Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses various topics including the Pivot conference, the future of media, social media platforms, and the intersection of technology and society.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Ad Read - Sierra AI
Sierra AI: AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24/7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Ad Read - The Guardian
The Guardian: Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique: fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at TheGuardian.com.
Kara Swisher
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. Scott Galloway has fled the country after our raucous conference in Miami. Actually, there was some raucousness. So filling in for him today is a friend of Pivot and all-around defender of democracy, Casey Newton, who also happens to be the founder and editor of the Platformer newsletter and lots of things to me. He's my tenant in San Francisco. He's my friend. All kinds of things. And he did a great job on stage at our first Pivot conference. Hi, Casey.
Casey Newton
Hey, Kara. Thanks so much for having me this week. I like that we're both in Miami in two different hotel rooms. That's what I like.
Kara Swisher
I requested to do this in the same room with you, and the producer said absolutely not. Nuts. You know, I've had enough of you. They keep me away. I have my handlers to keep you away from me.
Anyway, let's talk a little bit about Pivot Miami. I have to say, I was very pleased with it. It worked out really well. I'm glad we went ahead and did it rather than pull it because of Omicron that we thought was going to be a problem. But it has staved off. We'll see. Florida's a little loosey-goosey, I have to say. Florida is indeed much different. Don't you agree?
Casey Newton
Oh, yeah. I mean, just the utter masklessness of this state is really jarring coming from San Francisco, where we are still pretty locked down. Florida is another planet in terms of the way they think about COVID.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they're also very obnoxious about it, I have to say. I've gotten into a couple of beefs with people. It's really interesting: they got mad when people told them to wear masks. Now they're mean to people who just want to. If they want to, they can. So they don't carry their theories out.
Casey Newton
Well, also, I'm very susceptible to mask peer pressure. If I walk into a restaurant and I'm the only person wearing a mask, I want to cringe out of my entire body. I find that physically uncomfortable. So that's something I need to talk about in therapy.
Kara Swisher
It's not your business. I can wear it like underwear on top of my head. It's very interesting. Anyway, Florida has been lovely to us. It's actually been a really great time. We like lots of parts of Florida and it was a really great conference here in Miami. I love Miami. But we'll get to the big headlines of the day in a minute, including the mystery of Melania Trump's NFT auction, speaking of Florida. She's not too far away in Mar-a-Lago. But let's talk about Pivot MIA. What was your favorite part or least favorite part? I think I have an idea, but I'll get to it in a second.
Casey Newton
Oh, man. Well, I will not discuss my own panel as part of that particular question.
Kara Swisher
Yes, we are.
Casey Newton
But I really enjoyed what I think of as the media portion of the event, as a big media nerd. We got to hear from the president of the New York Times and the founder of Puck News. I really enjoyed hearing from their very different perspectives on the future of media.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, we're going to play a little bit of that in a second. What else do you think? I'm going to do an overall thing: I like the mood of it. I think people were dying to get back together. Two, this audience — Code is a much more staid event, I would say. This was an audience that really came to learn and it felt very fresh and startup-y. It felt positive, what can we do, solutions-based. There's a real energy in Miami, and there's also a party energy in Miami, and those things are fun to put together. There was a party on Tuesday night that y'all threw for us in a little speakeasy at the Faena, which is the coolest hotel in Miami. It was just great to be around people doing things that many of us have not done in a couple of years.
Casey Newton
Yeah, and also, people really had great questions. I was really impressed by people. They came to learn and wanted to hear about the things we were talking about, whether it was NFTs or people talking about change moments. I think Brian Chesky particularly talked about reflection and moving forward. I thought that was a very heartfelt moment, actually. It had a lot more heart and spice. I got a lot of thank yous because people hadn't been back together. Networking and in-real-life stuff is so important to everybody, our whole world. Having the ability to be social and then talk about interesting issues was important for a lot of people.
Kara Swisher
My question for you: did you think of this event as more of a podcast festival where the fans got to meet you and interact, or more of a business conference where people were coming to learn and network?
Casey Newton
I think both. The fans of Pivot are different than fans of other podcasts. They love Scott and I, or they have opinions about Scott and I. That's nice. You get a sense that you have changed them or they really enjoy the product. I really like that about podcasts. And they know you, they know us. How's the golden child? How's Bane? How's the Cialis going? Stuff like that. It's really nice. I was likening it to cooking. If you're a chef and you make something and people really enjoy what you just ate, it's a really nice feeling. They really liked the show. They had great suggestions. It's a lot like, remember on Twitter Spaces on the Peloton? Remember how the Peloton fans were really talking about things they liked and wanted more of? That's what it felt like. We have a real community. I think that's critically important. And we built it all during the pandemic online, so it was nice to get it in real life.
Kara Swisher
But let's talk about one of the spiciest moments of the conference. During your panels, the CEOs of Parler and Getter, which included a surprise question from the audience. I put Casey in this spot. I've interviewed both of them before. I'm super intrigued by the conservative social media movement. There's a lot of them and some are going to make it, some aren't, but we wanted to talk about it. Let me set it up a bit. George Farmer is the CEO of Parler and Jason Miller, the CEO of Getter. Jason is well known for working for Trump. George was very famous in the Brexit arena, and he took over from John Matze who got fired after an interview that I did with him where he said some things right after January 6th.
Anyway, you said during your panel that Trump incited violence on Twitter, which I completely agree with, but Candace Owens, of all people, who happened to be George Farmer's wife — we allowed people to bring guests and that's who he brought — took issue with that. She got up during the audience Q&A and read out Trump's tweets from January 6th where he told people to go home and respect the law. That was after he told the mob to march on the Capitol and, quote, "show strength." He also had spent months and months creating things that started leading up to it. So that's when this exchange happened. Let's play it.
[Audio clip plays]:
Candace Owens
So I just wanted to ask if you could expand a little bit on what you mean when you say that that's worthy of being deleted from a social media site because it's inciting violence. I want to operate on facts, not narrative.
Casey Newton
Well, sure. I mean, I think when you spend the entire period after the election saying that it was stolen and then you mask your supporters on the lawn of the Capitol and then you suggest that they just sort of walk into the halls of Congress while votes are being counted...
Candace Owens
I'm talking specifically on Twitter because you said this is what you mean.
Casey Newton
Right. Well, because what I believe is that we actually should take off-platform behavior into account. I don't think you get to be a terrible person in real life...
