Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the intersection of religion and law, specifically the impact of the overturning of Roe v. Wade on religious freedom, particularly for Jews and Muslims.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Noel King
Two, four, six, eight, separate the church and state! On the day that Roe v. Wade was overturned, religion took some hits. Protest chants, signs, keep your religion off my body. But a lot of religious people were furious about the decision, too.
Discussion continues, but it's unclear who is speaking, so we'll label them as "Host"
Host
In a written response to the overturning of Roe v. Wade, the congregation Lador Vador says the United States Supreme Court's decision and Florida's own anti-abortion law criminalizes the practice of Judaism. A synagogue is suing the state of Florida, Governor Ron DeSantis, and a handful of others, alleging the state's 15-week abortion ban infringes on the religious freedom of Jews.
The host mentions a listener's story, and then introduces a sponsor
Support for Today Explained comes from BetterHelp. Let me tell you a true story. Last weekend, I got an email from a listener who wanted to discuss their problems with me. And I said, look, I don't think that this is about me personally. At least I hope it's not. Why don't you try BetterHelp.com slash Explained. Absolute truth. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Find the one with BetterHelp.
The host introduces another sponsor
Our listeners get 10% off their first month at BetterHelp.com. That's BetterHelp.com. We all have moments where we could have done better, like cutting your own hair. Yikes. Or forgetting sunscreen, so now you look like a tomato. Ouch. Could have done better. Same goes for where you invest. Level up and invest smarter with Schwab. Get market insights, education, and human help when you need it. Learn more at schwab.com.
The host introduces the main topic of the episode
It's Today Explained. I'm Noelle King. So about that lawsuit, Rabbi Jen Lader serves as a spiritual leader at Temple Israel in the Detroit area. She is currently, though, not in Detroit. Oh, right now I am in my hotel room in Jerusalem on my sixth day of COVID quarantine, overlooking the beautiful hills outside while trapped in my room. Okay. So some good, some bad. Yep.
Rabbi Jen Lader
I was excited. It was so exciting to see some creative thinking and ways that we as a Jewish community who are activists, who are constantly looking for ways to make the world a better place for those who live in it. It was exciting to see somebody trying to build a just society by presenting our religious freedom as a method by which to create major change.
Host
There's only so much we can do with rallies and posters and t-shirts and sermons from the BIMA, but to be able to do something that really could affect the laws in the country and affect people of all socioeconomic statuses, people of all religions. Since this is coming down to the state level, it was really thrilling to see this creative energy coming from our community as a way to incite change.
Rabbi Jen Lader
What does Jewish law say about abortion exactly? Jewish law is actually pretty clear about abortion. Historically, our most important law, the highest mitzvah or commandment that Jews have is the preservation of life, is the saving of a life. And in our tradition, it is very clear, based on sacred text, that in the case of a pregnant person, the person who is pregnant's life is the one to which those laws are referring.
Host
There's a really interesting biblical precedent in the book of Exodus that's often used to illustrate this point. It's a case of two men fighting, and one of them knocks into a pregnant woman and causes the pregnant woman to miscarry. The man who caused that woman to miscarry is liable for damages. And it says that should harm befall the woman that he knocked into, should she die, for example, then he would be liable for homicide. He would be on the hook for her life. But in the case of her miscarrying, he's not.
Rabbi Jen Lader
So it serves as a proof text to us that when it comes to life, the preservation of life, what we refer to as pikuach nefesh, that in those cases, the person who is pregnant's life matters certainly above that of something which is not considered alive until it takes a breath in Jewish law. Until it takes a breath.
Host
The congregation in Boynton Beach, Florida is, and here I'm going to use their words, on their website they describe it as what they practice, cosmic Judaism. and the rabbi says it is the Judaism of tomorrow that respects science, tradition, and spirituality. So I read that and I think, okay, this congregation could fairly be called progressive. Am I making a wrong-headed assumption, though?
