Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics, including the controversy surrounding Andrew Cuomo, the debate over vaccine mandates, Apple's plan to scan images on iPhones for child sexual abuse material, and the parallels between the Trump administration and the current situation.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Ad Break - Sierra.ai
Ad Break - The Guardian
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. Scott Galloway is vacationing in God knows where. This week, I'm happy to be joined by Preet Bharara, Scott's favorite person. We're so happy to have you here.
Preet Bharara
He's so jealous wherever he is in Visa or wherever the heck, Scott. Wait, so you don't know where he is?
Kara Swisher
I don't. I don't. You know, he's got a plane.
Preet Bharara
That seems irresponsible on someone's part.
Kara Swisher
He gets, I know that, you know, but I just let him go and have this Bacchanal kind of thing for August.
Preet Bharara
Does he check in?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah, yeah. He sends texts. And if you notice, he's been like saying how close he is with Anderson Cooper online and stuff like that.
Preet Bharara
I've seen that. Well, you promoted that too.
Kara Swisher
I did, but I...
Preet Bharara
You've done some ego boosting, I've seen.
Kara Swisher
I know, I know, but I'm trying to make him feel better for not being here and him being bad about you being here.
Preet Bharara
Wait, so he's bailing on the job. He's on vacation. He's obsessed with you. And you're trying to make him feel better.
Kara Swisher
Yes, I am, because he's got to come back all fresh and stuff. And he's got a real issue with you. He's obsessed with you. Just like, for example, Andrew Cuomo, Governor Andrew Cuomo. You see how I did that? That was a good segue. He issued an 11-page letter on Friday attacking special investigators who wrote a damning report in his office. The letter claimed that investigator June Kim had, quote, "unwarranted skepticism of the governor because of Kim's ties to Preet." Me? Yes. Can you explain, please? I want a little bit of your thoughts on this situation. What a hot mess.
Preet Bharara
So I can explain. Okay. It has been suggested to me that in this letter sent by my former friend, Paul Fishman, who was the U.S. attorney in New Jersey, in which I mentioned 33 times.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, 33, an 11-page letter. 33 times.
Preet Bharara
33 times. I'm a podcaster now, yeah, and a commentator. I have no public office, I have no subpoena power, I have nothing to do with this investigation, and yet my name is invoked again and again and again. And I guess the premise is that once upon a time I was the U.S. attorney and we did some investigations and June is a really good friend of mine. And so, as they say in the letter multiple times at various junctures, Andrew Cuomo seems to have done things to harm my career among other things. It's reported that he told Trump to fire me. On another occasion, he readily admits that he called up the Obama administration and told them, don't make me the attorney general. And so therefore, because he tried to screw me in various career ways, June Kim, my friend, is in some ways biased. It makes no sense. By the way, he didn't make any of these objections.
Kara Swisher
This is an episode of *Billions*. I get if it's an episode of *Billions*, but they're always cross doing each other, but this is ridiculous. Does it make any sense?
Preet Bharara
So I'm a little close to the matter. Does it make any sense? If I'm watching *Billions*, yes. But otherwise, no.
Kara Swisher
This is the harebrained. Can I read you my favorite sentence?
Preet Bharara
Yes, go ahead. Please do.
Kara Swisher
And I want to know if ordinary people understand this argument. Okay, all right, okay. So in the letter, claiming bias on the part of Mr. Kim, they refer to me and say, quote, "During speeches and interviews, back when I was his attorney, during speeches and interviews, Mr. Bharara repeatedly articulated his deep distrust of politicians in Albany and his intent and eagerness to probe deeply to find evidence of wrongdoing. It is reasonable for our client to question whether Mr. Kim shared those views."
Preet Bharara
Well, I hope he did. Don't you hope that prosecutors care deeply about corruption? Well, Andrew Cuomo would know a thing or two about probing deeply. But in any case, do you have any problem with him?
Kara Swisher
No.
Preet Bharara
Did he get you fired?
Kara Swisher
No. Probably not. Trump didn't. You don't care.
Preet Bharara
I don't believe so. I don't think he's going to be the governor for him. I don't think you like him.
Kara Swisher
No, very few people do it, from what I can understand. Well, this idea also, just on the substance from home. So narcissistic, yeah.
Preet Bharara
This idea that someone has investigated someone once, and by the way, in connection with that investigation, was involved in the decision not to bring charges. Yeah, he didn't. Andrew Cuomo was not charged. Other people were. He was not. Yes. And the idea that you can't investigate again would mean that no prosecutor could ever investigate somebody or prosecute somebody twice, which happens all the time, which Andrew Cuomo himself did because he was the attorney general and a line prosecutor at some time. So it's, look, it's a distraction, like a lot of people do. And I'll stand by the other complaint they make about me. I'll stand by my comparison between Andrew Cuomo and Donald Trump. And maybe I'll appear in another letter.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's right. You are. And you have said that. Can you illuminate me on that? By the way, June isn't your guy, right? That's the plan here. Like, you're using him to get back in. He's your guy.
Preet Bharara
He's my guy. We don't have guys. I know. That's how it works. Maybe that's how it works in Andrew Cuomo's world. Oh, he's this guy. I know he's groomed me. I can see him saying it.
Kara Swisher
So what do you think is going to happen here from a legal point of view?
Preet Bharara
So the important news, we're recording this on Monday afternoon. His chief aide, as people refer to her as the most powerful non-elected person in New York.
Kara Swisher
His guy.
Preet Bharara
His guy.