Candace Owens
Thank you for answering my question.
Casey Newton
...and then come on a platform and be a good person. Off-platform behavior, you think should count? Yeah, I do think. Murderers and rapists and everybody who has a platform, fine, but off-platform behavior should be taken into account. These are complicated things, but something else I believe is that the president of the United States should actually be held to a higher standard than everyone else, not the very lowest.
Candace Owens
All right. Thank you for answering the question.
[End audio clip]:
Kara Swisher
Whoa. That was Casey. That was good. What do you think?
Casey Newton
Well, thank you. We obviously talked a lot about free speech during this panel. You guys always do audience questions, which is great. I sort of joked at the start that it was time for the free speech portion of the event. And man, did Candace embrace that opportunity.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, absolutely. I spoke with her afterwards, actually. I thought she was being disingenuous. I think there were a lot more violent, inciting tweets that Trump did and constant and persistent breaking of rules on that platform for a long time. It came at the very end of what had been a years-long violation by Trump of the standards that Twitter had set for themselves. You may not agree or disagree with Twitter's standards, but they had them and he broke them continually. So I think it was a really interesting thing. I know you didn't love the debate that was going on, but I think it's important.
Casey Newton
It was okay. I feel like I'm in a position where I'm a journalist, but I also get to advocate for democracy. What better place to do it than against people who, in my view, are working to undermine the foundations of that democracy? It's rare to have a chance to really engage with those folks directly. For what it's worth, I also caught up with Candace afterwards, and she worked very hard to bring me around to her way of thinking. At the end, I think we agreed to disagree and it was okay. It was a good exchange.
Kara Swisher
It's just really interesting. A lot of people don't like us talking to people like this, and I don't think that's the correct way to approach this. But people can disagree.
Another notable moment during that panel, actually the crux of it, you asked about free speech concerns on Twitter. Here's what George Farmer said.
[Audio clip plays]:
George Farmer
There is a point right now where you think, yes, this is the right thing to do. But at some point, you will be the subject of all of that. Everyone here will say something at some point in their life where all of you will then have the archaeology mob coming after you and telling you that what you said in 2011 or 2016 or 2021 is the wrong thing, and you no longer think the right way. That's why free speech is important, because at the end of the day, we all make mistakes, and you need mercy, and you need grace, and you need forgiveness. If you don't have that, and you don't have that sort of social media platform which allows for that, you're all going to get canceled. At the end of the day, you're all going to get wiped out.
[End audio clip]:
Kara Swisher
So is he right, Casey? It was interesting. He's a much more moderate-sounding person. Obviously, he has a fantastic British accent. But talk about what he was talking about there.
Casey Newton
Yeah, believe it or not, I do agree with him in certain ways. I just think we come at this from very different perspectives. He likes to conflate free speech on social platforms with free speech granted by the state. I think those things are different. I want to support a lot of free speech when it comes to what the state can punish me for. And I'm comfortable with less free speech on a business that has business imperatives. I think it's really interesting that these Republicans want to conflate businesses with the public square. But when you think about what they're advocating for — and there are bills that have been proposed that would do this — they want the state to force businesses to carry speech against those businesses' own financial interests, which to me is the least Republican, least conservative idea that you could possibly imagine. So I think that's strange.
At the same time, I agree that social norms change. If you're someone like you or me, Kara, who are constantly popping our mouths off on Twitter about this subject or that subject, there is a chance that society is going to move on from us. Things that we say today are not going to sound great in 10 years. That's why I delete my tweets every 18 months. But I think there are different approaches to this beyond forcing platforms to carry really terrible things.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's an interesting debate. The conflation is what drives me crazy. And it drives me even crazier when the social media companies do it. Whether it's Daniel Ek of Spotify or Mark Zuckerberg of Facebook, when they embrace it and then don't live it. They do editing all the time. And then they say, "We believe in free speech." I'm like, well, why are you editing? So they kind of want it both ways. That really drives me crazy. In this case, conflating is like saying "fake news." It's meaningless. "Cancel culture" — it's meaningless. Sometimes you say things and you deserve accountability for it or you deserve the consequences. In other cases, it's overkill on these sites when everybody piles on. I think it's much more complicated and they like to make it reductive. George is very deft and wants to make it a little more reductive. So it's either you get to talk or you don't. The crowd that says "I should be able to say whatever I want" loves that. It plays into the emotionality of Americans who don't realize they're edited almost constantly. And editing is different than not being able to speak.
Casey Newton
As I pointed out during the panel, the most popular social platform in the United States right now is TikTok, which is also the most censored of the platforms because it comes out of China, where they have very rigid requirements around what you can say or not say. So I think the market has actually chosen censorship.
Kara Swisher
Editing. Why can't you use the word "editing"? Is it censorship?
Casey Newton
Sure. You're right, I shouldn't say censorship. But the market has picked stricter rules over free speech paradise. At the same time, I'm happy to let other platforms try to build networks that have less strict requirements. Let's just see if people actually want that. It does not seem like Parler and Getter are racing up the charts lately.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I know. That's the difficulty. I think that's what's interesting — the business thing. One of the things I actually saw Candace after was I said, "Do not mess with Casey, he's my man." But my point to her and to George was: listen, have as many of these as you can. The issue is not so much free speech as it is there's not enough of them, and there's only one in the center. We're talking about power and lack of consolidation and not diversity and innovation. That's what's most important. If we could all agree on that, that would be fantastic.
Casey Newton
I agree. I said that to Candace afterwards. I said, a place where we are in agreement is it actually does suck that there are only two or three, maybe four big platforms in the United States where you can have this kind of robust political debate online. It shouldn't matter so much whether you have a Twitter account or a Facebook account. Ideally, there would be more competition, more interoperability. I think there are ways that we can arrive at that same goal even though we come at it from pretty different places.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and I think it's great that they're trying. I think there's going to be a shakeout. They're not enough. They're far too niche or a much smaller business. From a business point of view, there's a lot of them. There's Rumble, there's MeWe, there's this side of the thing. That's why we wanted to explore it, because the business is going to be tough. And then, of course, you have Truth Social coming, allegedly, which apparently just went into beta testing as we're recording this. I think Reuters just reported it.
