Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the leadership of Hamas, a Palestinian Islamist organization, and its role in the ongoing conflict in Gaza. The hosts interview Tom O'Connor, a national security and foreign policy writer for Newsweek, who provides insight into the top leaders of Hamas, including Yahya Sinwar, Mohamed Daif, and Ismail Haniyeh.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Tom O'Connor
Thanks for having me on the show.
Sean Rameswaram
Today, we're talking about Hamas. Specifically, the three guys at the top of the Hamas org chart. Tom O'Connor writes about national security and foreign policy for Newsweek. He's here to introduce us to Yahya Sinwar, Mohamed Daif, and Ismail Haniyeh.
Tom O'Connor
So, let's start with Sinwar. The last we've seen of him is a video that was released a few months ago, purported to be him, with some family members going through a tunnel.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the story behind that video?
Tom O'Connor
It's one of many that we have obtained since October 7th. All three of them, including Hani, are really from this same generation of children born into refugee families in Gaza that escaped from other parts of what was before the Mandate of Palestine, before the 48 war.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] So, let's start with Sinwar. He's also known as Abu Ibrahim in Arabic, born in Khan Yunus. He goes to the Islamic University of Gaza, like all these three guys do, essentially.
Tom O'Connor
And pretty early on in the 80s, he's arrested the first time. And we have to remember, the 80s is a very tense time in the Gaza Strip. The first intifada, which is a mass uprising, there's violence everywhere.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the 80s in Gaza?
Tom O'Connor
The commitment is not only to regain the Palestinian homeland for the PLO, The commitment is to do it by armed force. And this is really when Hamas forms. And it gets its support base from these disaffected Palestinian activists who become increasingly conservative and religiously focused in their sort of their activities.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] So, Sinwar is arrested once. I think the first time is in 1982. He has a few run-ins with the police and basically the Israeli security forces at the time.
Tom O'Connor
But he really gets this reputation when he comes out as this really brutal enforcer. And he's known for not only killing Israelis, but he's also accused of killing Palestinians that are accused of collaborating with Israel.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what happens to him after that?
Tom O'Connor
He's arrested once again in the late 80s. And this time he stays in prison for a long time. And he doesn't really emerge again, actually, till about 2011.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's his role in Hamas after that?
Tom O'Connor
Israel has begun transferring Palestinian prisoners ahead of their planned release in an exchange deal for the captive Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit. There's this big exchange, about 1,000 Palestinians, Sinwara being one of them.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's his role in Hamas now?
Tom O'Connor
He's basically part of what has become now Hamas's internal security forces. He's doing these interrogations and he's also doing something else that's very important. He's building ties with this axis of resistance that includes Hezbollah, includes Iran and some of the other groups in the region, really tied together by the IRGC.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] Now, let's talk about Mohamed Daif. He's a far more elusive figure than Sinwar.
Tom O'Connor
Yeah. So Muhammad Daif is a product of a refugee family that lived in Gaza. He went to university in the 80s. Funny enough, he actually had an extracurricular activity. He actually took on theater.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's his claim to fame?
Tom O'Connor
His claim to fame really is just excelling in bomb-making skills and strategy and ambushes. And he's really seen as one of the key figures behind the scenes when it came to these mass attacks going into even after the first Tifada, there was a second Tifada in the 2000s.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's his background like?
Tom O'Connor
The name actually, Muhammad Daif, is not his real name. It's a nickname that refers to the term daif means guest in Arabic. And it refers to the fact that he never stays in the same place for too long.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's his relationship with Hamas?
Tom O'Connor
He's a dedicated commando leader and he's almost like a, to some, a Che Guevara kind of figure. He's become so iconic in ways that even just his silhouette, which is usually how he presents himself like he did on October 7th when he gave this super galvanizing speech, but the silhouette is being raised at rallies and stuff like that.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what about Ismail Haniyeh?
Tom O'Connor
Yeah, so Haniyeh really today serves as the top leadership of all Hamas, as the chief of the Palaf Bureau. He's in Doha, based there. He travels. He's part of the public face of Hamas. He's pivotal to their international relations and their efforts to have more international legitimacy to forge relations with other countries, other powers.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's his role in Hamas?
Tom O'Connor
He was actually a former prime minister of the Palestinian national authority at this brief time where there was a unity government. And Haniyeh is no longer considered, of course, prime minister, but he assumes control over Gaza. And then he, of course, then goes on to become the head of all Hamas.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And how important are these three guys to Hamas?
Tom O'Connor
There's no doubt that there's both symbolic and tactical value in taking out top Hamas leaders, you know. But if we look at the history of Hamas, they've lost just about every top leader they've had over the years. And they've had new people.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the impact of losing these leaders on Hamas?
