, with plants, with soil. I think it's Australia. They're starting to prescribe it for depression, especially in men. Talk therapy has benefits. Also walking through a forest. And if you repeatedly do that, it does stuff for our blood pressure, our heart rate, our sense of belonging, our humility, our sense of joy and peace.
I hear birds behind you. Is that on purpose? You do literally hear birds. That is not a sound machine. I am trying to walk the talk here. It's medicine, and it's where we come from. So even as we invent so many ways to escape the planet, to escape each other, we've got to prescribe a set of homecomings for ourselves. And then the whole idea of saving the planet becomes less randomly ideological to some. It's not a partisan thing. It's literally the most self-interested thing we can do. It becomes saving ourselves.
Scott Galloway
Just to reinforce what you were saying about nature, and I consider myself a great endorsement, but my youngest really struggled during COVID and not being at school. It was really tough for a 10-year-old. And at one point, it got kind of scared for all of us. And I called a friend of mine who was at one point one of the top child psychologists in the world. And he said, "Where do you live?" And I told him, he's like, "You're blessed. Every day take him into the ocean." And nine days later, I'm not exaggerating, he just slowly started getting better. Something about being outdoors, and I would invite all his friends over because it was outdoors, it was COVID friendly. And I realize this is a story of privilege, but the ability to get him outdoors and reset him and water and the exercise, it was really, it was really wonderful.
Anyways, I ran into you in Austin. That's right. I think about a year and a half ago and you're with your wife. And just make, let me make some reductive generalizations. You guys had a really nice vibe about you and you seem generally like having a nice time with each other. And do you have any thoughts on being a good partner and being a good husband?
Baratunde Thurston
You usually keep coming with these zingers. Thank you for noticing that, first of all. I am about 10 years into this relationship. And humility, humility, humility, humility. I grew up, Scott, I like to joke in my live presentations, I wasn't a ladies' man, I was a ladies' friend. And the moms loved me and the girls didn't. And so that created a version of me where I was just starved for romantic attention. And anything that came away, I'm like, "This is it, we're in love." And then I was just trying to cling to that and hope nothing ever changed. And that doesn't work because I change and the other person changes. And I have a first marriage to show that. And I learned a lot from that relationship.
In this one, I have learned to be a lot more vulnerable despite the discomfort of that. I've learned that real love involves really knowing the other person and being willing to be known, warts and all, and to trust that when my partner says she really wants to know how I'm feeling, if it's not a good feeling, the type of feeling I'm used to hiding, she really means it. And that whatever temporary awkwardness, nervousness, sweat, pain is totally outweighed by the longer term depth of trust, relationship, and connection that comes through that.
Scott Galloway
Wow.
Baratunde Thurston
It's been the greatest journey. And I feel like we're both, you know, learning analog meat machines in this generative, sometimes adversarial process.
Kara Swisher
It was great. Anyway, you can read Baratunde Thurston in Puck, listen to him on How to Citizen, and watch him in the next season of America Outdoors on PBS this summer. And Baratunde, do not go to Bed, Bath & Beyond with Scott. That's all I'm going to tell.
Baratunde Thurston
Declension. Declension.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, there's declension that would happen. That's your episode title right there, declension. All right. Thank you so much. Truly, it's always a pleasure, you two. Keep it up.
Baratunde Thurston
Thanks, Baratunde.
Kara Swisher
All right, Scott, I think you should spend more time in the woods with Baratunde. That's what I think you should be doing.
Scott Galloway
You think?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah. Take him for long walks.
Scott Galloway
I think I need more time in the woods alone.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's probably true. One more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Break
Okay, Scott, let's do some wins and fails. I think I shall go first. I really was irritated by Anheuser-Busch for putting the two executives on leave after a conservative backlash to a Bud Light marketing campaign that featured trans influencer and activist Dylan Mulvaney. The beverage giant suspended Bud Light's VP of marketing and her boss. Just to be clear, conservatives never accused Dylan Mulvaney of doing anything wrong. She's just trans and delightful and that's enough. I watched the ads. They were fine. They were so non-controversial. Bud Light, you know, Anheuser-Busch is actually a very conservative company, if people don't realize that.
And then the right now is coming for Jules Hoffman, a non-binary musician who makes children's music on a popular YouTube channel called Songs for Littles. The show's creator has gone on a break after seeing tons of negative comments from users who oppose Hoffman's presence on the show. I mean, people have got to stop. It's just like, I don't understand, I just, I find it so disheartening, the attacks on trans people. And I don't know what to say about it. It's just a real fail. It's a fail of all of us. So unkind. And so even if you put into, you don't understand people like this, there's a point where you have to stop what you're doing to attack them so viciously.
And in particular, a guy named Matt Walsh is really possibly the most heinous person around on this topic. And no one's going to stop him, but please, please don't follow such a heinous troll like him. Anyway, that's my fail. What's my win? Paul Pelosi. So glad to see him healthy. Really a delight. And he's really bounced back from something that I think would hurt and traumatize other people. And it was really nice to see him.
Scott Galloway
Look, I know the people at AB InBev really well. And it's a good company. And it's full of good people. And I'm not going to call them progressive or conservatives, but the people I've dealt with, and I've dealt with people there at every level, I don't know their politics. And I like that. They're just good people doing good work.
Kara Swisher
Yep.