Casey Newton
Some people have been skeptical that it was going to launch anytime soon. Just because you're in beta doesn't mean you're about to go global. But there is apparently at least some sort of product, which a month ago I would not have guessed there would be.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, so we'll see. This is going to be hard on Parler and Getter in terms of keeping people. They have the same problems about monitoring and moderation. They've got issues around security, all of them. They've got issues around making money, all kinds of stuff. They're in the same boat as everybody else, whether you agree with them or not. I welcome — I know people say we shouldn't — I think those on the left that say "this is just terrible" — you cannot say that if you believe that they should be able to create. If they succeed, they succeed. If they don't, they don't. But it should be because they have a product people want to use. We'll see where it goes. It was a very interesting panel, and I'm glad we did it.
Let's talk about something that, as you said, is near and dear to your heart: newsletters. I spoke with John Kelly, the co-founder of Puck, about the past, present, and future of journalism. We talked about Substack. Your name came up a lot. He replaced — just so people know — Justin Smith, who got COVID, and Ben Smith and Justin Smith couldn't come. In a lot of ways, I'm sorry they weren't there, but this was really good because he's been going for a little bit, as have you. So let's listen to what John said.
[Audio clip plays]:
John Kelly
I think some people are going to be on Substack forever, and they're going to love it, and it's great for them. I think for some, it's a gateway drug. I think the next thing is going to be creating enterprise value as an economic unit, creating a brand. Brands matter.
[End audio clip]:
Kara Swisher
So what do you think about that? They're doing a sort of Substack altogether there in a weird way using their own technology. But can a publication succeed on the personal brand of one writer? You're doing very, very well. Or will Platformer need to acquire Tom Warner? I don't know. What do you think?
Casey Newton
This is one of my favorite things to talk about. One thing I would say is that when I left for Substack, I assumed that a bunch of people would be right behind me, leaving the New York Times and the Atlantic and other places to come do this. The reality has been that very few have. I think most people want or need a little bit more security when it comes to the steady paycheck, the health care, or the legal defense. Whatever your issue is, I think it's been harder to peel those people away. So that makes what Puck is doing interesting.
Kara Swisher
There's that.
Casey Newton
Well, I didn't want to say it. But you look at what the Puck folks are offering, and it is a little bit "have your cake and eat it too." We'll let you capture a little bit of the upside if you get a bunch of subscribers, but we're also going to take care of all of your normal work needs. They've attracted some really great writers. I think they're putting out some great stuff. I really like what Teddy Schleifer, your old employee, is doing.
Kara Swisher
They're all my own employees, just so you know.
Casey Newton
Yeah, well, you've mentored a lot of greats. I really like what they're doing. I think the risk for them is they get caught in the mushy middle where they don't offer enough of the benefits of working for the New York Times or the Atlantic, and they don't offer enough of the financial upside of doing what I'm doing. That leaves them kind of stranded.
Kara Swisher
Talk a little bit about it. How old is Platformer right now?
Casey Newton
Platformer is about 15 months.
Kara Swisher
So how do you feel now? What are the upsides and downsides?
Casey Newton
The upside is that financially, I'm living the best life I've ever had. I'm building a business that is just growing. To share a little bit: in January, which I think was an average month for Platformer — I didn't break any big news, I wrote some nice columns — my annual recurring revenue grew by about $10,000. When you think about what I had to do as a reporter working for a media company to get a $10,000 raise, it was basically get nominated for a Pulitzer Prize. But I'm now in a position where I can go direct to my audience, and when they like what they read, they buy more of it. That's an incredible position for a journalist to be in. I also get to do really cool creative collaborations. I'm still a contributing editor at The Verge. I got to come and moderate your panel. I'm working on some other deals that I'm going to announce soon. I love being able to arrange — and obviously, this is something I have borrowed from you and your example. I see how much fun you're having, and I'm like, I'd like to have that fun. So it's been fun.
Kara Swisher
All right. What's the downside from your perspective?
Casey Newton
The downside is I write four newsletters a week. That is my choice. But I'm somebody who wants to be in the mix. I want to be able to think about the daily news cycle. It just sort of always has to be good. I have to try to have four good ideas a week. I don't have four good ideas a week most weeks, but that's the challenge of it. Today, I'm in a hotel room, I'm recording this podcast. When I woke up this morning, I had to do some of the reading for today. I summarized the links, then I'm going to have to check out of this hotel, go check into a new hotel, try to write the newsletter, get it out by 8pm. That grind is just sort of always there. On balance, I like the grind, but I can see why most people throw their hands up and say it's not for me.
Kara Swisher
And you have to also — it's all on you. I think that would be the greatest thing. I think about that a lot. I don't care, but if something happens to you, it's like running any small business. If you run a store, if you run a...
Casey Newton
I've thought about this. 2017 was not a good year for my journalism. I was super depressed after the election. I had no idea what I was supposed to be writing that would be interesting to people. I fell into a funk. I was not that productive. The only way I got out of it was by starting the newsletter. But I do worry. Let's say three or four years into this, I just fall into a funk. My readers are smart. They'll be able to tell. They're not going to renew those subscriptions. The whole thing kind of goes away. But I don't know. I've loved it so much these first 15 months that I think of this as a 10-year project. I just want to see what it can do in 10 years. By that point, I'll be about 50. Maybe I'll want to do something more traditional. Who knows what could happen?
Kara Swisher
Let me give you one more piece of advice. You could do whatever you want. You don't have to worry about it. That's the pleasure of it — you're not at the behest of other people or employers or anybody else. You don't have to ask anyone for permission. That's always been the plus of the whole thing. If you don't like it, you can change the weather, essentially.
Casey Newton
Can I say one other thing I like about it?
Kara Swisher
Sure.
Casey Newton
These newsletters can be so much more distinctive than most of the publications that I read. The way most publications are run is they hire people to do beats, and those beats just don't change very much. It's a very slow process to change them. But we cover the tech industry, and the tech industry moves really, really quickly. There are still big publications in tech that don't have a single crypto reporter. I've been writing basically weekly columns about crypto and Web3 for six months now. I love being in a position where I can move faster than publications to find those frontiers. There's nobody to tell me no.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and you did. Scott interviewed Meredith Kopit-Levien, the president and CEO of The New York Times, about the same topic. Here's what she said.
[Audio clip plays]:
Meredith Kopit-Levien
If you have a niche and you can actually make something that is differentially valuable against a sea of less expensive or free — we're still competing with free a lot — alternatives, I think you can have a business. And by the way, I would say that in any space beyond journalism.
