Main Topic: The Biden administration's proposal to replace all lead pipes in the United States within the next 10 years.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noel King
There are more than 9 million lead pipes delivering water to homes in the United States. It's not great. We know that lead is bad for us. And in fact, the Biden White House has spent a lot of time talking about it.
Soft music continues in the background
Over the years, I have traveled around the country and I have met many parents to talk about this very issue. So many parents. Parents who were worried that every time they turned on the faucet to get their child a glass of water, that they may be filling that glass with poison.
Soft music continues
And then recently, Biden's EPA upped the ante in a big way. Here's what it's proposing, that all of the lead pipes in this country be ripped up and replaced in the next 10 years. It's ambitious. It'll be expensive. Is it even possible?
Soft music transitions to a more upbeat tune
Ahead on Today Explained, what it would take to get the lead out.
Upbeat music continues
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform.
Upbeat music continues
Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business.
Upbeat music continues
And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Upbeat music continues
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24-7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Upbeat music continues
It's Today Explained. Noel King here with David Sedlak, who teaches in the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering at UC Berkeley.
David Sedlak
Hi Noel.
Noel King
David studies water infrastructure and also why it's such a problem that lead is a big part of our water infrastructure.
David Sedlak
That's right. There are many things that lead does to the human body, but the one that we're most worried about when it comes to drinking water, environmental exposures is lead's action as a neurotoxin.
Noel King
It's especially toxic for children during their development. And exposure to very low levels of lead can result in reduced IQ and behavioral problems and other kinds of health effects that can follow someone throughout their entire life.
David Sedlak
Okay, so it's acting on the brain. The brain is one of the places where it has the largest impact, especially in developing children.
Noel King
If lead is as dangerous as you've just described, how did we end up with it transporting our drinking water into our houses?
David Sedlak
Well, lead's been around and associated with our drinking water for thousands of years.
Soft music transitions to a more conversational tone
Solway, Marcus, can you believe we finally have running water in our villa? All thanks to these incredible new lead pipes. Our Roman engineers really are the best.
Noel King
[laughs] That's a great point. The Romans who pioneered some of the first systems to send water into cities. And a lot of the pipework and valves and ways to move water involved the use of lead.
David Sedlak
In fact, the word plumber comes from the Latin word plumbum for the name for lead itself. So lead was essentially synonymous with the piping and valves and other types of infrastructure used to move water because it was so easy to work with and malleable.
Noel King
You have to remember, in ancient times, there weren't a lot of the modern materials that we're used to today.
David Sedlak
There were no plastics. There weren't the high-strength iron and metal and steel. And so lead was this readily available material that could be molded into all kinds of shapes and perhaps most importantly, could withstand pressure.
Noel King
And so it was the obvious choice for pipes. In 2,000 years, why didn't we make any advancements? How did it end up that here in the United States, a lot of the houses on my street, I know this for a fact, I was able to look it up, they have lead pipes bringing them water?
David Sedlak
As the modern water infrastructures that we built in cities in the 19th and 20th century grew, lead was the only real option, especially for the pipes that take water from the street into people's homes because they had to be flexible and malleable and easily installed.
Noel King
Basically, at some point in the 20th century, people came to recognize that lead might be an issue.
David Sedlak
And also, other types of pipes became cheaper and easier to install, like copper service lines.
Noel King
And so, the places where we find the most lead water pipes and service lines is in the oldest cities. So, you'll find the lead pipes particularly in the Northeast and upper Midwest.
David Sedlak
Okay, so for a long time, we're just crackalacking along, making our pipes out of lead. And then at a certain point, we start to realize it is not just a substance that we make things out of. It's actually really bad for us.
Noel King
Can you tell us the how and the when of this happening, this realization?
David Sedlak
Well, the recognition that lead was a wide-scale health problem actually isn't related to drinking water at all.
Noel King
It was something that happened in the mid-1960s as scientists started to understand the health effects of leaded gasoline.
David Sedlak
What comes from leaded exhaust is a polluted atmosphere and damage to children, like brain damage, learning disabilities.
Noel King
Estimates? 300,000 children have levels of lead in their systems that are considered dangerous.