Rabbi Jen Lader
No, they certainly sound like a progressive congregation. Where does this congregation in Boynton Beach fit on the spectrum of Judaism, which of course contains many, many multitudes, including some that would be more conservative than others.
Host
When it comes to Roe v. Wade, when it comes to reproductive rights, conservative and liberal Jews, and I mean that politically and not denominationally, are fairly unified and have been over the last 40 years. I was reading that in the last Pew study, 83% of American Jews supported Roe v. Wade and the right to abortion, which was higher than any other faith tradition and certainly higher than the general population.
Rabbi Jen Lader
So for us, it's a fairly clear-cut issue, and it's not one that is politically divisive within our congregation. I made this assumption that Orthodox Jews necessarily support the right to an abortion And I admit I was coming from a place of complete ignorance and I assume that they would probably fall on the side of the evangelicals in this argument You're saying that's not necessarily true.
Host
It's not true, and it's a misconception that a lot of people have. Because the pro-life movements often herald religion as the banner under which they act, It doesn't mean that all conservative or more traditional religious traditions agree with that point. And for Orthodox Jews, even though, of course, they value life above all else, of course, it is not a matter which anybody takes lightly.
Rabbi Jen Lader
there are cases in which a pregnant person would be absolutely mandated to have an abortion. And for abortion to become illegal in certain states removes their religious right to practice our faith in whatever denomination and whatever way people align. When it comes to abortion remaining legal in the United States, there is agreement because while the reasons that somebody who identifies as a reformed Jew may pursue an abortion and the reasons why an Orthodox, someone who identifies as Orthodox may pursue an abortion. The fact remains that there are cases for both in which it is religiously mandated for someone to have one.
Host
If the mother's life is at risk, there's no question that that life takes precedence over the life of a fetus. And so denying that right to a woman or someone who was pregnant would mean that an Orthodox Jew would not be able to practice their faith in a way that allows us religious freedom in our country.
Rabbi Jen Lader
When we say Jewish law, Rabbi Leder, what are we talking about exactly? So there's this whole idea that when you get two Jews in a room, you have three opinions. So we are people who love to argue and love to debate. When we're talking about Jewish law, we're talking about an argument that's taken place over centuries, where we look at biblical text, we look at our sacred tradition, And sages have intergenerational dialogue trying to interpret these laws and make them relevant for the time and place in which they live.
Host
So there are collections of text, collections of interpretation by our most venerated sages throughout history that have taken biblical stories and biblical text and used those as the foundation for the creation of laws to govern the lands in which we live and the people who live in them. So for example, we have texts called the Talmud, which is like this collection of interpretations of the Torah and the laws that sort of come out of that.
Rabbi Jen Lader
So the law comes from a lot of different places, and each community, each denomination interprets the laws in different ways and our need or requirement to follow them, which is a major difference between the major movements in America. These laws were written a long time ago, long before we human beings understood how a fetus develops. Has the law been updated at all?
Host
So these aren't laws written out. These aren't commandments. We don't have a list somewhere that says thou shalt abort a fetus if the mother's life is in danger. These are interpretations of stories and narrative and statements by sages that we've collected for many generations. Now, when we are talking about creation of laws and precedent for our community based on new scientific information, things we might not have known in biblical times, you know, for example, Can I make a cell phone call on Shabbat? That comes from a different group of texts called responsa.
Rabbi Jen Lader
So each community has a panel of brilliant rabbis who take modern questions and use our foundational knowledge of Jewish history and Jewish text in order to form answers that hold fast to tradition, that take tradition into account, but also recognize that we live in a different time and place than we did when some of these conversations took place or didn't. So each community makes those choices for themselves based on their understanding of Jewish law and their understanding of our obligation to follow it.
Host
I read an op-ed in the San Francisco Chronicle by a Muslim scholar who said these abortion bans trample on the rights of Muslims' religious beliefs, too. So to me, that would signal kind of an interfaith push around reproductive rights. What do you think about that?