[End audio clip]:
Kara Swisher
One of the things I liked about Meredith is she's very open-minded to this stuff. That was great. She accepts this and understands that they've got to think about things differently. So what did you think of her interview?
Casey Newton
She's a really fascinating person and clearly great at her job. I think about 10 or 15 years ago, you're reading stories about the New York Times having to take on high interest loans just to stay afloat. You look at their digital transformation, and not only have they made it through, but they're pressing their advantage and moving hard into games and cooking. Those products are succeeding too. She said on stage that their cooking product, which I pay for, now has a million subscribers. That's a really incredible digital media success story. I think the unanswered and maybe spicier question is: is the Times' success coming at the expense of other journalistic outfits in America? The Times is winning, but there are a lot of losers. Some of those losses are coming from the fact that the Times hoovers up all of the best talent in the journalism world.
Kara Swisher
When you think about the Sub-stacks, do you see consolidation among them? That's sort of what John is doing at Puck. Do you see that happening? Do you imagine a time — I know you did this stuff on Discord — how does that work? Because you're kind of like individual players. Do you ever become a team?
Casey Newton
I have been interested in whether there is a way that we could share some back office functions — tax, bookkeeping, maybe some editing. I'm still kind of interested in that. My experience with the folks I've worked with to date has been that they're very independent-minded. Everybody's working on their own thing. People have very little time to get together and do those collaborations. I think maybe if those people's circumstances change, or I find some different people, something like that might be possible. I think everybody assumes that there will be some kind of Substack bundle sometime. But you have to keep in mind how unusual these products are.
Platformer costs $100 a year. That's very expensive for a media product. You can get most magazines with incredible journalism delivered to your house for $6 a year, $12 a year. They'll pay you. I've talked to folks about doing bundles. I would have to be given so many subscriptions at whatever discounted rate you're going to be offering Platformer at to make it remotely worth my while. That is just kind of a weird thing. If you could get Platformer in the Atlantic for $50, how many subscriptions is the Atlantic going to have to sell of Platformer for me to make more than I would by just selling it for $100 a year?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, why do it at all?
Yeah, it'll be interesting to see if that's – but there is going to be a point where consumers are like, I don't want to buy all these things. That's going to happen. What's of value to you? I think a lot about what I buy and what I don't. I do buy Puck. I would buy yours if you didn't give it to me for free. But it was – maybe you should charge me. No, you shouldn't. Actually, you shouldn't. I should get it for free. But, I do pay for it. It's valuable. But the minute it's not valuable. No. You know what I mean? I definitely am discerning about that. And the times I would get rid of less, I pay for the times.
So I actually like that incentive, right? Because I think about how many of these zombie digital media brands are out there that are free, but you look at what's on them. There's not any real journalism. Everybody's just writing for that Google SEO hit. It's "what time is the Super Bowl?" It's "how to delete apps from my iPhone," right? It's just this SEO wasteland. And there's something about selling a product for money that forces you to get really clear on what value it is that you provide and then pushes you to offer more of that value. So again, I understand why most journalists do not want to have that axe hanging over their head.
But the alternative is you work in some kind of digital media company that is almost entirely shaped by the algorithms of Facebook and Google and Twitter.
Casey Newton
Matt Iglesias had this great piece today where he wrote about the sameness of publications. And he found in like five or six different publications over the past couple of months, a headline, something like "American parents are not okay." And it's running in every publication under the sun: Vox, The Atlantic, Wired, right? And that's another kind of downside that I just feel like we don't talk enough about is how similar all these publications have become, whereas Substack's going to be whatever they want and actually find big audiences.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's a little like a restaurant. I think about it like restaurants and chains and stuff like that. One of the things I like about it is it's fair. If you put out a good... I know journalists don't like to think of their things as content or products, but I've thought about it as product forever, always. And I'm not fancy about that. And everyone's just like, "Oh, it's a bigger, higher calling." I'm like, "I'm not a priest. I don't know what to tell you." And one of the things I thought is if I make a bad croissant, if I'm a baker, and people, it doesn't taste good, people aren't going to buy it. And if it's good, they'll buy it. It seems fair. It seems like a fair trade. That's how I feel.
Casey Newton
I agree. We're in the business of getting people's attention. And I think it's okay to be rewarded for the attention that we create.
Kara Swisher
And illuminate. I think this conference is worth the money. I think we gave them the value that they came for. And I like that. I like that trade. And if they didn't like it, they shouldn't come. And that's how I feel. I feel good about that. So Scott and I, speaking of really interesting interviews, interviewed Brian Chesky, who I've interviewed many times, of Airbnb, and what turned out to be a wide-ranging and illuminating discussion. I asked him about his decision to shut down bookings in D.C. ahead of January 6th. Here's that part of our interview.
Audio clip plays
Was there a blowback for doing that?
Brian Chesky
There's a blowback to everything I've ever done, yeah. There always is because these things get kind of politicized.
Kara Swisher
And does it make you do it less?
Brian Chesky
No. I mean, you just do what you think is right and people are going to agree or disagree on the internet.
Kara Swisher
So you're editing. You feel okay about editing. I have big arguments with Spotify, whoever the person of the day, saying they have no responsibility. I'm like, you have some.
Brian Chesky
Well, we all have responsibility. If you have a platform, hundreds of millions of people on it, and things happen, and you could have done more and you didn't, that sounds like the definition of responsibility. Now, whether you choose to do something or not, I understand different platforms have different risks. I would argue the risk of speech because you're such a physical body. I mean, really bad things can happen. And so we have to just take a slightly different and, I think, more hands-on approach.
End of audio clip
Kara Swisher
That was a really interesting interview, I thought. I've had lots of them with him, but he seems to have reflected through the pandemic. He talked about loneliness. He talked about being by himself. He talked about mistakes he made coming home to roost and good things, too. They, of course, just turned in a killer quarter, like really doing well. They came out of this pandemic doing great. They're one of those rare Silicon Valley companies that I think most people feel mostly good about. I feel like as issues have come up for them, they have been pretty forthright in the way that they handled them.