David Sedlak
So in the 1960s and through up until the mid-1970s, lead was an additive in gasoline to make the engine run more efficiently.
Noel King
And it was distributed all over because it would come out of people's tailpipes.
David Sedlak
And so children had high levels of blood lead through the 1970s.
Noel King
And when scientists started looking at where the lead was coming from, they decided that a lot of it had come from leaded gasoline and some of it had come from lead paint.
David Sedlak
So back in that era a lot of the paint that was used on surfaces particularly surfaces that got a lot of traffic like the kind of paint that you would use on your kitchen cabinets were made out of lead materials
Noel King
It's pure white lead. It's Dutch boy. And it's ready to use.
David Sedlak
This new paint, like the famous paste, gives your home the long-lasting protection of pure white lead.
Noel King
So there were lots of sources of lead in the 1960s, 60s. And as we became aware of the fact that this was having health impacts, there was an effort to get it out of gasoline.
David Sedlak
Cars built after 1974, you was unleaded.
Noel King
And once we recognized that that wouldn't do enough to remove the lead, people started to ask questions of why children still were showing up with lead every once in a while.
David Sedlak
And that turned people's attention to the possibility that the lead pipes and the lead-containing solder in plumbing fixtures might also be an important source of lead exposure.
Noel King
And so the government's now realized, okay, there were a couple of sources of lead getting into us. Gasoline and paint are now, we've sort of cut them out.
David Sedlak
What did the government do when it realized the drinking water was a problem too?
Noel King
Well, the obvious thing to do would have been to say, let's take the lead pipes out.
David Sedlak
But people realized pretty quickly that there were a lot of lead pipes and they would be hard to get to because they were not the big pipes that ran under the street, but they were the pipes that ran through properties and also that people had lead solder and lead fixtures inside their homes.
Noel King
And it's pretty unusual for the government to come into your home and try to repair your plumbing and pipes.
David Sedlak
And so one of the responses of the federal government was to pass a regulation, the so-called lead and copper rule in 1991.
Noel King
And this was an EPA regulation that told water utilities how to manage the chemistry of their drinking water.
David Sedlak
So rather than pulling the lead pipes out, we could change the chemistry of the drinking water to make it less conducive to corrosion.
Noel King
And that process of corrosion is one of the ways in which lead gets released into tap water.
David Sedlak
So the idea was that you could change the chemistry of the water and make sure that the lead wasn't being released into the tap water.
Noel King
Did it work? Did the government's lead and copper rule and mitigation and treatment techniques, did that improve the situation?
David Sedlak
So the lead and copper rule made a big difference in many places, but there were some places where there were some other things going on in water systems that had unintended consequences.
Noel King
And the one that probably had the biggest impact on the way people think about controlling lead release from pipes happened in Washington, D.C. in the early 2000s.
David Sedlak
And the city of Washington was struggling to meet the EPA regulations on chlorine disinfection byproducts.
Noel King
That is, when we add chlorine to water to disinfect it, it produces small amounts of chemicals that can be carcinogenic or can lead to miscarriages and other things you don't want in your tap water.
David Sedlak
And so the city of Washington switched the form of chlorine that they were adding to the water before sending it out in the pipes from so-called free chlorine or basically bleach to something called chloramines.
Noel King
And when they did that, that had an unintended impact on the release of lead from the lead-containing service lines, and the lead concentration shot up.
David Sedlak
And lots of people, especially children, were exposed to high levels of lead in the period immediately after the conversion from chlorine to chloramines.
Noel King
All right, so we've got this issue in D.C. In my adult lifetime, we've had this crisis in Flint.
David Sedlak
Tens of thousands of residents exposed to high levels of lead when the city starts getting its water from the Flint River.
Noel King
In Newark, you had elevated levels of lead in the public schools.
David Sedlak
These were all incidents that made big news. The public was aware of them.
Noel King
Why is it only now in 2023 that President Biden's EPA is saying we need to get all of the lead pipes out within the next 10 years? Why did it take this long?
David Sedlak
Well, the crises in Washington and Flint and Newark turned public attention to lead and they finally built the momentum and political support for the idea that, yes, we could afford to take all the lead pipes out.