Tom O'Connor
They have replacements and they have replacements for the replacements. We've heard that a lot. So, I think that and this is something Israeli officials tell us is that, yes, you know, we want we want to get these guys. You know, they're on our target list and we've seen them, you know, do these assassination operations for some of these guys who are abroad, like Aruri, for example.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the strategy of the Israeli military in taking out Hamas leaders?
Mairav Zonszein
When you actually break it down, they want to remove Hamas as a power in the Gaza Strip. Hamas will be dismantled. And Hamas leaders, wherever they're hiding, should know their own borrowed time. We will continue doing everything in our power to fulfill our mission. Free our hostages from Hamas and free Gaza from Hamas.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the challenge in taking out Hamas leaders?
Mairav Zonszein
It's very difficult to take apart a non-state kind of terror group that has taken root inside a very small, urban, densely populated area when they've been there for almost 20 years.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the impact of the Israeli military's strategy on Hamas?
Mairav Zonszein
They've gotten to some of, I think, the more senior commanders in charge of certain aspects of the military wing of Hamas. They broken a significant number of Hamas battalions killed thousands of Hamas fighters including senior commanders Hamas number three Marwan Issa was killed in an Israeli operation last week The rest of the top leaders are in hiding likely deep in the Hamas tunnel network
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the tunnel network?
Mairav Zonszein
You've got reinforced concrete. They have electrical wires. There is plumbing overhead. I'm about 5'8", and you can see this goes way above my head. So it's probably about 10 feet tall.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the challenge in taking out Hamas leaders in the tunnel network?
Mairav Zonszein
And as much destruction and devastation and killing that we've seen, I think there would have been probably even more if those hostages weren't there and they wouldn't have to worry about that collateral damage.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the impact of the Israeli military's strategy on the humanitarian situation in Gaza?
Mairav Zonszein
The other is, besides the kind of military difficulty and the urban warfare difficulty before October 7th and the criticism since October 7th of the Netanyahu government and Netanyahu specifically, was that he had a very clear policy of keeping Hamas in power and also of trying to contain Hamas in a way, because Hamas is a very good excuse for Israel to continue on its path of settlement expansion and occupation and rejection of a Palestinian state, rejection of Palestinian self-determination.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy in keeping Hamas in power?
Mairav Zonszein
Because we're talking about, you know, a terror group that many in the world don't think is legitimate. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu pushed back today against criticism of his Gaza strategy from within his own government.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the response from the Israeli government to criticism of their strategy?
Mairav Zonszein
Indecision is, in essence, a decision. This leads to a dangerous course, which promotes the idea of Israeli military and civilian governance in Gaza. This is a negative and dangerous option for the state of Israel, strategically, militarily, and from a security standpoint.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's response to criticism of their strategy?
Mairav Zonszein
We must make tough decisions for the future of our country, favoring national priorities above all other possible considerations, even with the possibility of personal or political costs.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the impact of the Israeli government's strategy on the US?
Mairav Zonszein
The U.S. has come out and said, like, you need to have a better plan for not only once you have taken Hamas out in a certain area, you have to kind of stay there and figure out who's going to take over.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the US's response to the Israeli government's strategy?
Mairav Zonszein
They basically have said, even where you have been able to take out Hamas, you have nothing to fill that vacuum. There's no alternative. You've rejected any kind of plan. You've rejected the Palestinian Authority in some level.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the impact of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
And that's obviously very problematic. It just sounds like strategic failure on top of strategic failure on Israel's part.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
Is it all but certain that Hamas will still be standing come the end of this war? Some people in Israel, even putting aside Netanyahu, are really committed to removing Hamas from power, even if it takes years, even if Israel has to be enrolling operations and some form of occupation for many years.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
And legitimately, Israelis who lived along the border there won't be able to feel safe staying there. You have a real security issue and an internal domestic crisis that Israel has lost. Israelis have lost total confidence in the ability of the state to protect them.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
And that's a real issue that the political and the military echelon need to deal with.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
Even if the Hamas current regime, as it stands, is somehow surrenders or exiled or removed at the end of this, there's still going to be Hamas people and Hamas approaches and ideology.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
And it's also a dynamic thing. It's constantly changing.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
So the Palestinian issue was pushed under the rug. U.S. presidents have denied that as an issue. Israeli prime ministers and consecutive governments and the society have just kind of decided that it's not an issue they need to deal with.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
And that hubris and that impunity led us in many ways to October 7th.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
So, you know, that's something that Israelis are going to have to reckon with now.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
And that's something that, you know, the world is reacting very strongly to, I think, years of occupation with no price to pay.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And what's the significance of the Israeli government's strategy on the Palestinian people?
Mairav Zonszein
And unfortunately, the price now is very, very high.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And that's it for today's show. Thanks to Mairav Zonszein from International Crisis Group for joining us.
Mairav Zonszein
Thanks for having me.
Sean Rameswaram
[pause] And thanks to our listeners for tuning in.
End of show