Main Topic: The 2020 US Census is facing significant challenges due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the Trump administration's attempts to alter the counting process.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained comes from the FIFA World Cup, of all things. The FIFA World Cup 26 is coming to North America next summer. It is the ultimate celebration of sports and culture. You can get closer to the beautiful game with a hospitality package, closer to the action, the best seats, the best suites, closer to match day and that world-class food and that world-class entertainment, closer to the experience of a lifetime. Book a hospitality package at fifaworldcup.com slash hospitality.
According to the United States Census Bureau, this is the first official week of nationwide door knocking for the 2020 count. The only problem is everything. Well, the census is really just a mess right now. Hansi Lo Wang's been paying close attention to the census for NPR and, by my estimation, the country.
Hansi Lo Wang
There are a lot of challenges facing the census, including the pandemic, including a shortened counting period. And we're at a point right now where roughly four out of 10 households have not been counted yet nationwide. And these remaining households are what the Census Bureau considers the hardest to count in the country. These are predominantly folks from historically undercounted groups, groups that have high levels of mistrust of the government, distrust of the government, are very wary of participating and sharing their personal information. Despite federal laws that protect people's personal information, that is now being complicated by multiple attempts by the White House to make changes to how the census is conducted.
Sean Rameswaram
There's no real direct comparison that can be made to any past count in the U.S. history. So it sounds like, Hansi, we have these two major buckets of challenges facing the 2020 census. There's all the stuff related to the pandemic, and then there's the general President Trump and his administration challenging this count. So let's start with the pandemic. How has the pandemic derailed the 2020 census?
Hansi Lo Wang
Well, counting was supposed to be done by now. Counting was supposed to end July 31st. That's when door knocking was supposed to have ended. And really the Census Bureau at this point, before the pandemic, was planning to really go through all the responses as collected and start the processing. All that has been delayed. Door knocking was pushed back for months because of the pandemic. It was impossible to send out doorknockers to try to do in-person visits in any safe kind of way. And doorknocking has only just started in some parts of the country.
Sean Rameswaram
And so that's a major, major challenge because in-person visits are really the way for the Census Bureau to make sure that historically underground groups, communities of color, renters, rural residents, folks who are less likely to fill out a census form on their own, that person-to-person interaction is the way to make sure that they are not missed in this once-a-decade count. And that effort is always a challenge because you're essentially trying to convince people to participate in something that they probably don't know about or don't want to participate in. But now we're also trying to do that while keeping social distance, while overcoming people's fears of having strangers at their door in the middle of a pandemic.
Hansi Lo Wang
So who knows what's going to happen over the next few weeks, how feasible it will be in some parts of the country to do an on the ground door to door effort.
Sean Rameswaram
Have deadlines changed because of the pandemic? Are there extensions that will ensure a full count?
Hansi Lo Wang
So legal deadlines so far have not changed despite requests from the Census Bureau. Back in April, the Census Bureau, as well as Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, who oversees the Census Bureau, he's an appointee of President Trump, and as well as President Trump, who spoke out publicly about this, about a request to Congress to extend the legal reporting deadlines for the 2020 census results.
Sean Rameswaram
Federal law says that by the end of this year, the Commerce Secretary has to present to the president the latest state population counts. Those are the numbers used to redistribute seats in Congress among the states. And the Census Bureau back in April said that at that point, they realized they can no longer meet that deadline. They need more time. And they asked for 120 day extension of that legal reporting deadline so that they can deliver those numbers next year in 2021. And that would allow them to reset their timeline and continue counting through October 31st.
Hansi Lo Wang
Well, what's happened recently is that I broke the story. I talked to three Census Bureau employees. They didn't want to be identified because they feared losing their jobs, but they confirmed that the Census Bureau had recently decided to end door knocking at the end of September, a month earlier than they had announced. And then the Census Bureau confirmed that days later and said that not only door knocking would be ended earlier, but also the collection of responses online at my2020census through toll phone numbers as well as through the mail. So all counting is going to end September 30th the Census Bureau says.
Sean Rameswaram
And this is all happening while there this great uncertainty. There is a window here where Congress could pass a law, most likely through the next coronavirus relief package, some provision that includes a deadline extension, which would theoretically allow the Census Bureau to keep counting past September 30th, another month, which is what the Census Bureau officials have said they need, more time, not less.
Hansi Lo Wang
This is very confusing, Hansi. So the count has been sort of ineffectual due to coronavirus. They agreed on asking for an extension and taking a little bit longer with this count. And then before Congress could even finalize it by working it into the stimulus package, they said, never mind, we'll end everything early. And all the while, this pandemic continues to rage across the country and the door-to-door count hasn't even really taken off in earnest in a lot of places. This has been very tenuous planning. All these changes to the schedule have really been conditional, that the Census Bureau was essentially assuming that Congress would pass a law and that because career officials, top officials at the Census Bureau have said as early as May that it is no longer possible for the Census Bureau to produce the latest state population counts by the end of this year, that these warnings are being made publicly. But Congress so far has not taken this up. Democrats have. They've introduced legislation, but Republicans have not. And so it's really unclear why the Census Bureau decided just recently was the moment that they had to essentially stop waiting and to end counting early.