Noel King
Finally, it was just recognized that, you know, this is something we need to do because no matter how hard we try, people are going to make mistakes. And that's going to lead to lead exposure.
David Sedlak
And that's just not something that we can tolerate.
Noel King
Folks, this isn't complicated. Every person in this country deserves to be able to turn on a faucet and have clean drinking water.
David Sedlak
Through the infrastructure law, we're making historic investments to make sure that they can.
Upbeat music transitions to a more serious tone
Noel King
President Joe Biden. Before him, David Sedlak of Berkeley.
Soft music continues
Coming up, surely this isn't possible. A researcher has some good news.
Soft music continues
Support for today explained comes from chime nobody likes fees and complicated banking says chime and chime gets that says chime chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts so when you set up direct deposit through time they say you get access to fee-free features such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more.
Soft music continues
Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft, up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals.
Soft music continues
Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees.
Soft music continues
You can work on your financial goals through Chime today. You can open an account in two minutes at chime.com slash explained.
Soft music continues
That's Chime.com slash explained. Chime feels like progress.
Soft music continues
Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bancor Bank N.A. Or Stride Bank N.A. Members FDIC.
Soft music continues
Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Timing depends on submission of payment file. Fees apply at out-of-network ATMs.
Soft music continues
Bank ranking and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023. Chime checking account required. Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian Our coverage has something unique Fierce independence Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can say so we free to report the whole picture We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe, expose corruption wherever we find it, and give fresh perspective on everything, from wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more.
Soft music continues
Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
Soft music continues
Support for Today Explained comes from Upwork. If you run a business, you know that scaling your business requires the right expertise at the right time.
Soft music continues
I sometimes wonder how many of you are running businesses out there. I would love to know. Please email me, noelle at king dot com.
Soft music continues
With Upwork, you can find specialized freelancers in IT, web development, AI, design, admin support, marketing, and more.
Soft music continues
Experts who they say are ready to help you take your business to the next level.
Soft music continues
With more than two decades of experience, Upwork has a simple and ambitious goal to pioneer a better way of working.
Soft music continues
Companies at every stage turn to Upwork to get things done and find more flexibility in the way they staff key projects and initiatives by accessing a global marketplace full of top talent.
Soft music continues
Plus, Upwork makes posting your job easy with no cost to join.
Soft music continues
You can register, browse freelancer profiles, get help drafting a job post, or even book a consultation.
Soft music continues
You can visit Upwork.com right now and post your job for free.
Soft music continues
That is Upwork.com to post your job for free and connect with top talents ready to help your business grow.
Soft music continues
That's U-P-W-O-R-K.com, Upwork.com.
Soft music transitions to a more conversational tone
It's Today Explained with Karen Baylor, a scholar at American University who studies environmental justice.
Karen Baylor
Hi Noel.
Noel King
Karen, what's in this new Biden EPA proposal? There's a lot in it, and a lot of it is genuinely new.
Karen Baylor
I think we might even say this is a non-incremental policy change, which is why a lot of people are excited about it.
Noel King
So really, the headline, I suppose you'd have to say, is there is a requirement now from the federal level for all lead service lines, which are the lead water pipes that lead from the water main in the middle of the street to people's buildings, all of those lead pipes have to be removed completely all the way, the full length of the pipe in 10 years.
Karen Baylor
And 10 years is a much quicker timeline than what we were looking at in the past.
Noel King
So the new proposed revised rule is full of potential improvements.
Karen Baylor
Okay, so you referred to this as non-incremental, and you weren't even being snarky, which I appreciate, but non-incremental would seem to also mean somewhat ambitious.
Noel King
This seems ambitious. Is it possible?
Karen Baylor
Ambitious is an excellent word. We could also say, however, that it's late.
Noel King
I think it is possible if lots of people do the right things and a lot of work is done.
Karen Baylor
Folks, this isn't complicated. Every person in this country deserves to be able to turn on a faucet and have clean drinking water.
Noel King
And through the infrastructure law, we're making historic investments to make sure that they can.
Karen Baylor
I want you to walk us through exactly what goes into replacing these lead pipes and what they're replaced with.
Noel King
Tell me what I might be seeing if I'm walking through my own street here in Washington, D.C., and the Biden administration's proposal is going through.