Rabbi Jen Lader
I love it so much. I love that the conversation is being shifted away from the idea that anyone who is religious, anyone who is religiously observant, is pro-life. I think that the Muslim community, based on their understanding of their holy texts, is very much aligned with our understanding of our holy texts. And we have a lot in common when it comes to reproductive justice. and our understanding of the sanctity of life.
The host introduces a new guest
Host
Today Explained, we're back with Asifa Qureshi-Londis, a law professor at the University of Wisconsin Law School who specializes in American constitutional law and Islamic law. Perfect combo for this one.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
I sympathize with the sentiment, and I'm happy that she's excited about that. I mean, here's where I entered into this whole world. There was an amicus brief submitted in the Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health case earlier in the fall that was written by a coalition of interfaith, I think women's organizations, Jewish, Christian, a few others, and they wanted Muslim organizations to join that brief. And that brief was making the argument that abortion bans such as the one in Mississippi infringed on the religious freedom of non-Christians and maybe other Christians in this country who didn't happen to agree that life begins at conception.
Host
And so I agreed with that argument that there are lots of different religious faiths in this country. I'm very glad that there are. And the religious diversity in this country has lots of different views on when life begins. And so we also have lots of different views about when abortion is appropriate. And any laws that reflect only one of those many views, if it's restricting the others, then I believe that it's an infringement on the religious diversity in this country.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
So Islamic law is made up of several different schools of thought. So the range of opinions on this question stems from different interpretations of the verses in the Quran that describe when life is breathed into the fetus. The Quran describes almost the evolution all the way through from the moment of, you know, just a cell to a fully formed unborn child. When that becomes a life with a soul is a question of debate.
Host
Because of that disagreement, you end up having variations on when the different schools say abortion would be appropriate. The most restrictive is the minority view, which is at conception, there's no permissibility for abortion except for saving the life of the mother. But it goes all the way to some would go to 40 days, some would go to 80 days, some would go to 120 days. But it really depends on which school of thought you follow as to whether abortion is permissible. All schools allow for abortion to save the life of the mother at any time.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
Is 120 days into the pregnancy, is that a very old law or is that something new that is grounded in what science tells us about viability? Oh, it's very old. It goes back to the very first interpretations of the Quran by religious scholars.
Host
Wow. So yeah, and I want to say something about the word law. In our English-speaking Western mind, when we say the word law, we think about state law. Yeah. What I'm describing here is a different type of law. It is the rules by which Muslims live our lives. That, in a Sharia perspective, is a part of the overall rule of law in a Muslim society.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
There's another type of law that is not based on scriptural interpretation, but it is what the state or the ruler does. And that has a very different mission and purpose. And traditionally, the purpose of state law is to serve the public good. And so that is what those laws are that the state is imposing on everyone is a very different question than what does scripture tell a Muslim to do in their life?
Host
Yes, and your op-ed doesn't just suggest that abortion bans run counter to Islam, but also to other Christian viewpoints. Talk about how Roe being overturned, in a sense, privileges certain types of Christianity over others.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
Well, to the extent that these laws are a reflection of or in agreement with one particular Christian view on when life begins, that is an enshrinement of that moral view into state law. And if it is enshrined in such a way that is a ban on certain types of abortions that other religions would allow, then that's an infringement on those followers of those religions fully practicing their religion.
Host
So when you take the most restrictive view of when abortion is allowed and enshrine it into state law, then anybody who follows a different moral view about abortion is no longer able to fully live their lives according to their own spiritual guidance.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
It's worth noting that the Supreme Court never argued that life begins at conception. It leaves things up to the states. How do you see the Supreme Court siding with the Christian right if the Supreme Court deliberately didn't address the question?
Host
I don't make the argument that the Supreme Court, per se, was siding with the Christian right. What it does it opens the door for the Christian right or any extremist you know moral perspective that is able to garner a majority in the state legislatures to then impose a particular religious view on the rest of us
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
So all the Supreme Court did was open the door to this being decided by democratic processes. And it very proudly said that that's what it was doing. So I think that all Americans should be concerned when this is left to majoritarian politics.