I still wouldn't really want to live next to an Airbnb where there was a new person living next to me every day. But I think on most of the other stuff, they really tackled it and been open about their struggles as they think through it. So good for them for acknowledging the responsibility that they have. That was a really surprising interview. He's running around the country staying at Airbnbs. I think it's given him a lot of time to reflect. He needed to get out of San Francisco. He needed to get out of his apartment. His mother was there all the time. And it was just really an interesting thing.
And one of the things is, look, the results are the results. He's done incredibly well. The stock is way up. It's a very interesting company. And I think that they have issues around safety, of course. They've got issues with what you were just talking about. They've got customer service issues, like any company. But I thought it was a really interesting thing. And he's been an outlier. He was very strong on, "We're not going to put people in danger around January 6th." He's made a lot of what some would call liberal calls, but he's made them and he's stood behind them, which was interesting.
I kind of like it. He doesn't try to hide behind things a lot. He just says, "This is what we're doing." And it's unusual.
Casey Newton
I agree. Taking responsibility and acknowledging responsibility. I thought that was a fascinating interview. Yeah. I wish I had heard more of it because that was when Candace Owens had accosted me. It was directly after my panel.
Kara Swisher
She's like three feet below you. You can handle her.
Casey Newton
Yeah. It was really interesting. People were talking about Miami. We had mayors here. We had all kinds of things. And what's happening, a lot of people are moving to Miami. They really like it, and how you sort of disperse talent all over the world. And that's what's really happening. I think that was, whether it's you in my cottage or, talent is being dispersed in a really interesting way. I think that was sort of the message I got. I'm spending a week here, and I'm seeing four friends who moved to Miami during the pandemic. I've seen one of them since I've been here. She told me that she had about 40 friends who had moved to the city since the pandemic. So there really is this new community. And these are young people. They're working in tech or tech-adjacent jobs. And they're really giving it a go. It's not just the Twitter VCs hyping it up. People are really doing this. I think the question is, and this was right before my panel, so I didn't catch who said it. But you had this great speaker, I believe it was somebody in the audience, who said, "Okay, but what happens when the sugar high wears off? It's fun to be in Miami. And is this the Peloton of cities?"
Kara Swisher
Yeah, that was a great line. It was John Oringer, who has been here. I think he is one who has not been doing the ridiculous hyping. I just did an interview with Keith Rabois, and we had a little back and forth about why he needs to insult his ex-girlfriend so continually, which is San Francisco. And that's a joke for people who know Keith. And it was an interesting thing, but John was much more measured. We had him on there. And I think it's important to talk about what you're doing rather than where you were and how where you were sucked, kind of stuff. So I thought that was great. But the Peloton, I wrote him, he goes, "I didn't like Peloton."
I said, "Come on, it's funny." And maybe you are. You have to see if you can really build out great education here. We talked about that. If they can build out real community, et cetera. All the things that big companies do, companies that really make a difference. But there's all kinds of fascinating companies here. And there's no question something's happening. But we've seen it before in Austin or New York. New York's big, but they were never able to match the company. You don't see Google or any of the big companies leaving California, but they might, right? We'll see.
Casey Newton
And I think this really ties back to Brian Chesky and Airbnb. That man's living on the road all year. Lots of other people are going to be doing something similar. So what does it even mean to live in Miami, right? Are these people putting down roots? Are they putting their kids in the public schools? Are they running for local office, serving on boards? Or is Miami Beach just a fun place to hang out for a couple of years while things calm down in other cities?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, it's going to be really interesting. I think Brian did make that point. He used to vacation two weeks or three weeks, and then you live somewhere the other 50 weeks of the year. That is definitely changing. And it depends on who you are. I can't get up and move at all. I've got a caravan, essentially. But I'm spending two weeks on the road this month in Miami and New York for worky reasons. But of course, I'm having a great time, too.
Casey Newton
Yeah, exactly.
Kara Swisher
Anyway. Okay, Casey, on to the big story. Android may get its own privacy feature, like Apple's App Tracking Transparency. Apple rolled that out last year. It cost social media networks quite a bit, as you know. Facebook was claiming $10 billion in revenue. It's also one of the factors that wiped $230 billion off of Facebook's market cap, I think one of the more significant ones. But Google hinted that its new measure would be less disruptive and abrupt, partly because it plans to work with the ad industry to develop replacements. What do you think of this? This is something you've been tracking quite a bit.
Casey Newton
Yeah, so I'm still learning more about it, but the ad tech people I know seemed moderately excited about this, or at least okay with it. Everybody assumed that Google would have an answer to Apple's App Tracking Transparency. And when this showed up, the most important thing Google said is, "We're going to implement this over two years." And basically, over this two-year period, we're going to ensure that we can track conversions. And essentially, whatever this new privacy-protecting system is, it's not going to make your sales go down. Or if it does, it's not going to be that much. So that's been the promise. And I think people in ad tech are more likely to trust Google on that because ad tech is basically Google's entire business. But we'll have to see. One of the things, Meta's vice president of advertising ecosystem, kind of a nice title, said, "Encouraging to see this long-term collaborative approach to privacy-protective, personalized advertising from Google."
Kara Swisher
If the ad industry likes it so much, is that a good thing for users' privacy?
Casey Newton
I think that's a good question to ask. Well, what exactly do we mean by privacy? There are some people that basically think we should ban advertising or that we should ban people from knowing what our gender or age is. There's a lot of views on this. I personally don't care if the coffee shop down the street or a mattress company wants to collect some basic demographic data about me. But some people get really worked up.
Kara Swisher
I think they got worked up because they've been somewhat abused. They just do what they want, right? I think that's really the case. Then they haven't collaborated. They're not collaborators, except negatively.
Casey Newton
Well, at the end of the day, the beneficiaries of all this are going to be Apple, Google, Amazon, and companies that can build out really good what they call first-party data systems, which means that we're collecting the data about you ourselves. We're not relying on getting it from third parties. That's the thing to remember. App Tracking Transparency, this thing Google's talking about, this is all about third-party data, what data brokers and other people are collecting about you. When it comes to what you're doing on your smartphone or what you're doing on Facebook, those companies still get to keep all of that data and use it however they want.
Kara Swisher
100%. Apple users, of course, are generally more valuable to advertisers than Android users. There are a lot more Android users, 3 billion active Android devices around the world, 1 billion iOS devices. But Apple does have the more trust in this and it's been part of their advertising. It's been part of their branding: that we are watching out for you. You see it everywhere.