Karen Baylor
The lead pipes are coming out. What's this going to look like?
Noel King
Well, you'll be walking down your street and you'll see a lot of trucks from DC Water, which is our local utility.
Karen Baylor
And what they'll be doing is digging up the middle of the street because these lead service lines, as I mentioned before, run all the way from the water main, which is the great big pipe that runs down the middle of the street to the house.
Noel King
So they have to dig up the street and then they'll dig a trench all the way from the street up to your building.
Karen Baylor
And then they pull out the lead pipes and have to handle them very carefully, of course, because they are, you know, a hazardous material.
Noel King
And then they will replace those pipes, reconnect to the water main, reconnect to the house.
Karen Baylor
Usually the replacements are made of copper.
Noel King
And then, of course, they have to cover everything up and they have to replace your sidewalks and replace the street.
Karen Baylor
It ought to be able to be done in a week, you know, for a whole block if they're doing it all at one time.
Noel King
It seems like this could be expensive. How much money is going to be available to states to get this project done?
Karen Baylor
And where's that money coming from?
Noel King
The cost is obviously very much a factor.
Karen Baylor
There are so many different sources of money. It's kind of mind boggling.
Noel King
And this is part of the challenge for localities is to figure out how to sort through all of the different pots of money that are available.
Karen Baylor
Fortunately, we have the bipartisan infrastructure bill or law, I should call it, that was passed recently.
Noel King
And that contains $15 billion nationwide for this work specifically, specifically this lead work.
Karen Baylor
It's also interesting, many people don't note that that law also authorizes $50 billion for water infrastructure in general.
Noel King
And so that's good news for utilities because it means that that money will take pressure off of other parts of their capital budget so that they could potentially spend more on the lead pipes.
Karen Baylor
Some cities have put in money into lead pipe removal directly from their municipal budgets.
Noel King
And then there are EPA has a state revolving water fund that funds this work.
Karen Baylor
Of course, the final pot that's so important is potentially raising the rates on water customers.
Noel King
And that nearly always needs to be one piece of the whole recipe.
Karen Baylor
What else is needed beyond money?
Noel King
If we can say, all right, the money is doable. What are the additional hurdles?
Karen Baylor
Well, one of the hurdles that you find in this new rule is the issue of legal access to the property itself.
Noel King
Generally, about half of the pipe is sitting on public land and about half of it is sitting on private property.
Karen Baylor
And there are various types of obstacles to that.
Noel King
And this varies hugely from jurisdiction to jurisdiction in terms of who owns that pipe.
Karen Baylor
But in the past, we know that utilities were sometimes given not the best information about those restrictions.
Noel King
A lot of utilities were told, for example, that they could not spend ratepayer money to do anything on private land.
Karen Baylor
But then a recent analysis just the last couple of years from some researchers at the Emmett Center at Harvard the Center on Environmental Law and also the Environmental Defense Fund They looked at laws policies and court decisions in 13 states that have lots and lots of lead pipes.
Noel King
And what they found really was that those policies did allow the spending of ratepayer money on private land for lead removal because, of course, it's a public good.
Karen Baylor
It's a public benefit. It's not a private benefit only to the homeowner.
Noel King
Okay, so there are some very interesting obstacles here.
Karen Baylor
You studied the lead line replacement program here in Washington, D.C. What were you studying exactly?
Noel King
What were you watching for?
Karen Baylor
So in that study, we were looking specifically at the difference between full replacements and partial replacements of pipes.
Noel King
D.C. Water replaced water lines serving thousands of homes from 2004 to 2008, but homeowners were responsible for replacing any lead pipes on their side of the property line.
Karen Baylor
It could be about $2,500 on average per house.
Noel King
It's a lot of money, you know, when you're living on a tight budget.
Karen Baylor
And so what the utility would do in those circumstances is a partial replacement.
Noel King
So the people living in the house, you know, still have a lot of exposure to lead because of the piece of the pipe that's on private property.
Karen Baylor
The CDC says partial pipe replacement can sometimes cause more harm than good.
Noel King
The study found that children living in homes with partial lead pipe replacement had elevated lead levels in their blood.