Kara Swisher
She's a woman. I know.
Preet Bharara
Melissa DeRosa stepped down yesterday. And from what I can tell, and having lived in the state for a while and understanding some things, that is a terrible sign for Andrew Cuomo. All these arguments that he and his lawyers are making tend to be distractions, tend to be cherry-picked. The one thing they're correct about is there is no formal adjudication of this report, right? It's just a report. And then other bodies can decide what to do with them, like a DA's office or like private civil lawsuits, or most importantly, the state legislature. And they can do with this information what they will. And so it's really a political argument now.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. And if Andrew has lost, you know, and it was a very sort of tight and terse statement that she made with no reference to him, no gratitude to him. All right, what's going to happen to him? So Lieutenant Governor, I want to move to another topic. Kathy Hochul is reporting to take over. Hockel, excuse me. What do you think is going to happen here?
Preet Bharara
I think nobody thought anything would happen for a while until the Assembly impeached, which would cause him to have to step aside during the pendency of the trial in the Senate. I think he's not going to wait. I think the good money is that he will finally see the writing on the wall and step down sooner rather than later.
Kara Swisher
Oh, interesting. I don't think so. I think he's a narcissistic prick. Want to take a bet?
Preet Bharara
Okay, I will. But you probably know, you probably know, because you have all the guys.
Kara Swisher
I don't know anything. I just observe. I'm just, he's such a narcissistic prick. I think that is really where I stand and go. He reminds me of a lot of people I cover. You know, he's just not going to stand down. Anyway, speaking of not standing down, Chinese giant Tencent faces a lawsuit from Beijing prosecutors who say the WeChat messaging app does not comply with laws protecting minors. Now, Apple, we're going to talk about that in a second. But, you know, WeChat's youth mode limits young users' access to some games, which is astonishing they can do this in this country when people go mad. And the filing did not specify how WeChat youth mode broke Chinese law. I mean, they're really pushing hard from a legal point of view on tech giants. They can just do it, right? I mean, compared to here. They can do whatever they want.
Preet Bharara
Yeah. What do you think about this? As you mentioned, I don't know enough about it because, as the reporting suggests, there's no basis.
Kara Swisher
Right.
Preet Bharara
Usually when you bring actions like this on the part of the government, you have to have some specificity, like you allege. I didn't spend a long time being a prosecutor in Beijing, so I don't know a lot about this.
Kara Swisher
Would you like to have power like this just to do what you wanted?
Preet Bharara
No, I like democracy better, such as it is at this moment. And we'll talk about that too, obviously. But what is interesting about this, I think, will be the relevance to our later conversation about what Apple is doing with iMessage. And one of the arguments that we will discuss is even if it's all well and good here in the United States where we have rules and we have some accountability, once you allow a certain kind of surveillance in other countries like China, that's where the problem lies. And so I think this is a portent for that.
Kara Swisher
Yes, that's a very good point. All right, time for the big story. Companies and governments around the world are weighing vaccine mandates, but citizens and employees are voicing opposition, even as the death toll from the Delta variant grows. He added airlines will require its 67,000 U.S. employees to get vaccinated by October 25th. This is a day after I did an interview with the head of American Airlines who said he wasn't going to. He got a lot of heat for that. In France, citizens must be vaccinated or have a recent negative COVID test to enter cafes or ride inner city trains. The requirement has prompted four weeks of protests and drew almost a quarter million people to rallies this past Saturday. Amazon has no COVID-19 mandate yet, vaccine mandate. The tech giant reportedly fears an employee walkout and labor shortage if the mandate is implemented. That said, other tech companies absolutely have mandates. I mean, Google and some others. New York City has mandated all of its 300,000 municipal workers get vaccinated or agree to weekly testing by September 13th. The move has been imposed by several of the city's unions. Preet, explain this to me with the lawsuits.
Preet Bharara
Go for it. Lawsuits. Well, the lawsuits seem weak. And frivolous lawsuits are brought all the time. Right. And we see that in the course of the prior administration as well. And it seems to me the nub of the lawsuits is the distinction between something being a permanently approved vaccine versus something under emergency use authorization. Now, I think the better lawyers who have examined this and will be defending these things understand that even emergency use is strong enough and tested enough that it can be required. And so I think those will fail. But what was interesting to me about this debate is at some point we're going to have permanent use authorization.
Very soon. Right. So that to the extent these lawsuits are relying on that distinction, that will soon be gone. And what are the arguments going to be there? Right. Who knows about these vaccines, but they'll have been approved. Right. But the motivation of the people who are bringing these suits, I think some of them care about the distinction between temporary and emergency and permanent. Some people do. But some of them just don't want anybody to give them a jab ever. And so those legal arguments are maybe relied upon too heavily. The other thing is, you know, some of these businesses are saying that there's this mandate, but not tomorrow.
You don't have to finish by tomorrow. Sometime in the future, in many cases, likely after they will have permanent use. And I wonder if that's intentional. So that argument is taken away from them in the coming weeks.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So what do you make of all the resistance? I mean, there's all these incredible stories. There's a story in the Wall Street Journal about a nurse whose parents died, and then she doesn't want to take the vaccine. And she's like, it's almost like people want to blame us for this. I'm like, yeah, I want to blame you for this. And then there was a guy in Texas who was a very anti-vax type of person. He died of COVID in five days after getting it, I think, something like that. Obviously, there's a lot of Facebook stuff where people are saying, I should have taken the vaccine. Can I have it now? And they're like, no. There's a lot of misinformation. There's a lot of politicizing, which I don't get, right? Because all the people who supported Trump and say he should get credit for Operation Warp Speed don't want to take the vaccine. There's a very sad story by a doctor in Alabama who talks about patient after patient who gets sick and said, no, I wish I could take the vaccine.