Host
But what's so interesting to me, And again, this comes down to how the words minority and majority apply is a majority of Americans did not want Roe versus Wade overturned. And a majority of Americans, they have nuanced views about abortion. It was a Christian minority that pushed for this and got what they wanted.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
So theoretically, that would mean if you leave it to the democratic processes, then the majority will then say, let's keep it legal and it should be fine. My concern is that that's not likely to happen.
Host
So what happens is you have a very activist community using religion or religious arguments to, you know, gin up a population to vote for this that will not actually be reflective of the population's desires. And we've seen that happen in all kinds of elections where the people elected don't actually have the full popular vote, but yet they end up because of the way that our politics works, they end up in power.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
So when you have the power of the state imposing a particular minority view of abortion on the rest of us, that should be concerning to everybody. But it's particularly concerning to me as a Muslim who knows that laws are often made that harm Muslims because we are not either taken into account or that we have misunderstandings about what Islam is all about.
Host
As a constitutional scholar, what do you think this decision means about the separation of church and state?
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
I think it's concerning because if laws are being motivated by a particular religious belief about life, then we could end up with a merging of those two in a way that we haven't seen before. Let's imagine a religious view that's not dominant in America, but what if it was able to garner majority in a particular area? So let's say a majority Hindu population or a Jain population that believes that there is reincarnation or that all life is sacred, including animal life, should not be killed.
Host
If they were to be able to pass a law that would make it illegal to slaughter cattle for hamburgers or even kill insects in the most conservative views of Jainism, as I understand, that would feel like a real infringement on a lot of Americans who don't believe that those things are killing a life.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
And so to me, that is, if we could take our time to think through that thought experiment, I think it helps us to understand why people who don't agree that life begins at conception, that laws that reflect that view would be such an imposition on us.
Host
You know that religion is a part of many movements to change law. The civil rights movement comes to mind. When does a faith-based movement become something that infringes on other people's freedoms?
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
I have no problem with people being motivated by their faith to think about what laws would help society. So if you're against slavery because of your faith, then I think that's a good thing in society. If you're against racism because of your faith, I think that's a good thing.
Host
When you bring those ideas into the public sphere and you advocate for laws, I believe there has to be something beyond just that you believe it to convince the rest of us that we should make it a law for all of us. So if I happen to believe it, that's great. But when I try to get the whole country to legislate, I need to make a case for why it serves the public good of everybody.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
Do you think we could see a new kind of religious liberty lawsuit where religious groups argue that as the country moves further right, their religious liberties are being violated?
Host
I hope that the America that I live in and that I love is also the America that everybody else loves, and that is the diversity of religions and races and languages and cultures that we have. I think it's our strength, and I think that whenever we pass laws that restrict that diversity and stifle it and blend us all together into one or press us all together under one, I think we lose something.
Asifa Qureshi-Londis
So these lawsuits, yeah, it's a little bit of turning on its head what religious freedom is about. Usually these people are arguing for religious freedom and often it is religious freedom for Christian practices and accommodations. In this case, when you go all the way with having the law reflect Christian values, you may end up having that law oppress other religious values and practices. And I would think that that would be a loss for the country.
Host
I would also like to take it even beyond just religious diversity and say, I would like us all to talk about what is the purpose of lawmaking in this country? Is it to do the general good for the as many of us as possible and the public good for all? I think it does not serve the public good to have one view of when life begins and find into state law. I think the state should leave it to individuals to make those decisions on their own. That's the best way to keep the diversity alive.
Today's episode was produced by Tori Dominguez and Haleema Shah. It was edited by Matt Collette and fact-checked by Laura Bullard. Special thanks on this one to Noam Hassenfeld, who hosts Unexplainable. Thank you, Noam. Thank you. Thank you.