Casey Newton
Yeah, they're watching out for you, and they're building a huge ad business based on their monopoly advantage on it.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, which is interesting, because remember, they were in the ad business for a New York minute, and now they really are. They were in the ad business, and then they denounced it, and then while denouncing it, they built a huge ad business. It's really a great racket they've got running over there. Although I got to tell you, if I had to pick between Facebook and Apple, there was no question, hands down, who I would trust.
Casey Newton
Yeah, sure. I think most people would.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I think most people would. So it'll be interesting. I'm just curious very quickly, what do you think the stock of Facebook has still not recovered? Any thoughts on that?
Casey Newton
I think that this could be a medium to long-term thing for them. If you look at what's happening inside that company right now, Zuckerberg is rearranging a lot of chess pieces. He just put Nick Clegg in charge of all policy expressly so that he didn't have to think about it anymore. So that means Zuckerberg is going to be working on product full time. They have to go solve a really difficult set of technical challenges around how do you build a headset, augmented reality glasses. So I really do think that that company is going to be in R&D mode for five years. And a lot of people who bought that stock because it was a great ad business in the newsfeed are just going to go look for something else.
But here's my one thing I'll say about them. People hate Mark Zuckerberg so much that they've forgotten how smart he is. And so I think that investors who are dumping them now might be in for a rude awakening if and when Facebook figures this out. Because let's not forget, we believe that they've sold 10 million Oculus Quest 2 headsets, which makes them the leader in consumer VR. And it's still super early days. So I just wouldn't count them out the way that a lot of investors seem to be doing.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I would agree. Although I have to say, you and I do disagree on this. I think the next version is going to need two things: a lot of computing power. So big companies will be, whether it's Apple or Microsoft. I think Microsoft's sort of the dark horse here because of the Activision thing where gaming is going to come into it. You need massive computing power and money. And a lot of the people are like, "We can't keep up here." So that's going to be critically important. But you need creativity. And I do not think Facebook is a creative company. It's a very executional company. It's very good at, "Here's the goal.
Here's the hill. We're going to take it." I think the creatives are going to push back rather heavily, sort of the empire. I mean, the resistance fights back. And I think it will. I think what we saw from Facebook, and I know they rushed it out very quickly, was so underwhelming. And it's not underwhelming in the way that they're hiding something. I remember when Microsoft came out with their version competitor to AOL. I was with Steve Case and Ted Leonsis and some others. And we were like, "This is a fake. This is so bad. How could it be?" And I'm like, "No, no, they have no creativity. They can't.
That's why." And it was a really interesting moment. They never did. It took them a while. Then they went back to their knitting. But they couldn't do what they were doing at that moment in time.
Casey Newton
Yeah. I agree that talent acquisition and retention is the great under-discussed question in all of this. And if you look at what Zuckerberg's been doing in VR for the past three years, it's been buying up all of the popular VR studios. So basically anybody that's made a hit VR game, Zuckerberg has bought or tried to buy. The FTC has finally gotten wise to this and is apparently challenging their attempted acquisition of Within, which makes Supernatural, the fitness app. But I think Zuckerberg knows this and he's going out and trying to scoop up all the best talent in VR.
Kara Swisher
I just think this is going to require something much more significant. It's got to be creative. I don't know if he's up to it. I'm going to take the opposite bet. I don't think they can do it. I don't think the people there are oriented toward that. But we'll see. Not counting someone out. They used to say that about Bill Gates. You can count him out at some point. Anyway, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we're going to talk about Melania's, speaking of Florida, NFT mystery, and some other things. And we're going to take a listener mail question.
Ad Break
Ad Read - Sierra AI
Avoiding your unfinished home projects because you're not sure where to start? Thumbtack knows homes, so you don't have to. Don't know the difference between matte paint finish and satin? Or what that clunking sound from your dryer is? With Thumbtack, you don't have to be a home pro. You just have to hire one. You can hire top-rated pros, see price estimates, and read reviews all on the app. Download today.
Sierra AI
Support for Pivot comes from LinkedIn. From talking about sports, discussing the latest movies, everyone is looking for a real connection to the people around them. But it's not just person to person. It's the same connection that's needed in business. And it can be the hardest part about B2B marketing, finding the right people, making the right connections. But instead of spending hours and hours scavenging social media feeds, you can just tap LinkedIn ads to reach the right professionals. According to LinkedIn, they have grown to a network of over one billion professionals, making it stand apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company roles, seniority skills, and company revenue, giving you all the professionals you need to reach in one place. So you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience and start targeting the right professionals only on LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn will even give you $100 credit on your next campaign so you can try it for yourself. Just go to linkedin.com slash pivotpod. That's linkedin.com slash pivotpod. Terms and conditions apply. Only on LinkedIn ads.
End of Ad Break
Kara Swisher
Casey, we're back. Let's see. What else is the news? Melania Trump's NFT sold at auction to maybe Melania Trump, but they're not sure. Blockchain transactions show. You can see these things. That's the whole point of blockchain transactions. The same entity that bought Melania's NFT also listed Melania's NFT. They moved it around a little bit. That practice, known as wash trading, is illegal for regulated securities, but since it artificially inflates the price. As one of my followers said, "I used to buy pretty much all my daughter's Girl Scout cookies every year." But the report from Chainalysis found significant wash trading in the unregulated NFT space. People tend to lose money wash trading because of the fees and everything else. But you're going to see a lot of this. And again, unfortunately, that's going to dominate so much of the coverage of NFTs, as it did early internet, is this kind of stuff.
Casey Newton
I didn't even know wash trading existed, but it makes sense. Yeah, it's a huge issue in NFT trades. And a lot of folks, the real crypto skeptics will tell me that the vast majority of all NFT sales are wash trades. Of course, it's very difficult to know because while the transactions are public on the blockchain, you usually don't know who controls the wallet.
Kara Swisher
Right, which they have several wallets. It's sort of a mix of very public and very private. But in this case, it is certainly easy to imagine Melania or her people trying to pump an NFT by selling it to themselves. But we don't know. So we're going to see a lot more of this, and at some point it's going to be regulated. We talked a little bit about this on stage, about where regulation is coming, who's going to do it. I think there's a push within the governments, both state, local, and federal, about who gets to do what. And that's normal. But at some point, the same kind of things that happen around securities are going to happen here, and we'll see.