Preet Bharara
I think we should spread those stories more, not in a judgmental way, even though I understand the urge to be judgmental.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, really? It's interesting because I think fear does more than coddling, honestly. Let's give someone a beer or $5 or whatever the heck you want to give them to $50. I do think fear is what causes people to do things.
Preet Bharara
It is, but also, I think the carrot works better than the stick according to some things that I've read, right? If you are told you can't fly, you can't go to a concert without getting vaccinated, that's maybe going to be worth more to you than $100.
Kara Swisher
Is that a carrot or is that punitive? That's a stick, right?
Preet Bharara
Well, let's call it a carrot.
Kara Swisher
Okay, all right. Through our rhetorical magic, look, if you get this vaccine, you get to go see Springsteen. I am all out of fucks I have to say about this. I just am like, I cannot say. I have a young child. And I'm like, oh, she, you know, by the way, got in a little bit of trouble yesterday, hit her head and we're in the hospital. And I was like, oh, great. We're walking into COVID soup and ended up wearing the mask all the time. But it was sad. I was, she was real good at it. And it was really, I just am like, no, this is not something I want for my children. Essentially, I don't want this to happen. But what do you imagine is going to happen? Will the Biden administration have a vaccine mandate? Is there any possibility of that?
Preet Bharara
Well, you know, what's interesting about that is to put the lawyer hat on again for a second. There's a division within in the Department of Justice called the Office of Legal Counsel, which was asked to develop an opinion, basically saying that governmental entities and private entities can issue mask mandates. They don't call them a mandate because they say, we're not sending people to your home and holding you down, but it's a conditional requirement. If you don't get the vaccine, then you can't participate in certain things. You can't come to your work as a police officer. You can't come to your work at the Justice Department. And so I think that a signal that they have strong legal grounds, which goes to your question about lawsuits, for proceeding. I think the balance for them is, you know, the people who are pro-Biden are getting the vax.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Preet Bharara
And the people who are not have to be persuaded in some way that works. Because, you know, Biden's numbers are slipping. Not that this should be described in a political context, but it is. And the irony is that it's the people who are against Biden who don't want to get vaccinated who are causing a problem for everyone else.
Kara Swisher
But that is reducing his numbers among independents also. It's a big catch-22.
Preet Bharara
Yeah, 100%.
Kara Swisher
Well, last question on this. When they're trying to do this, when you're a company, what do they do? You see more activity from companies than you do from governments. And obviously, you see some resistance from governments like in Florida and Texas and other places. Not just that mask wearing and vaccinations. Those are sort of two separate things, but they're together in some way. I never thought vaccines would get dragged into the mask fight essentially, but that's what's happened.
Preet Bharara
Look, there's a combination of things you can do. You can ask for vaccinations, but then in the alternative, you can have, look, you can have religious exemptions. There are people who in good faith, and there's a lot of people in bad faith who don't get the injection. You can mandate testing. The problem population are the people who don't want to get vaccinated, don't want to get tested, and don't want to wear a mask.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Preet Bharara
And that's a trifecta for disaster.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. Look, but in your experience, I'm sure you've seen over and over again that sometimes it's businesses who take the lead.
Preet Bharara
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
On issues of public health and social justice, too. And they don't mind being food, either. They don't, like, come at us. Like Walmart. Were you surprised by Walmart?
Preet Bharara
No. I know Doug McMillon. No. I don't. They have, they're a forward-facing company. They have to do that.
Kara Swisher
You know, when I was interviewing the American Airlines CEO, he was talking about it, and I said, I'm not getting on your airline. I said, that's my consumer decision. You know what I mean? Like one of your flight attendants coughs on me. I don't want to, I can still get COVID. I don't want to get it.
Preet Bharara
So you're going to just use Professor Galloway's jet?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I'm going to use his jet. Scramble the jets, Galloway. He definitely has his pilots vaccinated, right?
Preet Bharara
I don't know. I don't know what he does when he leaves the area of this squad cast. I don't know what he does, Preet.
Kara Swisher
Let's go on a quick break. When we get back, Apple does an about face on privacy, like you said. Stay with us.
Ad Break - Thumbtack
Ad Break - LinkedIn
We're back. Apple has announced plans to scan images on iPhones and other devices before they're uploaded to iCloud. Apple says the program is designed to detect and prevent the sharing of child sexual abuse material. It's called CSAM, I believe. The privacy advocates warn that this effectively nullifies Apple's previous commitment to user privacy. EFF, not surprisingly, has criticized the move, saying it's impossible to build a client-side scanning system that can only be used for this type of content. The move will include scanning iMessages of users younger than 13, as well as updates to Siri search that will intervene when users search for prohibited material. Will Cathcart, the head of WhatsApp, voiced concern on Twitter. He's a really interesting guy. And said the popular chat app will not adopt the system. So what do you think? What is going on here?
Preet Bharara
So, you know, this is just the latest example, the latest iteration of a debate that we've had even before modern technology, going back to the founding of all republics since we first started talking about the social contract, right? The balance between liberty and security. And I think on both sides of this debate, there are people who too often belittle the other side. So I think there are privacy advocates, no offense to them, who I think are not as concerned about things like child pornography and the manufacture of child pornography, which...
Kara Swisher
Well, they think the blocking of it hurts other things.