Sean Rameswaram
Do you think there may have been some political interference from perhaps the Trump administration?
Hansi Lo Wang
You know, one thing to keep in mind is that what has also happened recently is that President Trump put out a presidential memo. And this memo calls for unauthorized immigrants to be excluded, not from the census in general, but specifically from those state population counts used to redistribute seats in Congress for the reapportionment process, despite the Constitution saying that the whole number of persons in each state should be counted once a decade in order to determine each state's share of congressional seats, seats in the House of Representatives.
Sean Rameswaram
That memo is now out, and there are now multiple federal lawsuits I'm tracking trying to get that memo blocked and to get it declared unconstitutional. We'll see how that plays out. But in the meantime, not extending the reporting deadlines for the 2020 census results means that even if President Trump does not win re-election, he will be the president to receive those latest state population counts at the end of this year. The same population count that President Trump has said through this memo that he wants to change by excluding unauthorized immigrants.
Hansi Lo Wang
And this is something that's never been done before? No, it has never been done before. Ever since the very first census back in 1790, the numbers used for reapportioning seats in Congress have included counts of both citizens and non-citizens, regardless of immigration status. And one thing to keep in mind, the wording in the Constitution, even before the Constitution was amended by the 14th Amendment to require the whole number of persons to be counted. Persons is a key word. There's no mention of citizens, for example.
Sean Rameswaram
And President Trump may want to try to exclude unauthorized immigrants from the apportionment count. But experts I talk to say it's not possible to do that in any legal way. Because the 2020 census forms do not include a question about a person's immigration status, there is no way for the Census Bureau to know, based on information that it collects, the people that are counted for the 2020 census, what people's immigration status are. And so to try to exclude unauthorized immigrants would require creating essentially estimates based on statistical sampling, something that the Supreme Court has already ruled cannot be used when we're talking about the apportionment count.
Hansi Lo Wang
That when we're talking about how to divide up seats in Congress, we have to use numbers from the actual counting, not from sampling. So can we assume that the president might be influencing these decisions that are being made within the Census Bureau as well? Or is that sort of a leap in logic that you're not ready to make?
Sean Rameswaram
I haven't been able to confirm that, but I think one thing I'm trying to figure out is on April 13th, the same day, the Commerce Secretary, Wilbur Ross, made this public announcement with the Census Bureau director and saying, we've asked Congress for 120 day extension for reporting deadlines. The president came out during his then daily press briefings at the White House to say that the Census Bureau has asked Congress for a 120 extension. I don't know that you even have to ask him. This is called an act of God. This is called a situation that has to be they have to give in. I think 120 days isn't nearly enough. My administration.
Hansi Lo Wang
Hmm. So the president is willing to admit the census is this sacred institution, but he also like to tweak it in a few unprecedented and arguably unconstitutional ways.
Sean Rameswaram
The census ends at the end of September as things stand now. Your confidence in it being legitimate?
Hansi Lo Wang
It is a big question of how much of the country will end up being counted by the end of September. More with Hansi after a break.
Theme music starts
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained comes from Built Rewards. These days, it seems like everybody has a rewards program. You swipe your card and you get one cent on the hundred dollars. But with your rent, frequently, you just pay month after month. You never get anything from it other than that roof over your head. Not anymore, says Built Rewards. Built Rewards says it lets you earn points on your rent. By paying rent through Built, they say you can earn flexible points that can be redeemed toward hundreds of hotels and airlines, perhaps a future rent payment, your next Lyft ride, and so much more. Your home isn't just where you sleep, it's your community. And Built wants you to go out and do things in the community. You can eat at your favorite local restaurants, then earn more points. You can get VIP treatment at certain fitness studios. You can enjoy exclusive experiences just for Built members. Every month. When you're ready to travel, they say Bilt points can be converted to miles or hotel points all around the world. You can earn points on rent and around your neighborhood wherever you call home by joining Bilt.com slash Explained. That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T dot com slash Explained.
2020 2020 2020 Hansi, remind people how the census is conducted.
Hansi Lo Wang
So to conduct the census, the Census Bureau collects information through an online form, through call centers, through paper forms in the mail. They also send out door knockers to visit households that haven't filled out a form themselves. They also send out census workers to what's known as group quarters, Group living situations such as nursing homes, sometimes to prisons, to shelters for people experiencing homelessness, to dorms and student housing. There are also census workers that go out to RV parks to make sure that folks living in transitory locations are counted. Some of that has really been scaled back because of the pandemic, but some of that is still happening.
Sean Rameswaram
This has to be a count of every person living in the country, including in the most remote parts of the country. Back in January, I went to some of those areas and on the western coast, southwestern coast of Alaska, in Alaska Native villages, in Tuxuck Bay, that is where the census counting officially started. And that is part of special operations that the Census Bureau does once a decade, sending out census workers who sometimes take bush planes, who sometimes ride in dog sleds, snowmobiles, or snow machines as they call them up in Alaska. And that is all to make sure that even if you live in the most remote parts of the country, the hardest to reach parts of the country, that you're still counted. That someone is coming to your door, even if you can't get mail regularly, someone's going to come to your door to ask you questions to make sure you're counted.