Casey Newton
It's true, but we also said after 2016, "Oh, regulators are really going to step in and stick it to Facebook." And here we are five years later, still waiting for them to pass one dang law.
Kara Swisher
One dang law. But I think securities are different. I think health care and securities, they do know how to do this. And I think they will get in. They seem to have more existing power. So I don't think they need laws to be passed necessarily to start taking some of these enforcement actions. And that does seem to make it different. Anyway, Melania, good luck with wash trading. Nobody wants your hat.
Casey Newton
Nobody wants your hat.
Kara Swisher
Let's pivot to a listener question. You've got mail.
Listener Mail - Brock: Hi, this is Brock from Jim Jordan's district in Ohio. I'm calling because I gave up on social media about five years ago when I quit Twitter. And I joined Facebook in 2004 and gave up on it three years later. So I'm asking where I should go. Is there good social media? Is Snapchat or TikTok? They don't seem great. Where do I go? All right. Bye.
Oh, goodness. Well, Casey, you're kind of the perfect person to answer this. But it's nice that Brock is from the Jim Jordan district in Ohio. Did you see George Clooney is going to be making a documentary about his time as a wrestling coach? Wonderful. We'll look forward to that.
Casey Newton
Yeah. Look, I think I wish we could follow up with this listener and find out what he wanted from social media. Presumably he left it for a reason. And so it's a bit tough to predict. But what I would do if I were him is I would go to Reddit. You undoubtedly have some sort of interest and there's probably a community on Reddit that is interested in it. That's really funny, smart. I visit a couple of Reddit communities daily that just sort of bring me happiness and joy.
Kara Swisher
Which ones, Casey?
Casey Newton
I can lurk. Well, I'm a huge pro wrestling nerd and obviously nobody wants to talk to me about that.
Kara Swisher
Yeah.
Casey Newton
And so I go to the wrestling Reddit. It's called Squared Circle. I basically never post anything. I just read what funny people have to say. I watch short video clips. I learn about breaking news. And it's fantastic. It doesn't make me feel bad about myself. I'm not competing for clout or attention. I'm just being in a community of like-minded people who are helping me pass a little bit of time.
Kara Swisher
I'm getting my arms around this pro wrestling thing. I did not know this about you. This is really good.
Casey Newton
Yeah, we talked about it one time because your family has weird wrestling connections.
Kara Swisher
We do. My grandfather was a pro wrestling promoter in his spare time. This is why fate brought us together, I think.
Casey Newton
I know.
Kara Swisher
He used to drag me. I met Andre the Giant. I used to go all the time. I didn't like it. I gotta say, I'm not a fan, but that's okay. All right. Anyway, interesting. I like Spectacle, you know.
Casey Newton
You like Spectacle.
Kara Swisher
What else do you like? I'm very curious now. Let's see.
Casey Newton
I mean, the Reddits that are out there are incredibly diverse, like I was saying. They have one called Oddly Satisfying, which is just sort of interesting patterns in nature, very calming. There are a bunch of great crypto subreddits. So as I'm trying to understand everything that's happening in this world, I can just sort of see what smart people are saying. There are a lot of gay subreddits where people are discussing issues of the day. So there's just a lot in there. And they do have a central feed that will just kind of show you a little bit of everything. But I actually prefer to go right to the forum and then just kind of do a deep dive.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, absolutely. And also, by the way, Brock, Twitter is fun. Parts of Twitter are so funny. There's lots of really funny memes, jokes, all kinds of stuff, depending on what happens. And after a news event, some people are super funny, like very funny. And so I tend to follow people who are very clever and not necessarily acid. I don't like the acid people. When something happens to Trump, they have to... I get it. I don't like them either. But that's not enough. It just isn't interesting. I like people who are funny about stuff. And you can always find them, or interesting long threads, for example. There's some really smart threads on Twitter that I always learn from. Facebook, I don't find fun at all. I find it exhausting. So I'm on it. And TikTok can be really fun too. I don't use Snapchat. My kids do. But I like TikTok a lot. But usually when Casey points me to stuff, actually, which is interesting.
Casey Newton
There's great. I mean, TikTok, I do enjoy it. It's more of a time investment and you never know what you're getting. And so you sort of just have to be in that mindset of, "Okay, I have 10 or 15 minutes. Let's just sort of see what it wants to serve me up." And I find that I'm not in that mode as much as maybe some other people are. But man, when those TikToks hit, they are truly incredible. I've started saving my favorites to my favorite section in TikTok. And the other day, I just went through some of them with a friend. And within four or five videos, we were crying, laughing, looking at these things I'd already seen.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, Louie does that. Louie has a whole TikTok thing that he loves. He keeps a bunch of them off to the side and he watches them again and again. It's really interesting. Some of the content is so... What I love about a TikTok, even a Twitter, is the creativity. And I think we don't celebrate that enough. There's enormous creativity of people out there. And I know part of the social media thing that happened is everyone gets to talk and you're like, "Oh God, everybody gets to talk," right? But there's so much more talent out there than gatekeepers allowed us to see. And it's not gatekeepers. They just didn't get to it, right? Or they didn't fit the right paradigm. And so that's what's great about it. There is the amount of either dance talent or singing talent or just joking or just funny. Like it's really quite heartening. And so whenever I'm feeling like, "Oh God, the human race is finished," I tend to be like, "We actually have some very delightful aspects to it." So sometimes that's an excellent thing. And I don't look to the leaders. I look to the other people.
Casey Newton
It's true. I would also say TikTok does an amazing job of making creative tools for people to be creative with. They invented this idea of the duet, which is basically you can split screen with anybody else who's already made a TikTok and create something new. And so you just get this absolute creative explosion of things. And when you compare that to how not creative the tools are on a Facebook or an Instagram, I think it really speaks to why they have fallen so far behind. TikTok figured out a way to enable that creativity.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, they're not creative. Like the Google people couldn't do social. When they started, remember when they did Google Plus?
I was like, no way, they're not social people. It was just crazy that they thought they could do it. They weren't social at all, and they couldn't make it. And you have to know what you're good at.
Transition to ad break
Anyway, if you have a question about tech business or want some good advice, send it to us. Go to nymag.com slash pivot, or call us at 855-51-PIVOT to submit a question for the show. Casey, one more break and we'll be back for your predictions.