Preet Bharara
I think they're willing to tolerate it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, no, I see.
Preet Bharara
But you kind of can't have everything.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, you can.
Preet Bharara
As soon as you start talking about a balance, you have to figure out where that's struck. And some people advocated for it in one direction versus the other. And I think they have to take seriously this issue of so many people being exploited in the most horrific way. I think it was the most awful crime that I ever oversaw the prosecution of. On the other hand, you have knee-jerk folks in law enforcement all over the country who poo-poo the need for privacy. And they'll say in every circumstance, "I need it. No matter what the possibilities are, we need a backdoor." So the backdoor issue came up in San Bernardino some years ago. Apple stuck to its guns on that one. And so I don't know where the balance is properly struck. I don't love arguments that rely mostly on slippery slope rhetoric.
Kara Swisher
Slippery slope gets used too often.
Preet Bharara
It does. It's too easy. It's too facile.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Preet Bharara
Which is not to say that there may be some problems. Look, it may be that Apple is, my understanding is there are two facets to this. One is they're going to match photos that are conveyed to an existing database of pornographic, you know, underage pornographic materials.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Preet Bharara
And then they're going to scan everything or look at everything for people who are registered as under 13.
Kara Swisher
Well, they're going to, once they're uploaded, if they get uploaded to iCloud, if they bring it to the cloud, if they keep it on their phones by themselves. But the whole point is sharing this stuff, unfortunately. But go ahead.
Preet Bharara
I mean, look, maybe there are possibilities of opting out and parents can have a choice about some of these things. Maybe there can be ways to get people to not be as concerned by having outside oversight. I know these companies don't like that. And sometimes when they do that, as we've seen, it's not done in a fair-minded way or in a way that people respect.
Kara Swisher
Okay. You mentioned two things. One was with San Bernardino, which Apple was very strong pushing against James Comey on encryption. I don't know where you were on that issue. And then the second thing was when they took 230 protections away from sex trafficking and some other things. So that was sort of removing immunity from that. Why do you think Apple's doing this? And what did you think at the time when Apple, they were vehement about that?
Preet Bharara
So I wasn't involved in that. But my sense was, it was a business decision. And they're very smart. And I understand that there are companies that have philosophies about freedom or about exercise or whatever the case may be, high-minded or low-minded. But it's through the prism of business. And my perception always was that in the marketplace, being very, very pro-privacy was important for Apple. There was a parallel controversy with Microsoft. And it's a long story, but we were in litigation with Microsoft over trying to get documents that were kept on servers abroad. And it was a ludicrous argument in my view. They're drawing a distinction between servers abroad in the United States. And my view, that was a business decision too. You want to come across as being very, very, very pro-privacy. And the question I have here is, did some research about their business prospects and the views of the public changed to cause them to have a different point of view now than they did during San Bernardino.
Kara Swisher
What do you think? I think they've seen, they realize, I think they're doubling down on this idea as we're not trying to kill humanity. You know what I mean? Like that's their brand right now. We're not Facebook, stealing all your privacy. And at the same time, they're like, but we're going to protect your children. It's a very difficult needle to thread for them, I have to say, because it does sort of give me the creeps, right? I have kids who have these phones and they're young enough. I'm like, what are they going to do to those phones? And I definitely have to study it. But at the same time, I would trust Apple more than others. But at the same time, it could, speaking of a cliche, open the door for anybody mandating that Apple must search for lots of things. I mean, as a prosecutor, did you want to get your mitts on this stuff?
Preet Bharara
Yeah. Look, there's a reason why this kind of technology comes into the debate and to the fore when you're talking about the most serious kinds of things: terrorism, and the manufacture of child pornography. It's hard to come up with anything worse than those two things. I think there would be a lot more pushback and even a lot more debate if we were talking about lesser kinds of crimes. Prosecutors will use whatever tools that they have. And if they understand that a private company has the ability to get certain kinds of information, they will use that from their perspective in good faith to protect the public and hold bad, violent people accountable.
There'll always be someone, "Oh, let's get this guy. Oh yeah, but this guy's bad too." You know what I mean? There's never stopping. Law enforcement folks will also tell you that the most private place that exists is your home. And the constitution has a fourth amendment, which says only that you can't have unreasonable searches and seizures. What's a reasonable search and seizure? And I've heard law enforcement people, and I understand that point of view. And I also understand the other point of view, but to give the law enforcement perspective for a moment again, if it is the case that our constitution has recognized and the courts have recognized that even in the most private place that we have, you know, the bedroom in our home, that if there's probable cause to believe there's fruits of a crime, you can go look there.
Why is a phone so much different than your bedroom? That's the argument.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. I think ultimately if it gets put in bad hands, I mean, these things, we've, listen, we've opened the door a long time ago by using these things. And I think they're just too juicy for law enforcement not to want to do. And I suspect that Apple wants to be the privacy company, but not too private, right? I think they're, and they were going to be acted upon. This is something, let me just tell you, when I'm working on my book on Silicon Valley, and one of the things that was memorable to me when the Communications Decency Act did pass, there was another part of it that was declared unconstitutional. But I was at a lunch where, of all people, do you remember Fawn Hall?
Preet Bharara
Yeah, of course.
Kara Swisher
She was working on this stuff because she was obsessed with pornography on the internet, child pornography. Not obsessed, but she was concerned, but a lot concerned. And so she had a lunch where she had an envelope that she gave out, and it was child pornography on the internet at the time.
Preet Bharara
Oh, my goodness.