Scott Galloway
And I think they screwed up here, though. I think that they should have just said, "Look, Dylan Mulvaney is an inspiration. And just like George Strait and the rodeo stars we sponsor, we have several hundred influencers, and we support her and every one of our other spokespeople." And this thing just would have burnt out on its own. Boycotts and some wackos burning Nikes or shooting cans of Bud, that says more about them than it does about AB InBev. So I just don't think they handled it well. I think they responded and got scared and putting these people on leave. They just should have said, "Look, this is about a person who we think is interesting, we think means a great deal to other young people, and we're happy to have her as a spokesperson."
Kara Swisher
Did you watch the ads? They're totally delightful. They're benign. They're innocent. They're not even like – they're sweet. Isn't she pretending to be Audrey Hepburn? I mean, it's just sort of –
Scott Galloway
Yeah, they're sweet. Literally. It's the most ridiculous version of anything controversial. And all I got, a major GOP principle is be who you want to be without government telling you who to be. I don't get – there's nothing less – people left Europe and came to America because a bunch of religious institutions were telling them who they needed to be. And the whole point of America is the pursuit of liberty and happiness. And these individuals aren't – I mean, they're not bothering anybody. Like if they're making a political statement like, "Oh, and the trans community and the gay community and every community can make political statements," then fine. Maybe you have a civil conversation to push back and say, "No, I think you've gone too far. I don't agree." Right. But when someone's just making a video, I mean, it's just like this is nothing but trying to feed into really ugly instincts saying this person's trans and if you don't like trans people like me.
Kara Swisher
Watching it and being offended in any way. It's, it's, you know what I loved? I'll tell you though, Lizzo. Here's my win, actually. My win is Lizzo in Tennessee who brought drag performers on stage, which may violate state law, but I would love to see them try and arrest her. She's the queen.
Scott Galloway
Yeah, I just don't, this was a rare, a rare misstep from, like I said, these are good people and it's a great organization. It's not going to impact them. Their stock is fine. These things burn out. These incredibly loud, angry people who burn their Nikes or whatever it is they do, they're the ones who are not buying the beer to begin with. But they should have. Sometimes it's like in a marriage. Occasionally you should just be deaf and realize it's not about you. They should have just issued. They should have not listened to these people. They should issue a statement. "We have hundreds of influencers. This is an inspiring woman. We support her fully." End of press release. And it would have died down. It just wouldn't have been that big a deal.
Kara Swisher
You should tell them that. What's your positive? What's your positive?
Scott Galloway
What's my win?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, what's your win?
Scott Galloway
My win is in a very virtue-signal kind of way, the mall. And that is my message to dads is, I had kids yesterday, and now one is gone. One is like a hormonal teenager that answers everything in monosyllabic tones. Everything's either a yes or a fine. And I have a 12-year-old who's at that wonderful stage where he wants to plan and suggest and do stuff. And I'm just all about the yes. "Do you want to go hang out at a mall that used to be a power station?" "Yeah, that sounds great." "Do you want to, Dad, there's this great dim sum place in a mall. Should we go?" "Wouldn't that be fun?" "Yeah, that sounds like a lot of fun. Let's go." I just can't tell you, Kara. I literally went to sleep yesterday. I had two little boys and now one's a young man and I can tell in a blink the other one's going to be gone. So my win is malls.
Kara Swisher
This is a song called "Cats in the Cradle." Oh Jesus.
Scott Galloway
I am so emotional around this shit.
Kara Swisher
My, what I would say is let your kid go on a generative AI and type in "fun things to do with dad" and they will come back with like 15 ideas.
Scott Galloway
Oh, is it good?
Kara Swisher
Oh good. That's good. That's a good thing. And most of them are awful and you just got to say yes. Ignore all the crafting. I got to tell you, I'm going to give you one little thing. They don't go away, just so you know. I talk to Louie every single day and they don't go away. They don't. They stay there. If you did a good job, they stay there and they call you, they ask for advice, chit chat and stuff like that. Louie and I are getting our hair cut this week in New York together. That's what we're doing. That's strange on a number of dimensions. But anyways.
Scott Galloway
We're going to look good.
Kara Swisher
Beautiful hair. Why not?
Scott Galloway
Yeah, he does that best. We do shit like that all the time.
Kara Swisher
Good for you. Yeah, you will. You like that mom pretending to be cool that goes and gets ink, goes and gets a tattoo. We did. I did that with him.
Scott Galloway
Oh, God. Make it stop.
Kara Swisher
He loved my tattoos when he was a kid. That's the clincher. No, let me just say, he loved my tattoos when he was a kid. And then he got tattoos. And then he's like, "Mom, let's go get a tattoo." He wanted me to come. Although I would not go to a mall with any child of mine. I feel good for you for doing that. Anyway, we got to go. You've got things to do. We want to hear from you. Send us your questions about business tech or whatever's on your mind, go to nymag.com slash pivot to submit a question for the show or call 855-51-PIVOT. Scott, that's the show. We'll be back on Friday from where there's so much going on. Maybe we'll be able to update Don Lemon at that point. He's trading barbs on Twitter with the CNN people now.
Scott Galloway
Let's hang out with Don Lemon. Let's do a TV show. Don will be the third. I'll call him. Don, you and your sad sack you call a scrotum. You're past your prime deal.
Kara Swisher
Oh, stop. All right. Read us out, Scott.
Scott Galloway
Today's show is produced by Lara Naiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Intertot engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows and Mia Silverio. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thank you for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media.
Kara Swisher
Jesus Christ, are you eating a snack while I'm doing the credits? I'm so hungry. Just stop.
Scott Galloway
Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Lean into the mall. Lean into the mall.
Kara Swisher
We are thoughtful people. Now I shall have a bite of my macro bar. I'm so hungry.