Ad Read - Sierra AI
Mint is still $15 a month for premium wireless. And if you haven't made the switch yet, here are 15 reasons why you should. One, it's $15 a month. Two, seriously, it's $15 a month. Three, no big contracts. Four, I use it. Five, my mom uses it.
Kara Swisher
Are you playing me off? That's what's happening, right? Okay.
Ad Read - Sierra AI
Give it a try at MintMobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of $45 per three-month plan, $15 per month equivalent required. New customer offer first three months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See MintMobile.com.
Ad Read - The Guardian
Tron Ares has arrived. I would like you to meet Ares, the ultimate AI soldier. He is biblically strong and supremely intelligent. You think you're in control of this? You're not. On October 10th. What are you? My world is coming to destroy yours. But I can help you. The war for our world begins in IMAX. Tron Aries, rated PG-13. May be inappropriate for children under 13. Only in theaters October 10th. Get tickets now.
End of ad break
Kara Swisher
Okay, Casey, give us a prediction.
Casey Newton
My prediction is that assuming Truth Social does launch in the next three to six months, it will probably be the end of Parler and Gettr. I think that the winning platform in this space is going to be the one that has Trump posting to it. And if Trump decides that he does not want to get on Gettr and Parler, but he does want to get on Truth Social for whatever reason, I think it could be the end of those other two.
Kara Swisher
Interesting. That's interesting. I am going to take the opposite bet on that. I think Trump's losing a little bit of his mojo. I think all this, not the January 6th stuff, I just feel people are tired of him. They may like Trumpism, but him, he's a little hard to take anymore for even his most – if you talk to any of the conservatives behind the scenes, they hate him. They hate him. They love Governor Ron DeSantis. They do. They want to move along and get to the new fresh versions of Trump, I think. And so I don't know if it'll be – I think the hardcores, they always will go. They love him, right?
But I think in terms of a wider thing, the bigger they are, the harder they fall. That's my feeling. So I'm going to take the out. But you're right. I think it's going to be hard. I would love for you to be right. I do think Rumble is interesting. I think one of them is going to do really well just to have an alternative and then it's going to be broader. But I think it's going to be an interesting time. We'll see what he puts out there. You know someone's going to hack into it. And also Devin Nunes is running it. And I got to tell you, I'm not positive he's very good at technology. I think that's going to be an issue.
Pause
One thing that I will say. The questions remain. As I said, I did an interview with Keith Rabois for Sway today, and it's interesting. One of the things I didn't talk about, and I think it's just really appalling for being here in Florida, and the reason I wouldn't move here is Florida, this "Don't Say Gay" bill, would bar the discussion of sexual orientation or gender identity in primary schools. It passed the Florida Senate Education Committee. What an appalling thing to do in this day and age in general. The governor...
Casey Newton
It's so horrible. I mean, you think about all of the LGBT families and what that is supposed to mean for their children all through primary school. As far as I'm concerned, that's a human rights violation. And they're making it into a ridiculous thing.
Kara Swisher
I can see where they're going. Florida Governor DeSantis voices support for a bill that would prevent this discussion of sexual orientation and gender identity in the state's primary schools. He said it was entirely inappropriate for teachers to be having conversations with students about gender identity, citing instances of them telling children, "Don't worry, don't pick your gender yet." And also hiding classroom lessons. That's bullshit. It's just such, the way they reduce this and make it reductive. As someone who came out, and you too, Casey, this is just so – they're reducing it, this idea, "Don't pick your gender." It doesn't happen. Maybe once, but give me a break with this. And it's the same kind of crap.
Casey Newton
Same kind of crap. I mean, making LGBT kids terrified of talking about their gender identity or their sexual orientation until they're much older has terrible psychological consequences. This is awful for those kids. There are a lot of those kids. And the fact that this is just being used essentially as a way to probably scare suburban voters into saying, "Oh no, the Democrats are trying to make my child gay." It's awful. And we've seen this playbook so many times, and it's just always disgusting and has legitimate consequences.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, and this makes the state – I never moved to a state that does this. Never. And you're not going to attract the right – if you want blue cities and red states, it's not going to work that way. And I think it's going to be hard. And I think a lot of people do put up with a lot. But having been there and having lived through it 30 years ago, this is just not – this is the kind of cynical politics that uses students and does very reductive words like this. And again, as someone who came out and has small kids also, kids are – to have important discussions is different. And I agree parents should be at the forefront of that. At the same time, to set people against each other, it's politics at its worst, at its very worst. It's cynical. It's cruel. And Florida, it's embarrassing. It's an embarrassment. And as much as I love doing this event here, this is grotesque is what it is. And it's a stain on the state.
Casey Newton
Yeah.
Kara Swisher
And I think it's just really telling how all the big Miami boosters, like, nobody's talking about this stuff. But again, it's because they didn't come here to get involved in the politics. They came here to drink pina coladas at Miami Beach. And that really sucks, because we can't afford to let a generation do this sort of thing to LGBTQ groups.
Casey Newton
Absolutely.
Kara Swisher
And this is why California did have this tolerance. The tolerant cultures are the ones that create innovation. They just do. And you could make all kinds of fun of it, but it really is one of the key parts of innovation: tolerance towards others, tolerance about discussing things. And a group of people that goes on and on about cancel culture, this is the absolute – this is what that is. It's not just cancel culture, it's discriminating. It's all kinds of things. Anyway.
Casey Newton
Well, this is a legitimate free speech question.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, yeah.
Casey Newton
This is the state saying you can't say this, right? And all these same people who are so mad that Twitter deplatformed Trump are going to use state power to prevent teachers from talking about the gay families in their classrooms?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, exactly. Come on. Exactly. So that's why this is the way it goes. Anyway, we'll see what's going to happen here. But thank you, Casey, for doing this this week. It was really great. And you did a great job. And again, Platformer is a wonderful platform. We should get it.
Casey Newton
Thank you.
Kara Swisher
I'll be back with Scott on Tuesday, of course, and we'll hear all about his vacation and various things and his thoughts on what happened. We'll be running some of our great content from Pivot MIA as bonus episodes, which will be great. I think you should tune in for a bunch. And check the feed tomorrow for our full conversation with Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky. Casey, will you read us out?
Casey Newton
I would love to. Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman, Evan Engel, and Taylor Griffin. Ernie and Dredat engineered this episode. Thanks also to Drew Burrows. Make sure you're subscribed to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business. Thanks, Casey.
Kara Swisher
Thanks, Casey.