Kara Swisher
And I was like, oh, hello.
Preet Bharara
Was she arrested on the spot?
Kara Swisher
No, no. But it was really, you sort of get the emotional side of it as a parent. You're like, yes, get these people. Look how easy it is they have to use these tools. And then you want the companies also to protect you. It's really, it's a very difficult issue.
Preet Bharara
Look, it's the hardest. And by the way, the other complicating factor in this is politicians in the middle in particular understand this. And they have constituents who are privacy advocates and they have constituents who are law enforcement advocates. And during my time in the Senate, I saw most of the time, they wanted to punt. Punt it, not deal with it.
Kara Swisher
But as a prosecutor, you wanted this stuff, right? Wouldn't you like... Isn't it the best way to get information now? Or the easiest?
Preet Bharara
Yeah, with proper controls and a judge's supervision. You know, prosecutors have a view of their own magnanimity and believe that they won't abuse it. But we understand. And look, I have some perspective from that time. It's been four and a half years since I've been there. And I think I understand other perspectives better than I did, which doesn't make the decision any easier. Doesn't make the balancing any easier. And by the way, as you know better than almost anybody, this privacy debate is a little bit funny sometimes because at the same time that people are fighting tooth and nail to make sure that the government doesn't have access to certain kinds of things, these tech companies do and they make claims, I guess that they can't see them, that they cannot. They do, but they can. But like right, you think they can this, but they could change it. I mean, you know the same argument applies to them. They could change it. You know, we have given all this information that we've given access to all our information to them, and yet we trust them?
Kara Swisher
I don't know. Yeah, I don't trust them. Even Apple, which is, I think, the most privacy-conscious. I can show you stuff on your phone that they've been saving there locally, but still there, watching you and tracking you in ways that it's for use on the phone. It's always some excuse that they haven't.
Preet Bharara
In any case, what worries me, and then we're now going to get to our friend in Pivot, is when you have this ability, what if a crony gets into office? What if that James Clark guy, and if you like to have a comment about him please do, did what Trump said? Like if you get some president who feels like doing something... Jeff Clark, right? If you get someone who is willing to go along with it, it's problematic. They could pick anything. Or Governor Cuomo, I think, "Let's investigate Preet because whatever." These are the pitfalls of a free society that sees an emergence of technology that we've not seen before.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, exactly. Well, speaking of which. Maybe Lieutenant Colonel can fix this.
Preet Bharara
Yes, exactly. Let's bring in our friend of Pivot. He's a retired Lieutenant Colonel of the U.S. Army, who served as a key witness in President Trump's first impeachment trial. He covers the episode and its fallout in a new memoir, *Here, Right Matters: An American Story*. Welcome, Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman. How are you doing?
Alexander Vindman
Hi, Kara. Hi, Preet. I'm doing OK. I actually was just thinking about your conversation on Apple and privacy and disruptive technology. I wrote an article for *The Diplomat* on this topic about disruptive technology and understanding the future trends, including artificial intelligence and the need. I brought in Isaac Asimov and the three rules. We should have some guardrails to protect ourselves against this. So it's fascinating. I'm glad you guys are having this conversation.
Kara Swisher
So in that vein, let's recap to our listeners. You were present for a telephone call between President Trump and the newly elected president of Ukraine. On that call, Trump suggested that Volodymyr Zelensky investigate Joe Biden and his son Hunter in exchange for U.S. support. The U.S. had at the time suspended millions of dollars of foreign aid to Ukraine. And you reported this call up the chain of command. This was just a regular telephone call. So you were not surveilling it, but you were on the call, as happens when the president talks to various foreign leaders, different people are on the calls. Can you talk a little bit about what... We had a long interview post when you left and when you were leaving. Talk about where you've been since then. Then we want to talk about the book.
Alexander Vindman
Yeah, it's been about nine or ten months since we last spoke. It's been an interesting trek. I think last time we spoke, there was a lot more ambiguity about what my future might hold. There's still an enormous amount of ambiguity now. There's some sort of wishful thinking about whistleblowers doing the right thing and then kind of landing on their feet. I think Preet knows this maybe even better than most. That's not what usually happens with whistleblowers. Their life is turned upside down. They have to recover from a massive upheaval. In a lot of ways, I've had a similar experience, but I was just well-postured to recover. I think there's a breed of resilience that runs deep in my family based on a background of starting over and restarting. It's a story I talk about in *Here, Right Matters* that's allowed me to land on my feet, but still with an enormous amount of ambiguity moving forward. I haven't quite figured out—
Kara Swisher
What do you mean ambiguity? People are like, "Oh, you, that kind of thing," or what?
Alexander Vindman
No, it's not even external towards me, although there is some of that. It's internal about what I want to do. I made a declaration back then about staying active on national security, advocating for public service, accountability, and demanding values-based leadership. I've been active on those areas, but those are conceptual as opposed to what it is that I'm going to do for a living moving forward.
Kara Swisher
Right. You would have stayed in the army, correct? I guess if I just stayed quiet, I would have been out of war college at this point in a kind of high-value critical assignment for US national security somewhere overseas. But that's not the way things are. And now I'm trying to find my way, invested in completing my PhD at Johns Hopkins. I'm basically all but a dissertation at this point, so coursework is done.