Karen Baylor
What we found was that in the districts within the city, known as wards, the eight wards of Washington, D.C., in the districts that had lower income, lower median income, and higher percentages of populations who identify as African-American and black, they had more partial replacements and fewer full replacements.
Noel King
Now, what this essentially means, right, is that the people living in those parts of the city are receiving a less effective remediation and they're exposed to public health hazards that other parts of the city are not exposed to.
Karen Baylor
So it's a real equity concern.
Noel King
Now, I should mention that our data was from 2009 to 2018.
Karen Baylor
So that was during the period when partial replacements were frequently done and accepted and the cost sharing was in place.
Noel King
Fortunately, D.C. changed that rule in 2018.
Karen Baylor
Oh, now D.C. is paying for homeowners to get it done? They are.
Noel King
They are. Yes, starting in October of 2019, they've been doing that.
Karen Baylor
Okay. So what could other cities, a lot of cities are going to go through this, what could they learn from Washington, D.C.?
Noel King
Well, they absolutely could learn a lot.
Karen Baylor
And, you know, when I read through the EPA's new revised rule, I think the EPA learned a lot from D.C. as well and from other places in the country that have been successful about this.
Noel King
One of the big takeaways, I think, for other cities is that you really have to be quite deliberate in thinking about the equity implications of your lead removal program.
Karen Baylor
How you do it, you know, really matters.
Noel King
In, you know, back in the old days, as we say, it was logical.
Karen Baylor
You know, they'd say, well, we're just going to go to the places that have the most lead pipes.
Noel King
And we're going to try to get as much lead out of the ground as possible.
Karen Baylor
If that means we do partials, then we do partials.
Noel King
If it means that, you know, we send our crews into wealthier, wider parts of a city, because people there are, you know, willing to pay for these, then, you know, that's what we do.
Karen Baylor
Because our goal is to get the lead out of the ground.
Noel King
And so I think what we're learning, though, is that those approaches end up having unintended and pretty severe impacts on the equity patterns of access to this service.
Karen Baylor
And so I hope other cities will learn that to target those neighborhoods where you really need to start doing the work.
Noel King
You're telling me you've seen success stories. Can you tell me one of those success stories?
Karen Baylor
Well, sure. One of the, I think, really inspiring ones is Madison, Wisconsin.
Noel King
In Madison, they started really wanting to remove the lead pipes in the early 90s.
Karen Baylor
Now, the lead and copper rule, you know, was brand new at that point.
Noel King
And immediately, the city of Madison, Wisconsin is thinking, we're not just going to add chemicals to our water in order to, you know, avoid lead leaching.
Karen Baylor
We actually want to get these lead pipes out of the ground.
Noel King
We had done some studies using our water and demonstrated that there really was limited benefit.
Karen Baylor
The alternative was to use orthophosphate.
Noel King
And as we know, that is what triggers eutrophication or the algae growth in Madison area lakes.
Karen Baylor
So they really started the actual removals in 2001, and they had about 8,000 pipes that needed to be taken out, and it took them about 10 years.
Noel King
It was a Herculean task.
Karen Baylor
Madison is a model for the rest of the country?
Noel King
I would say so.
Karen Baylor
I mean, we made a decision 20-plus years ago to take out the lead. We don't have that in our system anymore.
Noel King
Now, Newark, New Jersey then, originally had a time frame of about eight years for replacing all 24,000 of their pipes.
Karen Baylor
The water coming from Yvette Jordan's tap looks pure, but this year she learned it contained lead levels nearly three times federal rules.
Noel King
The city says it's embarking on a plan to replace lead water pipes, but that will take some time, possibly years, to get all of that done.
Karen Baylor
And they ended up doing it in about three years.
Noel King
Newark has become a national model for replacing lead water lines.
Karen Baylor
We went through a storm and then the sun came out and, you know, not all storms are there to wash you away, I guess.
Noel King
So, you know, these are just a few of the success stories that I think give us hope that we can scale this up.
Karen Baylor
That was Karen Baylor of American University.
Noel King
Today's episode was produced by Isabel Angel and edited by Matthew Collette.
It was engineered by David Herman and fact-checked by Anouk Dussault.
I'm Noelle King.
It's Today Explained.