And just for people who don't know, what is at stake here? One way to think about it is that the entire country would be flying blind, really, for the next decade. We wouldn't know exactly who is living in this country. And that's information that we rely on to determine how to divvy up political power, how to divvy up federal funding, an estimated $1.5 trillion a year in federal tax dollars for Medicare, for Medicaid, for schools, for roads. That's all determined in part based on census results. And so what's at stake here is that some communities might not get their fair share in federal funding and political representation for the next 10 years.
Hansi Lo Wang
And there seems to be no chance that they just kibosh the 2020 census and do it in 2021. That's not being considered right now?
Sean Rameswaram
I have not heard that. And the thing to keep in mind here is this is a constitutional mandate to do a counting of an actual enumeration once every 10 years. And we're due for it this year.
Hansi Lo Wang
So this year's census, with all the drama over the citizenship question, with all the COVID-19 drama, and now all of this most recent drama about whether or not you're going to count people who are maybe undocumented or not with this presidential memo, I wonder, would we go with this census's data no matter what, even if it's not nearly as accurate as it should be? Or is there a chance that we would go with the data from the last census in 2010?
Sean Rameswaram
These are all questions that the country will have to grapple with after the counting is finished for the 2020 census and we start to see results. It's hard to overstate the implications here because in addition to congressional seats and funding for public services we also talking about voting districts all the way down to the local level. We also talking about major policy decisions. You know by the time when there is a coronavirus vaccine and public health officials have to figure out how many vaccination shots each community may need, they'll likely have to turn to census numbers.
Hansi Lo Wang
And so these numbers are just so influential in daily life in the United States, there is a lot at stake to just say, let's throw out these numbers. And this is also a headcount that is costing an estimated $16 billion, which is not a lot in the greater scheme of the federal budget, but there has been pressure from Congress for years for the Census Bureau to cut down on the cost of the census. So it's going to be a big ask to ask for more money to conduct a whole new census? Not to mention any legal questions.
Sean Rameswaram
Is it possible to conduct a whole new census that would be used for reapportioning seats in Congress? That's an open question right now. Is there a chance that, you know, there's a better way to do this? Have we learned anything from this 2020 experience that, I don't know, maybe there's a better option out there on how to conduct this census?
Hansi Lo Wang
There have been discussions within the Census Bureau for years now to rely more on existing government records. This is something that the Census Bureau has done for decades. But what's being considered is using these records to a greater extent in order to come up with essentially demographic profiles of people living in the country. And rather than relying on households volunteering their information by filling out a form on their own or by being interviewed, something that is very costly. And the Census Bureau has been experiencing declining response rates for decades.
Sean Rameswaram
But the thing to keep in mind here is that so far, research has shown not every person living in the country is equally represented in these records. And what that means is that relying more on these records could result in white people being overrepresented and people of color being underrepresented because these records are not a reliable source of information about every resident in the country so far.
Hansi Lo Wang
So the existing mix of online and mail and door-to-door is the best system we've got.
Sean Rameswaram
Have the politics and the pandemic and the drama of this 2020 census done lasting damage to the institution?
Hansi Lo Wang
You know, this is the first census that I've watched so closely, but folks who have been watching this for decades see this as an unprecedented moment for the Census Bureau to be under this political cloud and all of these controversies that seemingly don't stop. And their fear is that it has tainted the public's perception of not only the census, but also the Census Bureau, and whether or not people will associate this headcount with all the controversies that have come up under this administration.
Sean Rameswaram
That is a major concern, that an institution that really strives to be nonpartisan. That these are really folks who are trying to put out the best most accurate data about what's happening in the country to put it out for public consumption and are trying to follow the science follow best practice and to really research and research and research every step and decision that they make before they carry out a census or any other survey that they do.
Hansi Lo Wang
That all of these last minute changes and all this pressure to shorten their work and go against the advice and analysis put forth by career officials, all of this has really raised a lot of concern that the Census Bureau's public perception is being harmed. And when we're talking about the census, public perception is a big part of it because it requires the public to feel comfortable, to trust the Census Bureau with their personal information and trust that federal laws that protect that information will be upheld.
Sean Rameswaram
Hansi Lo Wang reports on the people, power, and money behind the 2020 Census for NPR. Hansi, before we go, anything you want people out there to know about the census? It's not over yet after all.
Hansi Lo Wang
I think it's important for people to know that there is no citizenship question on the 2020 census because that question has been blocked by federal courts. A lot of people still don't know that. And door knockers from the Census Bureau are out there. But if you are worried and you do not want to interact with a worker from the Census Bureau for whatever reason, you don't have to. You can fill out a form on your own if you haven't already by going to my2020census.gov, calling one of the toll-free numbers, and you could do that instead of being interviewed by a door knocker.
Sean Rameswaram
Anzi, thank you. We appreciate your work on the 2020 Census. You're welcome, Sean.