Preet Bharara
I want to ask you a question about the parallels between what you experienced on that July 25th call and some of the things we're hearing about now. I'm struck by how similar they are. In your case, what you write about and what you experienced was a call between the president of the United States and the leader of Ukraine. Part of the message was, "Could you announce an investigation into Joe and Hunter Biden?" Not necessarily open one, but announce one. And then he knew he could run with that. Literally, the quote we have from the acting deputy attorney general's notes from the final weeks of the Trump administration was Trump saying, "All you have to do is say the election was corrupt, and I'll do the rest with the Republicans." Can you speak to how you react to that, given the experience you had and how similar they are and what it tells you about that administration?
Alexander Vindman
It's interesting. I guess I'm past any point of shock with these revelations because it's almost exactly the same thing. He wasn't really even looking for dirt on Joe Biden. He just wanted an announcement of an investigation by the Ukrainians into Joe Biden. So it's the same exact thing. You would think there would be a lesson learned from impeachment. There wasn't. Part of that was because the Senate Republicans failed to do their job and live up to their oath and hold the president accountable, whether that was removal or even something as simple as a censure. Instead, they went all in, basically encouraging the president to pursue.
That's not a stretch. They encouraged the president to continue doing what he did. Subsequently, we had a massive mismanagement of a global pandemic that, in my mind, there is zero doubt cost hundreds of thousands of lives. If it was managed properly, we would not have had those kinds of casualties. The impact on the economy would not be huge. In a parallel universe where Mike Pence was the president because Donald Trump was removed, there was little doubt that the pandemic would have been handled much more effectively. Having failed to learn a lesson there, having inflamed protests in the summer of 2020, the president moved in to try to steal an election.
And he's the one who obviously tried to steal an election.
Kara Swisher
With the same tactics.
Alexander Vindman
With the same tactics. The same tactics. Fortunately for us, he's just not very effective. And usually he does as much harm to himself as he does to U.S. national security. He wasn't able to pull it off. But we came pretty close, in my view.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, one of the things—I had George come in as a guest host the other night—and he said he has all bad intentions, but not very effective, which is, I guess, good, but not that good.
Preet Bharara
That was my experience.
Kara Swisher
One of the things in the book deals with your relationship with your father, who was a Trump supporter. I don't know if he still is. Can you tell us how you did it? My mom is a Trump supporter. I have relatives who are Trump supporters, especially a Fox News watcher. She was an anti-Trump person. I have tapes of her saying what an awful person he is, and then suddenly she was not. It was really a shift. I don't know what went on with your dad, but can you talk a little bit about it? Because here you are doing something that, quote, hurts Donald Trump. Talk about that experience, because it's disappointing, to say the least.
Alexander Vindman
Sure. It is. Although, my dad, I'd never catch him as disappointing. He's always back in my corner 100%, even during this, where he thought the best thing to do would be to march into the president's office and seek accommodation and say, "How do we work this out?" That's the way he thought it would be. And frankly, if I did do that, things could have worked out very differently. But for my dad, he's a product of his history, 47 years living under communism. In those 47 years, recognizing that communism was a failed enterprise, the pendulum swung in the complete opposite direction towards conservatism, an unhealthy kind of conservatism as a complete absolute rejection against communism. This is not an uncommon phenomenon amongst Cubans, Venezuelans, and so forth. He was a product of that. In addition to that, he also appreciated that maybe something like Donald Trump, a non-politician, a businessman, could shake up the swamp and take this country in a new direction. So that's his starting point going in. And that's his starting point with his counsel to me. We had plenty of disagreements on what kind of harm or good the president was causing to the United States.
Kara Swisher
But what you did, he supported you for what you were doing? Or did he say, "Don't do it"? Because your brother also got pulled into this.
Alexander Vindman
When he didn't know any better, when he was listening to Fox News and the president's rhetoric, he thought the president was on the right foot. But as he learned more, as my mom actually said, "No more Fox News in the house." Once he stopped getting that programming, he started to listen to the bigger context and understand what's going on. He had absolute faith in the fact that I was being truthful and just relaying the circumstances factually. He broke with the president. Then, of course, when the president attacked me personally for simply telling the truth—when we did the CBS Sunday Morning interview, he was like, in his view, I just did the right thing. And the president attacked me. That is something he just can't reconcile with. It wasn't palatable. And he broke with the president.
Kara Swisher
You know what you need more of? You need more of Vox Media and Kara Swisher and some others.
Preet Bharara
Can I ask you a more fundamental question about what you've learned about character and judgment and personality? What qualities of personality cause a person to be more likely to stand up in the way you did and be courageous in the way you did than other folks? I've talked about this with Michael Lewis, who identified for me the quality of self-possession, people who don't care as much about what other people think and are very, not arrogant or conceited, but are just comfortable with themselves. Do you have a view on the kinds of things that make a difference? Because I think it's important to figuring out how we educate people, how we train future leaders as well.
Alexander Vindman
I'm going to start out with the more controversial characteristics and then work to the safer ones. I think there's a little bit of an irreverence that I've always had. With regards to the office of the president, I've always held that office in extremely high regard. Frankly, not until that phone call did I really fully believe that the president was behind this enterprise. I thought it was do-gooders trying to ingratiate themselves with the president, trying to advance the president's interests. But I refused to believe that the president himself, no matter the fact that I'd seen him in action and knew he was kind of corrupt, transactional, and self-serving, did I believe it because of the reverence of the office. But in my background, there is a bit of an irreverent streak that helps.
Kara Swisher
That's an interesting trait to have for an army officer who spent their career in the military. That's not on the checklist, right?
Alexander Vindman
It's not. Irreverent. It's right after "follows orders well."
Kara Swisher
Yes, it is. That's not true. Look at Milley. Look at... I think people do. You're supposed to think for yourself.
Alexander Vindman
I do. But you take a critical eye and try to look at the merits of a situation on both sides, juxtaposing views. It's important. I had a chance to work for Chairman Dunford, who I thought was a superb leader, and he welcomed that kind of feedback. General McKenzie, who's now the CENTCOM commander, was a very strong supporter and at one point called me in and encouraged me. One of the last conversations I had before I left the Pentagon was like, "You're not our typical lieutenant colonel. You're doing great. Speak your mind." I had plenty of leaders telling me to do that, encouraging me, and nurturing that healthy, respectful irreverence.
So I think that's one trait. Another one is having a sense of yourself and already having a moral compass as a background to build on. I think I got a lot of that from my father, who did not tolerate dishonesty. That was made clear to us from an early age. And it's something I certainly instilled with my subordinates in the military, with my daughter. This concept of once you lose trust, it's nearly impossible to regain it. I too often maybe give people the benefit of the doubt until they prove me wrong, and then it's hard to recover. But that's a starting point for me.
Kara Swisher
Okay. So we've heard reports that military leadership worried about a coup in the waning days of the Trump administration. Do you think their concerns were valid? This was General Milley and others. You said they wanted you to think for yourselves, and it looks like they were doing some of that. Do you think the military would have resisted a more organized coup attempt on January 6th?
Alexander Vindman
I think the military was dead set on not being involved at all in domestic politics.
Kara Swisher
As they should.
Alexander Vindman
That's absolutely right. But we were in uncharted territory. In a world in which the president was able to effectively rouse his constituency—frankly, already radicalized, deeply radicalized to violence—and they secured the Capitol building. They basically held the White House. Law enforcement wasn't well positioned to respond. I don't know what the right answer would be, but it doesn't seem like the military could completely sit out on the sidelines as our democracy was being stolen. In a more effective world where you had a competent president who was able to actually realize the enterprise, sitting on the sidelines, I don't know if that makes a lot of sense.
My criticism of the military is that they're too prepared to take half measures. I think we've seen that play out over a couple of decades of war. They took at best half measures. Maybe that's even a kind judgment with regards to defending somebody who was in a position to not defend themselves—me, in uniform. I didn't have the ability to defend myself. I didn't have the ability to say anything. And they were willing to have me sacrificed, encouraging the president to continue to pursue coercive tactics to break the military like he did so many other institutions under his watch. Not break completely, but harm them and have them bend to his will, with the State Department, with Defense.
I'm concerned that the military, in being weak in responding to each one of these different events—me, the protests in the summer of 2020, the president's rhetoric about stealing the election, whether he was encouraged to then potentially leverage the military, either to have them come out in support of him or to somehow indicate that the military was behind him as he tried to attempt his coup—I don't think the military did any favors to itself by completely sitting out on the sidelines. It's just not right.
Preet Bharara
Interesting. I wonder, Lieutenant Colonel, aside from President Trump, is there some person in this whole saga that you write about and that you endured who disappointed you the most, either in the way that they didn't support you or didn't speak up, or they turned out to be someone that you didn't think that they were?
Alexander Vindman
Yes. Yes, very much so. One of the last acts that Chairman Dunford did on his way out—I think it was his last day—he put out a statement to CNN talking about recognizing that I was under attack, attesting to my capabilities, my integrity, and so forth. And that's it. After that, it was crickets. I don't say this as a criticism against the Department of Defense or the Army as a whole. They're honorable institutions filled with tremendous public servants, selfless servants. But the leadership, I think, frankly, failed both me and the nation in certain regards in not holding the line to the ethical standards and principles of the institution.
The leadership, not the institution. That's an area that I'm increasingly more comfortable to talk about because it's a hard place to go for me as a career military officer. But we are in a place where we're not in a state of war. We are coming out of two decades of the military failing to achieve the military and political objectives. There's a moment of introspection as to why these things occurred and possibly for us to be able to address these issues and become stronger. So that's where I would come in on criticism. And then House leadership, GOP leadership, has failed to live up to their obligations and their oath.
They've moved on and disappointed us on other things.
Kara Swisher
Yeah. So I have this question for you. It's a serious question, but perhaps frivolous. I can only find one interesting omission from your book, *Here, Right Matters*. And it's the lack of an index, which is interesting to me. You wrote a Washington book without an index. I wonder if that was intentional to drive Washington people crazy, because how the hell do you expect Washington people to read your book unless they can first turn to the index and find their name? Answer, sir.
Alexander Vindman
That is an excellent question.
Preet Bharara
Actually, 33 times in an 11-page letter. Anyway, sorry. Preet wants to find himself.
Kara Swisher
This is beautiful because Jennifer Pritzker, my benefactor and my position at Lawfare, actually asked the same question, and I didn't have a good response. I'm writing a book about... I don't want people just to flip to the portion of the book that has their name in it. I've got a second book project that's a dissertation that's going to have plenty of index and bibliography. I guess I didn't even think about it, but it's a good point. I'll keep that in mind.
I'm going to ask a better last question. What do you think is going to happen to Trump? You've been through the ringer with the right-wing media, but they've stuck with him. So has the GOP, who disappointed you. They attacked you as un-American, citing your family's immigration history. What do you think is going to happen with Trump and his movement as you look at it? They toppled you.
Alexander Vindman
Well, I guess we're even. I got him impeached.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that's true.
Alexander Vindman
Honestly, I'm less concerned about Trump in 2024. I'm much more concerned about his movement. The reason is that he's basically taking slivers out of his pie. He's done that repeatedly. His base of support is shrinking. I don't think he's going to be viable. He already lost by 7 million votes in the previous round. What I'm concerned about is Trumpism. The fact that you have a bunch of sycophants in political positions who are willing to go to any extreme to continue to divide this country, double down on a shrinking base, and think that that's a strategy for political victory. They're taking all sorts of extreme measures with regards to voting rights, gerrymandering, all sorts of other things.
Even if they fail, they do a lot of harm to this country. So it's Trumpism that I'm most worried about. It's this idea that there is, in fact, an absolute truth. It's the idea that we are one people united by far more than what divides us. And it's really a culture war that's being inflamed for self-service. I criticized Tucker Carlson this week. He went to see Viktor Orbán and was touting authoritarianism over democracy. The fact that there is no shame anymore with being anti-American on the right—that's what concerns me.
Kara Swisher
Do you know what? He never had shame. You can't shame the shameless, Lieutenant Colonel. Anyway, thank you so much. Everybody should read his book, *Here, Right Matters: An American Story*. Thank you, Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman.
Alexander Vindman
Thank you. Thank you, sir.
Preet Bharara
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
All right, Preet. That was great. Would you have turned President Trump in? That's a tough call that guy made.
Preet Bharara
Boy. Well, I don't know if I would have turned him in, but I refused to take his call.
Kara Swisher
Right. No. So I don't put myself in the category of Lieutenant Colonel Vindman.
Preet Bharara
That's true. I had enough sense not to talk to the guy.
Kara Swisher
Yep. He was always trying to play something, but to take it up, that took something to do that. But you're right. You both have that in common, very much so. All right. One more quick break. We'll be back for wins and fails.
Ad Break
Okay, Preet. Wins and fails. I'll let you go first.
Preet Bharara
Okay. So aside from the very obvious fail that we've already discussed at some length—the defense of Andrew Cuomo's lawyers and their invocation of me—fail. And then for my real fail and win, I had the same episode involving the same person. It's a former acting attorney general, Jeffrey Rosen, who was only attorney general for the final weeks of the Trump administration, and as we've been learning over the last number of days, has done something very good. He's decided to come in and talk to congressional investigators, revealed information about how Donald Trump was calling him to try to get him to overturn the election, as we discussed with Lieutenant Colonel Vindman, saying, "Hey, just call the election corrupt and I'll do the rest."
He did a good thing in denying the request of the acting civil division chief, Jeffrey Clark, to tell Georgia and other states that there were problems with their election because there's no proof of that. So that's all good. That's a win. I also consider it a fail because it took him too long. This is information that he's carried with him for eight, nine, ten months. And it might have been good information to have brought to investigators and congressional figures during the time of impeachment. Because all of this is part of the same thing. It's this stuff that the president was doing at the time.
Kara Swisher
Very John Boltony of him.
Preet Bharara
Yes, totally. And I get that people are saying this is great, but I think you can't call it a win without also calling it a fail because this information would have been very helpful in real time. Although he makes the argument that he couldn't have, he didn't have that lot.
Kara Swisher
There's always a way. You figure out a way.
Preet Bharara
I mean, look, he's doing things that are part of the win side of this. Knowing that there might be a legal objection by Trump and his lawyers, he basically rushed in over a weekend, this past weekend, to talk to investigators, which is a good thing. So when there was a will to try to get the story out and not be stymied, he figured that out in recent days. And maybe something happened that changed his view. I don't think he thought he was going to take that to his grave. And earlier would have been better.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, very good ones. Okay, I'm going to say a win. The U.S. military just—it's breaking—will mandate the COVID-19 vaccine for troops by mid-September. They're going to order 1.3 million active duty troops, even if the FDA has not issued full approval. Hopefully they will by then, but that's pretty quick. They can do things fast, speaking, as Lieutenant Colonel Vindman just noted. So that's going to be interesting and controversial, but they're going to have to be taking their medicine. They're in the military. They're going to have to do it, I think, unless they leave. The fail is this climate report that just came out, and it's just devastating.
The hotter future with this new climate panel that just—it's a major scientific report, and it's really disturbing. It's a United Nations scientific report. Humans have already heated up the planet by 1.1 degrees Celsius, or 2 degrees Fahrenheit, since the 19th century, and it's going to get even more. This is the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the body of scientists. Even if nations start cutting emissions today, which is a big if, total global warming is likely to rise about 1.5 degrees Celsius within the next two decades. A hotter future is now locked in. So that is a fail, and it will continue to be.
It's depressing, but it's so. Anyway, Preet, that is the show.
Preet Bharara
On that note.
Kara Swisher
On that note. This was a real treat. It was a treat. I really appreciate it. And everybody should listen to Preet's podcast. Say when and where they can get it.
Preet Bharara
*Stay Tuned with Preet* wherever you get your podcasts.
Kara Swisher
All right. Come back on Friday when I'll be joined by guest host Baratunde Thurston. A heads up, that Friday episode will go out a little later than usual. So if you don't see it in your morning commute, don't panic. But maybe listen instead to *Stay Tuned with Preet* while you wait. Go to nymag.com/pivot to submit your question for the Pivot podcast for that episode and others. The link is also in our show notes. Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman and Evan Engel. Ernie Endredot engineered this episode. Make sure you subscribe to the show on Apple Podcasts, or if you're an Android user, check us out on Spotify or frankly, wherever you listen to podcasts. If you liked our show, please recommend it to a friend. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back later this week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Thank you.